Showing the single result
32 Pingbacks
- So Many Books – TulipGirl
- The Church as (inadvertent) Political Institution – Randy Greenwald
- Restoring the Lost Love of Reading – Randy Greenwald
- Buying Books – Randy Greenwald
- The Best of 2016 – Randy Greenwald
- Too Many Books! – Randy Greenwald
- Bookish Habits #1: Dr. Roy Starling – Randy Greenwald
- Bookish Habits #2: Rev. Mike Osborne – Randy Greenwald
- Bookish Habits #3: Dr. Wesley Hill – Randy Greenwald
- Community for the Self-absorbed Millennial – Randy Greenwald
- Bookish Habits #4: Jim Jones – Randy Greenwald
- Bookish Habits #5: Dr. Steve Brown and Dr. Bryan Chapell – Randy Greenwald
- Time to Read – Randy Greenwald
- Chutzpah in Nashville – Randy Greenwald
- God, Monasteries, and the Rhythms of Life – Randy Greenwald
- Finding Good Company – Randy Greenwald
- Four Practices of Pastoral Self-Care – Randy Greenwald
- Four Practices of Pastoral Self-Care – Randy Greenwald
- Five Books Every Pastor Should Read – Randy Greenwald
- The Fool’s Wisdom – Randy Greenwald
- Missing Your Blog – Randy Greenwald
- Laughter – Letters to a Church Displaced – Randy Greenwald
- Prayer – Letters to a Church Displaced – Randy Greenwald
- Gentleness – Letters to a Church Displaced – Randy Greenwald
- Present – Letters to a Church Displaced – Randy Greenwald
- Habit – Letters to a Church Displaced – Randy Greenwald
- Perspective – Letters to a Church Displaced – Randy Greenwald
- Charity – Letters to a Church Displaced – Randy Greenwald
- Ascension – Letters to a Church Displaced – Randy Greenwald
- Foolishness – Letters to a Church Displaced – Randy Greenwald
- Five Ways to Help Birth Book #2 – Randy Greenwald
- What’s Next after The Book? – Randy Greenwald
gusto
Good argument. I’d like to see what happens to the bill in the senate.
Dave and Chris
First off, a warning: this got rather longer than intended. And if this is not the type of discussion you want, Randy, delete it, and let me know to keep my big mouth shut! :-)I think the gist of this rings true: when we make it a felony to feed and clothe people, whatever their status, the state has intruded into a sphere of influence that should be rightly reserved for the church. For that reason, I agree with Mr. Hutchinson on this bill.One problem I have with Mr. Hutchinson’s argument, however, is his apparent pragmatism in the example of the building codes. He writes:”Consider an analogy. The city you live in has a law that you need a building permit to add on to your house. The permits are expensive and City Hall grants so few that you know it’s not worth it to try. You know that if you get caught, they’ll fine you a small amount and let you go. So you build without “the permit. After living in the addition for a few years, the city passes a law making it a felony to build without a permit. The law will effect everyone retroactively. You complain that you’ve already build the edition and the city replies that you have a “30-day grace period” to tear down your addition. Would you think it just? Maybe, but probably not.”According to his example, if it seems unreasonable to us, or difficult, we are justified in breaking a law as long as we are willing to bear the penalty if caught. Unless you are dealing with a Biblical mandate, I don’t see this as a biblical approach, but rather a pragmatic one. A proper response from the Christian is to either work to change the permit laws so they are more reasonable before building, or apply for the permit and take his chances. If we are convicted that the building law is unjust, and we are willing to bear the consequences of breaking the law, I don’t see we have any right to complain if the penalties are increased.If we are to take the above analogy a step farther, how would we feel if we had applied for a building permit, and waited and waited fruitlessly to receive one. But then, the county decided that those who had already built, contrary to the law, would be given a grace period during which they could receive approval. You, as a law-abider, will have to wait even longer as the permits for the law-breakers are processed. I fail to see how this furthers the cause of justice. This is a sticky issue– and how we serve the cause of justice is not as plain as I wish it were…Chris, off the top of my head…
Dave and Chris
P.S. Love the blog name and allusion! 🙂
Adria
The bill allready fell through in the senate. This newsletter article was written 6+ months ago. But, it will come up again in the same or different way, and I agree it is a difficult issue.
Randy Greenwald
Adria — I admit I have not followed this, and that I published this to glean from Travis his insights into the issue as a whole and not with regard to this particular issue. However, according to my read of the congressional record, this still is alive in the senate.
Gail and Keith
The US history on immigration is one of setting policy, but looking the other way in order to achieve whatever agenda or political persuasion is being promoted in any given Administration or era. The current outcry over illegal immigration smacks of racism. Is the general public really concerned about terrorism or is it, at a deeper level, discrimination against those who are different? It is disturbing to hear political candidates race baiting, playing to some, not all, citizens ungodly views of people of another culture who are different than themselves.A sports radio host said recently, it’s not the Hispanics coming over the border to pick our tomatoes (or oranges) that are a danger to our security. They just want to make a better life for themselves and their family. HR 3347 is a bad law. It won’t stop the terrorists.It will make criminals of hard-working people along with those, the Church, who seek to show them mercy and compassion. Yes, the US immigration policy needs a huge overhaul, policies need to be enforced, but let us be careful about how we do that.
Gail and Keith
The previous post was Gail’s opinion. I am not speaking for my spouse. G
Randy Greenwald
Your comments have all been very interesting and helpful, if only to muddy the water a bit and to be reminded that the issues on our plate are not always clear. I am troubled by politicians (or preachers!) who, in seeking to appeal to the greatest number of people, propose what seems to be a simple solution (“Amnesty!” or “No Amnesty!”) when the human issues are not quite that black and white. I appreciate Chris’s caution regarding pragmatic reasoning. I believe Travis was using this as an illustration to help us in our context understand how the immigrant might feel about this, and not as an argument in itself. However, the caution is well taken.I understand that we ought to obey the law, and that we ought to only disobey when the state by its laws seeks to forbid us doing what God commands, or to force us to do what God prohibits. But is there room somewhere to ignore foolish laws? I wonder….Thanks to all who responded.rrg
MagistraCarminae
This was a thoughtful article. Thanks for posting it, Randy!For those of you who have not had the opportunity, the letters written by Ted and Gayle Haggard that were read at New Life Church on Sunday can be found here:http://tinyurl.com/ymbezehttp://tinyurl.com/yb7pv5I was encouraged by reading them, and pray that what would appear to be real repentance and dedication to the Lord will indeed be the case during what must surely be a painful ordeal ahead of repentance and death to self.I am reminded of the old saying that the Church is the only army that shoots its own wounded…I am also reminded that we, in the church, should be unsurprised when such things happen: heart-broken, but unsurprised. There but for the grace of God would go any of us.Chris
Adria
I find it interesting that he didn’t reflect, compare, or empathize at all from personal experience. Someone who didn’t kow about his history could read the letter and just assume he is just another christian commenting on the whole affair. Hmmm…?
gusto
Is there any way to put the date on comments and not only the time?
Gail and Keith
Gail commenting here:Randy said about McDonald’s blog:”But as well, he makes some observations about the evangelical movement as a whole, and the political associations we make. These words say better than I ever could what I often feel.” I agree with your comment, Randy, but I think that McDonald attaching it to the Haggard scandal is a separate issue altogether. Haggard’s sin is one issue. Evangelicals hitching their political fortunes to the Republican Party, or any political party, for that matter, is another. Starting back with the Moral Majority of ’79, Christians put their hope for salvation in a Political Party and it continues today. To be sure, many Christians have attached their star to the Republican party thinking that they are the means to bring society as a whole back to what they believe to be our Judeo-Christian roots. As a result, we’re all scornfully labeled as The Far Right, Radical Christian Right, etc. We’ve allowed ourselves to be pawns in the political game, used to achieve their agenda, and then cast aside.Christians are to be a moral force, involved in all areas of society. We are to proclaim Christ’s Kingdom to a World tainted by the Fall. How that is to be done is fodder for lively debate among many fine Christians. Gail
A sinner's 2 cents
One thing that I appreciate about this whole situation with Haggard is that it shows that even ministers are people who need the grace and mercy of God. They aren’t somehow less vulnerable to sin or more holy than the average Joe because of their position. What Ted Haggard did was wrong but what he is doing about it is real Christianity. He admits his wrong without excuses and seeks forgiveness. May God help the Church to not be too quick to judge.Tom
Randy Greenwald
A couple replies:First, to Chris — I don’t think that the church is shooting its wounded in this case. I’ve not had that impression. Nor do I think that it is ‘shooting the wounded’ to expect or even demand that a long period of time elapse before we e his repentance to be real.To Adria, I think that he purposely does not make direct reference to his prior indiscretions. He alludes to them, clearly, but does not drag it all out for the world to see. There may be wisdom in that. To remind a generation of new readers that he messed up and then to feel obligated to retell that story over and again might be painful and certainly would be sensational. I’m not sure that is necessary.And, Gail, I agree that the issues are in some sense separate. However, I don’t think the world sees them as separate. Ted Haggard was seen as a political entity by the bulk of our culture, and embodied the very thing we want to avoid: the one to one identification of Christianity and a political party. That said, your comments are ‘spot on’ and something I wish I could better articulate.And, Tom, I too appreciate your ‘sinner’s two cents’ worth’. But I look at any repentance with a sadly jaundiced eye. Is he repentant? Or sorry he got caught? Only time, lots of it, will reveal that!Thanks for all of the comments.
Randy Greenwald
Gus — I think I’ve set it up now so that the date appears with the time. We’ll see. Still learning.
Randy Greenwald
Well, that didn’t work. I’ll keep trying.
Randy Greenwald
I think I’ve fixed it.
A sinner's 2 cents
This is an interesting topic, but not one which I’m all that knowledgeable on. But since it’s here, let me make a comment. Personally, I’m more comfortable with “whatever is not forbidden by scripture, is permitted in worship”. But let’s look at it from a different perspective. Is it still worship if certain elements are missing? For example: Is it still worship, if there isn’t singing, or preaching, or praying, or administration of the sacraments?Tom
Randy Greenwald
Tom,This post was a test to see if anyone was out there. My tree fell in the forest, and lo and behold, it made a noise. Imagine that.Ironically, I just got off the phone after a lengthy conversation on this subject. I am trying to determine the degree to which I am and am not comfortable with the Confession’s statement on worship. My conclusion at this point is quite similar to your own. As proof, I quote here what I wrote just prior to looking at your comment:”I do believe that worship that is Scriptural will have singing, praying, preaching, and sacraments, and I believe that such worship will be God centered, reverent, and beautiful. These things I think are true to Scripture. As to how such beauty, reverence, and God centeredness is maintained and developed, that is a question of wisdom that the leaders of each worshiping community need to decide. That is the way in which I believe Scripture regulates worship.”This is, I think, at a minimal level at least, in agreement with the Confession, though not with some of the Confession’s more strident apologists.Thanks for dropping in!
MagistraCarminae
Randy-I don’t have leisure to comment at the moment, but I “heard” your tree, too, and it has me thinking…Chris
MagistraCarminae
Hmm- we have heard good things about “Stranger than Fiction.” Have you seen “Deja Vu”? We are wondering if it is worth the effort.Thanks for being our film critic! And do you think it shows our age when getting to a movie is an “effort”?!Chris
MagistraCarminae
The Parrelells Desktop might actually convince me, but I am afraid it is a lost cause in my PC family. THis is largely due to the fact that they are techno-geeks of the sort that build and take apart computers, and fool with the hidden file settings in MS. Additionally, they each run programs without mac-accessible options…Do you think computing will be better in heaven?Chris
Kathryn
The beauty the Mac is that underneath all of the pretty stuff that makes OS X enjoyable and easy to use, the foundation is the uber-geeky Free BSD operating system. Granted, the average user neither knows or cares, but for someone who does care (a.k.a. me), there’s a wealth of opportunity for tinkering around.What’s nice though, is that with my Mac, I can tinker when I want to, on my terms, whereas when I was running Windows most of my tinkering came from fixing things that would break at the worst possible times and for no readily apparent reason
MagistraCarminae
Hey- this sounds great! Any chance of popping one of these our way?Chris
MagistraCarminae
I got was able to retreive the link 🙂 I had already heard this as an MP3 file you sent me some time ago. Sounds like fun!Chris
Adria
He’s Back!!!Looking forward to what’s to come. Love you!!
Adria
I don’t really care all that much. 🙂 May the best man win. What’s the bet?
Stingray
Randy….Come back from the darkside, your being brain washed.Rob ;-)Just kidding I envy your Mac, my Ipod made me a believer.
MagistraCarminae
Welcome back, Randy-The “two” have spoken 😉
MagistraCarminae
Well, looking at the list of screenplays from the author, he has written two of the movies I most hated in recent years, and do NOT recommend to anyone…”Being John Malcovich” and “Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind”. Am I missing something in my movie viewing? Hmm…
MagistraCarminae
Condolences to Jeff on the UNC loss. Dave is currently beating me by 3 points…
Randy Greenwald
I know several people who liked “Eternal Sunshine.” Can we ever really erase our past? Should we want to? Intriguing questions. Anyway, I don’t watch movies to have my own world view verified. I watch to understand what and how others think — and to glorify God in the gifts he has given even to those who rail against him.
MagistraCarminae
OK- as the dubious “one” person who hated Eternal Sunshine, I feel somewhat compelled to explain what ellicited such a response from me. But realize that I only saw it once, and often my opinion gets highly refined after a second viewing. Also, it was a couple of years ago I think, so my mind is foggy on the details.Dave and I watched it with our college-aged sons, Ben and Tim, who both liked it immensely. I guess I felt that the junk one had to wade through (language, nudity–or near nudity, drug junk, etc.) was simply not worth it for the message delivered. While I agree that it raised interesting questions, its answers were implied and vague, and not “enough” in my opinion to make wading through the garbage worth it. What answers did it give? Love, even flawed, is better than nothing? ugh… And light-hearted? Really? I thought it was utterly depressing.I don’t think I am a prude. I don’t think I’m looking to have my own worldview verified. I think I am asking the question, how big must the gem be in order to make it worth raking through so much muck? I ask this not only when film-viewing, but when reading, too. Sometimes the violence, hopelessness, nihilism, etc., is integral to the gem of wisdom buried beneath. But what did Eternal Sunshine have to share?I think the balance we as believers try to strike between engaging culture and yet not being “of it” is pretty tricky. I think using our legitimate Christian liberty is tricky, because I know my own heart is utterly capable of excusing its sin and claiming to be purer in its motivation than it is in reality. How can, then, a young man or woman keep his or her way pure in this world? How’s that for a thought provoking question…Chris, ducking in NM…
MagistraCarminae
See my post on Confessions of a movie goer…
Randy Greenwald
Thanks for taking up the challenge I threw at you. I am new to this blog thing, and probably should take care that I not be seen as being critical of you. Your comments are well taken, and I regret stirring you up so much that you devoted worthy time to a self defense that at this point maybe three people will actually see… 🙂 I often myself wonder if I am deadened to some things because of the assault on my senses by movies and the like. However, and this is the key, your sons loved “Eternal Sunshine.” Why? It was not because of the near nudity, drug junk, etc. of course. It may be because that they, being younger, think differently than you do. Art, and film is an art, gives us a window of understanding that now and then we need to peer into. I’ve seen a number of movies which I did not like, yet which, though pushing me to the edge of what I can tolerate, have provided such a window. A young man I met who is working on a Ph.D. in literature said that “Fight Club” was a movie that greatly resonated with his generation. I watched it, and much of it I did not enjoy. At points I grimaced. But it resonates with a portion of the people among whom I am to minister. What does this film say about them? Perhaps a great deal if I am willing to listen. Our conversation was enriched because he was astounded that I had been willing to watch movies that meant something to HIM.What answers do movies give? They give the answers that our culture can give, often inadequate. But they form a part of the language of our culture which I believe we need to learn to speak.There is a lot more that I want to say, but as is usual, I know that we are not really that far apart in our thinking. Thanks for your challenge. I hope you still love me!
MagistraCarminae
Dearest Randy,I did not feel attacked, nor defensive, and yes, I still love you! 😉 You will have to toughen up a little if you hope to make a go of life in the blogosphere!You make good points, and like you, I bet we mostly agree. Interesting…Ben and Tim also liked Fight Club– whch I have not seen. Perhaps I need to ask why. It would be interesting if they would chime in here and explain…I wonder sometimes if they “relate” because they see the world differently, or if they relate because their consciences have been seared to some degree, and they are no longer sensitive to brutality. I am enjoying the conversation, even if it is only two way…
Adria
I may not be chiming in, but I am listening…. 🙂
Adria
I can’t yet hear the Joy FM interview, though I am looking forward hearing it when it is published on the website. I did appreciate the article in the newspaper. That was a pretty exciting conversation!! I really wish I could come to the art show, but that would require money. 🙂 Maybe next year!!
MagistraCarminae
Hey, I have continued pondering this question. Are you tired of dealing with it yet? Let me know if you are, and I will let it die.Does art have any responsibility to be normative? By that I mean, does art have any responsibility to point towards the good, the true and the beautiful as what should be, rather than only portraying what is? I am having some incipient thoughts here that I am not finding good words to express yet(at least new and beginning for me, though I suspect that if I took more time to read abut aesthetics, I would find the exact words I need from the writings of others.)I know it is good to appreciate the talents and gifts of others, even when they don’t use them to glorify God consciously– all truth is God’s truth, etc. But I don’t buy the “art for art’s sake” argument any more than I buy anything else existing in some moral vacuum where it is an entity unto itself with no responsibilities to the culture at large. So my question is, what responsibility does the film artist have for presenting normative truth versus reflecting fallen reality? Is he free of the responsibility when, possibly coincidentally or unintendedly, the way “truth” is presented in his film becomes normative for the culture that views it? And again, I struggle with the question of by what standard should we judge the worth of what we are willing to wade through for the sake of enjoying art? How seriously and in what ways do we have an obligation to keep our eyes, ears, etc. from evil? I have had a friend who is film student and lover and amater maker, who makes a distinction between sex and violence in films. Her point, not original with her, but likely “borrowed” from Brian Godawa, is that violence is a public sin which we are all exposed to, and so it is open to public viewing and treatment in film. However, sex is a private thing: it is to be private, and when sexual sins take place, they are private, and never to be open for “viewing”. She makes the point that when violence is portrayed in film, it is always “make believe”, and the actors are not really harmed. But when sex/nudity is portrayed, the actors cannot help but be violated, and neither can the viewers. I find this an interesting distinction, but I may have asked enough questions for today…Chris, pondering in NM
MagistraCarminae
I enjoyed both the article and the interview– and you *did not* sound bored to death. I thought it was great!
MagistraCarminae
Amen and amen…The sermon by John Chrysostom has been sent to me twice in the last two days, so I post is here as further reflection…Easter SermonJohn Chrysostom (349-407)Is there anyone who is a devout lover of God?Let them enjoy this beautiful bright festival!Is there anyone who is a grateful servant?Let them rejoice and enter into the joy of their Lord!Are there any weary with fasting? Let them now receive their wages!If any have toiled from the first hour, let them receive their due reward;If any have come after the third hour, let him with gratitude join in the Feast!And he that arrived after the sixth hour, let him not doubt; for he too shall sustain no loss.And if any delayed until the ninth hour, let him not hesitate; but let him come too.And he who arrived only at the eleventh hour, let him not be afraid by reason of his delay.For the Lord is gracious and receives the last even as the first.He gives rest to him that comes at the eleventh hour, as well as to him that toiled from the first.To this one He gives, and upon another He bestows.He accepts the works as He greets the endeavor.The deed He honors and the intention He commends.Let us all enter into the joy of the Lord! First and last alike receive your reward; rich and poor, rejoice together!Sober and slothful, celebrate the day!You that have kept the fast, and you that have not, rejoice today for the Table is richly laden!Feast royally on it, the calf is a fatted one.Let no one go away hungry. Partake, all, of the cup of faith.Enjoy all the riches of His goodness!Let no one grieve at his poverty, for the universal kingdom has been revealed.Let no one mourn that he has fallen again and again; for forgiveness has risen from the grave.Let no one fear death, for the Death of our Savior has set us free.He has destroyed it by enduring it.He destroyed Hades when He descended into it.He put it into an uproar even as it tasted of His flesh.Isaiah foretold this when he said,”You, O Hell, have been troubled by encountering Him below.”Hell was in an uproar because it was done away with.It was in an uproar because it is mocked.It was in an uproar, for it is destroyed.It is in an uproar, for it is annihilated.It is in an uproar, for it is now made captive.Hell took a body, and discovered God. It took earth, and encountered Heaven.It took what it saw, and was overcome by what it did not see.O death, where is thy sting?O Hades, where is thy victory?Christ is Risen, and you, o death, are annihilated!Christ is Risen, and the evil ones are cast down!Christ is Risen, and the angels rejoice!Christ is Risen, and life is liberated!Christ is Risen, and the tomb is emptied of its dead;for Christ having risen from the dead,is become the first-fruits of those who have fallen asleep.To Him be Glory and Power forever and ever. Amen!
Staci Thomas
Randy-Thanks so much for your marriage advice and for being real. I’ve been watching Piper’s latest sermon series on marriage and he stresses that marriage is not about being in love, but instead is about convenant keeping. This is all helpful stuff when what the world offers is fleeting fluff.Thanks again-Staci
Gus
Agree with Randy and Stacy that love alone is not enough to stay married. Emerson Eggerichs titles his introduction to _Love and respect_ “Love alone is not enough”. The book’s subtitle is: the love she most desires, the respect he desperately needs. The book is about obeying Ephesians 5.33.
Kathleen Hamilton
Well, now that Chris has spilled the beans on this blog, more people wmay be chiming in.Chris, I believe those ideas came not from Brian Godawa, but Wayne Wilson in his book Worldly Amusements. I tend to agree more with you on this subject, and can’t quite figure out why my eldest son likes movies like Fight Club (which I have never seen). I know he has said he wants to see Eternal Sunshine, but don’t know if he has yet. Nevertheless, I wonder why young Christians will see movies with sex scenes–I don’t care how “relevant” to today’s culture these movies are, I just can’t see the justification of that when it’s so clearly condemned in scripture. Violence and drug use (and yes, even profanity) may be a different story, though I choose not to spend my time watching movies filled with those things.As a matter of fact, I could live my entire life without watching another movie–I do enjoy some, but they aren’t tops on any of my lists. So, why is it that young people today are so attracted to them? It can’t be just that they have grown up in the media age–I did too! I watched far more television in my youth than my kids ever did. But we also did not keep them from watching movies–so it’s not like it was forbidden fruit. Maybe it’s just people he has been exposed to at college–most of his weird ideas have come since he went to college ;-).
Gail and Keith
Gail here. You and Barb are cute as as a button–or, is it buttons? Thanks for those thoughts on marriage which was a timely reminder for me of the line we tacked on to the end of our wedding vows nearly 34 years ago, “with Jesus Christ continuing to be the foundation of our lives together.” G
MagistraCarminae
What a great quote!I remember you once, after listening to a message at a cartain funeral, making me promise to shoot you if you ever had so little to say. My promise still stands, and I’ve had no need to do so!:-)
Adria
Remember this as you spend time around me and talk to me over the next couple of months dad. Remember your many prayers and mine as well. Then see God’s amazing blessings which none of us deserve. Love you!
A sinner's 2 cents
Having grown up in a legalistic, fundamentalist background, and even though I’m a presbyterian now, I still find it difficult to estrange myself from the mindset that somehow my performance moves God to bless me. It’s like if I have my quiet time in the morning, God will bless what I do the rest of the day. But if I fail to spent time quiet time with God, then somehow the rest of the day seems to far apart. Even though this kind of thinking misses the purpose of the gospel, I still sometimes find myself in that mode. The fact of the matter is, the gospel is not just to be preached to unconverted sinners only, but to regenerate christians as well. In Christ is our only acceptance. Thanks for the post Randy.Tom
Gus
This subject raises conflicting emotions in me. On the one hand, you write “One can be humble…and never have a quiet time.” That gives me an excuse for laxity. (I realize that is not your intention.)On the other, you write about the benefits of QT; then I feel guilty when I neglect this spiritual disclipine and virtue.–ae
MagistraCarminae
We were just talking about escape last night in my women’s bible study. We are reading a book together called “Peace Making Women”, and in the section on “Conflicts Within”, the authors discuss ungodly shame (which is a feeling that is not directly correlated to a real sense of guilt), depression and fear. “Escape” as a route of avoidance was one of the things we discussed. Elijah tried it when he was plain worn out after Mt. Carmel. More than a few of us have used this to procrastinate on dealing with the real issues, so I think you are in good company!! As we discussed this last night, we decided that the antedote to those things that make us want to escape is to remember who we are in Christ: purchased, loved first, held onto by a mighty and Sovereign hand, delighted in. Sometimes remembering that that requires real discipline, coralling my feelings, and gathering my thoughts on the Truth, and that’s hard work! It’s much easier to read my novel…*sigh*I’ll pray for you, and you pray for me! 😉
MagistraCarminae
Woo Hoo! I finally not only “get it”, but I finally “did it”! This RSS for Dummies was exactly what I needed. Thanks, Ole Buddy, Ole Pal! 🙂
Randy Greenwald
What’s with this “Ole” bit. Is that a Spanish cheer for me or something? :-)Glad this helped. Surprised with all the techies in your family that it took so long!
MagistraCarminae
The problem with all the techies in my family is that the ones that are young and probably “get” it are the ones that are now pretty much gone from home 🙁 My old techie is too busy…
MagistraCarminae
While this is an excellent reminder, I think perhaps he undervalues the dimension of fellowship and accountability that comes from committed, like-minded relationships where the gospel does reign. I simply don’t think it is impossible to have friendships which continue to challenge us in gospel ways that involve like-minded people. Yes, we run the risk of being self-insulating. But we are to have real fellowship with one another as members of the body, and that includes sitting “at table” together!
Randy Greenwald
Chris, the key word in my statement and the author of the blog in question is ‘all’. No one is suggesting we abandon Christian relationships and friendships. But as we say about so many things, when a good thing becomes the only thing it becomes a bad thing. Most Christians I know are not in danger of abandoning their Christians friends for non-Christians friends. It is the opposite problem we confront. Jesus was known as a friend of sinners. I am not sure too many of the people I know (me included) could be convicted on such a charge.
MagistraCarminae
Point well taken. Excuse the knee-jerk-type reaction! 😉 I think I respond out of my own frustration with believers for whom fellowship is seeing each other once a week at worship, and otherwise have little to no fellowship or opportunity for body life.
Staci
It is definitely my experience that there is no correlation between my behavior and my quiet time. Often, I sin magnificently on days when I have had fabulous quiet times. Other days, I feel closer to God than ever before and I realize I didn’t have a quiet time that morning. Where I do see the correlation is wanting more of His Word when I do have a quiet time. When I heed the call of the alarm and I start meditating on a passage, I never, ever want to stop. I’m never looking at the clock saying, “Man, when is this hour going to be over so I can stop?” When I’m in the thick of it, I always want more. Such experiences should make me jump up at the call of the alarm EVERY morning, but consistency is a constant battle for me. So, I guess what I’m saying is that quiet times really do “put me in the way of grace.” When I’m in the “way” (i.e. a quiet time), I’m experiencing “grace” (wanting more of Him). It is only when I’m exercising the spiritual discipline that I want Him more. Because it is clear that when I’m not in the “way”, I’m not necessarily apt to want more of Him on the merits of my own thoughts about Him.My friend Margie and I have somewhat heated discussions about this topic regularly. She won’t make any decisions unless she is “prayed up” as she says and she seems to just freeze and fall apart if she doesn’t have a quiet time. I tell her it is becoming a work in her life. She tells me I don’t put enough importance on it. I think the spiritual discipine of quiet time is really important, but my sinful nature really battles a seven-day a week consistency with it.So, thanks for putting it that way – that it puts us in the way of grace. I heard you say that in a past Sunday School class, but I didn’t really think about it much until I read this blog.Staci, who will once again beg and plead at the throne of God tonight to help her wake up at 4:30 so she can have a quiet time in the morning…
adrianna
Not being an English teacher, or even an English major, I yet find myself being a pedantic rule follower. As a result, I probably – sometimes (or often?) – miss the point of the communication. I like his point re consistency. Perhaps we can amend the familiar statement about England and the US being “divided by a common language” to “divided by grammar rules.” Eats, Shoots, and Leaves is a humorous treatment of grammar and punctuation. The author is British.adri
Matthew
It scares me from time to time how similar our thought patterns are, I do however think it is a good thing. Great blog and I will tell “my good friend” she is famous =)
adrianna
But look at it this way: she can’t very well wear a graduation gown to social events or church, can she? The pretty dress will look so much better on those occasions.
Matthew
She didn’t buy the dress to wear at graduation, she had a graduation so she could buy a dress…. silly father…
MagistraCarminae
I’m looking forward to your version of the “events”, as I have already spoken with your eldest…Chris
Mu
Hi, Randy.Good to “see” you here.– Phil
A sinner's 2 cents
Thanks for the link to the General Assembly. I didn’t know they were broadcasting it. I was able to catch the later portion of the discussion concerning the FV,NPP report. Now that the report has been adopted, what does that mean? How does that change things?
A sinner's 2 cents
Hey Randy,Sounds like you learned a lot this week with Colin. You are right that trust is learned. Colin, in a mysterious way, does trust God. He does have faith, and that faith will grow through time as he is nurtured in the covenant community. God is his God just as He promised you, and you can be assured of that fact, even though Colin is still young. He will not belong to God any less or more when he is older. Sounds hard to believe, but we should believe it.
Nejcik
I’m guessing Jonathan Edwards, not sure whether or not whether it’s “Charity and its Fruits,” the one book of his that I own – and which has been scaring me away too. I’ll give it another shot (right after I copy and paste some of that quote into Google to see if I’m right).
MagistraCarminae
Someone beat me to it! :-(It is also sitting on my shelves, only glanced at. But then, I hold to the attitude expressed by Roger Nicole when he was asked about his rather extensive (4,000+ volume) library…”Books are to be referenced, not read…”:-)Chris
Nejcik
Well, I got the author. The other guy that Google found quoting it was somebody arguing in favor of contemporary worship music
Nejcik
Don’t feel bad, Chris, it was only 6 minutes! BTW it’s not “Charity and its Fruits.”
A sinner's 2 cents
I like Edwards and I hate him at the same time. Several years back I started reading the book in question, but couldn’t finish it: Mainly because it was too long and felt a bit redundant after few sections. But I do remember how reading some parts of the book made me feel. I remember how after the end of one of the sections, I was on my knees and weeping for shame of my lack of true affections for Christ. I like Edwards a lot, but I haven’t read much else by him since. The thing with Edwards is that he makes me feel horrible about myself(which I could do without his help). I find that whenever I read Edwards, I feel so little compared to him. It’s like a guilt trip every time I open a book by him. Not that a reminder of our deficience is a bad thing, but I can only take so much. Maybe someday, when I’m feeling good about myself, I’ll revisit him.Tom
Gail and Keith
Yes, do keep it going! And, we’ll refer others. Now, let me figure out how to do that! G
MagistraCarminae
Do keep on keeping on here- I refer folks all the time, and you may have a larger readership than you think…
Fiona
Great-it’s unanimous!I currently subscribe to 4 Blogs which I thoroughly enjoy.One, is obviously yours and another is a photo-journalist, who is also a Christian. The other blogs are by a shepherdess and last but not least…an Australian artist who lives in Tuscany, Italy. When time allows, I enjoy reading these blogs for the following reasons; I am encouraged by the Christians who post and are willing to share a little bit about themselves and what God is teaching them etc. Although the other blogs might be written by non-Christians??, I am continually entertained by their comments and very interested in the information they share related to my topic of interest…(not to mention their photos and pictures of their art work!). Although I am only a “spectator” when it comes to blogging (this is my first comment ever!), I have come to appreciate the time and effort that must be involved, in creating not only an attractive post, but most importantly, an informative and interesting one! When the situation arises, I will gladly recommend your blog to my friends! Keep them coming!
Fiona
I forgot(oops!) to mention the “moral of my story” which is this:Someone might come across your blog because of a “catchy phrase” or impressed by a photo, but what you have written could be the first introduction a person might have to hearing about Christ and how He has blessed you, or what He has taught you. You may never know the full impact this might have on someone’s life. Worth the effort? Definitely.
Gus
yes – keep on keeping on; we enjoy reading – we read all your posts – tho’ we don’t comment frequently. you know we’ve spread the word half way round the world.
Gus
We are saying WAW as we listen to Mozart’s clarinet concerto, and have to say it also as we consider God’s goodness.g&a
Randy Greenwald
Okay, okay, okay. All my friends say keep at it. If my Mom was still alive, she’d probably say the same thing. Some of you I did not know were reading still, so this is good to know. You guys are a huge encouragement to me. Thanks.
Gus
Oops, I meant WOW.
Gus
There may not be a grand-daughter if her daughter or daughter-in-law has an abortion.
A sinner's 2 cents
If Guliani wins the republican primary, would you vote for him in the big election? He seems pretty weak on the abortion issue.
Randy Greenwald
What effect really does presidential politics have on this issue? We’ve had Reagan and two Bushes since Roe and still have abortion. Greater impact comes as people’s minds are changed at ground level — perhaps even through side comments in the occasional novel. Would I vote for Guliani? When the time comes, it will depend upon the choices.
Matthew
Define “weak” from what I have heard he is pro-choice. But I agree, the change will not come from a president. The deeper issue I might have with Guliani is the fact that he has been married 3 times and his current wife was a live-in girlfriend. I believe this speaks strongly to his moral character, if he is willing to brake a marriage oath can we trust him to lead a country? On the other hand you can not claim that he doesn’t love his country, from what I have heard his actions on and after 9/11 were nothing short of amazing.
Gus
As heart-wrenching and traumatic as the death of a newborn is, I think it must be equally difficult – if not more so – for a woman to place her child for adoption. My heart also aches for the grandparents who “have a grandchild but don’t have a grandchild.”I agree that women who choose life and adoption for their pre-born babies are to be greatly admired for that decision. –adri
Gus
“‘Tis a puzzlement” about the quickly-ripening fruit; never thought of specially treated grocery store air, though. Need a good banana bread/cake recipe?–ae
Gus
Oh – and did you know? — Time flies like an arrow; fruit flies like a banana.–ae
MagistraCarminae
LOL! Trust those Puritans to do things thoroughly and in order…I read this in college, as a newlywed, and a baby Christian, and new to the Reformed faith. I don’t remember despairing any more about this than anything else I read, and a good deal less than I probably should have! 😉
Adria
So, I have a book to reccomend. I have only read part of it, but what I have read I found fascinating. I have also heard one of the authors (Scot Roley) speak. I highly reccomend this book.God’s Neighborhood: A Hopeful Journey in Racial Reconciliation and Community Renewal by Scott Roley, James Isaac Elliott, and Michael Card (Paperback – Jun 2004) Adria
Gail and Keith
Check with RGB–she has a number of books she’d recommend. I think the topic of your next lunch series is most excellent. One book is, “More Than Equals–Racial Healing for the Sake of the Gospel” by Spencer Perkins and Chris Rice. I’m part way through it; it’s excellent.Gail
Fiona
This website is a great resource:WWW.SERMONAUDIO.COMHere are some sermons, somewhat related to your topic:The Problem of Violence by Dr. Frank McClelland (03/14/2004)God Knows Our Hearts, also by Dr. Frank McClelland (11/22/1998)The Duty of Impartiality in the Treatment of Others – 11 byMr. David McClelland (04/17/2005)Love for Neighbors – 21 also by David McClelland (09/17/2006)A Christian View of Gov’t.& Politics #5: Gov’t & Race Relations by Dr. Stacey H. Taylor |(02/11/2005)Life-Giver: Valuing People by Stacey M. Cox (05/14/2006)
A sinner's 2 cents
Hey Randy,Thanks for the post(man). I love that guy. He is an intelligent and thoughtful critic of our entertainment culture. I’ll have to check out his “Bridge to the 18th century”. It sounds interesting. Is it as good as “Amusing ourselves to Death”?Tom
Randy Greenwald
It would be hard to top “Amusing Ourselves to Death”. However “Bridge” is provocative and poses some challenges for how to do ministry in the current age. He is not a Christian, and he places too much confidence in the rationalism of those who have gone before us. However, it is a good book. I do recommend it.
Gus
I too like Postman; Amusing Ourselves to Death is worth a second read. I found it fascinating that though not a Christian he had such a good analysis and wrote an excellent critique of televanglism. His thoughts on US politics and elections were perceptive and, I think, quite exact.–adri
Fiona
I believe there has to be commitment for there to be a progressive and successful relationship, within the church community.I also realize that it’s not always easy to have everyone ‘on board’ because we are all so different: e.g. personalities, cultural backgrounds, how we were raised (meaning what values are important to us), different levels of Christian maturity and development, not to mention what is going on in our personal lives, and what our needs might be etc., and although these factors might not dictate as to how we will commit to a particular church community, they can influence our decisions and our level of commitment. So in answer to your question: ‘Mutual promise’…”Is this what it takes to establish, build & maintain community?I believe boasting about one’s commitment in a marriage, doesn’t let one off the hook. It’s whether or not a person is fully engaged in, or involved in the relationship, not to mention the depth of their love for the other person. If not, you are just biding time. Thus, the same principle applies to the church community. [This is a big topic, so trying to condense my answer is proving to be quite difficult.]:) The reality is, we live in a society today that if certain conditions are not met within a relationship (whether personal or public) people tend to step out or leave quite easily, BUT true commitment (I believe) is being involved, being faithful, being consistent and being loyal EVEN when it is difficult. I believe obedience (to God) and LOVE should be at the basis of our personal relationships and also our relationships within our church community. ALTHOUGH, I do recognize that if there is only one person in the relationship who is commited and shares these beliefs, disagreements can sometimes become more serious, which is the same for the church. IF, after prayer and genuine effort to try to come to an agreement on things and conflict is starting to fray a person’s relationship with other church members, then perhaps it’s time for that person to go somewhere else. How one leaves a church under these conditions, is also a way for one to demonstrate Christian maturity and grace, instead of going off like a school kid in a huff. In summary(lol), what Michael Card proposed with his group of friends is quite noble, but I’m not sure that agreeing to not move within a certain time frame, is a realistic goal, especially when it comes to a large number of people within a church setting.I do admire them though for their perseverance and their COMMITMENT! 🙂
A sinner's 2 cents
The church is our mother, outside of which there is no ordinary possibility of salvation. It is not so much about commitment as union. Commitment flows out of our tie to the church. I’m not disagreeing with what has already been said, just thinking out loud. It’s a difficult question. It would be an easier issue if those who leave a church, never join another one. The scenario changes when they simply change churches. There certainly is a lack of commitment among american evangelical christians for their local assemblies, but then again, most evangelical christians don’t really believe that the visible church is necessary for their salvation as long as they have jesus and their bible.
Geoffsnook
Randy,You are exactly correct. I don’t think that God has finished saving people in this area! There are still ‘sheep not yet of this fold’ in Bradenton. So there are those out there for whom Christ will be welcomed more preciously than a cinnamon roll. At the same time, they may not welcome Him as quickly. People may not see their need for Christ right away, but they might see the need for justice in the world, security, purpose, meaning, community-all of which Christ is the answer. I think these are like the aroma of the cinamon roll. And people usually smell before buying. Once they see that the smell is really coming from the roll (gospel), those whom God has called WILL go all in.
Tami@ourhouse
Randy,Thank you for your transparency. I too, often forget just how attractive the gospel is. The Bible tells us in the book of Romans(1.18-20)”…what can be known about God is plain to them, because God has shown it to them.” This text encourages me in evangelism because I can trust that people already have some sense of God’s existence. Whether they are suppressing the truth or seeking after God both people know to some degree God exist. This means we can share Christ with confidence knowing that God has made himself known to them already in “general revelation.”With all of that said please pray for me becuase I am a absolute failure at sharing the gospel. I work very hard at it but see little fruit. I will pray for us both to not loose heart but to press forward in the work of the gospel. Take care my friend, Scott Ellison
Gail and Keith
Man’s inhumanity to man has always been a source of fear/horror for me. The princes and principalities of the air do not elicit that same emotion because I know who my Deliverer is. In Him there is peace. G
Tami@ourhouse
Wonderful quote. Thanks for sharing. Scott E.
Mu
“Fair and biblical way” as in “May God smite my enemy”? Or the mark of Cain?Seems the more interesting question is how have so many Christians been deceived by this war criminal administration? Or why are the mechanics of “pious fraud” so easy because the pious are so easily manipulated?Have to wonder.Hi, Randy. Email me if you want.phlbbrtn@gmail.comWe could try to catch up after 24 years. Just a thought.Phil
MagistraCarminae
Amen and amen!
Rebekah
I got to know a very nice 70+ year old lady through a project she wanted us to do at work (now lets me call her Grandma Dunwoody, and she calls me her granddaughter), but one time she was visiting my office, and a white man came in and I was very accomodating with him and practically bent over backwards to schedule an appointment for him with my boss, and I shook his hand before he left. After he left, she told me, “You never shook my hand when I first came in, that’s because of this,” and she tugged on her brown skin. I got a sick feeling in the pit of my stomach and I wanted to hide under my desk, because in the back of my mind I knew she was right. I may not hate black people, but I hadn’t started viewing (…and maybe still haven’t) blacks as my 100% equals. I realized that I was gregarious and excessively accomodating to the white visitors in my office, but I didn’t extend the same courtesies to our black visitors. And this was just last year.
MagistraCarminae
How wonderful to have Bill there! Hs ministry has been such a blessing to us, too, thanks to you sharing about him with us way out here in the boonies…:-)Chris
Randy Greenwald
This is the very kind of observation that we are wanting to fuel the sessions we do. Mental judgments based upon race impact even the best of us. Thanks for sharing this.
MagistraCarminae
OK, if this caught your interest, how about this: http://www.worldwidewords.org/nl/bhgp.htm#N3I am currently mourning the coming death of the hyphen. This site is a wonderful repository of interesting, little-known facts about words and language, and you might get a kick out of it!Chris
MagistraCarminae
I agree with your main point here, Randy: we need to be able to communicate to our own generation in a way that it can understand. The truth of the gospel is clear in all generations: surely we can communicate that clearly!On the other hand, however, we are a people who have in many ways followed our culture’s obsession with visual imagery and sound-bites, and forgotten that we are called to be people of the Word. God chose to communicate to us most clearly through that medium of the written word. That should change the way we think about language, with its abilities and potentialities, and cause us to question our investment in it, or lack thereof. I sometimes see in myself the pull to watch the movie instead of read the book because it is easier. But the medium *is* in some ways, the message. Movies are excellent tools of communication, as are other forms of visual art, but they don’t communicate in the same way literature does. If we all fail to make the investment needed to learn from literature, we are all the poorer for it. And Edwards is a good example. I think it is a noble and worthy goal to make accessible a current and relevant book on marriage in a readily accessible style. But let’s also encourage one another to mine the depths of Edwards, or possibly a book from 1842 on marriage if its content is worthy. Like classical music or fine art, the more you are exposed to its depth and riches, the more accessible its style may become.
Randy Greenwald
Chris,We are not in disagreement, but we may be pulling in slightly different directions. Yes, God has given to us a word, and that does in great respects sanctify written language as a means of communication. However, do we not see in that word God revealing himself through a variety of means, not all of it written? The tabernacle was a visual message, as was the Passover and now the Lord’s supper. The prophets did not just write, they spoke. And sometimes their speaking was dramatized.Jesus never wrote a word. He spoke, and he often spoke in highly visual imagery, accommodating his words to the listeners.We need to take care that we not move from the sanctification of words to an idolatry or tyranny of words. You know that I would love to elevate my own ability to understand great writers, great thinkers, great music, great art. I urge people to read Edwards and Calvin and Owen and others.However, an 1842 book on marriage? That will hold some interest to those of us who want to see marriage issues set in the context of time, but it is of little to no use to a young couple wanting to learn how to love one another. There is only one Edwards. But there are dozens if not hundreds of accessible books on the beauty and challenge of the marriage relationship. Let’s not add a stumbling block for a couple who need desperately to know what to do when their expectations of marriage crash into a reality they never considered. Let’s save exercising their intellect for another day.Thanks for reading and commenting.
Anonymous
I don’t believe the age of the words should be the basis of our judgment of a book. If the author speaks [the] truth, that truth will carry through the generations.The pastor overseeing the counseling must see something in this older book. Perhaps its something that can be uniquely applied by this couple. Assuming he as suggested the book before, he is probably not oblivious to this issue of “relatability”. I would be interested to know what denomination (one area where I’m pessimistic) and what book it was.I don’t mean to take up an antagonistic view but I think we can miss out on a lot if we make judgments based on what things sound like or look like in stead of what they say. I’m not saying accept, I’m saying judge.In the grand scheme of things 1842 wasn’t that long ago. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1842. When I have questions or doubts about marriage the book I turn to again and again was written probably closer to 42.
Randy Greenwald
Anonymous,I confess that I should not rush to judgment regarding the pastor who chose a book with archaic language for his counseling purposes. No doubt he sees something in that book that is worth capturing. But I WAS that guy once, a guy who thought that nothing good ever arose after the Confederacy fell (okay, I’m exaggerating, but not much). In this case, we are not discussing the Trinity, but how a couple relates in the commitments or marriage. On this subject, there is much good that is written that is not only accessible but which also takes into account the modern situation in which this couple will find themselves actually living. Some things do change.As for the Book written closer to 42, I suspect we both share a commitment to it. I’m grateful, though, that we have translations of it, in a style both accurate and readable for modern eyes and ears. Or perhaps we should make all our people learn Greek or, forsooth, forcibly adapt themselves to the Shakespearian English of the KJV.
Geoffsnook
I think you have some good thoughts. My buddy told me that the guy who oversees RUF ministries once said that one time each year tons of our neighbors actually come to us. It’s Halloween. Does it make sense to close our doors to them? I’m looking forward to the few who actually come to my doors, in hopes I can meet their parents and offer a last minute invitation to my neighborhood cookout. I just printed out a few more for this occasion.
E.D.
You might be interested in this short article: http://www.biblicalhorizons.com/open-book/no-28-concerning-halloween/for next year!
AH
Well Pastor Greenwald I am glad to see you’ve gotten yourself a blog! I always thought you would be good with a blog. How are things at Hope going along? How is the family? Things here in mississippi are well as we are leaving *hopefully* very soon! I will look forward to coming by and reading your stuff. We think of the church often, give our love to everyone.The Hatfields
Randy Greenwald
Yes, Arin, this is me. I don’t have time to do this well. Thanks for dropping by. I use to loiter around your blog, until it seemed to no longer accept my loitering! I’d love to update you on life here, but this is not the place. Send your e-mail to rg7878@gmail.com so I can touch base with you properly. Great to hear from you. My love to Corey and to the kids.r
Geoffsnook
Wow. I had never even heard of the film. But I usually don’t hear about them until they drop into my price range! I can spend 6-7 bucks on a movie or spend that amount on fishing lures-which last a few hours longer!Regardless, I hope that Christians can intelligently dialog with others and ask questions with our neighbors instead of just picketing and protesting movies. However, parents ought to be very discerning. But like the Da Vinci code, I imagine that it could produce some good dialog that wouldn’t have normally been had. That film had Christians scared, and it probably did more good than harm. Christ’s church still moved forward.
MagistraCarminae
Excellent article, friend. Well done.
cavman
So, are the Christians who are ready to protest (I too have gotten the e-mails)falling into the stereotype the author presented as the Magisterium- are we guilty of an media inquisition?Sadly, we often do much to maintain the rep of those who are just out to make others miserable instead of revealing the “sweetness and excellency” of Christ.
Nejcik
Eight drafts? You mean, like, you actually DRAFT these things? Wait, no, that came out wrong – from reading them it’s obvious that you do. But my impression from most other bloggers is that they just kinda shoot from the hip.This is the third or fourth post of yours that I’ve seen expressing some kind of angst about whether you should keep this thing up, how many people read it, etc. I appreciate your finely crafted prose; I figure your discipline in writing blog posts is a result of your discipline in writing sermons. And I realize that as a pastor you have a duty to be theologically sound. But maybe some of the angst would go away if you just turned it down a notch and just let ‘er rip. Maybe you don’t need to apply quite as much intellectual and thological rigor to a blog post as you do to a sermon, or a devotional, or a pastoral letter?OK, so the obvious response to this is “Oh yeah, it’s just a blog, it only has to be about 80 percent right, maybe 60.” But I think you know what I’m getting at. Maybe try looking at it more as a casual conversation than as writing. It’s a question of genre, and I’m just wondering if you’re mis-applying the rules of another genre to what you’re doing here.
Randy Greenwald
I am obsessive, that I readily admit. But when I say ‘eight drafts’, that does not mean I have eight fully written statements to edit and post. It means I have scribbled down the basic ideas for eight posts. I also admit that I must read and rewrite what I post before I hit the ‘publish’ button to avoid great embarrassment. My initial work can often be ludicrous. (And I do need to exercise some care. I mean, after all, there may be professional writers out there reading my blog….)That all said, your advice is wise. “Let ‘er rip.” Now that sounds fun. My angst is not really about blogging, but about the basic use of my time, which for me is always a tension. (You should see my e-mail ‘to reply’ mailbox. Stuffed full. People all over waiting for replies from me.)So, I need to hit a rhythm, and will do so. Soon. Maybe.Hmmm. Maybe blogger should change the button labeling from ‘Publish’ to ‘Let ‘er Rip’!rrg
MagistraCarminae
What a beautiful group! And what a wonderful and exhausting day! Happy Thanksgiving!
Gus
you post that and expect us to listen to a serious sermon two days later??? Ha!Ha!ae
Randy Greenwald
Nope. Two days from now would be Saturday. I expect you to listen to no serious sermons (at least from me) on Saturday.
Gus
Pfft! I’m old but I can still count; I should have know better than to comment before breakfast and when my bg was already a bit low. But, knowing you, even if I say three days… you’ll probably arrange for Geoff to preach on Sunday. — ae
Gus
I meant *known* – now I can’t type either, though I do know how to spell. — ae
Rebekah
I haven’t laughed that hard in…well, I don’t know that I have!
Gus
wise words from Mohler — and you. –ae
Tami@ourhouse
So great to see the whole family. Congrats on the future additional Greenwalds! Your post reminded me- We met you guys after Thanksgiving weekend- you and Barb invited us over for an impromptu lunch of leftover turkey sandwiches after church. You pulled out your giant table- great fellowship! One question- how does an introverted mom of four young children recharge? Please address this issue in your next post. 🙂
Staci Thomas
Well, as an introverted mother of four young children (yes…I am an introvert…I crave alone time…I call Give-Me-Alone-Time the Sixth Love Language), I find that reading and running are the only ways to effectively “recharge”. Anna Karenina is providing a lovely escape these days. My early morning exercise routine is a great way to find energy when I thought there was none. By far, though, reading the Bible is my lifeline. I’m at the point where I crave it and can’t live without it, and I know that my four darling children have brought me to that point. I craved far lesser things years ago when I had more time and less children.The following question is one that I am often asked: “Where do you find the time to read and exercise?” My answer is always this: “Early morning and late at night.” That answer is ALWAYS follwed with this question: “How much sleep do you need?” My reply usually goes something like this: “It is not sleep I need. It is the coffee. Lots and lots of coffee.” :-)Staci
MagistraCarminae
I laugh at the “Kidstoned” commercial, and at Staci’s “coffee” comment. As an extrovert, I may not be the best to suggest anything… but time with the Lord in peace and quiet seems only to happen for any of us early or late, and that seems important for all of us as moms, either introverts or extroverts.I would also suggest you look for ways to keep your schedule simple, and train even the littles among your kids that everyone in the house has “quiet” time: a time when, for 10 minutes at first, and then larger mounts of time, everyone is expected to be quiet in ones own bed (sleeping, looking at books, or other quiet, individual activities). I used this, and have known lots of moms of big families for whom this was a precious quiet break in the day!And when I needed to recharge and couldn’t seem to find the time or opportunity to do it, I tried to remember that the Lord brings rest when we need it, and if He wasn’t bringing it, I probably didn’t need it as much as I thought I did. :-)Praying for you today-Chris in NM
Anonymous
Good advice in the previous two comments. In addition: ask a trusted granny type in your church or neighborhood to come and spend an hour (each week?) with your children, to read to them or watch a good video. She’d probably be delighted.Set a timer and stick to the agreed upon time so that you don’t abuse her willingness to help. Your children must know you are not to be interrupted except in case of fire, broken bones, or other great bodily harm. Besides reading the Bible, prayer, and meditation, take time to read a novel. Anna Karenina is great but something like Jan Karon’s Mitford series with its short chapters may be more do-able in limited time slots.Do you knit, crochet, or do needlework? A simple project can be great therapy. Again, stay within the time limit; it’s tempting to do “just one more row….”One hour a week isn’t much time, but it’s a start. It may even expand to more time as mutually agreed upon.
MagistraCarminae
Today I ran across another reference to this:http://beyondourreach.blogspot.com/2007/12/uganda-update-and-call-to-prayer.htmlPraying-Chris in NM
Gail and Keith
It’s time for the Somber and Dull blogger to begin posting now that there are no weddings planned for the foreseeable future. G
MagistraCarminae
Hurrah! Welcome back!
Gail
Ditto! G
David
Make it 80% (4 out of 5)!
Gus&Adri
I read the book a longtime ago and have forgotten many of the details of what happens after the crime, except for the horrible desperation of the criminal. I think you encapsulated the summary of the book in your analysis of the motivation.GE
Rebekah
hooray, i was wondering when you were going to write something again!
MagistraCarminae
Like Gus&Adri (whichever one they are…) I read it many years ago. It is a tough book to take, and is about the way the beliefs of the criminal affect what he has done. If you hang in to the end, you get a slight glimmer of hope in the last sentence or two…D. is tough for me to read, also. I prefer fluff and clarity, but D. makes you think and wonder at the fallen nature of our world, and where redemption is to be had. My eldest son would wax eloquently about the beauty of tragedy because of how it reflects the nature of man and this world and our sense of what ought to happen but doean’t. Hang in there!
TulipGirl
No, not that kind of emerging.I guffawed, seriously, when I read that.
TulipGirl
“. . .I could avoid feeling directly attacked and could feel superior to those who are closer to that segment. And seeing that in me hurts. . . . This sense of Christian superiority is the very thing which is exposed, and which I so easily fall into.”Yeouch. While I haven’t seen that movie, I have seen that reaction in myself in regards to the foibles/failings of brothers and sisters in the Lord.
Fiona
Happy Birthday Barb!Wow! We share the same birthdate!…Although I’m only 29! ;-)Hope you’re being spoiled today!(Pass this message on, eh!)Cheers,Fiona
snowbot
Happy birthday from Keith and Kristen!
TulipGirl
*mush, mush*
Gus&Adri
Happy Birthday! Sorry to be so late, even after it was in yesterday’s bulletin.We wish you many more in health and happiness.The E’s
MagistraCarminae
Happy birthday, Barb!I like you being 32 because of what that makes me :-)Love,Chris
snowbot
I’m glad you enjoyed Match Point (I think I recommended it to you, yes?). Like you, I don’t agree with the film’s conclusions about luck but found it to be a fascinating film nonetheless. Perhaps reading Dostoevsky would provide further insight into it. I think I need to read him anyway, since his name keeps creeping up on me lately!
MagistraCarminae
I want to intrude on a date night…watch movies and go to Starbucks to talk…What fun!
Randy Greenwald
Keith – yes, you recommended it. After I got it home and before I watched it, I wondered why I had listened to you!and Chris, you are welcome any Friday night. We’d be happy to have you!
Rebekah
I think that’s a good assessment of the traditional/modern/seeker friendly sort of situation as it relates to the religous climate we’re in. Since people aren’t seeking out churches, the style of the church isn’t important–it’s more the people that are in it, and that issue forth from it. As people go forth from the church and encounter people outside of it, that’s the more meaningful reflection of the Body of Christ that people are looking at when they think of Christians. If there are authentic people and relationships to be had, and they are truly seeking Christ (or initially just some kind of meaning in life), I really don’t think they care if the church is contemporary or traditional.
Gail and Keith
Yes, it is a correct assessment of today’s religious culture. Traditional? Contemporary? Change the name of the church to entice people to come in the doors? It will attract some people, but what will reach people is the individual church member going out into the world and engaging the culture; becoming involved in the lives of those around us. G
Anonymous
Hey Randy,Interesting topic. I agree with you that the issue is not so much traditional vs contemporary, but that our society in general simply does not see church as a necessity. Perhaps that’s where we need to begin thinking: how do we make them see their need? I also agree with Rebekah and Gail. Individual christians need to be good neighbors, good friends, good workers, good citizens, good people. If they like us, and we are a reflection of our church, then they may like our church as well.Tom
TulipGirl
It’s very. . . encouraging. . . to have someone who has both “gone the distance” in parenting as well as still being in the thick of it to affirm the path that we are traveling along with our children.And I certainly to appreciate you sharing your experience and wisdom as a pastor and father.
TulipGirl
And I say “traveling” because I know that we’ve neither arrived nor will the path be free of valleys. . .
MagistraCarminae
Excellent post and excellent comment. It is so very easy for us to worry about pleasing other men, and fool ourselves into thinking we are pleasing God. And when we manage to keep up the illusion of “perfection” for a time (and we can never do it indefinitely) all we do is alienate ourselves from our kids, and from the others we could be encouraging or helping to bear burdens, and from a real and honest relationship with the Lord. It is so self-destructive, and so very easy to do.
Gus&Adri
Like the book – and the boy’s name of course 😉 – as well as your analogy and the lessons you’ve been taught and then shared with your readers. Yes the story is easier than Crime and Punishment.ae
MagistraCarminae
Sending hugs your way, and praising God for you-Dave and Chris
Gail and Keith
Thanks for your post, Randy. Even in the midst of the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day, (or weeks) when my emotions are all over the place and ready to fly apart like a too tightly wound clock, I can rest in God’s Word. Emotions are tricky, but God is my rock, the one constant, unchanging truth in a sea of turmoil. G (Preached that to myself this week)
TulipGirl
I didn’t realize just how much was going on with y’all right now. . . And I know it wouldn’t be better if you were in Australia.
snowbot
Thanks, Randy! You are too kind. I’m glad you’ve enjoyed the blog, hopefully both of your readers will too. : )Keith
MagistraCarminae
OK, I’ll bite. The first three that pop into my mind…in no order other than that…The Man Who Was Thursday by G. K. Chesterton (not quite done with this yet, but enjoying the witty wordplay, underplayed irony, and sheer fun. Classic Chesterton!)Life at the Bottom by Theodore Dalrymple (This is his nom-de-plume. Serious, thought-provoking critique of our times and what keeps the poor in poverty, written in a wonderful, ironic style.)Ender’s Game by Scott Orson Card (How about a little science fiction? Fascinating ideas, told in a stark and straight-forward writing style. Just for fun.)
TulipGirl
My book stack and Amazon wish list are always much bigger than my eyes and time. . .”Little Britches” by Ralph MoodyI’m reading aloud to the boys before we go to Colorado. . . I remember finding it on my grandmother’s shelf and my Dad reading it to us. It’s a good read aloud for your two younger ones (I was your daughter’s age one of the times Dad read it to us.)
TulipGirl
One of the most encouraging sermon series I’ve heard was preached on the marks of a healthy church by Eric Huber. . .
snowbot
The first 3 that came to my mind:”That Distant Land” by Wendell Berry.”Confessions of a Reformission Rev” by Mark Driscoll.”Planting Missional Churches” by Ed Stetzer.
snowbot
Comments – Berry’s book is a collection of short stories from his Port William series. Great stuff.Driscoll’s book is his personal account of starting Mars Hill Church in Seattle and the challenges he met along the way. A fascinating story in my opinion.Stetzer’s book, while aimed primarily at church planters, is useful for anyone who wants to better understand how to effectively reach today’s culture with the gospel.
Randy Greenwald
I never should have asked. My lists just grow longer…Thanks for the suggestions thus far. I do confess to initially misreading Tulipgirl’s title and wondering what in the world her father read to her when she was a girl.:-) But I’ve corrected my mistake.Keep the suggestions coming.
Gus&Adri
Recent good reads:Steinbeck’s East of Eden; Mark Haddon, The curious incident of the dog in the night-time (a story of an autistic savant); Gene Veith, A place to stand: the word of God in the life of Martin Luther.geAdri says: Only three?!Michael Horton – Putting Amazing Back into Grace. Basic reformed doctrine, but it reminds me WHY I believe what I believe.Tolstoy – Anna Karenina. A classic with great themes.Alan Paton – Cry the Beloved Country; even better, in my opinion is Too Late the Phalarope. Did I just cheat? Well, I listed only three authors.
snowbot
Interestingly I just ran across Tim Keller’s Suggested Summer Reading.
Rebekah
“More Than Equals,” by Spencer Perkins, “Walking With the Poor,” by Bryant Myers,” and “Divided By Faith,” by Michael Emerson. I’ve been in a rut of things that relate to my field, but they would probably still be my favorites.
Gail and Keith
This link fits right in with the “Summer” reading recommendations.”http://www.nytimes.com/2008/06/18/opinion/18wed3.html?ref=opinionThe article “Reading Into the Future” is by Eleanor Randolph. In the event the link doesn’t work, you can find it on the New York Times site. I’m with the author, I like to get my hands on book books, not e-books. G
Randy Greenwald
Whew! I can’t keep up. I leave on vacation Friday. But, of course, instead of taking a truck load of books, I’m taking a van full of family, and I somehow enjoy sitting around flipping through their ‘pages’ much more these days when I have the chance. The Keller book list is fascinating. Where’s he find time to read? I do have THE FELLOWSHIP OF THE RING on cd (unabridged, a birthday present) so I might load that on my iPod for the trip up.Rebekah, I have all the books you suggest. I’ve bought them over the years on your recommendation, and I intend to read them. Really. I want to grow as liberal as you! :-)Adri, you need a book on math. But I agree, TOO LATE THE PHALAROPE is a great read.As to e-books, I don’t think I’ll ever get there. There is something tangibly pleasant about holding a book. I’ll listen to a book to make good use of long journeys, but in the main, nothing surpasses holding it in my hand.Any others care to check in?
Seth Greenwald
“(he will never like gardening and I will never enjoy list checking)”… Who does that sound like???
TulipGirl
Snowbot, thanks for the link to Keller’s summer list. . . passed it along to a friend who passed it along to a friend who passed it along to her pastor (at a PCA church in DE) who really appreciated it. You know how it’s a small world on the ‘net. . .
TulipGirl
Enjoy your wonderful family time!
Anonymous
Wonderful advice, especially for your crew of girls. I love the last line. In the interest of practicality I’d add, “Above all, keep your distance from boys…until they are at least 27.”Staci
Gus&Adri
Laughing with you! The ending paragraphs seem to say that the old adage is still true: “The way to a man’s (boy’s) heart is through his stomach.” Plus, some of us have experienced the fact that teenage boys have hollow legs. –ae
Gus&Adri
“…might walk in and find me asleep…”Couldn’t you just say you were thinking hard – with your eyes closed – about next Sunday’s sermon? Or that you were “resting your eyes”?On second thought, not too good an idea for a pastor. :)–ae
Gus&Adri
Let me speak up for close-knit families who got there without camping.:) It’s wonderful to be at a family reunion with 50+ folk ages less than a year to nearly 80 (or 90+ when Grandma/Great Grandma was still with us.)We often reflect on Psalm 16:6 – “The lines have fallen to me in pleasant places; Yes, I have a good inheritance.” I suppose David had in mind more heavenly thoughts, but there’s no denying a congenial family group is a great gift from a loving Father.ae
Rebekah
I was just thinking about how I might start going home to take naps on my lunch hour…now, I think I will…
ande
Thanks for this review. The nature of false worship leads to the same place. Both looking for their own treasure and both finding in the end what they were looking for. They got what they wanted but what they wanted was not good. Have you seen Magnolia? (one of the roughest and crudest movies ever so be careful) but with a redemptive point… TWBB to me is his sequal to that movie… if at all possible.I am not offended by his portrait of the preacher because it is helpful to me to see how selfish ambition and vain conceit (phil 2:3) affect all. This entire movie is a picture of the insanity of sin.
Randy Greenwald
Ande,Now that you are sober, your comments are much more intelligible… 😉 I had Magnolia in mind when I wrote this post. I’ve upset a few people in the past by recommending that movie because of its crude language. However, the John C. Reilly character in that film is for me one of the most honestly portrayed Christian characters I’ve ever seen in film. Everyone in this movie is falling apart except this one fallible but good Christian man. I loved the film. All three hours of it. Thanks for bringing it up here.Hey, if you ever come to visit Geoff, let me know. I’d love to meet you.
Gus&Adri
Three cheers for Freddy the Pig! He is great fun. Freddy Goes to Florida I’ve read more than once, but have equally enjoyed other of his adventures. –ae
Anonymous
Hey Randy,Thanks for the post. This is a topic of interest to me. I have read Edwards as well as his faithful disciple Piper and have benefited much from their writing(more from the latter). Their convictions and passion for the glory of God really come out in their books. They are a great gift to the church and will continue to be for years to come. I agree with you that Christians shouldn’t be complacent in their faith, and that real faith does produce fruit. My general difficulty with Edwards and Piper, though, is subtly revealed in your friend’s comment about getting “un-saved”. They seems to somhow, intentionally or not, bank our assurance on grand religious experiences. So much so to where a reader feels unsaved if they didn’t exuberate such emotions regularly. In the end, their experiences (as it comes out in their books)become the standard for the rest of us(a tough thing to live up to). Another difficulty I have with them is that they seem to approach their congregations with an apologetics of suspicion; that is, assume unbelief unless there are true signs of faith. It seems like the opposite should be the case; we belief the sign of the covenant, assume they are christians until they apostasize and reject the gospel. Tom
TulipGirl
Cool! Honestly, one of the draws to my previous coffee joint (now Bella in Sarasota) was the free wifi. I took all my online exams there. (Less distracting than home.)
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, Tom. I think, though, that both Piper and Edwards would say that they are NOT basing their assurance upon grand religious experiences. They want us to consider what might be true evidences, fruit, of conversion and to help us see beyond the spurious. I’d rather not wait until someone apostasizes before I raise the alarm that the lack of fruit should be a concern for the person. The question is the nature of the fruit we should seek. There are dangers here. We cannot peer into the heart. But we are called by the Scriptures to examine ourselves in a way that I think does go a bit beyond the presence of the covenant sign, don’t you think?
Randy Greenwald
I’m not sure two hours would enable you to take your exams at Starbucks! Stumbled across a Chik-fil-A in Atlanta that offered free wifi. I’m now hoping the Creekwood CFA will pick up on that idea!And, yes, isn’t it funny how a public place with dozens of customers can be less distracting than our own living room couch!
Anonymous
I agree fully. Being a covenant member doesn’t excuse me from bearing fruit. I still have obligations to believe and repent, to love and forgive, etc. We are on the same page on that.Tom
Anonymous
This is an interesting statement – “When I expressed to a friend not too long ago that I was reading Jonathan Edwards’ treatise On the Religious Affections (yes, I’m still plodding through), he quipped, “So are you unsaved yet?”There are a handful of places in this treatise that are the most discomforting, but difficult to apply. I was listening the other day to Vance’s narration of this book and was really being edified and crying out “amen.” Then he began the 12th positive sign, “XII. Gracious and holy affections have their exercise and fruit in Christian practice.”It is the “sins of omission” details that unsaint us. We all feel weighed in the balance and wanting. If anyone has the edition with the footnotes, the sermon quoted from Solomon Stoddard can really un-nerve you. (Way to Know Sincerity and Hypocrisy).But we should take comfort in the fact that the best of men were searched by this treatise and came out the better for it. I am studying the life of Asahel Nettleton for an upcoming Sunday School. He went through a time of serious introspection with this book in hand, as well as Edward Payson. But though both men had doubts, they were both very godly Christian pastors from the beginning of the 19th century.If there is a single sermon that is the most helpful to assist to analyze if the root of the matter is in us it is his sermon, “Hypocrites Deficient in the Duty of Prayer.” The description of the effects of the new birth by Edwards are so accurate and helpful. A regenerated person is a praying person.
TulipGirl
I’ve heard so much good about Freddy the Pig (and remember Adri’s endorsement a couple of years ago!) I need to find some of the books soon for our family read-alouds.
snowbot
I’ve never heard of Freddy, but I love good recommendations like this. I’ll have to seek out his adventures. Thanks!
Gus&Adri
tulipgirl and snowbot: unless you are completely different from Randy and me – and others I know of – you’ll be hooked after one Freddy adventure. As with Winnie-the-Pooh, much of the humor will probably fly over the heads of the youngest children, but adults chuckle and perhaps even LOL.–ae
Gus&Adri
Sounds like fun; and Florida needs the rain! 😉 Sorry we had to miss it; maybe next year?But we saw a fireworks spectacular that evening; yes, my hometown does their show on the 3rd every year. The population doubles that evening – to a whopping 10,000!–ae
TulipGirl
How cool!
MagistraCarminae
Ahh- 30 years ago, I was in piercing pain from an abscess in my gum, and still managed to sing at your wedding in an upright position…Have a wonderful time in Chicago, and if you need “insider” tips, call me for my brother Matt’s cell number– they live near the Loop!Love,Chris
Gus&Adri
Congratulations! And here’s to the next 10, 20, 30, ??Hope you are having fun in The Windy City.Gus and Adri
MagistraCarminae
Coming through loud and clear.Hope you had a wonderful time in Chicago!Chris
TulipGirl
Btw, guess who brought a copy of Freddy Goes to Florida to church today?! Thanks, Gus and Adri. . . We’ll really enjoy reading it on our vacation drive!
Gail and Keith
That is a great picture of you and Barb! chicago is a neat city with lots to see and do. Another fantastic pizza place is The Silo in Lake Bluff near Libertyville. It’s at least 30 years since we’ve been to the Silo, but it’s still a popular dining spot. G
TulipGirl
I’ve driven by the Silo numerous times. . . never eaten there. I agree–love the picture. So glad y’all had a fabulous time!
The Domestic Intellectual
Hi. I’m a friend of John and Xande’s in Chicago. Just had to say that I found this book fascinating and am looking forward to others by Larson. He has one on called Lethal Passage about guns in the US that looked interesting, but I am sure anything by him would be gripping.
Randy Greenwald
DI: Thanks for the recommendation. I finished the book late Monday night, and was gripped by the illustration that Holmes is of utter depravity. Chilling. What made reading the book fun during this, my first visit to Chicago, was wandering around (yes, clearly a tourist) and seeing the places where the events took place, even as I read.
TulipGirl
Yikes.When I was in 2nd grade, my mom taught college English classes and sometimes brought me along with her. While I still do make grammatical mistakes (not just typos!), I do tend to reflexively cringe when I see and hear grammar errors. Blame it on my mom. *eg*
MagistraCarminae
Spoken like an antiquated English teacher. Didn’t you know things like punctuation are no longer important? Didn’t you hear earlier this year about the “death of the semicolon”? You don’t want to imprison people and stop them from free expression, do you? And rules aren’t popular.(Cringing right along with you…)
MagistraCarminae
Amen!
Randy Greenwald
In defense of the sign guy, my writing is full of typos and stupid mistakes, some of which finds its way inadvertently into my preaching. Just yesterday someone pointed out an egregious spelling error in a sermon title on the church’s web site, which had been there for two months! I don’t point these things out as one who cringes, but as one who laughs at our human fallibility. And when that means I can laugh at another church and feel haughty and superior, all the better! And the semi-colon? Isn’t that what you get after certain cancer surgeries?
Randy Greenwald
Hmmm. What are you ‘Amening’ to? Oh, I know… that rotten apple comment! Yup, you know me well.
Gus&Adri
Agree on momotheism. But lets dont 🙂 get started on misplaced and missed apostrophes and other errors. "Grammar/punctuation freaks" will go even more nuts!And I'm not an English teacher or major; just an oldie who went to school when grammar rules were taught and expected to be used. The spouse (even older) also; and English isn't his native language.Note: we have a new computer and are trying to figure out where that "&" came from in the name; will attempt to correct.
Gus&Adri
OOPS! there you go: a typo – I promise – in monotheism. Talk about fallibility!–ae
Anonymous
This made me think of St. John’s College – campuses in Annapolis and Santa Fe – which one of our children considered attending. Simply google the name; the first site has much info on their philosophy as well as the names of people the students read/study: Homer, Euclid, Chaucer, Einstein, DuBois, Augustine… and many more; and the required classes. The info includes thoughts similar to what you quote from Friedman. In the early ’90s it was said that IBM would hire any St. John’s grad – simply because of their broad “classical” education – knowing that they could then train them to suit IBM’s needs.
MagistraCarminae
And this made me think of the way our experience actually tells us that the ancients (medievals) had it right: a classical Christian education in the humanities broadly is really the best preparation for life. St. John’s is one take on that classical model.:-)
The Domestic Intellectual
Great reminder!
MagistraCarminae
I watched the “last lecture” several months ago. it was excellent, really. I also wonder, have I lived well? Have I chosen the best things to do with my time, that will prepare me for eternity? Have I really enjoyed God and His creation and gifts to me? I’m afraid this is yet another area where I am left wanting, and a debtor to grace alone…
MagistraCarminae
What a painful tendency this is. I see it not only in Christian circles, but in the workplace (at least here, where there are dangers in the workplace, but so many rules that no one any longer has to think about what may be really dangerous or exercise common sense!) I’ll look forward to reading the article.ChrisP.S. I found out from my ddil in IN that she is a regular reader here, too. That takes you up to at least 4!!
snowbot
Great post. I immediately thought of Derek Webb’s song, “A New Law”:Don’t teach me about politics and governmentJust tell me who to vote for Don’t teach me about truth and beautyJust label my musicDon’t teach me how to live like a free manJust give me a new lawI don’t wanna know if the answers aren’t easySo just bring it down from the mountain to meI want a new lawDon’t teach me about moderation and libertyI prefer a shot of grape juiceDon’t teach me about loving my enemiesDon’t teach me how to listen to the SpiritJust give me a new lawWhat’s the use in trading a law you can never keepFor one you can that cannot get you anythingDo not be afraid
Randy Greenwald
Chris and Keith,Both comments add to the post and show that at least two of you ‘got it’. I hope that means that more did. It’s tough, though, as I think about applying wisdom to parenting, for example. It is easier to proliferate rules than it is to instill wisdom. You’d think I’d have that figured out by now. But, I guess as well, you could say that time spent on the baseball diamond does not make one a gold glove winner. Thanks!
Anonymous
You shouldn’t expect many comments on this post. We are two of your four or so readers and we don’t use such new-fangled technology. Maybe the other two don’t either. I’m just sayin’.–ae
Adria
Yeah, so I don’t say much but I am a regular reader. I have not tried a Starbucks Hotspot. I just use my own at home. 🙂
Geoffsnook
Randy,Maybe I need to get out there more often. The Administration building can be a bit lonely…
MagistraCarminae
Hmm- good food for thought. I have bookmarked the links for future reading. But since we are made in the image of the Triune God, this seems an appropriate, if challenging, application. Generally I think we tend to under-apply the implications of the trinity, since it is such a baffling concept to us.
Anonymous
I have no clue who these people are, but I love their story. Being a single person in a society where marriages are constantly falling apart, their story gives me hope as well as a warning. Thanks for posting it.Tom
Randy Greenwald
Tom,If you follow the links in the post you will discover some things about them. Their music might not appeal to you, but they are, I believe, Christians seeking to do thoughtful music from a Christian worldview in a secular world. You ought to check them out. (They are also from Cincinnati, my home town, and are named after a neighborhood in Cincinnati.)Randy
Anonymous
Free WiFi at church on sundays. 🙂
Anonymous
Personally, there are 3 reasons why I go to church. First, I go because I fear God’s judgment. I know we’re saved by grace apart from works, but there is also this sneaky suspicion that if we didn’t go, it would mean we’re not saved. Second, I go because it helps fill a social need. I like to be around people who have similar interests and pay attention to me. And third, I really do love God and want to grow. And I believe that outside of the church, there really is no ordinary possibility of salvation or santification.Tom
Rebekah
Unfortunately, you have to work your entire medical career to go and pay off your med school loans (or at least half of it), so it will have to take a committment from the training end of the medical community if they want to send doctors. They would have to give an education for free, and those that want to give away free medical care aren’t always the kind of students that end up getting the free tuition…(at least as I’ve always understood it…)…
Randy Greenwald
Good point. Things are always more complicated than first appearances seem. But that does not mean the data should not move those who have access to the distribution of resources for missions and aid.It is clearly not everyone who can really live and work in the conditions that such missions demand. But… for those who are willing and able, we should do everything possible to encourage them to do so.
MagistraCarminae
Amen. Why let others steal all the good words?!
Rebekah
Agreed–there’s nothing more disheartening than going to worship and seeing a congregation full of people who are so dead, so it would be heartening for people to return to excitement in worship. On the flip side, there are too many people that are too fixated on needing that same type of worship environment that they grew up in to get that same emotional enthusiasm. And that’s what often prevents us from worshipping with brothers and sisters in Christ across denominations and across races. Worship is a choice, and we can choose to worship God in any setting. There is nothing that is more encouraging to me than one of my college professors who made that choice to be joyful in worship at (what was to him) a raucous worship service in a (PCA) church, even though he would have been most happy in a stodgy OPC-style service like the one he grew up in, because it was important to him to have his family be a part of a community where the relationships they were building were more important than the comfort of the worship. That’s stuck with me and if you can change a stodgy Dutchman and make him happy for the sake of the Kingdom, I think you can change anyone!
Randy Greenwald
Rebekah, I know your heart. But I must say that the tendency to desire worship that ‘feels good’ is not the exclusive provence of the Dutchman (I’ve never seen one change…) or the Scot or the white man. Just as we do not see many white evangelicals sacrificing to worship across racial lines, nor do we see many black evangelicals making a similar sacrifice to worship in white churches. My only point is that try as we might to speak objectively about worship, we are still always drawn to what is comfortable, and we need to take that into account when we debate worship. But that is true of every person, not just the white presbyterian. Don’t you agree?
Fiona
Phew!…I was so worried that you and Geoff were now speaking in tongues…eh! :-)fm
Rebekah
I do agree. But you don’t have any Black readers (that I know of)–Reformed and Dutch are the ones more likely to grace your pages. I speak of people that are in your and my scope of relationships because it’s so close to home. (As is the concept of multiracial church because there are a lot of African Americans in my scope of relationships.) We see our Reformed churches splintering into tinier and tinier sects because of this comfort factor, but having not been to any other churches lately, this is what comes to mind.God hasn’t called us to be comfortable, He calls us to do what’s right, and like you (sort of) said in your response to my comment, we ought to take that into account in deciding who we should worship with.
MagistraCarminae
n a different direction, I once listened to an interview with Bob Kauflin about worship (he is not only an amazing musician, but director of musical stuff at Sovereign Grace Ministries: a reformed and charismatic group.) I was taken by one particular comment of his when he stated something to the effect that Jesus is worthy of all our emotion. That seems so true to me. Yet, culturally, we display that emotion in a variety of ways, do we not? And while Christ is, indeed, worthy of all our emotions, it is a severe temptation, as you say, to replace Him with the emotions themselves.What a sticky wicket…
Randy Greenwald
R, you are certainly right. I don’t imagine many reading this are African American. I don’t even think my kids read this! And, honestly, I’ve been a bit cast out of the traditional Dutch community, and my honorary wooden shoes were long ago revoked. So, I’m not sure how many of a Dutch persuasion read. But, I don’t know that, really. Regardless, I have been successful when we realize that the arguments we make about aesthetics or order or music or whatever in worship are going to be heavily tinged with the cultural bias we bring to the table. That’s all. And, Fiona, to some that sounds like I’m speaking a foreign tongue! And MagistraCarminae (aka Chris, no doubt a fugitive from the law seeking to hide her real identity…) says what I think is an important thing to note, though I’m not sure it can completely be avoided… that we find more thrill in the emotions than we do in Christ. So, we plod along, and Jesus still accepts our praises. That is a wonder! Thanks for all the comments – keep them coming. I love the interaction.
Fiona
Isn’t it great, that only the LORD knows our (true) hearts and minds? 🙂 Sadly, I believe the Christian church can sometimes underestimate the intelligence and awareness of the non-Christian and the ability they possess to spot someone being phoney, or trying to fit in by taking on a ‘role'(for whatever reason).Some of the points made in the linked post are sadly true–but at the end of the day–who cares? I don’t. I am so discouraged at times by how (we) Christians are paying more attention to how trendy or ‘cool’ we can be in order to be accepted, or to make the church more palatable for non-Christians. People are not attending church because the pastor wears a suit and tie; they are at home because they have so many colourful distractions: toys, gadgets and over-stretched schedules. Don’t you know–Sunday is ‘sleep-in’ day? People are ‘burnt out’ from the pressures around them; ageing parents, teenagers acting out (or both!), cancer and diseases, heavy financial burdens and major debt; not to mention marriages on the brink of failure. It isn’t personal people–they just don’t care, or realize that their needs have to be met through Christ. So how do we reach them or keep them? We be true to the gospel and we love and care for those who are in the church right now. I noticed pastoral appearance or reference to aesthetics is mentioned quite a lot in the attached link, but whatever happened to the power of prayer and calling on the Lord to bring people in? Also, since when is it the sole responsibility of the pastor to try to bring people to church or keep people IN the church? We are all in this together.With all the time that is spent trying to think up popular schemes or methods in order to attract people to come to church–people are dying. Deep down, I believe people want authenticity whether they are a Christian or not.Prayerfully and by the Lord’s grace and help, we will be made spiritually attractive and also outwardly appealing to those in our immediate circle and communities; not only by our words but MOST imporantly, by our actions. In order to be ‘authentic’ Christians we need to lean on God and not ourselves. It’s really simple, but I think WE complicate things. The Lord just asks us to be faithful and obedient to the message of the gospel, to Him and His Word. He will do the rest.Lastly…(Hey, I havn’t commented in a long time!)Sorry, but these thoughts swell from what I have see around me, from those in my personal life lately and those in the city where I live. People need for us to love them, to show them compassion and respect and through this we are pointing them to Christ. They really don’t care if we are ‘hip’ or not! 🙂
Fiona
Uh-oh, did I sound arrogant? I hope not. 🙁 Although, if I did, I’m sure someone will ‘kick my derierre’…(preferably with a slipper!)fm
Randy Greenwald
Preach it, sister! Have I invited you to our church recently? I think you’d fit in really well. It’s not too far to travel, is it? I promise not to kick you any where or to dump coffee on you. I’m tired but I wanted to say that I appreciate your comments.
Rebekah
And this is why I don’t label myself “Right-Wing Conservative” anymore… It doesn’t make any sense to not regulate things that let us breathe freely!
Randy Greenwald
Those ‘Vote Obama’ signs would probably call into question your membership in the vast Right Wing Conspiracy anyway… 🙂
TulipGirl
Woohoo! Congratulations!
Anonymous
“…email, it’s Facebook, or blogs, or puzzles, or novels.”Pleading GUILTY, your honor. However, I/we don’t feel any obligation to confess to which – maybe even others – I/we are guilty. It does help, though, to not have the “ding” alert. (Well, maybe it helps a little….)
MagistraCarminae
Doing a happy dance for you, J! Congrats!
snowbot
A few good Christian blogs I like are Between Two Worlds, Challies.com, and The Resurgence. Also, Monergism is a good spot for Reformed theology resources.
Anonymous
The first may be more for women: http://rocksinmydryer.typepad.com/shannon/She is a PCA woman who writes (often humorously) about family etc, and each Wednesday hosts “Works for me Wednesday.” This is where readers can share helpful hints on a plethora of subjects. For anyone who cooks, allrecipes.com is a helpful site. You can find dozens of recipes based on what ingredients you want to include.Personally, I find google to have a wealth of information on any number of topics. It sometimes relates closely to the aforementioned recipe site because one can learn how to purchase, ripen, store, prepare – for example – unfamiliar fruits/vegetables.–ae
The Domestic Intellectual
(the first comment had some editorial errors)A couple resources that I am very fond of:True Womanhood blog: in celebration of the thinking Christian womanhttp://truewomanhood.wordpress.com/ They have thoughtful discussions where women who often have quite different viewpoints are treated respectfully and thoughtfully.Bible Gatewayhttp://www.biblegateway.com/Great online search tool especially good for word searches or concordance searches when you are not sure what version the verse is from:-)I also enjoy subscribing to a variety of preachers/sermon series via iTunes podcast.Boundless Webszinehttp://www.boundless.org/A publication by Focus on the Family it has many excellent articles, blog posts and podcasts on a variety of issues applicable to the whole body of Christ, but especially to those in the 18-35 demographic.I also recommend the use of the iGoogle homepage option for staying on top of news and blog subscriptions.
TulipGirl
Like snowbot, I find monergism.org to be a great clearinghouse for Reformed resources. Though, like any place online, read with discernment — I’ve come across a few links that had me raising an eyebrow. (Oh–off topic–the bookstore at monergism.com is having a sale on Berkhof’s Systematic Theology. Only $20!)Even though my daily drive isn’t that long, I do have time in the car without the kids to talk to and I like to listen to the mp3 player while I drive. I’ve become quite a fan of podcast lectures and sermons. Covenant Theological Seminary has the courses of their core program online for free download at Covenant Worldwide. “Humanity, Christ and Redemption” is my favorite course so far — truly thought- and worship-provoking.UC Berkeley also offers a large number of courses available as podcasts for free download. Yes, THAT Berkeley. Listen with discretion. Still, they offer some very interesting lectures.For mom encouragement, I like the ThatMom Podcast. She’s down-to-earth, has both grown kids and kids at home. It helps that I’m friends with her daughter and like their family a lot!The local library websites (Sarasota, Manatee) are great to reserve and renew books. And I’m a sucker for Google Maps. Love looking at the satellite view of the house my Dad is building, the building where we lived in Ukraine and planning trips.
snowbot
Oh yeah, Reformed Theological Seminary offers all kinds of lecture recordings on iTunesU (http://itunes.rts.edu/).Redeemer.com has all of Tim Keller’s sermons available, but they charge quite a bit of money for them. I’d love to see them offer those for free one day. However, they do offer about 20 of them for free here. And over at Mars Hill Church of Seattle’s site they have high quality sermon videos and audio of Mark Driscoll’s stuff (http://www.marshillchurch.org/). Those are available via podcast/iTunes as well.
Anonymous
One place I find refreshing and insightful is st anne’s public house. They have talks and interviews that are always relevant to the Christian life. Check out their archives in the cellar. Here’s a link.http://www.stannespublichouse.com/home/Tom
Anonymous
A few changes in your appearance and garb would be in order. May we suggest: let the beard grow (in both length and whiteness), a little more loss of hair on top; and we can’t wait to see the robe with maybe a rope belt and sandals (without sox, please.) Oh, and maybe a bead or string necklace….Even then, not sure we’d like the music. Maybe just stick to your always good sermons?The E’s
The Domestic Intellectual
This is something I struggle with, primarily because many of the things that I love to do come with relative ease. If it is easy in the beginning, it is hard to push through to a high level of competence. As a linguist friend told me once: I can get a B with no work and it takes a ton of work to get an A, so I’ll take the B. It has been hard for me to shake that attitude.
Anonymous
Here are a few I useJohn Piperhttp://www.desiringgod.org/Blue Letter Bible – good for translations, greek, etchttp://www.blueletterbible.org/Modern Reformation Magazine – great archived articleshttp://www.modernreformation.org/default.php?page=main&var1=Home
Anonymous
I read the book some time ago. I loved it because it made me learn American history I didn’t know or had forgotten. I also was vaguely aware of the televised series and was intrigued. Now I’m hoping the set is in your “lending library for friends.” (Maybe in exchange for dinner/games, even retroactive?) :)–ae
Anonymous
I loved the HBO series. I agree that the beginning part moved too quickly. Now I need to read the book for the first time!Staci
Randy Greenwald
ae – we rented the DVDs from Blockbuster Online, so we can’t put them in your hands. But I suspect the library or any local Blockbuster will have them.Staci – by all means, put this book on the 1000 books to read before you die!Randy
MagistraCarminae
.. and I’m on my way over to the weather channel…Chris
MagistraCarminae
And the first part of the above post, apparently lost in cyber space, was, “I am praying for you all here, Randy!”
TulipGirl
With the schools and businesses closed tomorrow (but not a strong indication to evacuate), we’re planning on making beef stew, lighting candles, reading aloud, and enjoying the storm.Though at the same time, mindful that things may get worse.
TulipGirl
Fay fizzled. But our family still gets an unexpected day “off.” *grin*
TulipGirl
*grin*Even 10 years ago, we’d use the ‘net to find a church to visit (even if they didn’t have a website.) Though that did lead to some interesting misadventures in only having an address and no clue where we were going. . . *L*I think it’s great that all the sermons will be available. Looking forward to the new site (and hooray for the tech guru putting it together!)
snowbot
I’m excited about the new site. Glad to help!
Anonymous
Interesting to learn more about this great writer. But doesn’t he have assistants who help with research etc? I can’t imagine that he can do all that himself. Maybe he gathers up all the info they discover and takes it with him to his special spot. Hard to believe the “no computer” part these days, isn’t it?I/we have enjoyed other of his books; next on my list is The Path Between the Seas regarding the building of the Panama Canal.–ae
Anonymous
In May, I read Mr. McCullough’s Commencement Address to Boston University. It was an outstanding speech. Do an internet search for the actual text of the speech and you will find, that in fact, it truly does look as if the speech was typed on a typewriter and not a computer. He likely avoided the hypothetical problem of children spilling water on his computer keyboard. But I digress. Here are some of my favorite lines from that commencement address. “Make the love of learning central to your life. What a difference it can mean. If your experience is anything like mine, the books that will mean the most to you, books that will change your life, are still to come. And remember, as someone said, even the oldest book is brand new for the reader who opens it for the first time. You have had the great privilege of attending one of the finest colleges in the nation, where dedication to classical learning and to the arts and sciences has long been manifest. If what you have learned here makes you want to learn more, well that’s the point. Read. Read, read! Read the classics of American literature that you’ve never opened. Read your country’s history. How can we profess to love our country and take no interest in its history? Read into the history of Greece and Rome. Read about the great turning points in the history ofscience and medicine and ideas. Read for pleasure, to be sure. I adore a good thriller or a first-rate murder mystery. But take seriously –read closely –books that have stood the test of time. Study a masterpiece, take it apart, study its architecture, its vocabulary, its intent. Underline, make notes in the margins, and after a few years, go back and read it again. Make use ofthe public libraries. Start your own personal library and see it grow. Talk about the books you’re reading. Ask others what they’re reading. You’ll learn a lot. And please, please, do what you can to cure the verbal virus that seems increasingly rampant among your generation. I’m talking about the relentless, wearisome use of the words, “like,” and “you know,” and “awesome,” and “actually.” Listen to yourselves as you speak. Just imagine if in his inaugural address John F. Kennedy had said, “Ask not what your country can, you know, do for you, but what you can, like, do for your country actually.” “Thanks for the discussion.Staci
The Domestic Intellectual
Fun post! I love to hear how other writers craft their work. Being open to children while being creative is a huge boost to creativity for me… Granted, I don’t have any children of my own yet to test my daily tolerance. I have found, generally speaking, that their energy and wonder are amazing catalysts to productivity.On a side note, I was reading Orthodoxy by Chesterton the other day and in the introduction Philip Yancy mentioned that Chesterton dictated his books to his secretary and seldom revised. Many of my college papers came that way, but only after months of thinking them out:-)
Randy Greenwald
DI – if you have not read Stephen King’s On Writing, you should, if you like reading about how writers write. A fascinating insight and, of course, well written.
Geoffsnook
Well said. Thanks for the reminder of the privilege and responsibility people play in shaping lives for God’s glory.
TulipGirl
Keeping an online notebook. . . yes, that’s a good way to describe what blogs can be.It’s like a tool for a modern day Jonathan Edwards. Instead of having paper pinned to our coats, and writing while riding a horse, we have our computer screens at the ready as we go about our daily tasks.
Anonymous
No, it wasn’t a test. I’m not a test-giver. Clearly, I am a mistake-maker. Sorry!Staci
Anonymous
“…why do such things…need to be said at all?” I can’t adequately answer that question, but if statistics are to be believed, these are indeed startling:1/3 of high school graduates never read another book for the rest of their lives.42 percent of college graduates never read another book after college.80 percent of U.S. families did not buy or read a book last year.70 percent of U.S. adults have not been in a bookstore in the last five years. Source; publishing guru Dan Poynter, via http://www.humorwriters.org/startling stats./html (University of Dayton)It’s inexplicable. I cannot imagine such a life. I’m with Thomas Jefferson who said, “I cannot live without books.” And with Babington Macaulay who is quoted thus: “I would rather be a poor man in a garret with plenty of books than a king who did not love reading.”–ae
Matthew
There was something that intrigued my interest about the statistics. If only 1/3 or 33.333% of all high school graduates never read another book then are colleges no longer making their students read? Because according to The Wall Street Journal “more than 45% of recent high school graduates enroll in four-year colleges” Someone is confused… Statistics unlike facts are not stubborn things.mghttp://www.opinionjournal.com/extra/?id=110009535
Randy Greenwald
MG, a man after my own heart. Typed this comment after returning to his new house from a visit to the local library, thrilled to find that it was only a block or two away. Statistics can be very fluid things, and can be used greatly to obscure the truth. However, Math not being MG’s strong suit, it is possible, it seems to me, if 1/3 never read again, that leaves 2/3 who do, and out of that 2/3 might come the 1/2 who attend college. Of course, then, if you add the 1/2 of college graduates and the 1/3 of high school grads who never read another book, you would have about 50% of the world never reading another book.We could go on all day and night. But my question becomes, is there something in our education that kills the desire to read? Or is there a reading gene that naturally predisposes us to read? Or whatever.
MagistraCarminae
This is such an interesting question… and one I’m not sure I’ve contemplated much. But the first thing that comes to mind for me is that somewhere along the line, the importance of what I’d now call the “life of the mind”, was instilled in me. It certainly started in my home, where we argued about politics and were constantly challenged to change the world, and where my parents were readers. It was flamed by teachers who understood and saw a spark in me that they encouraged. George Grant says yu must lead if you want your children to read. :-)When you speak of “liberal arts schools”, the classical educator in me must warn that we use that term pretty loosely these days. When you can get through a liberal arts education without ever taking a higher math course, or a real course in philosophy, and majoring in things like hotel management, most of the liberal arts are gone from college. Part of our problem as a culture is the loss of these things. But it is a lot broader than computer games and sound-bite entertainment. It has to do with people not being taught what the life of the mind is or should be, or why it is important.Too tired to continue, but since you asked… Chris
Randy Greenwald
Thanks for taking the time to say something, Chris. I have a BS in English Education from MSU, a degree for which I never once had to read a line of Shakespeare. I hope that had the ‘education’ part of the major been dropped that I might have been required to read something of substance. But still…
Anonymous
My positive memories and influences: *My mum reading-aloud to me during my childhood. My mum was raised in Edinburgh, Scotland, by parents from the Victorian era and she was a child during WWII. My mum loved to read books (and still does!) and with the use of her own imaginataion would write stories. These stories or the classics (as we know them) would then be performed by her and her friends in plays–makeshift costumes and all! I believe her childhood experiences and her appreciation for books, influenced her children’s approach to the arts and reading. I still remember my mum reading-aloud, she had an amazing ability to place the right inflection or tone to a character’s words which (in a child’s mind) brought a story in a book-to LIFE! :-)* I still remember my dad (after he became a Christian) walking into our house carrying bags filled with good books, records and Christian tracts in other languages. He loved to read and he made sure he took the time to do this. I believe that just watching him read, also influenced me. This demonstrated to me that his desire to learn (in a silent way) proved he didn’t have all the answers, which to me was a sign of humility. Also, his desire to purchase good books that were rich in content (for not only himself) but for his wife and his family, impacted me. It was love–in action.He also verbally encouraged my siblings and I to read; but I remember him best for saying (with his thick Scottish accent), “It’s good to read books, but don’t forget to read your BIBLE!” :-)Lastly, my desire to read and learn has developed more in adulthood because of life circumstances during my younger years. My greatest influences for learning have been my teachers and my dad, who learned to play the piano and speak French in his late 50s and before he became ill, he was learning Spanish.I think that my greatest influences have been made by those who have encouraged me to learn; are enthusiastic about what they know; and are generous enough to share what they know-but all in a spirit of humbleness. Thanks for the opportunity to share.Fiona
Anonymous
I love the poem, especially as one who grew up in a home with no tv and a family of readers. The readers continue in the younger generations.I’m still mulling over whether it’s “nature or nurture”; I think I am ready to conclude it’s a combination of the two. One thing is certain: if it’s nature (a “reading gene”), then your reading youngster did not inherit it from you and Barb. That furthers my thought that nurture has a huge influence.–ae
Geoffsnook
Randy,Its funny, actually scary, at how much Connar, our 3 month old, stares at the TV screen every chance he gets. He actually looked around me one time so that he could see the TV screen. That was our sign that we can’t have the TV on if he has it in his line of sight. So when I’m watching Ray’s games I have to shield his body or pause them, or turn them off all together.Thanks for the challenge to read. I need to hear it. It will be harder since football season is coming up!I like reading, but it is also a discipline for me.Finally, please never make reference ever again to Oompa Loompas. I hate those things. I really do. Those things freak me out. I hate Willy Wonka and that movie. It’s a horror film if you ask me. Rack me, I’m out. War the Rays taking the pennant in 08.
Randy Greenwald
Nurture no doubt has an influence. I think that’s been proven. And what are you saying, ae, about my children not inheriting our genes? :-)And, Geoff, I apologize for the O-L reference. I hope the trauma does not disable you completely. I post the encouragement to read, knowing how weak I am myself. But, for my nighttime reading, just finished a long project and picked up, finally, Moneyball, finally. Fascinating.The wife and I tried for years to NOT own, and then not to BUY a television. But I grew up with TV on all the time. I think that is why I’ve grown to have such a love/hate relationship with the thing. I’d rather read a book. However, one can’t watch the Rays play ball in a book!
TulipGirl
We’re with you on the love/hate relationship. I grew up without TV, and miss a lot of pop culture references. Hubby didn’t have a TV in his late teen/early 20s. In general, we haven’t been fond of the TV, and haven’t had cable since. . . well. . . since it came with our flat in Ukraine.Buuuut. . . we’ve gotten into the habit of watching dvds/videos/hulu. . . movies or tv shows. And we’ve had the glowing blue-eyed monster babysit the kids from time to time. Can’t escape it completely. (Don’t want to.)Btw, I posted that Oompa Loompa song a few years ago. I read it aloud to the boys on the first day of school that year, announced a moratorium on tv watching, and we dove into school and reading and adventures together.
Rebekah
We used to take half-day trips to the library, and then the other half-day we got to skip our regularly scheduled lessons to read what we’d brought back. 🙂 We always, always were read to, and the stories were read with magnificent melodroma. I loved books so much I suppose because of the interesting places and people I travelled to and was introduced to. My interest in reading has diminished, probably because I’ve gotten lazy, and probably because I got tired of having to read so much in college.
MagistraCarminae
Did you know that you have regular readers in Bloomington, IN? Ben has decided you have very similar movie tastes…which worries me slightly…:-)Chris
Randy Greenwald
That ought to worry you! The world is falling under the spell of Hollywood. The end is coming! The sky is falling! Actually, how can you go wrong with these three movies? Each so well done in its own right.Next up to post comments on: Into the Wild, reference to which might find its way into the comments I will make at an upcoming wedding at which I will be officiating…. Doom is on the horizon.
Rebekah
Mmmmmhhhmmmm. I think that’s fanaticism to rival Brightbill hockey fan-dom.
Randy Greenwald
Yes, of course. All great martyrs have had the air of fanaticism about them, haven’t they?
MagistraCarminae
The work of Harvest USA is pretty amazing, and I have benefited from reading their newsletter, often with articles by John Freeman. We need to treat homosexuals like we do every other brand of sinner: love them like Christ did. That is possible without condoning sin, but not easy.
Anonymous
Funny. Very, very funny.Staci
TulipGirl
*guffaw*(Though, I must admit, I do look forward to the high-quality Bella’s coffee a certain “stadium” features.)
TulipGirl
Amazing, amazing article about your neighbor Paul’s skills on and off the court.
Anonymous
I believe if you google the name as Nathaniel you will find Bloomberg articles. Using Nate produces no such results.That oughta settle it.
Anonymous
Amen! God is definitely in the details of our lives!
MagistraCarminae
Is the emphasis on “strange” or “wonderful”?!How good God is, and what a blessing it was to have you and Barb and Colin there, and to hear you expound God’s word to our kids at the beginning of their journey together! We love you guys!Dave and Chris
MagistraCarminae
🙂
Gail and Keith
Which is why I say, not everyone should homeschool.
TulipGirl
*LOL, Gail*(btw, missed you today. . .)
snowbot
So, who would you guys vote for? Any Jason Bourne partisans out there?
Randy Greenwald
Oops… Snowbot didn’t say that. I did. Keith used my computer for his film class, and was logged in to his email account. Relax, Keith… I didn’t read any of your gmail messages!
Gus/Adri
A companion to verses 5&6 is Philippians 4:4-7.ge
Elsa
If you open the picture in its own window, you can see that the file name is “s_beets_CIG.”Could the crop be beets?
Gus/Adri
Romaine lettuce? Or some kind of leaf lettuce. –ae
Gus/Adri
Okay, now that I’ve read elsa’s comment I’m changin’ my guess to sugar beets – based on the relationship of you and your “sugar beet” gal. =)–ae
Randy Greenwald
Wow… what a bunch of detectives you all are. Elsa, you are sharp. I did not think to change the title to something obscure. But I know that at least TWO of my readers would have identified this picture without a hesitation – having spent hours standing in the rows hoeing them for days on end as young girls. Which simply brings me back to the original question. Is something like hoeing a field messing with God’s glory in the growth of the crop, or is it cooperating with and contributing to his glory? And can the same logic be applied to the church?
Anonymous
I think the logic transfers over directly. Jesus told his disciples to pray to the Lord of the harvest that He would bring forth workers for the harvest. Jesus is reminding us that it is God who calls and equips workers in the harvest of souls. In the same biblical book in which Jesus makes that statement it is also records Jesus teaching, training, testing, correcting and rebuking his disciples. Yes, God is the one who calls and equips but we are responsible for our God given role to tend the crop following the example of Jesus.Good post Randy!Scott Ellison
Gail and Keith
Adam tended the Garden of Eden, did he not? So, we inhabitants of the garden (church), do likewise.
Rebekah
I was going to say tobacco….Just as farming is a blend of common and special grace, so is church growth…
TulipGirl
Wow!Rejoicing with you!
MagistraCarminae
Woo Hoo! Have a great time!
Geoffsnook
When bad things happen to the Red Sox, I would call that more divine intervention than “luck!”-Bill Buckner
Gail and Keith
Hey, that magic number is 1!
Randy Greenwald
Here’s the thing on the magic number. It is calculated with both teams playing 162 games. It is possible for a tie to occur. So, the magic number has to be calculated in such a way that the winning team ends up 1 game ahead of the other in the standings. For that to happen, the Ray’s number is ‘2’.In this case, however, should the Rays and Red Sox end up in a tie, the Rays get the nod because they took the season series from the Sox. So, since the Rays win a tie, the number is reduced to ‘1’. I’m still holding out for a clear cut win… I want the Rays in fact to finish at least 2 games ahead of Boston. And the pipe dream is that the Angels do the impossible and lose three of their last four games to allow the Rays to overtake them in the wins department. Not likely, though.
Gail and Keith
Oooooooooohhhhhhhhh! Nothing is ever as it seems. Such a complicated juggling of stats and figures. G
Geoffsnook
I wonder how many people will be scared away by my picture. But thanks for the Pub!
Gail and Keith
Feeling welcome, loved, accepted, at home in a church is certainly important. A young woman told me today she felt all those things when walking into the church fellowship for the first time. That is a good thing, what we’d like our church culture to be like. We, A., J, and I, discussed the need to encourage one another in our walk with the Lord and so we thanked God for the gift of relationships. But personally, can I be myself entirely? No. We’re not there yet, but with God’s grace we will be some day.G
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, G. Note that in response to the Pena quote I said, “I’d like to be in a church like that.” We are always hoping, as you say, that God will lead us and change us and bring us every day closer to the ideal we seek.
Seth
This is why I hate presidential election races. Nobody fights fair. It is always a spin game where you make yourself look good by implying that the other guy (or gal) is one step away from being the spawn of Satan. Blatant disrespect for the office of the President is rampant these days, but how can we expect the American people to respect their leaders when they do everything they can to disrespect each other?
Randy Greenwald
One could claim that ads are put out by an overly zealous campaign machine, but they always end, “I’m Candidate X and I approved this message.” If indeed you approved it, then you have to abide by what is said therein. And if what is said is a lie or a distortion, can we trust you to lead us as president? Thus far it seems as if neither qualifies on that ground. Pretty frustrating, I agree.
Matthew
I to was hoping that the ads this season could focus on what Candidate X stands for and less how many lollypops Candidate Y has stolen from small children.
Randy Greenwald
Funny, isn’t it. The McCain ads focus on Obama, and the Obama ads focus on McCain. Glad this is a positive campaign…
MagistraCarminae
He’s amazing!
Adria
That was awesome, absolutely beautiful.
Randy Greenwald
Should have heard it live. Quite impressive.
MagistraCarminae
Very spiffy! Are you having too much fun? 😉
TulipGirl
What is missing in that list is one of Hope’s great strengths — Christ-focused preaching and grace-centered teaching.
Randy Greenwald
There is a lot missing in a list like this, and perhaps some things that are a bit off the wall, I know that. But I put a list like this out here so that we might ponder what ‘measures of health’ we might not be seeing, if any.Your comment is a great compliment, though, and I thank you for it.
Randy Greenwald
Now and then one should be allowed a diversion, don’t you think?Yes, it has been fun.
MagistraCarminae
Ok- as much as I respect Chick-fil-A (we don’t have them around my neck of the woods, unfortunately) I must say it does present a different picture than I had of you writing your posts. Somehow I was envisioning you in a dimmly-lit, comfortably overstuffed chair, with the aroma of roasting coffee and baking yeast breads and pastries, not eau-de-oil-fryer…
Randy Greenwald
Yes, kind of destroys the atmosphere. I actually work on this during ‘family night’ while Colin, Isaiah, and 392 other kids under that age of ten bounce around. Sometimes there is a clown there playing “Old MacDonald” on a cassette tape full volume so the deaf children (I suppose) can hear the song. I like your picture better. But where’s my pipe? Wouldn’t I need a pipe? 🙂
MagistraCarminae
Yes, a pipe, and possibly a glass of scotch, and while we’re at it, let’;s throw in a fireplace, and a sweater with leather elbow patches…
Randy Greenwald
I’m with you, but if we go this far, I definitely am going to have to ditch the laptop, perhaps for a yellow legal pad. That will make posting a bit more complicated, to be sure, but the laptop clashes with the rest of the scene. And with the fireplace, I believe I’m going to need some cooler weather. So, we may have to part with Florida.And please, make it a cup of tea. I’m not prudish, but I’m not sure scotch and I will agree. And one thing further: no cats. Do not suggest a cat curled up at the foot of the chair. I don’t like cats. (Which is odd, since fully erect bi-pedal cows don’t seem to bother me.)
MagistraCarminae
LOL! I sure do miss being around you…
MagistraCarminae
Excellent quote, Randy. I think in my younger days I was tempted to remove all mystery from our beliefs, but much mystery remains and is at the heart, isn’t it? It’s all about God being God and us, well, not being God.Chris
Rebekah
I wanted to see this, but haven’t managed to yet. Your description of this particular vignette sounds like it might be like the Bruce Willis / Michelle Pfeiffer movie “The Story of Us,” which is somewhat inappropriate at points, but is really, really good and is, as the name indicates, the story of a couple who drifts apart and decides that they aren’t in love anymore.
Andrea Rowe
This is my favorite part of “Paris, je t’aime”, and I think teaches a very good lesson about loving people. It actually teaches a good lesson about sanctification, if you think about it….we grow into the role God created us to play as we act it out. That might be a jump, but the lecture from my seminary class this morning is still in my head….
TulipGirl
I like two or three. . . IMO, the most important thing is whether it is readable, easy on the eyes, with plenty of white space. (And yes, I have a large print Bible, too — have since I was 17!)One of the sites I like content-wise I rarely visit because it is so hard to read.
TulipGirl
Nah, laptops don’t class with the scene, as long as you are using a Mac. Right?And you can get a pipe from S. E. Thile, one that would really fit the image.
TulipGirl
class = clashWhoops.
Randy Greenwald
Absolutely right. The MacBook will blend in well with the rest. And the pipe would be purely cosmetic. Smoking has never been my way of calming frazzled nerves. For that M&Ms are my drug of choice, I'm afraid.
Randy Greenwald
Wow, Andrea, that’s great. I don’t think that that’s a leap at all. That’s a great observation. Don’t let those classes get OUT of our head!And Rebekah, I’ve somehow missed this movie. Tell me it has a satisfying and happy ending and I’ll put it on my list of movies to see!
Gail and Keith
Three is my choice with two as a close, close 2nd. Both are readable, pleasing to the eye, warm, coffee and cream-like. :-)Gail
The Domestic Intellectual
#3 seems to fit your content and style, although I am partial to #4 with a different color scheme… but that is the one that I use on my blog and it fits ME well… not necessarily you:-)
Rebekah
It does have a happy ending, I think! It’s not only a great lesson in interpersonal relationships for marriage, it’s a good lesson for interpersonal relationships in general (I took it for the class “Interpersonal Relationships.”)
Rebekah
I think there’s too much background mess in #2, so I vote no to that one. I don’t see anything inherently wrong with the current scheme, but I do like #3 or #4 (#3 for the color, #4 for the font, but the excessive whiteness of #4 is very, very, white).
Seth
I, being steeped in the International Style, am partial to #4. I like the cleanness and the font. However, since I read the blog via Mail, I rarely have/get to see it, unless I post. So take my opinion (keep in mind it is an aesthetically trained opinion 🙂 ) for what it is.
MagistraCarminae
I vote for either 2 or 3: something about the brown with the “somber and dull”.
Andrea Rowe
I haven’t seen any blogs with 4, so that might be a good reason to go with that one, along with the attractive font.
Anonymous
It’s from: The Godly Man’s Picture, by Thomas Watson, a Puritan Paperback edition published by the Banner of Truth.It can be purchased through Amazon.com for $8.00.
Geoffsnook
Randy,Wow, what a powerful picture of love. Sometimes we do have to take steps (behavioral) and the emotional will come later. Same thing goes sometimes with personal disciplines.
Gus/Adri
I too like #2; I’m partial to brown, and had the same thought as another commenter about the brown fitting with somber and dull.–ae
MagistraCarminae
Thank you, Randy. I (Chris)read these quotes with tears to Dave this morning, until I could not read them, and Dave had to finish. This drives me to my knees at the thought of my own poverty in the things of God. Thank you for these reminders.Chris and Dave, in CO for the weekend
Randy Greenwald
Humbling, no doubt.But, Chris, don’t grieve over your poverty. Give thanks to God for the richness bequeathed to us by the saints who have walked before us.These quotes encourage me to not forget the wisdom, care, and providence of God, and the longing we should have to see him.I trust Dave did not take too much delight in the comments about the ‘depravity of their wives’… 🙂
Randy Greenwald
Hey, I don’t know who you are Mr/Ms Anonymous Person, but thanks for the info!
Geoffsnook
I like the Picture. It has the tongue out, so that’s pretty close. Better than the picture the Bradenton Herald usually uses for me!
Geoffsnook
Randy,Thanks for reminding us of this timeless truth. Happiness is not real unless shared. I almost called you last night, but instead just shared the moment with Amy!
TulipGirl
Ha! That was hilarious! (And, I’ve been known to squish four growing boys in the backseat of my Honda civic hatchback. . .)
Geoffsnook
Randy,Thanks for reminder to look at church history. It is a perfect complement to my nostalgia thoughts. I love history, so church history to me is entertaining to read. But it is also devotional to see how God sustains His church. And it is also challenging how His saints have responded to His call over the years. And finally, it is practical, allowing us not repeat mistakes. Nothing new under the sun.
David
How about hoping for 8-2? I have a feeling that “somber and dull” is more that just the name of your blog this morning!Remember … it’s just a game …
MagistraCarminae
Hey Randy-Are you in mourning today?;-)Chris
TulipGirl
I’ve added the book to my Amazon wishlist — though I doubt I’ll read it any time soon.However, I really got a lot out of these lectures on Ancient and Medieval Church History, and highly recommend them.
Randy Greenwald
It took me a while, but I emerged from my funk – aided by a fishing trip, of course, that that hope springing eternal stuff. So, yes, from the depths of somber dullness, let’s shoot for 8-2.
Seth
Nice. I like the balance between the “Cleanness” of the white that I liked and the richness of the others. It works quite well. A large improvement, no doubt about it.
Randy Greenwald
That is precisely what it is. Thanks for the compliment.
MagistraCarminae
This looks like a GREAT way to mourn…as long as one has taken dramamine, of course…Commend Colin on his catch for me!
Randy Greenwald
Dramamine not needed. Really. The Gulf, even a mile or two out – whatever we were – was nearly as calm as a pond. It was amazing. Calm, not too hot, beautiful blue sky. Really, God was gracious. This was, of course, a day designed to bless Colin, not me, but it worked on us both.
TulipGirl
Wow, how cool!And congrats on the the haul.
Rebekah
But you won the lottery? That’s at least better than us–not any of our names were picked!
Rebekah
While we’re praising dullness, let’s all go out and vote for dullness–early voting starts today, so go out and vote it, while you were just inspired by it! 🙂
Anonymous
Woohoo! Congrats on the Ray’s win! Besides, great pitching last night, seeing the Rays win on their home turf, made this victory–even sweeter! A Blue Jays Fan
Anonymous
Oops! Pardon my typo: Rays’ win!fm
Randy Greenwald
What made it even sweeter was that it silenced the cocky arrogance of the Red Sox fans. I don’t think I would have minded if they’d lost to Toronto…
Randy Greenwald
This was a post in praise of dullness, not in praise of all of those who manifest that trait! I think one should perhaps factor in a man’s and a party’s stated policies, don’t you think? 🙂
Gail and Keith
Phew! All I can say is, Game 7 and the Rays win was a lot of stress. My head was pounding, and not from the deafening noise. But, how cool it was to be be able to attend in person and see the Rays come up with a Championship. No hockey game is that stress-filled, even during the Stanley cup!(Go Lightning!) Maybe we’ll win next drawing, but here’s hoping the Rays win it in 4. Go Rays!
Blue Jays Fan
HA!
TulipGirl
Rebekah, I’m passing over the dullness this year for a bit more passion. *wink*
Gus/Adri
But you didn’t dye them blue!–The E’s
Randy Greenwald
Not yet…– The G’s
Amy
I can’t believe my conservative, laid-back, father-in-law has a mohawk! Excuse me…a Rayhawk. And to think that you are spreading this wild abandon of culturally accepted haircuts to your young, impressionable son… shameless. You’ll only have yourself to blame if Colin becomes a fanatical Rays fan. I hope you’ll be able to live with yourself:) (I think it looks great!)
Gail and Keith
FAN-tastic! True blue fans sportin’ the Rayhawks. G
Randy Greenwald
Yeah, well look what’s happen to my oldest son.Shameless.
Anonymous
Yes, Randy, I do think that we are too comfortably ignorant on difficult issues, both as a nation and as a Christian community. My mother has been a fabulous model for me in this regard. She did not attend college but instead worked to pay for my father’s undergraduate and graduate education. She had two children in the 70’s and stayed home with us when all of the other women in her circles were going back to work to do something “important”. I watched her on a daily basis become educated as an “uneducated women” on difficult issues for her. For example, she grew up in a non-sports loving home. My father and little brother love sports, football especially, and so she learned the game. Why? Because she realized that she was missing out on something wonderful? No. She learned the game because she knew it would deepen her relationship with her son. Today, their relationship goes way deeper than football, but I know that becoming fluent in the pigskin language gave her inroads to that deeper relationship. My dad worked his entire career in the nuclear power industry. Again, my mom learned the language and the theories and the problems and positives and could discuss her husband’s line of work almost as well as he could. What a beautiful gift it was to listen to their dinner table conversations!In the same way, I have found that becoming less ignorant on the topics of the day can deepen my conversations with my non-believing friends. As I’m able to talk the language of the topics that are important to them, the the conversations deepen, and they eventually go to discussions that can be directed toward God and Christ. Knowing political platforms of both parties has enabled me to have great discussions with several non-believing friends that have lead to conversations on morality and then God. Learning a little about the independent, punk rock music industry, while certainly not my favorite topic, has enabled me to have conversations with my CEO-of-a-record-label friend that lets her know I care about what she does (even though I hate that kind of music). That care has opened roads to conversations about the meaning of life and Christ and the Bible. When my husband was a relatively new believer, our pastor went to the wastewater treatment plan where John worked to try and understand his career path a little, even though said pastor could have cared less about a sewage plant. John still talks about the impact that had on him.So, while I do think we have a responsibility as humans to get rid of our ignorance on uncomfortable topics, we have an even greater responsibility as Christians to know about the things that are important to the people to whom God has providentially placed in our paths.What do we do about it? Three things: stretch ourselves, listen and read. Then read again and again. Read while at the stop lights. Read while waiting at the doctor’s office. Read while watching the World Series!Great topic! Thanks for bringing it up.Staci
Randy Greenwald
Staci, this is so good. What a great model you have had. I will need to post a follow up in which I reference your comment. I want more people to read this. It is so good. Thanks for taking the time to write it.
Anonymous
I thought you were joking! I WAS joking! I feel like such a wimp. Now I REALLY have to go buy a shirt….Staci
snowbot
I’m going to go tell all my friends that my pastor has a mohawk.
Geoffsnook
Good thoughts on the Hawk. We had one trying to come through our glass window on three separate occasions. Not sure what he wanted, but man those things are cool.In the new heavens and earth, a better question to ask is this: will snook eat mullet or other bait fish? I sure hope so, because it is so cool to watch them get popped on top! But for sure, stupid porpoises won’t eat snook. But will we? Will we be hitting up vegetables more often? Will we be vegans?
Audra Danielle Dorsey, that's who!
Haha, that’s awesome! The hawks look great. Go rays!
Seth
If you are looking for a good fantasy series, I think that The Chronicles of Prydain by Lloyd Alexander is a good choice. It has been some time since I read them, but they were written for children, so I don’t think that they are as intense as LOTR. The main character is Taran, a boy who longs to be a hero. Eventually, through a recognition of his own inadequacy, he succeeds. They are loosely base on Welsh Mythology says the infallible font of all knowledge, Wikipedia. I remember reading them all several times and enjoying them immensely, though I may have been older than 6 and 9. A catholic blog I found has an exaustive list of potentially “Objectionable” material, but they also list a boy befriending a girl and trying to protect her and “A girl kisses a dwarf on the head” as “Adult Content”. All this to say that I loved them, and I think that others will also.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, Audra. By the way, great looking site.And Snowbot, it’s ‘had’, not ‘has’, I fear. Someone once said, “What we have hear is a failure of nerve.”Yep.So, Staci, buy the shirt. But don’t feel wimpish.
Randy Greenwald
Hey, Mr. Geoffsnook, you are supposed to have the answers, being a pastor and all….
MagistraCarminae
FWIW, we think the Hobbit and the Lord of the Rings is a bit intense for 6 and 9: there are some downright frightening sections!The Prydain books by Alexander are excellent, but perhaps not exactly “like” Lewis in Christian content. However, these were some of our favorite read-alouds!We would recommend the Princess and the Goblin and the Princess and Curdie by George MacDonald, for one. These are some of the only books I recommend in the abridged, as MacDonald needed a good editor…If you want Christian allegory, there are two books by David and Karen Mains called Tales of the Kingdom and Tales of the Resistance. Not great literature, but fun stories.And for pure fantasy story fun, you might look at the Redwall Books by Brian Jacques. They are a bit formulaic, and not neary as good as the Lloyd Alexander books mentioned above, but full of adventure.Ben suggests the children’s books by Mark Helprin: A City in Winter, Veil of Snows, and Swan Lake. I haven’t read those.HTH-Chris and Dave
Gail and Keith
For sure, this called for caffeine in my 16 oz. coffee mug! I had to jerk myself up by the collar and remind myself, ‘so the Rays lost last night. Get a grip,girl! It’s only a game!’ Gail
The Domestic Intellectual
Although I don’t agree with all of their philosophy, I find The Economist to be valuable, particularly in my relationships with international friends. I usually scope the NYTimes headlines at work as well. For a Christian perspective, I always appreciated World magazine.
MagistraCarminae
I think we need to read good theology, good fiction, and a good selection of things that come from a perspective different from our own. We need to read for pleasure, read for current events information, and read for depth of understanding. I try to make myself read worthy books, and reward myself with fluff, but avoid a steady diet of fluff. I like World Magazine, blogs, the Intercollegiate Review, and lots of books.
Gus/Adri
We also like WORLD magazine – contrary to what some people believe, it often disagrees with Republican stance. One of us frequently reads The Economist – though, like another commenter, not always agreeing with their views. The drudge report some may consider sensationalistic or even muckraking, but on that site one can access a wide variety of columnists, ranging from humor (Dave Barry) to others such as Maureen Dowd, Eleanor Clift, David and Rush Limbaugh to name just a few. We read a lot of books, both novels and non-fiction; just about anything and everything. One of us reads more serious stuff (theology) but both like David McCullough’s John Adams, Path Between the Seas et al. and other works of that type.Recommendations come from friends and family, NPR reviews, blogs etc.David Breese, _Seven men who rule the world from the grave_ reminds us of dangers of prevalent cultural philosophies.
TulipGirl
Coming late to this. . .There is so much brilliant children’s literature, that I like to be careful to read as much literature aimed at younger children in the younger years as I can. It seems older children lose the taste for “younger” books, and only rediscover how wonderful they are when they are adults.One of our favorite read-alouds, while not fantasy, is an adventure story — Helen Taylor’s adaption of the classic, “Little Pilgrim’s Progress.”I’ve also read The Hobbit aloud to the boys. I agree with MC that they can be intense. In principal, I’d probably wait until the children were a little older to read it — but we really liked it a lot and my boys were pretty young when I read it to them!Another not-quite-fantasy book that we’ve enjoyed is D’Aulaire’s Book of Greek Myths, which the boys call the Hilarious Book of Greek Myths. (D’Aulaire’s can sound like Hilarious when you’re just a kid!) I respect that some families prefer to wait until their children are much older to introduce this sort of mythology, but we found it a good foil for talking about what we DO believe and why people believe otherwise.Hubby introduced me to The Chronicles of Prydain. His mom read them aloud to him. (For locals. . . The Goodwill Bookstore tends to have these in stock regularly.)I have the unpleasant affliction of falling asleep when I’m reading aloud in the evening, so we haven’t done much of it lately. But we did listen to the Brian Jacques books on tape together a year ago or so. The boys loved them. I heard about the series first from Jerram Barrs — and have a copy of his booklist for children posted here.
Andrea Rowe
I think the “stay up when it awakens you” part is the hardest….but then again, you also have to do the “go to bed on time” part. That is the hardest part for me!
TulipGirl
Several people close to me (not at church, but elsewhere) have basically taken the abortion issue off of the table this election season with the comment, “Nothing has changed the past 8 years in protecting the unborn.”And I can understand that sentiment. But then. . . one of the first things the current president did was to reverse the executive orders of the previous president regarding federal funding for abortion. The past two Supreme Court nominees have been ones that tend towards stricter construction of the Constitution (as opposed to the tendency of activist judges of the Warren court.) And one of the current candidates has stated that one of his first acts as president would be to promote and sign the Freedom of Choice Act, which would go beyond Roe v. Wade.It seems as if our culture as a whole HAS been shifting towards what the pro-life movement has advocated — a place where abortion is unnecessary and unthinkable, a place where the choice for life is doable, where the community support structures are in place, where shame doesn’t require hiding pregnancy. And this is a good thing. . . But it’s still tenuous and FOCA and federal funding would not help. . .So, I simply can’t put this one issue aside. . .
snowbot
Have you seriously considered casting a vote for a third party candidate? “Always vote for principle, though you may vote alone, and you may cherish the sweetest reflection that your vote is never lost.” – John Quincy Adams
Randy Greenwald
Indeed I’ve considered it. But I’d appreciate it if you, or Mr. Adams, would persuade me that such a vote is NOT lost.
snowbot
Comparison of U.S. Presidential Candidates
snowbot
FYI, I’m still undecided. But for what it’s worth, I just ran across this article from Constitution Party candidate Chuck Baldwin.. it’s his attempt to persuade you that a vote for him is not a wasted vote.
Gus/Adri
Snowbot, if there are two candidates that are pro-life, one is willing to engage other countries for mutual benefit and the other is extremely isolationist, I choose the former.g
Gail and Keith
Many of you know I am rabidly pro-life having risked arrest and gone to jail to save the unborn. I still am a radical when it comes to the unborn, but I’ve softened in the last year or two when it comes to being a “one-issue voter,” a term I despised being labeled with. My vote is already cast and so……we await the outcome for good or ill. G
Randy Greenwald
Maybe ‘softening’ is one way of looking at ‘maturation’? I don’t know. I do know that change can be a good thing. Maybe we all are on a trajectory of maturity. I hope so. Gus’s comment reminds us that in reality none of us are ‘one-issue’ voters per se. We have issues that are of greater importance than others – all will have those – and then there is a hierarchy of issues lining up beneath that. So, though I say that there is one issue driving me, that is not really the case.
Rebekah
Despite my tendency to get jumpy, and excitable on this topic, I am really very rational…I only get disturbed when people don’t go through the complex decision matrix that you, Randy obviously went through. (I’m not pointing any fingers at any of the readers of this blog–just at strict partisan voting in general). As tulipgirl points out, some gains were made during the past 8 years to fight the pervasiveness of abortion, but what made me take it off the table, so to speak, is that I think abortion is fixed in the American mindset as a given right. It’s not going to be outlawed, and I think there are enough checks and balances in place from solid conservative leaders and watchdog groups that it’s not going to become much more pervasive. And within your own personal sphere, you can do life-affirming things. (And I didn’t say that because I think tulipgirl is wrong–that was just more…a reflection upon my personal thought process). Somebody asked me the other day how I as a “good little Christian” could be supporting the ticket I was heading out to campaign for, and I said, “Well, the only thing I support the other ticket on is their view of abortion and gay marriage,” then consequently left off the important rest of the answer about how as a “good little Christian,” I support the ways the ticket values life in other ways… So, I guess I’m saying that I think…you could be sinning to vote for either candidate…or you could be honoring God…by voting for either candidate. It all depends upon your heart orientation as you bubble in your ballot.
Randy Greenwald
Rebekah – thanks for being rational! It is worthwhile to ponder your comments. You may give me too much credit for rationality!I’m so encouraged by the conversation that my post started. I sometimes wonder if Christians, conservatives in particular, can differ civilly. I’m encouraged here to think we might. And if we do, then we can hear each other, understand each other, and perhaps really think and not react. But if someone called me a ‘good little Christian…’ I think that’s when I’d become jumpy!
Gus/Adri
Re: ‘abortion right’It will be interesting to find out if the South Dakota constitutional initiative to ban abortions passes.g
Matthew
There can and will never be a candidate for president who represents and agrees with what I think is the best direction for this country. Having said that I have strong disagreements with the candidates of both major parties, but such is the nature of politics. Voting for a third party candidate is nothing short of a wasted vote. Running on these tickets is nothing short of insanity. The simple fact is we have a two party system, and have for over 150 years. There was mention of the Constitution Party the most votes they ever received by their most popular candidate Howard Phillips was less then one percent of the vote. Running on a third party ticket to me is childish, immature, and a giant waste of taxpayers money. To continually bang your head on the wall and cry that it isn’t fair is not the way to change things. Yes, I can appreciate some of the views that these candidates have and some of the things they stand for, but to vote for them is doing nothing more then getting “the one” I disagree with more from the major party into office. I didn’t really care for Ron Paul when he was running for the nomination of the Republican Party, I do however have respect for him because even though he is a libertarian he was mature enough to try to get the nomination in a format that works. No, he did not get the nomination but he was able to raise awareness for his beliefs and paved the way for others. How many people have heard of Chuck Baldwin? Or take Bob Barr seriously. The two major parties are what we make them, join one of them, be active, let your voice be heard, and you can change the status quo. But I implore you, don’t waste your vote.
Matthew
A quick note on Chuck Baldwin, this guy is one of those special people that I can’t have a rational discussion about. This man is a conspiracy theory nut, a loony, and a crackpot. Coming from me, who believes in Big Foot and that Marilyn Monroe was murdered is saying volumes. He continues to ignore every piece of evidence to the contrary and perpetuate the lie of a North American Union and that the Security and Prosperity Partnership of North America will end life as we know it goto the web page and read about it Chuck http://www.spp.gov/. There will be NO Amerodoller. “They” are not going to merge Mexico, Canada, and the US. There are no secret plots to dissolve our national sovereignty. There are no planes for a NAFTA Super Highway running from Canada to Mexico. What’s worse is he knows this is true but he uses it to get attention to his pathetic political campaign. A man according to his own article wants to release immediately two boarder patrol agents who shot a man and then tried to cover it up. Disgusting.
Seth
Well stated. One thing that I have noticed is the death and demons seem predominantly relegated to the store shelves. Most of the people that I see dressed up, excepting the occasional teenager, are in costumes that show off a sense of humor rather that morbidity. One of my coworkers and her boyfriend are dressing up as George and Jane Jetson. How awesome is that!! When I can dredge up enough expendable cash, I want to piece together a Dread Pirate Roberts costume…
Matthew
If we had the cash Alissa wanted to dress up as Mulder and Scully. Left to her own devices she would no doubt dress up as a ray of sunshine or a flower, or something else full of happiness.
Amy
I hear of different roots for Halloween. I think I saw an article last year that was arguing it had Christian roots. Who knows what the real truth is? For most people who aren’t wicka or whatever, Halloween simply means getting candy, spending time with kids, and dressing up.Provided Staci Thomas’ kids are healthy, we’ll be borrowing a Bumblebee outfit for Connar. Its too small for me.BTW-Randy, you need to be a Candy Nazi. Don’t let teen-agers or parents “work the system.” They’ve probably “worked the system” their whole lives and the buck must stop at your house! I would advise getting some face paint to make you look tougher and meaner.Geoff
Gail and Keith
Halloween has its roots in the ancient Celtic festival known as Samhain, a celebration of the end of the harvest season. Later cultures believed that departed spirits came back to inhabit the bodies of those left behind. To scare them away they began decorating turnips, potatoes with scary faces. Various Popes moved All Saints Day from May 13 to October, perhaps to counteract the pagan festival. You’ll find more than you cared to know by doing a Google or Wikipedia search.G
Randy Greenwald
C’mon, Matthew – Alissa dressed as a ray of sunshine would just look like, well, Alissa! And, Seth, well, as you wish. Connar would be cute no matter what you put on him – it’s Geoff I want to see as a bumblebee. And decorating turnips and potatoes, now that would be fun. I’ll have to think about that.
Geoffsnook
Randy,I could go dressed up as the home plate umpire for Game 5. That dude was every bit as scary as a witch, and without the predictability…Geoff
TulipGirl
A paleontologist? Cute!
TulipGirl
“. . .what made me take it off the table, so to speak, is that I think abortion is fixed in the American mindset as a given right. It’s not going to be outlawed. . .”More or less, I see things in a similar way. I still think great strides can be made to continue to make abortion undesirable, unnecessary, unthinkable. . . Most of that will continue to be through cultural shifts. Maybe it’s just my perspective, but while “abortion rights” seem to be more of a given among GenX/GenY — doesn’t it seem to you that these same groups are more pro-life than what we saw 10-15 years ago?And while I believe this is primarily a cultural shift and that it is highly unlikely that abortion will be “outlawed,” in the near future, there are still government actions (judicially, legislatively, administratively) that can either hurt or help vulnerable pregnant women, their children and families. Funding for Planned Parenthood here in the states and around the world, judicial appointments, enforcing health standards for freestanding abortion clinics, Women’s Right to Know acts. . . so many things that either promote abortion as the “solution” or promote true solutions. But, I’m preaching to the choir here. . . *grin*
Andrea Rowe
Geoff, I want to see some photos of Connar the bubblebee!!
TulipGirl
Oh! I forgot to write also. . .”And while I believe this is primarily a cultural shift and that it is highly unlikely that abortion will be “outlawed,” in the near future. . .”I’m not ready to give up hope that protection of the preborn, the aged, the infirm and the vulnerable is beyond good and life-affirming legislation. The boys and I watched “Amazing Grace” a few weeks ago during Mommy Movie Night. What an amazing example of perseverance, going against what the culture had accepted as the norm, continuing to shine the light on the darkness of slavery. . . I have a friend who has said she is cynical, and if Roe is reversed and legislation on abortion goes back to the states, the result would be people pridefully saying, “Not in my state. . .” while turning a blind eye to the problems around them.On the contrary, I believe that after the dust and legislation pretty much settled in various states, I think we’d see people’s efforts expand. . . continuing to care for mothers and children. . . but also to other communities in need. Maybe I’m optimistic. . . maybe I’m naive. . . But I am hopeful.
Randy Greenwald
Tulipgirl’s an optimist. I love an optimist. I wish I were one! I am one only in the light of the eventual crush of Satan under the feet of Christ, and though Paul says that will be soon, he said that 2000 years ago.I am not expecting to see much change in terms of abortion being substantially outlawed. That would surprise me. But what I don’t want to see are restrictions which are now in place eased any further. I’d be interested in hearing from Rebekah, though, what life-affirming things Christians can be doing beyond supporting (or not supporting) pro-life candidates. That’s not a challenge – I’m sincerely interested.
Anonymous
“I’d be interested in hearing from Rebekah, though, what life-affirming things Christians can be doing beyond supporting (or not supporting) pro-life candidates. That’s not a challenge – I’m sincerely interested.”I’m not Rebekah, but I’d like to weigh in on this a little. A life-affirming thing that Christians can do is to encourage their loved ones/friends with infertility problems to consider adoption as a first choice instead of a second choice after significant infertility treatments have been attempted. All too often, infertile couples are uneducated in the moral issues that surround things like in vitro, as they are desperate to have children. Christians tend to be hesitant to discuss the moral dilemas surrounding such significant fertility treatments because educated discussions can lead to the abortion realm. Encouraging, urging, suggesting adoption to people struggling with infertility is a wonderful, life-affirming thing that Christians can do to help the pro-life agenda. That, in my opinion and experience, would be a very good place to start.Staci
Gail and Keith
You said: “And as Christians it does little to enhance our battle against the deep wickedness in our culture by turning the lights out on our neighbors’ children who only want to look cute and to get a piece of candy.” So, those who do turn the lights out and hide in the back bedroom are hampering the spread of the Gospel? Hmmmmmmmmm. No room for personal conviction???? Just wondering. G
Rebekah
I’m not sure what exactly to say–I said we can do “life affirming things,” but what are they? I don’t know… I agree with Staci that encouraging couples to adopt, instead of venturing into what I say is the morally “biguous” realm of in vitro, is a huge one. (I actually had somebody tell me that he supports abortion because people aren’t willing to adopt the kids that are already out there and need parents). As a culture supporting families that choose to have lots of kids and not denigrating them (Hope hasn’t ever been a church like that, but culturally, big families are smirked at). And then at we get so worked up at Planned Parenthood–and rightly so, because their sex ed IS awful–but I’d love to see the “Christian Community” come up with a sex ed curriculum that can take over and be a really good, solid alternative to what Planned Parenthood is offering. That’s a whole other discussion that I could blog about all day long, but there’s a whole different mindset at play that views abortion as just another form of birth control and a baby as a disruption to the convenient and happy life that was previously at play. But I’m still a pessimist, and I think that nothing will change. I think things at the youth level in sex ed programs would probably have the biggest impact.
Randy Greenwald
Actually, plenty of room for personal conviction! It is my opinion (conviction) that doing so does not accomplish much. But I don’t at all expect that that would (or should) be everyone’s conviction. Correct? That’s why I put these things out here, so we can have interaction on subjects where we differ.
MagistraCarminae
Well, I’m just glad that Gail is keeping you honest. Way to go, Gail!Chris, off to get some ice cream…
Amy
Randy,Great response. I obviously agree with your assessment on Halloween. But folks are free to differ in their convictions. Our goal at Hope has been to create a place where people can disagree and still love one another. I think posting stuff like this can help us sharpen, question, or hold fast to our specific convictions. Keep it up! Andrea,I’ll be sure to put up some pictures if we get that costume. Otherwise, he’ll probably be a baby buccaneer.Geoff
Randy Greenwald
Rebekah – thanks for your thoughts. As to this: “I’d love to see the “Christian Community” come up with a sex ed curriculum that can take over and be a really good, solid alternative to what Planned Parenthood is offering. “I believe that CareNet has produced and has used locally an alternative. I’m not familiar with the details, but I know it is there and I suspect it is quality.
Gail and Keith
The Rays gave us an exciting season and the sport gained thousands of new fans. Eight Men Out, The Black Sox and the 1919 World Series by Eliot Asinof is a good read. Now we continue on with college football (Go Gators, Go Penn State!) and hockey! http://www.tampabay.com/sports/hockey/lightning/ You don’t get a faster, more energetic sport than hockey. Basketball, neah, not so much. G
Randy Greenwald
Thanks for the recommendation. Actually Jeremy had recommended that to me (twice) and I kept forgetting the name. Now it is safely tucked away in my Amazon.com wishlist, for any gift buyers out there…. Click here! (In case you didn’t know where to go… :-)Oh, I have no shame.
Gail and Keith
Hey, you may borrow our copy! Notice how I missed the hint. 🙂 G
Seth
If I recall correctly, you came back from that trip seriously sunburned. So in that sense, the “Rays” won…
Matthew
If you want to found out anything and everything you ever wanted to know about all the diffrent dynamics that go into not only the playing but the broadcasting of the game Tim McCarver’s Baseball for Brain Surgeons and Other Fans: Understanding and Interpreting the Game So You Can Watch It Like a Pro is a great read to get you ready for next season.
snowbot
Great discussion! By the way, based on my previous comments, apparently I made the impression that I was arguing in favor of third parties. That wasn’t my intention! I posed the question for the sake of discussion. And the only reason I mentioned Chuck Baldwin was because Randy wanted to hear an argument in favor of third parties… so I directed him to his argument, since I had just read it. But I wasn’t intending to endorse him or even the idea of third parties, necessarily. Just clearing that up. Apparently there was some confusion on that matter. : )
Gail and Keith
What a great picture of Colin radiating sunshine! G
Randy Greenwald
Well, Matthew, sounds good to me. And gee, if I’m not mistaken, Christmas is just around the corner…So, what do you think of this guy’s assessment on Amazon.com: “Don’t bother to pick this up … McCarver has no business writing about something he doesn’t understand. There are much better ways to spend your hard earned cash!!”Did he read the same book?!
snowbot
Just adding to the discussion… I found this website to be of interest – ProLife ProObama. I’d be curious to hear thoughts about the arguments laid out there.
Matthew
You may or may not like Tim McCarver and his broadcasting ability’s, but one thing he does know is baseball.
Rebekah
How cute, and fun for Colin!
MagistraCarminae
Randy-Great thoughts! You say:”To long for patience and self-control, among other things is good. This is to long for Christ-likeness. To long for the things of the Spirit, to lust, even, after the fruit of the Spirit (Galatians 5) is a good thing.”Isn’t part of the problem we have when we seek out the fruit without the Spirit? WHen we seek the outward manifestation, say, of self-control, as if it is available to us apart from Christ and His Spirit? Those tricky heart motivations are so important.You also say:”So, to walk according to the Spirit is to first know (by the law, even) where we are supposed to be, as painful as it is to realize that we are not yet there.”Amen and amen! As we are reading the Mortification of Sin in our Sunday School class, Owen makes this painfully real as he discusses the daily battle to die to self and live for Christ! What an excellent reminder for us. Can’t wait for next Friday’s thoughts…Chris
Rebekah
I have a great #11 thing to do: Watch NHL hockey, preferably the Tampa Bay Lightning.
Gus/Adri
WOW! He’s cute, and the big fish is great. What an accomplishment.–ae
Gus/Adri
FedEx Express is one of four types of shipping service the company offers. It means “same day expedited”; there are also “custom critical”, “international next flight” and “expedited freight service”.Yes, it looks redundant, but what name would you choose to express what they want to indicate?–ae
Randy Greenwald
Come,now. Don’t you find the tiniest bit of humor in “Federal Express Express”? What’s next? Delta Airlines Flight Service? Avis Car Rental Car Rental? I don’t know what they SHOULD have called it – and that is a good question – but I think that what they CHOSE to call it is just funny.
snowbot
I don’t know if anyone is still reading these comments, but… I appreciate John Piper’s comments here. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YGjGbZNyIBY
Anonymous
This comment from Chris:”Isn’t part of the problem we have when we seek out the fruit without the Spirit?” has been so helpful to me as I’ve pondered this topic over the weekend. Sometimes it is helpful when someone puts words to your current struggle. Seeking fruit without the Spirit is what I so often do, but I wasn’t realizing I was doing it in that way until I read her comment.So, thanks again for the discussion, Randy. And thanks to Chris, who gave me one of those lightning bolt moments!Staci
Randy Greenwald
Hold on. Wait a minute. I’m the preacher here. You are supposed to walk away with profound movement in your soul because of what I say, not because of some mere commenter. What’s this world coming to? Is the Holy Spirit working through ordinary people instead of us highly trained super-spiritual professionals? Oh, whatever am I to do? Getting serious, would be a good start, but I fear it’s too late for that for me. Thanks for sharing your hearts, both of you. The two of you someday must meet.
Anonymous
Randy,I do walk away with profound movement in my soul from what you say, and I did when you spent a CONSIDERABLE amount of time answering my question many months ago. Chris is saying what you expressed in that Word document that you sent to me…she just said it in 16 words and it bit my soul when I read your thoughts that concisely! Oh, that more people would have a pastoral staff, like I do, that spend the time shepherding their flock like you and Geoff do. I am so thankful. And I’m thankful for people like Chris, who can bite my soul with words, having never met me!!!!!!Staci
MagistraCarminae
LOL Randy! You’ve been ministering to my soul for the last 30 years, by God’s grace! And Staci- if we never get to meet this side of heaven, we will when God’s family is gathered before His throne, and we’ll have lots of time together then!Chris
Gail and Keith
I’m finding that a person’s eschatological view during this election season determines that person’s emotional state as he considers what happens if Candidate “A” wins over Candidate “B” or, “B” wins over “A.” Some years back we cried as our candidate lost. We despaired at the blackness that would ensue. Well, the world didn’t end. We forgot, for a time, that God carries out his plan regardless of which oval one bubbles in on the ballot, regardless of which candidate wins. Vote responsibly by carefully considering the issues at stake? Yes. Then rest in God to carry out his plan whatever the outcome. G
Gus/Adri
It seems to me that election campaigns have become increasingly acrimonious in the last ten years.gus
TulipGirl
“Some years back we cried as our candidate lost. We despaired at the blackness that would ensue. Well, the world didn’t end.”Was that ’92? Because I remember feeling at the time that there was much reason to despair. . . and. . . like you said, well, the world didn’t end.
TulipGirl
“I believe that CareNet has produced and has used locally an alternative. I’m not familiar with the details, but I know it is there and I suspect it is quality.”I am acquainted with the woman who heads that up locally. . . And that was one of the things I was involved with in Texas B.C. (Before children. . .) I think there is more of a “think global, act local” approach to much of the pro-life movement. (In contrast, for example, to federally-directed initiatives or International Planned Parenthood Federation.)
Gail and Keith
Yes, it was 1992. My first time to vote in a Presidential election was 1968. I listened to those returns at school in England. We all know what happened years later during that President’s 2nd term! G
TulipGirl
I’m impressed at the mad skillz of candy distribution at your household.We had less TorTers this year, than in years past. . . We usually have a nice representation of out-of-neighborhooders, too. I like that, though I do worry about people driving through the winding roads with so many kids afoot.The boys’ favorite costume they saw this year was the “pumpkin belly” — a brave preggers mom who turned her belly into a pumpkin!
Carol
Here are a few more links for snowbot:http://www.nrlchapters.org/obamabookhttp://www.obamawantsyou.com/http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_NN4TKrViNE
Gail and Keith
We had, maybe, 10 kids at our door.And we have lots of candy! The grocery store had buy one, get one free–and all of it chocolate! G
MagistraCarminum
Rejoicing in the good work accomplished by the Greenwalds that night. Barb is the woman!!Chris
Gail and Keith
Well! I don’t know whether to laugh or to cry. Thanks for that interlude in this off the charts election day. G
TulipGirl
I haven’t been able to listen to the song yet, but you definitely get brownie points in my book for knowing and liking OtR.
snowbot
I hear greenbot.net is available… Great song!
Anonymous
I thought certainly the candies used in your sermon illustration were leftover from the 31st. You mean you had to go out and buy MORE?!No one comes to our door, though there are some youngsters a few units away. We don’t stock up on candy b/c we don’t want it in the house.Spouse asks, “Why didn’t Randy borrow from son’s bag if he so much wanted treats?”–ae
Randy Greenwald
Well, ae, perhaps I have not dipped into my son’s bag for one of three reasons:1) he is Boba Fett, for crying out loud. That is one dangerous dude.2) where I come from, dipping into someone else’s supply is not called ‘borrowing’3) there’s nothing in his bag that I like.I let you determine which is the real reason.And yes, Tulip Girl, we are talking mad scientific skills. The woman in this house is nothing if not concerned for details in matters like this.
Randy Greenwald
greenbot.net would be a bit skimpy on selections. Remember, I ditched a lot of good music in a fit of holiness a couple decades ago.And as a pastor, I treasure brownie points however I get them. I seem quite adept at squandering them profusely over time!Glad to find some other OtR fans. Maybe someday they’ll actually come to Florida.
Matthew
We had 2. Alissa and I bet before the night began she said 3. I won the bet. I think she bought the candy more for personal consumption then giving away to various Boba Fetts and princesses, seeing as she picked out everything she like out of the bowl as to not let it get taken.
Randy Greenwald
Alissa, you are my kind of girl… 😉
Matthew
“A fit of holiness” Classic =)
Gail and Keith
Well said. G
Staci Thomas
Yes, yes, yes. As I marched my four children into my polling place yesterday, I was overcome with the honor it was to be able to vote freely and safely. The four countries from which my children got their start in life do not provide their citizens with the same opportunity I had yesterday. What a wonderful country this is, indeed.Staci
Anonymous
Not only did we vote – and it took less than 10 minutes with lines so short – we got our free Starbucks coffee afterward. What a country!The E’s
Anonymous
Agree. One fly in the ointment is the inability to prevent fraud. Maybe we’ll have to imitate the countries where voters dip one finger in indelible ink. But wait… someone will find a way to quickly bleach the ink. Oh well, we still have a good system.GE
MagistraCarminum
Amen and amen. You ought to get that woman to post her excellent thoughts more often!Love,Chris
Gus/Adri
As someone has commented, M L King, Jr.’s dream is not here yet. Some voters are still voting for or against the skin color.GE
Randy Greenwald
Oh, yes, Chris. And I ought to jump out of an airplane. And run the Boston Marathon. And try for the land speed record at Bonneville. And run with the bulls in Pamplona. Yes, I ought to do this. ‘Tis a bit easier written than accomplished, experience has shown.
Gail and Keith
I have that book and if you leave your kid as a ransom, you may borrow it. I don’t want to lose it. :-)Gail
Anonymous
Well said, Barb! I was wondering when we would hear from you! You should comment more often. :)As the saying goes: “Quiet waters run deep!” Keep them coming Barb! Love ya!Fiona
Geoffsnook
I have no idea what you’re talking about. I can’t think of a time I wish my lips would have been glued together before. Yeah, right….BTW-the word verification code to post this is “Wings.” That means something. I don’t know what, but something. Maybe Wings Night?
Randy Greenwald
There are times, of course, when it works the other way. My lips remain ‘stuck’ when I really should be saying something. Like, “Have you considered Christianity?”Wings, eh? Very curious.
Geoffsnook
Well played Barb. That should be your introduction to start your own blog.
Anonymous
The book is in the church library also.I’m glad to share “my” Gus with all y’all.–ae
Randy Greenwald
So, are we going to borrow Gus, or the book?
Anonymous
My complements Barb, very well said! Especially the first sentence of the last par.: “I long for the day,when…..” If I just may add my optimistic view of this sentence:I believe that this day has arrived. I firmly believe that the majority of the voters did not vote for Mr.Obama because of his race, but voted for Mr.Obama because they believe he is the better candidate to lead our nation through this very difficult and turbulent times to a strong and healthy recovery.Paul Der
MagistraCarminum
Excellent post, Randy. Thanks for this encouragement this morning!Chris
TulipGirl
Echoing Chris. My first thought? Excellent.
Anonymous
Amen! I’m encouraged to hear about our new members.Tom
Gus/Adri
Neat footnote! I’m thankful for tulip girl – her posts and her person and friendship.I have to add, though, that – being Dutch and a five point Calvinist and all – I consider myself a tulip girl too; but she got the name first!–ae
J
Learning. . . slowly. . . about the role of the covenant in our theology and our understanding of the Gospel has had a profound impact on how I understand myself, my family history, and my children.
Gus/Adri
Venturing a guess, which was thought out before your footnote was added. 1) there is the element of liking to be scared: could I become a person like this, doing such awful things?2) an element of pride: I am better than that; I could/would never become such a person i.e. do such evil.FWIW–ae
MagistraCarminum
In addition to what Adri said (which had also come to my mind), I wonder if we don’t in some way vicariously enjoy the sin of others, knowing we do not have to commit it ourselves to enjoy its pleasures. This, I think, is the most dangerous reason we watch the sins of others, like voyeurs, experiencing from afar.
Gail and Keith
I do not enjoy watching films portraying evil. It speaks of “man’s inhumanity to man” and scares me, I suppose, because these atrocities could easily be perpetrated on me. Interesting side note on the phrase I quoted:http://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/244100.htmlThis phrase, which is always used with a sense of regret, was coined by Robert Burns and used in his poem From Man was made to Mourn: A Dirge, 1785: ‘Many and sharp the num’rous ills Inwoven with our frame! More pointed still we make ourselves Regret, remorse, and shame! And Man, whose heav’n-erected face The smiles of love adorn, – Man’s inhumanity to man Makes countless thousands mourn!Gail
Randy Greenwald
I am sitting at Panera, overhearing (NOT eavesdropping) a conversation between an EMS guy with an obvious law enforcement background talking with another whom I can’t identify. The ex-cop is describing the difference between the impact of pepper spray and a taser in subduing a bad guy. The reality this brings reminds me that these things are real. The mafia is real. Crime is real. Violence is real. People without concern for life are real. Evil is real. Sin is real. I don’t enjoy being reminded of it, but there is value in being reminded. Story – in this case movies – does draw me into a world that I would not normally frequent or observe. I don’t want to stay there, and I don’t wish to participate in a story that legitimizes or glamorizes that evil. But there is yet some value in being brought into it, safely, even for a time.
MagistraCarminum
I think this is true, Randy. But your questions was “Why do we enjoy watching evil”. There is a tough line for me to draw between enjoying evil as entertainment and seeing evil as a reminder of its potence and power in this broken world. I have no problem with being reminded. But I think I should have a problem with watching evil for entertainment. The problem is that line is so blurry for me. I think this is likely because I love evil too much, and don’t hate it enough.
Randy Greenwald
I’ve been reading Flannery O’Conner, and she presents to us quite an array of twisted characters. “A Good Man Is Hard to Find” is a great story which ends with an awful display of violence, but the man who commits that violence is presented as a human character for whom we feel at least a bit of sympathy.Perhaps we enjoy what is human in these stories and should not condemn ourselves for that.
MagistraCarminum
I must admit that while I enjoy O’Connor to some degree, and understand her use of imagery and violence, it is not my cup of tea. And you are right in pointing out that we feel sympathy for the humanity of men in their tragic state. However, many things that one could argue avoid glorifying evil, give a more voyeuristic look at it than I am comfortable with. There are some things, after all, that should not even be named among us. Part of the question I struggle with is when I have crossed that line over into giving myself ideas I should be trying to avoid having. I don’t know if you understand what I’m saying. Speaking for myself, I can often find ways to justify watching evil that I probably shouldn’t, and give all kinds of great sounding arguments, just because on some level I want to. That is not a good reason to watch evil.
Randy Greenwald
Chris,Agreed – our hearts are deceitful and may find pleasure where they ought now. But, our hearts are also fearful, and may place limits where they need not. Oh, for wisdom.
MagistraCarminum
Amen, Randy. Perhaps the real question is, how do we watch film, or read books, or do anything for that matter, with an eye to the protection and growth of our own holiness through the process of becoming more Christ-like? I need to ask that question more often when I watch movies.
Randy Greenwald
I’m waiting for someone with film studies coursework under his belt to chime into this one, but thus far, Snowbot has remained strangely silent. ARe you there…?
Mike
Hey Randy! Thanks for commenting on my post – it’s good to catch up with you and see your very active blog. You’re a dedicated blogger, and I like what I read. Blessings to you, Barb, and the family!
Randy Greenwald
Dedicated? Perhaps. Addicted? More likely… !
snowbot
I’m sorry I didn’t have the pleasure of making your drink this time. Hopefully it was just as tasty! : )
Randy Greenwald
Wasn’t even CLOSE! 🙂
Matthew
Speaking of being OC sprayed.. I get to enjoy that little experience AGAIN tomorrow. I have seen and enjoyed both films. Why do violent sports, or video games appeal to so many? I think it runs along the same lines.
amy in NM
Thanks Randy, I had a sin soaked day yesterday. Today is a new day to start again with a prayer that God will change me more and more.
TulipGirl
TG = Thanksgiving? I think I like that. *grin*
MagistraCarminum
If I had to choose my favorite 20th century novel, this would be it, hands down. And I got the “somber and dull” from the start, just for the record.The picture is beautiful.Chris in NM
Gus/Adri
How I agree with Chris on the novel! But Too Late the Phalarope may be even better. I think “somber and dull” suits perfectly. ;)Not!–ae
MagistraCarminum
Adri-I also enjoyed Too Late the Phalarope, but not as much. There is so much redemption in Cry the Beloved Country…Chris in NM
Randy Greenwald
Thanks for the comps on the picture, Chris. I shot about thirty pictures of that sun going down. More precious in the memory, though, was that the entire family was there enjoying the sunset. What a treasure that was.Too Late the Phalarope is good. Both books probe the regrets of fatherhood, and that is, well, somber. But not dull.And before I leave the subject, I thought JEJ was good in the movie version, but Richard Harris was remarkable. That said, the movie misses, in my mind, most of the redemptive themes. Still worth watching, however.
MagistraCarminum
I agree about the movie. It was an excellent movie unless you compared it to the book :-)Chris
TulipGirl
I’d heard of, but not read, Paton’s wonderful works. Picked up a copy at the Goodwill Bookstore yesterday, reminded by this post.
Geoffsnook
Wow Randy. Glad to hear of your experience. At the very least-and there is probably much more that we should be learning-is the importance of stepping outside of our comfort zones to speak to those that who may need encouragement. Some folks that we know need encouragement, and perhaps some folks that we don’t know who need encouragement.
Gail and Keith
I think the Reverend Mr. Osborn is off base on this. The person who commented on his post makes a lot more sense. G
Randy Greenwald
You may be right, G. But the discussions need to be held, with respect and biblical wisdom. Otherwise we tend to base our positions on emotion or pragmatism.
Gail and Keith
If one disagrees with someone is that considered being disrespectful?(Rhetorical question) I did not say I agreed with everything the commenter had written in response to Mr. Osborn’s post. Certainly I have no M.Div tacked onto the end of my name. G
TulipGirl
We have one linux-based computer in the mix, thanks to a friend who re-purposed it for our homeschool. I’m hopeful that it will inspire the boys to mess around with coding and such. . .
Gail and Keith
Kathryn installed Linux on her computer quite a few years ago. G
MagistraCarminum
When he was in high school, Tim built a computer and made it a dual-boot machine with linux and windows. I know the joy of making it work from watching him 🙂 We have 4 PCs (one laptop)on our in-home network (more than we have people…) and whenever the children come home, they EACH bring their own laptops.It really does seem ridiculous somehow…
MagistraCarminum
The only thing that would be better is a photo of the twins and rolls, both freshly delivered! 🙂
TulipGirl
Yummm! What a neat opportunity!
Gail and Keith
How cool is that!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! G
Anonymous
I caught it; and – sorry – but I don’t believe your reason (excuse?!) for why it was there.Kudos to Barb. What would you do without her. (Don’t answer; we already know, so that was a rhetorical question.)–aePS – sorry, but sometimes I have to laugh at the word verification “words” e.g. “dizinin.” Do you put them there deliberately, based on who is commenting? It feels to me too close to “dizzy ninny” or “ditsy nincompoop.”
Amy
Randy,I’ve heard more positive response about Hellboy II than I could have anticipated. It looks incredibly ridiculous, but now you’re like the billionth person to speak highly of it. I’m going to have to get Net Flix, since we can’t go to the dollar theater anymore.As far as Dan in Real Life-that was a fantastic picture of family. And it was super clean, as far as I remember.Pieces of April was also a quality flick. My favorite of course is Little Miss Sunshine. There is a beautiful picture of family finally coming together.Funny that movies can teach us stuff, eh? Guess that’s one more proof all of us are made in the Image of God.
Rebekah
Something about April in “Pieces of April” came off as cliché to me, but I think by the end of the movie, I kind of wanted her to stay far, far away from her family, sadly (but it’s been a while since I’ve seen it), as wonderful as it was that she tried to pull them all together.”What’s Eating Gilbert Grape” is one of my all-time favorite movies, simply because of Leonardo DiCaprio’s awesome acting. I think that he is one of the worlds worst actors (he does pretty much the same character–brash …obnoxious…pretty much what he is in real life…), but he does an amazing job of portraying a troubled autistic and mentally challenged kid. And then the family is an absolute mess, but they are so very loving to each other in the only ways they know how to be.
Randy Greenwald
Just for the record, I only said that I would WATCH Hellboy II. I’ve not yet commended it. I did find Hellboy I very interesting, and entertaining to boot. LMS certainly brings family together. Of course, you’ve got the whole ‘grandfather-teaching-the-granddaughter-the-stripper-moves’ thing going on, but beyond that, what a great movie. “This song is for my grandpa” “That’s nice. Where is your grandpa right now?” “In the trunk of our van.” And you have to love the suicidal Steve Carell responding to the final judgment at the end, “We can LIVE with that”!And what can you say about DiCapprio in Gilbert Grape? It was an amazing performance. I was not as thrilled with the movie as a whole, but its picture of the centrality of family, no matter the depth of our own individual weaknesses is marvelous. It suggests to me that though Hollywood does not affirm a Christian world view, it cannot help but to reveal a longing that is consistent with it.
MagistraCarminum
Irony, indeed. Making no presumptions here, either about your opinion, or in regards to Rev. Wright, who I am sure has said many excellent things.
Rebekah
I’ve only seen a handful of “Sopranos” episodes, and it’s a terrific show because the character interaction is rich and real feeling. But that brings it back to the problem of Tony the sociopath. Other than the obligatory mobster Catholic Church interactions in the episodes I saw, there wasn’t a lot of grace in Tony’s life and he didn’t pursue grace-filling opportunities–they were more grace-leeching than anything.Anyway, good post. It’s always helpful to have neutral TV characters that can point you into real life.
Gail and Keith
Get some investors and you’re on your way! G
MagistraCarminum
LOL! Brilliant!
J. Wesley
Brilliant! However, how can one effectively parody something that’s already a parody of itself? Considering the fact that publishers like Nelson publish anti-Trinitarians like Benny Hinn, it’s hard to fathom any depth to which they won’t sink. They’ll probably take your idea and run with it. . . I’ll bet you a copy of “The Gospel According to Tony Soprano”!
Randy Greenwald
I am not normally called ‘brilliant’ – so to have it happen TWICE in one day! Wow!And no matter how intrigued I would be to see a copy of the Gospel of Mr. S, I think I’ll pass on the bet. Not much surprises me anymore. I’d be sure to lose!
TulipGirl
Giving thanks, with you, for the abounding family blessings.
MagistraCarminum
Amen, yet again, Randy. This has been such a practical and encouraging series!
Gail and Keith
No, haven’t seen the movie. Regarding one’s kids critiques of films, we’ve been that route countless times in our household. They say either, ‘ya gotta’ see this movie!’ or, ‘It was great, but Mother, you’d hate it.’ And this, ‘No, I am not going to see that movie!’ summarily dismissing any recommendation I might give to a movie. G
MagistraCarminum
As I recall, the cinematography was gorgeous, but we couldn’t wait for it to end. And LOL, Gail! We’ve had the same here…FWIW-Chris
MagistraCarminum
For the record, I knew it was Greenland. But HOW did I know that?
MagistraCarminum
Umm- make that Denmark.(Sheepishly backing away from my computer and hoping no on notices…)
Randy Greenwald
I take it then that you are not really up for the ‘extended cut’ version…
MagistraCarminum
Umm- I will definitely pass on the extended cut…
MagistraCarminum
I think heaven will be an eternity of delightful surprises as we meet and worship with brethren very different from us. And we boring white folk will also have something to add 🙂
Randy Greenwald
Do I detect a bit of defensiveness here? I no where suggested that a traditional white protestant service is boring, did I? No question that ALL cultures will bring something to the table. All cultures will have their tastes expanded, methinks.
MagistraCarminum
No defensiveness intended at all– only what is “normal” or boring to us, is not likely so to others, and I think we forget that sometimes. I meant no rebuke of any kind. We agree.
Geoffsnook
Randy,I love the Thanksgiving Service. I think that is a great tradition we should continue having at Hope. Yes, it was a little taste of heaven on Earth. And since we have that taste in our mouths, we should do all that we can to keep tasting it by living our life with the goal of Jesus’ Kingdom moving forward (bringing heaven to earth). BTW-it is good for white people to clap, eh? As long as we can stay on rhythm.
Gail
I don’t know, but I don’t think I like the direction of this discussion. It seems like our friends are treated as a circus sideshow. There are White congregations who clap in praise all the time; it is not unique. I appreciate that the point of the post is that residents of heaven are from every tongue, tribe, and nation, but using the example that was used just bothers me. G
Randy Greenwald
Sorry you feel that way, Gail. I don’t know what might make you feel that. I think my only point was that there is and will be diversity, and that we ought to celebrate and enjoy that diversity whenever we can. These are our friends, and I am humbled that they would come worship with us, and bring their gifts as they did. I guess I’m just missing something. If there is anything that would cause one to look twice, as one would do at a sideshow, is that here were black and white worshiping together. So, as Geoff suggested, we need to continue to labor to bring that bit of heaven to greater expression on earth. Certainly there is nothing here with which you can disagree? Again, I apologize for not understanding your reaction!
Gail
No, I don’t disagree. I don’t mean that Blacks and Whites worshiping together is a sideshow. That’s wonderful. The comments about the choir, the clapping seems condescending to me. You don’t get what I was trying to say and I’m at a loss to explain it. Maybe I’m just over sensitive. Should have gone with my first thought which was, ‘don’t say anything.’ G
Randy Greenwald
Okay, that helps. Nothing meant to be condescending, for sure. I think I can say that for all the commenters. (Geoff was poking fun at those of us who are more uncomfortable with physical expression.) And though as people with limitations we will not always understand one another, that is no reason to remain quiet. I’m glad you spoke up.
Geoffsnook
Great movie. I probably saw the movie like 15 years ago. I was simply amazed that the folks in a catatonic state could react and actually catch and throw objects. Makes you wonder how aware some folks in those states are. I know this had nothing to do with your post. But I just thought it was an amazing movie. Even when I was a teenager!
Gus/Adri
Adri said we watched it a long time ago, but I can’t remember. It’s on order from library.gus
MagistraCarminum
LOL! Praying for your day!Chris
Matthew
The whole rest of the wedding is forgotten except for “the tear on his cheek” Holy cow! I have feelings like the rest of humanity! Though my wife would question that from time to time.
Matthew
I have seen it. I wouldn’t waste your time. I can remember to much about it except it came across cheesy and I almost fell asleep.
Randy Greenwald
Hey, I mentioned also the beautiful woman. I remember her…
Randy Greenwald
With all these comments, now I’m seriously wondering what could make a film so BAD to so many and yet so STUNNING to others. Just don’t know if I want to invest 2.5 hours taking the risk.
MagistraCarminum
I think the cinematography is stunning. The plot and script (and even the acting)are terrible. But the scenes of virgin woodlands, majestic shores, etc., are breath-takingly beautiful. The problem is that eventually you get underwhelmed by the rest of it. At least, that’s my opinion!
Anonymous
Hey Randy,I like your illustration with your son; how he would apologize for falling off his bike. I find that that’s how I am with God. I become so consumed with my failure and spend so much of my energy saying sorry that I forget to press on. It’s a terribe way to live, being down all the time and yet somehow thinking that this is just me being contrite. I have forgotten the joy of the gospel. No wonder this makes it easier to fall again; chasing after the lesser joys of this world because I have lost sight of the greater joy found in Christ.Tom
Anonymous
I suppose it could be worse. 🙂
MagistraCarminum
Thanks for the tip on the song: downloading now! And, btw, I am Averell Lenox Fenwick the Fourth, but most people call me Missy. How weird.
Randy Greenwald
Could be worse? Uh, I’m not sure. It makes ‘Randall Ray’ sound solidly lyrical….And about the song, Missy, I stumbled upon that accidentally while looking for another song. I’m excited.Yours, Topper
Gail and Keith
Waaaay back when Six Pence None the Richer was practically nobody, they put on a concert at Palma Sola Bay Baptist Church (now The Bridge). Shoulda’ gotten their autograph then!G
TulipGirl
G&K, yup. . . they were originally from the New Braunfels area of Texas, just north of San Antonio. SA had a great little indie station that featured them on Saturday mornings. . . I have a. . . get this. . . a cassette from Sixpence from that era. (Sheesh. My kids hardly know what a cassette is!)
TulipGirl
Fun pic. I haven’t figured out to send a pic from my phone to my email. . .
Rebekah
hooray! texting is soooo addictive. tulipgirl, instead of putting in a phone number, put in an email address–myname@email.com…
Randy Greenwald
Well, I have an 8-track…Just kidding.
TulipGirl
One of my happy memories is going out to my Dad’s car, and listening to his 8-track player in the car. . . Simon and Garfunkle.
Randy Greenwald
Your dad must have driven antiques since the 8-track ended its run sometime in the mid-70s, unless you are a LOT older than you look!
Gus/Adri
Troglodytes that we are – and frugal, as you know – don’t expect any such from us, and don’t send any our way either!One of us can more easily remember some phone numbers and press the buttons quickly, rather than find the list, scroll down etc. The E’s
Anonymous
The title intrigued me and drew me in so that I read the entire post.Good thoughts; look forward to what you have to say about men.
MagistraCarminum
What an intriguing application of Edwards! As the mother of young men, even I must concur with your wisdom and experience regarding men. And (taking a bit of a rabbit trail) shouldn’t young people, who are considering lasting relationships, bring that other person around their family and their church body, and seek the advice of those wiser and more experienced than themselves? We have had a couple of experiences when women in our church started going with men whom I didn’t trust as far as I could spit them (and that wasn’t far!) In one case, the young woman listened to the advice of others, but in her desire to get married, she didn’t introduce her next beau, and then married him, and divorced him in a year. In the second case, the woman did not want opinions of anyone else, and married the man, and he left her within a year.I am not saying that fellowship and family can help us avoid every heart-break, but we ought to take serious advantage of the collective wisdom God has given us there! And it is the job of the young women (and men) to ask.
Randy Greenwald
Very wise. And yet I just spoke yesterday with an amazing young man whose romantic interest sought to do all that and then her parents rejected the young man. I think you might be aware of similar such situations where godly young men are suspect for all the wrong reasons! Families and communities must not turn their wisdom into a weapon for micro-control.
MagistraCarminum
Ah, yes. Taking God’s good gifts and using them as weapons against one another…and unless I exercise a great deal of restraint, I will be off on another rabbit trail…
Anonymous
Great Post, Randy.A lot of good insights. I must confess that I find myself guilty of the charges: both putting on the veneer to win a girl as well as being blind to the good around me. I mentioned a while back that I have given up reading Edwards, but I guess in this regard, though he’s dead, he still speaks to me.Tom
MagistraCarminum
Very clever way to point out the most amazing aspect of sanctification: grace to huge that it covers all our sin!
Gail and Keith
Conscience, you are one tricky dude, but Grace has foiled your schemes once again: Romans 8:1, “There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus.” Note to Randy: Seriously, you are blessed with the gifts of putting God’s truth down on paper and through the spoken word. The wider world needs to benefit from it. G
TulipGirl
“. . .godly young men are suspect for all the wrong reasons! Families and communities must not turn their wisdom into a weapon for micro-control.”Isn’t it sad? And ugly? Unfortunately, I’ve seen that. . .
TulipGirl
*sigh* I keep adding books to my Amazon wishlist, books I want to read SOME day. . .
MagistraCarminum
Awww- and as I recall, Miss Black came to Loveland that Christmas, and you all came to an ICY Christmas retreat I was attending and Dave was chaperoning…or something like that…That seems like a million years ago in some ways, and like yesterday in others!Love you two!
TulipGirl
Nahhh. . . you must have misheard.*eeeg*
TulipGirl
*mush, mush*
Randy Greenwald
I actually thought about going back and checking… but that would ruin everything.
Randy Greenwald
Mush is okay, right? Or at 52 is mush indecorous? Uh, Chris, it WAS a million years ago. Shall we look in the mirror? 🙂
TulipGirl
Mushiness is always good. *grin*
TulipGirl
OT. . . you mentioned a recent study that was the source for some of your stats this morning. . . to which study were you referring? (*blush* Yes, I’m a demographics geek.)
TulipGirl
*grin*
Anonymous
Great post! He truly was our wonderful counselor. Reminds me of a writing from Spurgeon from 2 Samule 15:23. http://www.ccel.org/ccel/spurgeon/morneve.d0531am.htmlMerry Christmas!
Jedidiah
I’ve actually known about these guys for around 7 or 8 years now. I didn’t realize there were so many musical gems in my music collection for others to rediscover. 🙂
Matthew
The church that Alissa and I have been attending plays a wonderful mix of both hymns and contemporary music. It is really nice to hear the songs we grew up singing mixed with songs we love to sing everyday.p.s. What does this C.S. Lewis guy know anyway? He just wrote some silly children’s books. =)
TulipGirl
Ahhh. . . glad you posted this quote in full. Saves me from trying to remember enough of it to google or emailing you for it. . .I’m very thankful that the Lord has us in a church body in which our hearts are easily spurned towards worship. (As opposed to worshipping God in spite of being at church, as it has been at some times in our lives. . .)
TulipGirl
Coming back to clarify. . . that wasn’t usually due to “music,” per se. . . but a general lack of focus in worship and the big personalities of people involved. . . Music or style or what-have-you was incidental. . .
Andrea Rowe
I certainly hope that you are not hoping for too much here! I wonder if it is something the Church is growing toward…
Gail and Keith
Keith and I saw the movie last week.It’s a delightful movie, with dark scenes which I feared would scare the daylights out of kids, but in this age kids are used to viewing much worse. The movie was a little slow going in the middle. I had already ordered the book before viewing the movie and am just reading through it. I love the author’s writing style. G
Matthew
This book is immensely popular at the book store Alissa works at. She is going to nab a copy next time they get one in for us to read to Isaiah. The cool thing is Kate DiCamillo wrote it while working at Half-Priced Books in TX. She since has quit for obvious reasons.Matthew
Matthew
Let me restate my previous comment. She may not have written the book while actively working at half-priced books. But I know she worked there!
Randy Greenwald
The Half-Price Books connection is a cool one! Maybe other employee/story tellers have a print future, eh?And yes, G, the writing style is captivating. Very conversational and fairy-tale-esque. I love it.
Randy Greenwald
I’m intrigued, Andrea. In what way might we be hoping for too much?And, Matthew, this Lewis guy, he wrote Children’s books? :-)TG – great to be a place of worship for you. Now, if we could spread the word…!We need to have a special blog reader Sunday – inviting the readers of our various blogs to attend services. Hmmm. 🙂
TulipGirl
“My point should be obvious. If we read only those things written by those claiming to be Christians, we will miss some of the most wonderful insights that God himself has for his people.”Conversely, if we read only those things written by those claiming to be Christians and read them uncritically, we can be easily misled and miss some of the most wonderful insights that God himself has for his people.
Anonymous
Thanks for sharing. One of them is a little scary; okay, I’ll tell you: it’s that third one!
Anonymous
This is great! Thanks so much for the encouragement to read Calvin in 2009! I’ve ordered the “good” version and emailed for the reading schedule. Anyone out there is blog land with me?????Staci
snowbot
I’m in! I’ve already got the reading schedule and book and am ready to roll.Keith
Anonymous
At various times we’ve used Calvin’s Institutes – the Battles translation – in evening devotions. His language is eloquent.It’s so rich you can sometimes absorb only a paragraph; akin to having only a small bite of a rich dessert.At other times it’s almost shocking to see how direct and to the point he is in exposing the errors within the Christian church.G and A
Randy Greenwald
That is the most difficult thing about Calvin – the strong polemic language he uses at times. However, he was a product of his times, and I believe that we cannot emulate him in this (as I’ve heard some attempt to do). It would be akin to importing the boisterousness of the British Parliament into the US Senate. Culture needs to be taken into account.
MagistraCarminum
I agree about the third one being a little frightening…I think it’s the beard growing out of his eyes…
MagistraCarminum
Yep.
Randy Greenwald
Yep?Your comment begs for clarification.
Randy Greenwald
You all haven’t seen me recently, have you.
arsapphire
I agree with you, and so does John Calvin:”Therefore, in reading profane authors, the admirable light of truth displayed in them should remind us, that the human mind, however much fallen and perverted from its original integrity, is still adorned and invested with admirable gifts from its Creator. If we reflect that the Spirit of God is the only fountain of truth, we will be careful, as we would avoid offering insult to him, not to reject or condemn truth wherever it appears. In despising the gifts, we insult the Giver.”-Calvin, Institutes II.ii.15
arsapphire
I actually found that quote from the Institutes in Jerram Barrs’s book “Echoes of Eden.” (pg.23) I think anybody interested in this subject would benefit from reading this book, when it is published (I don’t think it is yet…I just have a copy of the manuscript)
TulipGirl
*snort*
TulipGirl
How cool! I was just thinking the other day that I’d like to have a project of reading more Calvin this year — though, I’m not sure I’m ready to tackle read-through-the-Institutes. . .I’ve listened to the better part of Prof. Calhoun’s lectures on Calvin, and highly recommend them. . .
MagistraCarminum
My “yep” was in response to your “You agree?” question. The answer is, yes, I do!
Gus/Adri
I know I’m going on a rabbit trail, but since Randy mentioned the British parliament, one of my peeves is that Congress doesn’t engage in real debate. All we hear on C-Span is committees questioning people, or members taking turns talking about their position on issues, with an inordinate amount of time figuring out how much time they have used on a particular topic. I’d like to see our president engage congress in debate the way the British PM debates members of parliament.G
MagistraCarminum
Thanks, Randy! I’m going to give the two-year plan a try. Last year I listened to the ESV in a year through my E-mail, which was a nice change of pace. Now slower reading is in order!
TulipGirl
Have you considered drawing up a through-the-NT-in-a-year plan?Though, to be honest, I think I’m going to print out and utilize the Bible Reading Plan for Shirkers and Slackers by Margie Haack.
Rebekah
That may even be the similie of the year (counting in 2008, since we’re in a fresh year)–too cute!
MagistraCarminum
oh- this brings visions of the slightly slimy, cold and congealed insides of the wrapper after the sausage is gone. What a great word picture!
MagistraCarminum
We are taking the plunge, too, and share your, um, trepidity! Packer, in his foreward to A Theological Guide to Calvin’s Institutes, says this about the various translations and translators:The readability of the Institutio, considering its size, is remarkable. Calvin’s pacing is steady and urgent throughout. Just about every sentence contains concentrated thought expressed in elegant, fast-moving, colorful,punchy Latin rhetoric. (No English translation fully matches Calvin’sLatin; that of the Elizabethan, Thomas Norton, perhaps gets closest; Beveridge gives us Calvin’s feistiness but not always his precision; Battles gives us the precision but not always the punchiness, and fleetness of foot;Allen is smooth and clear, but low-key.)You can read the whole foreward online here:http://www.wtsbooks.com/pdf_files/9781596380912.pdf
Gus/Adri
I met a theology student in the ’50s who was reading the institutio in Latin. Now, THAT takes a lot of perseverance and linguistic ability–to say the least.G
snowbot
Kristen and I read “To the Reader” today, aloud. It was enjoyable. We’ll see how it goes!
TulipGirl
Like you said. . . touching the heart and mind. . . that’s what drives me to worship.
MagistraCarminum
What fun! We’ll have to meet at S and A’s sometime, and leave Dave and Barb to work puzzles at home 🙂
Randy Greenwald
Now THERE is a great fantasy…. But, yes, Barb would love to do the puzzles.
Anonymous
Sounds, SWEET! 🙂 Yes, hearing a live blues or jazz band is high on my list of favorite things to do…(as well as seeing a live hockey game!) :-)Gotta love those big cities!
Gus/Adri
Interesting comment by this writer on the mania over these books. I’ve read of older women – I mean 30-40ish – who are gushing devotees, which I’m at a loss to understand.I was struck by the description of the decal showing a heart in female hands and the accompanying words. I much prefer the Calvin College logo and theme: My heart I offer to you Lord, promptly and sincerely. It’s a quotation from John Calvin and on college gear and clothing usually written in Latin: Cor meum tibi offero Domine, prompte et sincere. It shows a heart in an outstretched hand.–ae
Randy Greenwald
Very interesting parallel, ae. Much as been made of the fact that the author of the series is a Mormon. But I don’t think that has a thing to do with the cover art.But why are you at a loss to understand the gushing devotion of 30-40ish women (you are 40ish, aren’t you)?
Gus/Adri
If I were – and thanks very much 🙂 – I possibly might gush, but I think it would be over different literature. My concern, though I have not read the book(s), is that because they are [reportedly] “clean” they will be considered Christian fiction. Sorry, but that’s a term I shudder at anyway. Oops, my bias is showing.–ae
Matthew
I have not read any of the Twilight books but Alissa has and she loves them. we live in a culture of trash TV, trash books and magazines, trash internet, and trash movies geared toward the young female and male. Throughout there is a persuasive theme of sex. Not just sex but sex with anyone male or female. A theme that you can only truly love someone if your having sex with them with little or no thought to marriage. The twilight books are a wonderful message and I would love for my daughter to be twilight crazy. Edward and Bella are “soul mates” is the best way to describe it. The author makes a point of the fact that they do not have sex until they are married. Yes there is no mention of God she just says he is “old fashioned” but it is looked as something noble.mg
TulipGirl
I haven’t read these books. . . yet probably will at some point, mostly because of the hype around them and to be able to talk with some of the people in my life who are real fans.I thought this article from Prof. Jones was very interesting:Vampires and Young Female DesireIt raises some yellow flags that I think are worth considering. . .
TulipGirl
“But the interesting thing about the comments to the post “For Parents of Girls”, which no doubt means nothing at all, is that if we were to put all the children of all those who commented in one room, in that room there would be nine boys, zero girls!”*L* Maybe that’s why I skimmed the meat of what you were saying. . . I don’t think as much about the realities of raising girls, the development of girls. . . More about boys and books.(Though the author of the article I referenced has two girls. . . and I know that is on her mind. . .)
Gus/Adri
“…WAS NOT INJURED!?!” What about his pride? To say nothing of the dangers of hypothermia – Br-r-r-r!Afraid I’m adding insult to injury by LOL. –ae
MagistraCarminum
Oh my. I can picture one of my sons ending up this way, but I’ll not mention any names… Poor guy!
TulipGirl
Btw, the McNeill/Battles edition is being made available online for a limited time, thanks to Westminster John Knox at this site:http://www2.ptsem.edu/ConEd/Calvin/They are also providing daily audio portions.
MagistraCarminum
May I just say that I found the letter to the King of France fascinating? Calvin is lively and thorough in defending the Reformation there.
TulipGirl
“I have converted them all to audiobook format.”I’m impressed. You’ve got mad tech skillz.”However, be warned that the audio changes Calvin so that he writes as one who is gender inclusive.”I’ve heard it is only for when that reader is recording, and it isn’t when there are other readers.Personally, I find it annoying. While I think that inclusive language is beneficial in many contexts, I like to think that most people are smart enough and stable enough to take references to “man” and understand them to be all humankind, when reading older works.
Gail and Keith
Our movie won! Slumdog Millionairewon 4 awards. It’s a must-see.John Adams, the book, is a great read. We plan to get the TV series.G
Randy Greenwald
You’ve got mad tech skillz.No, I’ve got software. Audiobook Builder
Rebekah
That’s a very interesting article TulipGirl. The colossal peeve of a certain sister is the idea that girls have to rely on a hero as they are passive actresses in their own lives–a typecast helpless princess. I tend to be a sucker for hero/princess stories, so I can certainly see the attraction more than others I know might.It does sound vaguely disturbing that, despite the reported wholesomeness of their relationship, there is an undertone that the young woman’s attraction lies in a fixation to the dark underworld–so despite the niceness of that particular vampire family, she likes the darkness that she knows exists in that particular boy. However, I shall withhold judgement until I see the movie/read the books…which I need to do since a lot of people really love them.
Anonymous
Up From Slavery, Booker T. Washington’s autobiography, is outstanding. I read it a few months ago and was struck by the incredible character of the man. Staci
Gus/Adri
George Whitfield, at least the first volume, maybe both; it was years ago. Agree on John Adams; have yet to view the series, but hope to. Also read one on his wife, Dearest Friend: A Life of Abigail Adams, by Lynne Withey. IMHO it wasn’t as good; I thought/felt the author tried to make her into a 20th C feminist. I do realize Abigail was astute politically, and interested in her husband’s work. The truths about their strong and enduring marriage I enjoyed learning.You keep adding to my “to read” list, which is already too long. “So many books, so little time.” (Sigh) A few years ago I read one on letters of TR to his children. (Not exactly a bio, though.) I don’t remember the name of book or compiler, but it was enjoyable. I believe he called the children his “little bunnies” or other such endearment. The letters were homey and charming. Now I’m intrigued by the two bios on him you mentioned yesterday. I’ll have to put at least one on my list, as well as Truman by McCullough.–ae
Randy Greenwald
Up from Slavery, going on my list.Don’t necessarily put Truman on your list. I’m reading it… not necessarily recommending it.I do recommend the Dungy bio, though. Just finished it, and with him just announcing his retirement, it is timely.
Gail and Keith
Ready the Dungy biography. He’s a humble man who is not afraid to name the name of Christ. I gave the book away–maybe to the church library. G
Anonymous
It might be important to ask: Perform where? Before what audience?
Randy Greenwald
Yes. Context is everything, isn’t it!
Gail and Keith
How much direct influence did Calvin have on the trials and execution of the Anabaptists? I’ve done some reading, acknowledging that much of the material I’ve read has been on Mennonite websites. There are quotes from Calvin’s letters.G
Randy Greenwald
Great question, Gail. I can’t answer it. But I think it is important to keep in mind that no ‘great’ man will be without his sin, and no one will be able to separate himself from his time. I’ve learned a great deal from theologians from the Ante-bellum South, and I can’t imagine the blind spot they had regarding slavery. I can’t fathom it, and yet it is there. Apparently Luther is reported to have had a very clear anti-semitic strain. I don’t know whether that is true or not, but the assertion is made. So, it is important that we worship no man, and that we judge a man by the standards of his own era, not our own. Agreed?
Gail and Keith
Agreed. I can just look back 15 years ago to my most active pro-life efforts and be embarrassed at some of the things I said outside the abortion clinic. Not for a sec do I regret my activism. There are only a few things I would do differently.Not that I fit in the ‘great theologians of our time’ category. G
Rebekah
One of our ancient Anabaptist relatives on the maternal side got killed by Calvinists…perhaps that’s why I’m not very denominationalist, even though I love Reformed theology…as long as somebody is Evangelical, and loves God…who cares?!
Rebekah
That’s hilarious! If taking up an instrument…or anything!…was that easy, I’d do it!
Gus/Adri
Wow! Thanks for that thoughtful review. I’ll pass along to you a church magazine which includes an article on Calvin/ism, including some info on the Servetus controversy. –ae
Rebekah
This is just too funny…these wonderful eavesdropping anecdotes are keeping me sane this week…
TulipGirl
In spite of the should-have-known-better bits of misinformation, I found it very interesting to see the NYT carry a piece on this part of the Christian sub-culture.Molly Worthton is quite interesting. Considering this piece and her previous piece in the NYT on New St. Andrews. . . well. . . she’s definitely one I’m going to watch with interest.
Randy Greenwald
Agreed, TG, it is interesting. But it is sometimes hard to tell whether reports like this reflect interest or ridicule. Why did this report become one of the Times’ most emailed articles?
Gail and Keith
You’ve succumbed (as have I) to the likes of Joe Fox, who pushed out the small, intimate book sellerKathleen Kelly. (You’ve Got Mail)G
Randy Greenwald
No, I’ve gone BEYOND Joe Fox and his superstore, to the completely impersonal path of the internet. It’s sad, but so terribly convenient!
Gus/Adri
We used a local clockmaker to fix the chimes in our antique clock, but then, I don’t think we could have found a long distance clockmaker! He even makes home visits for his craft if the repair is simple enough. This was a Christmas gift to each other–a way to avoid giving a gift to yourself. If this still bothers your conscience you can say this is a gift to your home.G
Anonymous
Speaking of Joe Fox (and Guilt)… In late November, my mom asked me to find out what it would cost for 9 copies of C. H. Spurgeon’s devotional: Morning and Evening. I decided to go online to check the price at our largest Christian bookstore chain, in the Toronto area. Their price: $27.00 EACH (plus tax) for a leather bound copy (and this didn’t include my time and travel costs). I then checked the online price at Chapters-Indigo. Their price: $16.87 (PLUS a further discount with my i-Rewards card and FREE shipping). Pretty hard to beat.In December, I went online to check the price of another book at the SAME Christian bookstore–but this time, I found the store had gone BANKRUPT and was selling all of their stock at reduced prices. So, after Christmas I made a trip to the store to see what they had.ALL BOOKS: $2.99!!Talk about emotional shopping. There I was, sniffing back tears as I mourned the closing of one of my favorite bookstores (and places to meet single Christian men.*grin*)…and yet, at the same time I was feeling guilty for feeling so happy about the price of the books! Even worse, while I patiently waited in the mile long lineup to pay for my treasures, an announcement was made over the PA system; “If you purchase 10 books, we will give you an additional 5 books for FREE!” YEEHA! (Sniff)Fiona
Rebekah
I have mixed guilt… I try to buy local, but when they do things like charge you $1/extra shot of espresso in your super charged latte… that ain’t right! SBUX doesn’t do that! $6.34 for a triple latte? That’s just outrageous!
MagistraCarminum
I think we don’t have enough to do when we contemplate and calculate such guilt..it is possible to be too introspective, right?;-)
Randy Greenwald
Absolutely, I am the expert at over the top introspection. But this isn’t born of that. Rather, being a seller of rolls, I’ve seen in this economy four coffee shops go out of business. Some of them, of course, needed to. They were poorly run. But some should not have had to but the economy and the proliferation of Starbucks. Independent book shops and coffee shops and the like are run by men and women who are wanting to wed their passions and their incomes, and I would like to help them. But too often, I can’t. Guilt is too strong a word. I should call it ‘sadness’.
Gus/Adri
I think there is a little flaw (big if you are a local shop keeper) in your comparison: Amazon doesn’t have to spend money to maintain an attractive book shop or any shop for that matter; maybe a warehouse(?), and doesn’t collect sales tax.G
Gail and Keith
What a wonderful, proud day it was!
TulipGirl
That should be interesting. . . though there are a few promises I hope he either is unable to keep or chooses to compromise.
Randy Greenwald
I’m all for the puppy, though. Some others, well, not so much.
Rebekah
word up! i had frost all over my car, and i thought i was going to have to get out an ice scraper to get to work! gee…
Randy Greenwald
Rebekah – you HAVE an ice scraper?
Rebekah
i most certainly don’t–i would’ve broken my credit card!
Fiona
This morning, I woke to the sound of snow removal trucks…I don’t feel sorry for any of you. 🙂
Randy Greenwald
But Fiona, where is your Christian sympathy? It is only supposed to get up to the mid fifties today. Don’t you feel our pain?
Gus/Adri
This has nothing to do with Jack Frost, but there is a contradiction in the phrase ‘crescent waning moon’ in the screen shot. Wane means to have a progressively smaller part; crescent comes from the Latin for grow. But then, I don’t know how to rephrase the information without making it too long. Sorry, I should stop majoring in minors.G
Fiona
Nope. (Cry babies)I suppose this means it will be a “two blanket night” for ya’ll? :)Enjoy your hot chocolate!
Elsa
As a Minnesotan, I think you Floridians are wusses. I walked part of the way to work last week when it was -5 degrees.
Randy Greenwald
Okay. Let it fly. Let Christian charity go out the window and let’s start calling names.Let me finish Elsa’s -5 degree story. Notice she walked part way to work. The ambulance took her the rest of the way…
TulipGirl
I read this post this morning and thought it was cute and clever. . . Then I went outside. It was frigid. (And I did have to break out my credit card to scrape off the frost, Rebekah.)*shiver*I’ve become acclimated to the Florida winters — and definitely do NOT like this.
Rebekah
We are tropical people. This is like torture.
Anonymous
“I have terrible veins…”Tip:Drink LOTS of water, milk and other liquid (except alcohol!) a few days before you are scheduled to donate. If you are donating on short notice, then start increasing your fluid intake from that point onward.The fluids will help to plump up your veins.Kudos to you and Barb, for supporting a great cause!Fiona
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, Fi. I do all of that, and it apparently helps. However, the phlebotomists still break out in sweats when they see me walk through the door…
MagistraCarminum
May I just say that I think this is discrimination? Giving rolls to people JUST because they give blood?! In my family, where blood was once upon a time given on a regular basis by two adults, now neither of us can give blood any more. So I can’t even ask for a dispensation to give blood abroad and still get the perks…{vbg}
Gus/Adri
Agree 100% with previous comment. My blood is not acceptable through no fault of my own. Requesting free samples from the bakers wouldn’t be a good idea for me either. Hubby and I gave frequently in the years we were able.Oh – and is the only reason the phlebotomists “break out in sweats” that they know about your lousy veins? Perhaps they also know your fear and dread of sharp objects. :-)–ae
Randy Greenwald
Calm down, legions of fans. We will be giving roll samples from 11:00 AM to 1:00 PM to ANYONE who comes by. IF you donate, then we will waive the delivery fee on an order of rolls.However, as a special blog only special, anyone who comes to our table from Los Alamos, NM will be given a free tray of rolls. Promise.
TulipGirl
“However, as a special blog only special, anyone who comes to our table from Los Alamos, NM will be given a free tray of rolls.”What a deal!
Rebekah
what a great promotion–good choice by Lakewood ranch blood services!
Rebekah
What a horrible wife! Way to be an affirmer…gee…!
Rebekah
woops, misread the quote, nevermind.
Gus/Adri
Talk about attention-grabbing headlines…!G&A
MagistraCarminum
Hurrah! I’ve been waiting…
TulipGirl
I’m glad you’re starting it up again. . . I always read, but never know what to say.
Gail and Keith
In spite of the warning, that song assaults you before you have time to hit the stop button!Good thoughts on getting those ideas out of the brain and into the air rather than letting them stagnate. G
Randy Greenwald
Sorry about that… I did not give enough warning.Here is another interesting comment:”The master discipline is not hard work. It’s actually no work at all, because work requires time and effort. A shift in your direction of focus is instantaneous, with zero expenditure of energy. Yet it remains the master key to a positive experience of life and creating results. “Motivation” and “discipline” are often heralded as critical factors; but both require themselves to create themselves. You have to be motivated to motivate yourself and disciplined to discipline yourself, which is a Catch-22. When you observe behavior that appears motivated and disciplined, you can always trace it back to the choice to simply put a focus on one thing versus another.”
Gus/Adri
As an ardent Freddy fan, the article you linked to makes me very sad. It’s too bad that re-publishing is not profitableThere are a few copies (hardback) available on amazon; they seem pricey at $16-$20+ for a book for children.Wish there were a GOOD local used book store! Wish I had an eight year old nearby to share the stories with.–ae
Randy Greenwald
We have one you can borrow now and then…an eight year old, that is!I can’t help with the bookstore, however.
Nejcik
Our Berlin-based photographer has a sure-fire formula for pepping up a boring headline: “A Century After Hitler’s Parents Have Sex, Polish Stocks Little Changed”
Rebekah
You really did pick a really bad stretch to miss!
Randy Greenwald
The superstitious side of me notes that when I was watching, Pittsburgh did well, when I did not watch, AZ did well. But I would not reveal that superstitious side of me in public, so let’s keep it between the two of us.
Gail and Keith
Because, experts are not omniscient.And, they are fallible. G
Geoffsnook
“Experts” like me seem to be most often right when I don’t want to be and vice versa!
Gail and Keith
Sure is a beautiful picture! Reading opens the door to all sorts of learning and adventure. Is he reading “Freddy?” Looks familiar.G
Randy Greenwald
Actually, that would be The Last Battle!
Randy Greenwald
Love it. The ‘s’ word does it every time!
Rebekah
Too cute! Reminds me of the wonderful days spent absorbed in books after afternoon field trips to the library when we’d return with piles and piles of books…
TulipGirl
*grin*
Gus/Adri
A beautiful thing indeed! It made me think of:There is no frigate like a book To take us lands away, Nor any coursers like a page Of prancing poetry. This traverse may the poorest take Without oppress of toll; How frugal is the chariot That bears a human soul!–Emily Dickinson————————- And:You may have tangible wealth untold,Caskets of jewels and coffers of gold.Richer than I you can never be;I had a mother [father] who read to me.–I don’t know the author–ae
MagistraCarminum
It is beautiful. But C. may prefer handsome…
Gail and Keith
Had the abortionist been there this child would most likely have been left to die anyway even though the law says it’s illegal. Approximately 3700 babies are aborted every day in the United States. Every time I read about the death of these children I am grieved. I am reminded of Jeremiah 19:1-6 where God talks of the abomination of the Israelite’s sacrificing their firstborn sons to the alter of Baal:”1 This is what the LORD says: “Go and buy a clay jar from a potter. Take along some of the elders of the people and of the priests 2 and go out to the Valley of Ben Hinnom, near the entrance of the Potsherd Gate. There proclaim the words I tell you, 3 and say, ‘Hear the word of the LORD, you kings of Judah and people of Jerusalem. This is what the LORD Almighty, the God of Israel, says: Listen! I am going to bring a disaster on this place that will make the ears of everyone who hears of it tingle. 4 For they have forsaken me and made this a place of foreign gods; they have burned incense in it to gods that neither they nor their ancestors nor the kings of Judah ever knew, and they have filled this place with the blood of the innocent. 5 They have built the high places of Baal to burn their children in the fire as offerings to Baal—something I did not command or mention, nor did it enter my mind. 6 So beware, the days are coming, declares the LORD, when people will no longer call this place Topheth or the Valley of Ben Hinnom, but the Valley of Slaughter.”
MagistraCarminum
Great analogy, Randy! Now I have to work at not congratulating myself that I see the lizards, and remembering that for every one I see there are more lurking out of my sight…
Anonymous
The “mother who read to me” bit was written by Strickland Gillilan.
MagistraCarminum
Well, nothing is new under the sun. The moral dilema of the storyteller has been argued about at least since Socrates… (part of his argument with the Sophists, I think, was that they were using the power to persuade in an immoral way.) This is a very important question, but one not that easily answered. One thing we can probably agree upon is that a story teller has some obligations to his audience. If the audience trusts him enough to give themselves to the story, the story teller should not betray that trust.What it means to betray that trust, and how we measure it, is, of course, the rub…
Gus/Adri
Jekyll and Hyde are never too far from us.G
Gail and Keith
What about Michael Corleone in The Godfather who attended his nephew’s baptism, reciting the liturgy of the church, while his mob was in the process of methodically murdering his opponents? Or FL Senator Bob Graham who celebrated the birth of his twin grandchildren while adamantly defending a woman’s right to choose? Or Governor Lawton Chiles who rabidly defended abortion, but established a fund to help disadvantaged children? G
Gail and Keith
He’s relevant to the community in which he lives. I would have to hear his messages in total, know what his complete theology is, (how bad can he be; he’s Reformed!)before coming to a conclusion. The reporter zeroed in on one topic, sex, but I expect that his messages are more than just that. From that little snippet I can’t say I can find fault with him. G
Rebekah
A certain fundamentalist university publishing house gave a negative review of one of Updike’s prose pieces in one of their middle school literature book’s, and I really wish I remembered the name of the piece, so that I could go back and reread it. This poem looks very would put a whole different spin on it…
MagistraCarminum
A missionary friend first alerted me to Mark Driscoll. I saw the Nightline piece, but have also listened to some of his sermons online. While I think he at times has an unfortunate lack of control over the things that come out of his mouth, like all of us, I give him the benefit of the doubt that God is working in and through him. And I pray that he is livinh honestly before the Lord, not manipulating people with his shock-value, not building his own little kingdom.
Gus/Adri
I don’t disagree with what he says; I merely wish he said it a little differently; he could be a little less crass; or more discreet.–ae
Anonymous
Speaking as a twenty-something, I like the guy. He’s honest and gives it to you straight up; something young folks need to hear. Christians have a tendency to be too gentle and not enough tough love. Driscoll is giving it to them. I’m thrilled to see that the world noticed.Tom
David
Randy … it’s hard to get a good read on a person in a 6 minute video, especially knowing that the tape was edited and you do not get everything he said to the interviewer. That said, he is a Calvinist standing up for Jesus Christ in the public forum. He seems like a good man, a bit too edgy for me … but would Jesus have been too edgy for me in His day?
Amy
Tom,I totally agree with you bro. I’ve read three of his books already and listened to him preach before.He tells it straight up. I love his vision for the church.At times he can be a little arrogant, but I’ve learned a great deal from him since I was introduced to him.
Rebekah
I liked the movie better the second time. That I watched it a second time doesn't mean I would buy it, but I did like it.It was bizarre–that's indisputable. I'm not sure what the point of the movie was. I'd have to think about that. But it was entertaining to me.The characters were all very well crafted. But were they real? Hmm…for the most part, they were pretty real, even if they were exaggerations. What makes the movie perhaps the most unsettling is the scale of the violence and the way the film smacks you in the face with the messed up lives of the characters. It could be considered a stretch to compare these two films, but I hate the 1932 Laurel & Hardy movie "The Music Box" because its somewhat violent and inane. Yet…so many people think it's funny. Perhaps it's just the way that "Burn After Reading" is presented…
Randy Greenwald
Bizarre is a Coen given. Interesting and exagerated characters as well. I suppose it is something like Millers Crossing – such a cavalier approach to human evil that kind of makes it seem inevitable and of the essence of being human. Pretty hopeless in the end. I don’t think, though, I’ll see this one a second time. Alas.
MagistraCarminum
OK- I scored 7 out of 10 🙁 But really, the last question was difficult if you haven’t read that book… You said we had to be honest, but you didn’t say anything about not whining…Now I’ll slink away, ashamed…
amy in NM
5 of 10 but…. I really haven’t read most of that literature…pathetic but true. Are we grading on a curve?
Bab
Okay, I got 7 out of 10.. The last question was really tough for those of us who haven’t read the novel. Almost put Cain and Abel as the answer, but didn’t. Oh well.Your loving wife 🙂
Gus/Adri
In collaboration we got 7/10; would have been higher if I’d gone with him on some answers. ;)EVERYONE should read East of Eden; it’s probably Steinbeck’s best novel.–ae
Elsa
9/10. I’m a good guesser.
MagistraCarminum
I’m glad to see I’m in such good company…and it makes me wonder if we are a biblically-illiterate group, who is more literate?Elsa is *not*just a good guesser…she is who I ask all my literary questions of, and she and Ben together are just about unbeatable…:-)And LOL Amy!And Adri- I enjoy Steinbeck’s writing style, if not his worldview, but haven’t read that, and will have to give it a try!What fun, Randy 🙂
Bill Martin
Sorry guys… I got 9 of 10, but I was always a good multiple-choice test taker. And I have read East of Eden. Faulkner beats Steinbeck, though, in my feeble opinion.
Randy Greenwald
Bill and Elsa, no need to apologize for doing better than all the rest of us. We know that you are BOTH brilliant. We would expect no less. And Amy (no longer) in NM, the curve is in place, for sure. And Bill, I should say that I know that you took the test while stoked with brain food. Unfair edge. I do agree with you about Faulkner. I love Faulkner.And to those of you wondering, one comment is signed ‘your loving wife’. She indeed is a loving wife, but she is not known for her spelling skill. Last I checked, her name was Barb, not Bab… 🙂
Adria
Scored 6/10. Obviously not a good guesser. 🙂
Gus/Adri
Here's a more detailed article on the Rwandan genocide:http://www.economist.com/obituary/displayStory.cfm?story_id=13137097&fsrc=nwlptwfreegus
Randy Greenwald
Great addition, Gus. Thanks.
Anonymous
Amen, Randy.After reading about George Matheson (at Wikipedia), I was amazed at how wonderfully his life story and spiritual experiences, complement what you have shared today.”And I will bring the third part through the fire, and will refine them as silver is refined, and will try them as gold is tried: they shall call on my name, and I will hear them: I will say, It is my people: and they shall say, The LORD is my God.” Zechariah 13:9 (KJV)FM
Matthew
I have been a avid John Updike fan since the first time I went to MCC back in 2002 I was sad to see that he died. So I went out and had Alissa buy at half of half price what half priced books had to offer.
Gus/Adri
The articles posted on the link show that the problem is far more complex than throwing money at it.G
Amy
Gotta love the Krauss. I haven’t listened to that album in a year or two. Need to get back to it. Good reminder.Geoff
B
7 out of 10…by the skin of my teeth! Glad I stumbled upon your blog…I’ll be back. Blessings – B.
Randy Greenwald
Well, B, we’re a bunch of stumblers here, so I’m glad you found us, too.
Rebekah
I was thinking about how giving up food would be a self-centered thing for me, since I eat so healthy anyway for self-centered reasons, so perhaps some of us should do something like eat junk food for Lent, if we want to follow the true spirit of the practice!
MagistraCarminum
Oh, how I wish we didn’t have to get burned before we would listen!Good post, RRG.
Randy Greenwald
Actually, if we are basing our righteousness upon our healthy eating, then perhaps a Hershey bar/day would indeed help to slay that idol and bring us more squarely to Christ alone. Of course, in the interest of pure sacrifice, daughter J said she’d give up smoking and I determined to give up beer… 🙂
Randy Greenwald
I’m not so sure that I listen too well even then.
B
Thanks for these words. Good for me and mine today. I hope you don’t mind if I link to this post from my blog. And I’m really enjoying your writing…I found you through Tulip Girl. Blessings – B.
Randy Greenwald
Glad whenever what I say is helpful. And link away!
Anonymous
I guess we all have a tendency to want to pay for our own sins, or at least punish ourselves if God’s not going to. Either way, we make the cross of Christ pointless by our self-“flagellation”. Good thoughts, Randy. Another reason to read Harry Potter books.Tom
TulipGirl
A friend was asking about Sinclair Ferguson today. . . and when I was trying to remember why I liked him, I came across this quote that reminded me both of this post and our conversation today:”In times when there is grievous sin, never forget that there is more grace in Christ than there is sin in your heart and your child’s heart combined. In Christ there is a way back from the far country of a life style even for children who have given full expression to heart depravity.”–Sinclair Ferguson
MagistraCarminum
It’s been more than 25 years since I first read this little book, and it still makes a lot of sense to me. Now if I could just put it into action…
Geoffsnook
What a great book quote! Should be “required” reading. What timeless truth! I’m with Chris, I just need to put it into action.
B
Great quote…funny, my husband had just been told about this book last night and asked me if I had ever heard of it. I hadn’t. Looks like something we should read. Still enjoying reading your blog….blessings. B.
Anonymous
Maybe they sent if from a friend’s computer, or one at work, or the library…?–ae
MagistraCarminum
LOL! I don’t think I ever understood the mental aspect of sports until I had a collegiate athlete myself. The talent and hard work are only part of the picture. That mental game makes the difference somehow.We love March Madness, though I think it has been a distraction for us from horrible things. We have a terrible record of cancer occurrences beginning in March: one for me and at least three for Dave. So part of me always likes just getting through March, and watching the games at home instead of in the hospital.
TulipGirl
OT. . . I’ve been waiting for the 3/1 sermon to come online — 3/8 is up now. I guess that means 3/1 didn’t get recorded? (I wanted to pass the link on to some friends.)
TulipGirl
I dunno. . . I think we’re gonna here a lot of people saying they were hip before Calvinism was cool (again).Though, honestly, I’m glad that Reformed theology is shaping more of the discussions within evangelicalism. Still I have concerns that Reformed theology will be “blamed” for some of the pre-existing dysfunctions in the wider Generic North American Protestant culture.
TulipGirl
here = hear*blush*
MagistraCarminum
Excellent article and reminder, Randy!
Gail and Keith
Half of the game is 90% mental
Randy Greenwald
I’ve heard that before. It’s kind of like deja vu all over again.
TulipGirl
*tears*
Seth
6/10… Guessed on more than half, I’d say. I really should read more.
Seth
Amy and I started to watch this with some friends of ours here in South Florida. We quit about 1/2 way through. We couldn’t really follow what was going on, and it wasn’t funny or intriguing or anything. It was just there. I can put up with profanity if the movie has a point or if it fits the situation, but this was just too much. What a waste of half of an evening.
Staci Thomas
This is a great passage. Thank you for posting it. Here’s a shout out to all of your readers who have the time to listen to sermons online…Keller’s Sermon on this passage called “The True Elder Brother” is outstanding. It is one of the free sermons on his website.Lord, show me the multitude of times a day when I am acting like the elder brother. Amen.
Randy Greenwald
I read The Prodigal God straight through this morning. Yup, I’ve got the elder bros. thing down pat, especially that part about God owing me stuff… 🙂
Gus/Adri
I’m on my way to breakfast, so listening to a sermon will have to wait, but this reminded me that Nathaniel has attended Redeemer’s church plant in London, and hopes they will plant a church in Warsaw.GE
TulipGirl
That would be great, Gus!I don’t want to put anyone on a pedestal, but. . . boy oh boy. . . my heart is always driven to worship our amazing God when I listen to Keller’s sermons.
Rebekah
this may be my favorite of the narnia books
Randy Greenwald
Colin and I are listening to this as we travel around town. I had forgotten what an intriguing treasure that it is.
TulipGirl
. . .beginning with the older ones. . .Hunh. I never saw that before, either.
Anonymous
A great nephew who lives in MI is also a Spartans fan, and closely following the team along with his father (not an alum of MI State.)
Seth
Yes, you need to add that “Presbyterian” part. I have seen my Pentecostal father-in-law get close :)Seth
Seth
It was educational. I learned that even when playing a team from another state, it is NOT ok to call the Spartans “Michigan”.
MagistraCarminum
This is a thought-provoking post, Randy. That emptying of self, and trusting the Lord to be all: how do we actually do that? And to do that with the joy of the sure knowledge that Christ is sufficient. I wish it were easier…or at least less painful…
Randy Greenwald
Ah, how?Take two joy pills and see me in the morning.Or…”I am the vine; you are the branches. Whoever abides in me and I in him, he it is that bears much fruit, for apart from me you can do nothing.” (John 15:5)The fact is that we DON’T do this. All I know is to be consistent in staring at the cross, reveling in the gospel, and holding on as God painfully peels away bit by bit my reticence. “…Weeping may tarry for the night, but joy comes with the morning.” (Psalm 30:5)May God never let us revel in anything but the cross.
MagistraCarminum
Amen. And may He come for us soon!
TulipGirl
I got five right. . . but only knew two. The rest were good guesses.
TulipGirl
The ideas in this post are great. . . but I keep coming back to it to look at the woodcarving.
MagistraCarminum
% correct for me, too. Way to be alike, TulipGirl!
Gus/Adri
6 correct; a big surprise for me. Looks like I’m a good guesser too.–ae
David
I had 7 correct – I haven’t even seen most of the movies, so that tells you how well I guess (I guess). I think that I knew 3 of the answers. BTW, the “%” in Chris’ reply translates into “5” if you do not press the Shift key.
Gail and Keith
You have my condolences on the loss. I kept thinking, “Oh, poor Randy…” You found the positive in the loss. Jeremy’s friends at UNC were annoyed at the drunken revelers who disturbed their peace and quiet.G
MagistraCarminum
We, too, kept thinking, “Oh, poor Randy!” They really did look just as terrible as they looked wonderful on Saturday.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks for the sentiments, but it really wasn’t all that bad. It wasn’t a surprise, really. And contrary to how it may look, I don’t live and die for these things like I once used to!
MagistraCarminum
I still have a falling-apart copy with a note from you on the front cover, and remember reading this for the first time at your suggestion. We are rereading it now in our Sunday evening Fellowship time, and it’s still fresh and relevant!
Gail and Keith
Then you won’t mind this:http://blogs.newsobserver.com/multi/franklin-street-time-lapse
Seth
I got 4 out of 10 right. Out of those 4, I knew 1 for sure, and 1 90% positive. Ouch.
TulipGirl
I haven’t read this yet (though it is on the shelf!) And you aren’t the only person this week recommending it. . . I guess I know what I should delve into next. (Especially since two of the books on my to-read-list had an unexpected swim in the pool and are still drying. . .)
Gail and Keith
At your suggestion I have just read Chapter 19 “Sons of God” in Packer’s book Knowing God. Fantastic stuff: “….I am a child of God. God is my Father; heaven is my home; every day is one day nearer. My Savior is my brother; every Christian is my brother too.” Jesus is the Standard by which we live our lives. He alone kept the law, He lived the Sermon on the Mount. On another note, for many, many years I sat under ‘dispensational’ teaching. I do not recall hearing that Jesus Sermon on the Mount did not apply to the church. (Not to say it isn’t taught; I just never heard that) Indeed, as a grade schooler attending Daily Vacation Bible School, the basis for one summer’s teaching was the Beatitudes which we memorized. Each day’s lesson was based on one of them. G
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, Gail, especially for your clarification regarding dispensationalism and the sermon on the mount. Most dispensationalists do extract principles from the sermon on the mount, and so it is not completely rejected. I was simply referring to a comment made by Charles C. Ryrie in his classic defense of dispensationalism Dispensationalism Today in which he says, “It is usually charged that dispensationalists teach that the Sermon is all law and no gospel. To those who object to this claim, we merely ask, ‘Where can one find a statement of the gospel in the Sermon?'” So, I did misquote. He does not say ‘grace’; he says ‘gospel’. But I think the impact is the same.Glad you find Packer encouraging. I certainly have.
Gail and Keith
Ah, yes, Dr. Charles Ryrie. Chuckle.I’ve heard him speak on a few occasions. He was one of the conference speakers when I worked at Word of Life Inn in N.Y. and a frequent speaker at an independent Baptist Church here in town. The Ryrie Study Bible is a dispensationalist’s gold mine. 🙂 G
Gus/Adri
You wouldn’t want to hear hateful the things I thought – sometimes even said aloud – about Clippy in our pre-Mac days: just ask my husband, who reminds me occasionally of that “help” which I didn’t need or want.–ae
Gropius
Very funny post. Clippy will go down one day. We will all take him down.
TulipGirl
Speaking of yummy baking smells, I like your new banner!
Randy Greenwald
Thanks! I tired of the sunset, and had taken this pic to use on the website, and thought, “Why not?” Makes me hungry…
Anonymous
Speaking of smells – especially of wood: as a child I loved the smell of new wood/lumber. I would ride my bike past a new garage being built on our alley, and revel in the lovely fragrance. I had a juvenile fantasy of being incarcerated (for what, I never knew) and the punishment – the judge not knowing my idiosyncrasy – would be to be locked up and forced to smell new wood for a long time.Don’t laugh!
Randy Greenwald
Strange fantasy, no doubt, but I’m not laughing. For the latest project I picked up twenty 1×10 pine boards from the lumberyard and hauled them to my garage. Both my van and the garage smelled heavenly for days.I’m developing a new fantasy… I’ll start selling knots of pine for people’s sniffing pleasure….
Gail and Keith
“Play it once, Sam, for old times’ sake.” Ilsa”You played it for her and you can play it for me.” and “If she can stand it, I can! Play it!” Rick
Randy Greenwald
Which, of course, is what many would be thinking were I to use the line!
Gus/Adri
Pizza includes carbohydrates, protein (in meat and cheese), vegetables (in fresh toppings or the tomato sauce)…. What’s not to like; or be good for you, especially when used in moderation?From a prayer by John Calvin – “O Lord, …pour out thy blessing …and sanctify to our use the meat and drink which are the gifts of thy kindness toward us, that we, using them soberly and frugally as thou enjoinest, may eat with a pure conscience….”Enjoy your next pizza meal!–ae
Staci Thomas
I’m looking forward to this. Thank you for taking the time to address the article.Staci
Stoic Objectivst
Likewise on hearing your views on the subject.
MagistraCarminum
Roman Holiday is one of my favorite movies! And the photo of the roll makes me hungry…
TulipGirl
Oooh! That’s one of my faves, too!
Gail and Keith
What a nice gift! If you’d like to borrow the other 2 films in the trilogy, we’ve got them, “A Fistful of Dollars” and “For a Few Dollars More.” G
MagistraCarminum
LOL! I can see it all unfold before me…It reminds me of the time I got up in the middle of the night with a sick child, and was So tired and couldn’t focus my eyes properly, and they kept watering. Eventually I realized I had picked up Dave’s glasses by mistake…
Randy Greenwald
And I wouldn’t dare tell in public about my very routine oriented youngest daughter who got ready for her morning shift at work, complete with uniform and make up and only when she was getting ready to walk out the door did she see that it was only midnight. She had misread her clock. She did not need to be at work until 7:00 AM. No, I would not tell that on her in public.
Gus/Adri
I was gonna say – if that’s a routine morning, you can have it! I’ll stick to my simpler routine, which begins w/ coffee brought to my nightstand by a loving, glasses-wearing husband. No chance of his mistaking my specs for his, b/c I use only colorful (not masculine) reading glasses.–ae
TulipGirl
“I’ll stick to my simpler routine, which begins w/ coffee brought to my nightstand by a loving, glasses-wearing husband.”Ahhh. . . I like the sound of that!
TulipGirl
Twice I’ve come back to read this, and laughed.
Randy Greenwald
It’s funny from a copy editing point of view. But I shudder to think of the horror of the parents of this young man reading that in the paper as they struggle with the other elements of grief. I laugh and shudder at the same time.
Rebekah
“Downfall” was so great! (But you’re absolutely right that it wasn’t cheery.) I liked it because it portrayed Hitler as a person, not as a demon, but in portraying him like a person, it made what he did and who he was even worse.I hadn’t thought of it from your perspective though, which is a good point to take away.
Rebekah
P.S. That’s the fun of movie discussions–5 different people can watch a movie and have 5 completely different opinions!
Randy Greenwald
That’s the reason I love posting these things. I enjoy hearing the different perspectives. The movie did present Hitler as a person, as a more complex and rounded human person, but it presented him as well as being seriously deranged, I think. Worse was Goebbels, an even more creepy character.
MagistraCarminum
Yikes! Remind me that if we ever watch movies together, i want to do the choosing…;-)
Randy Greenwald
The choosing is all yours. I have to remember that you first introduced us to The Princes Bride!
Adria
Hey, can you send it up here so I can read it as I am horizontal? It sounds like one I would like. Then I can give it back when you come up for the baby. 🙂 I am looking for good things to read.
Gus/Adri
For me, it’s ditto for your final sentence. It was quite some time ago that I read and enjoyed it.–ae
Gus/Adri
PLEASE! If you are going to post such mouth-watering pictures, put a warning at the top — for folks who’ve not yet eaten breakfast. –ae
Randy Greenwald
Your wish is my command. (That is, as long as you keep your wishes within reason, and don’t express them between 9:00 PM at night and 5:00 AM in the morning, and, well, you get the picture.)
Rebekah
that’s cruel! bella doesn’t sell them anymore (do they?), so i’m stuck without cinnamon rolls!
Gail and Keith
Oh, that is a very good, manageable size for one to sink one’s choppers into! G
Randy Greenwald
Rebekah – there is a rumor that there may be some at the coffee house Friday and Saturday night…
Rebekah
Hooooraaay!
Gail and Keith
That is a great article! A friend sent out the notice to her huge e-mail list so it’s getting wide-spread publicity. g
Staci Thomas
I had a ton of fun last night. You people are a blast!
Rebekah
show’s that a sucker is born every day, and your sins will find you out! fun times…
TulipGirl
Ahhhh. . . if the music and the art aren’t enough to bring the community together — Cinnamental Rolls certainly are!
TulipGirl
Enjoyed tonight’s music and art. . .
Gus/Adri
In reading about people’s thoughts on two different Gods, I couldn’t help but think of Lamentations 3:21-24, and 31-33. Surely these Old Testament verses reveal a gentle, loving, caring and compassionate God!–ae
MagistraCarminum
We are very proud of you… and I won’t even make any Mac jabs…
Randy Greenwald
A Mac jab would be appropriate. I’ve not had good success with the durability of the Mac hardware. This, however, is a Western Digital hard drive, and I’ve had them go bad in PCs as well.
Gus/Adri
I think you missed your calling. You should have been a brain surgeon!GE
TulipGirl
Awww. . . you know the way to a wife’s heart is through fixing her laptop. (Hubby has demonstrated that tender knowledge of a woman’s sensitive needs, as well. . .)
Gus/Adri
My suggestion is that you watch the baby delivery video just in case – you might get to grandbaby’s birth in time to help! You could hum “Georgia on My Mind” while you watch. –ae
Rebekah
Dude, shoulda bought a Dell.Just… kidding… that is a wonderful achievement!
Randy Greenwald
But I’m ‘too cool’ to buy a Dell… 😉
Adria
I take issue, I believe the family would let you use all the words from another language that you could… Plus the reason Gama can use from two different languages is because he speaks more then a “very little” english. He speaks enough to communicate, and enough to be the boss of the landscaping team, directing and instructing what needs to be done completely in english.
Gus/Adri
Your ingenuity reminded me of my neighbors. Fabio’s wife had a Volkswagen in need of a new headlight but he thought the dealer’s price for replacing it was too high. He found the VW repair manual on the ‘net and fixed it himself saving himself a wad of money.GE
TulipGirl
Gus and Adri introduced us to Bananagrams, and we bought it and brought it to a family reunion in Colorado. They all adored it — especially since much of the family is word-oriented, and it was a game that could involve the kids and adults. Unfortunately, my hyper-competitive aunt (the one no one will play scrabble with anymore) dominated the bananagram table after awhile. . .
Randy Greenwald
Whew. Never attack Adria’s man – ESPECIALLY when she is pregnant! You know, of course, that I was teasing about the cheating. The ‘very little English’ comment was way exaggerated, and I’m very sorry about that. “Very little’ better explains my Spanish!
Anonymous
“Where can I get some liquid nitrogen?”Probably, in a cryogenics lab. My father used to work in the cryogenics lab at the University of Toronto, where he was responsible for the production of liquid nitrogen, being used by the physicists.I still remember the day, when he brought some home to our house.*Grin*FM
Randy Greenwald
But, FM, in Canada, don’t you just need to put stuff outside? Who needs liquid nitrogen up there?!
TulipGirl
I enjoyed reading this essay of interesting things. . .Fadiman has also written an fascinating book that looks at the cross-cultural clashes that happen in the US in the realm of medicine, The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down. (And rather than a Presby prof, it was a Wesleyan prof who recommended it to me — which goes to show Fadiman’s appeal bridges theological divides.)Btw, my paternal grandmother was a Lamb — ostensibly, distantly related to Charles and Mary. Hence I knew of their walks with insanity — but how common is that among the very gifted?
Anonymous
Very funny. Perhaps you should also consider taking a Canadian Geography course. Non?Canadian Lit, eh? Sounds like your prof was more interesting than mine. Did you read: The Hockey Sweater (“Le chandail de hockey”)? It’s a short story written by Quebec author Roch Carrier. It’s great!
Randy Greenwald
Tulip Girl – you are related to the Lambs AND you are very gifted. Oh please, please, please back away from the butcher knives… :-)And, FM, I did not read the book you refer to, but we did read La Guerre, Yes Sir!.
TulipGirl
“I am, of course, here jesting with my readers, and I’ve discovered that in Reformed circles I usually need to explain my jokes. (page 276)”*giggle* Though, the dry wit and snark are often to be found among many of the Reformed. . .
TulipGirl
Ahhh. . . I’m thankful for pastoral counsel. . . *eg*
Randy Greenwald
My desire is that Reformed people lay down the snark and pick up the winsome.
Amy
That decision book looks cheap. Hope its short too!
TulipGirl
While I would agree that winsome is the way to go in generally relating to one another, I would contend that in humor, the occasional snark is like having a sprinkling of cayenne on gumbo. Delicious, used sparingly.
Randy Greenwald
I’ll accept that. Snark with Love works!
MagistraCarminum
Excellent points, Randy. I have to admit that when I hit the quote about the gospel of Mark, which is fairly early, I quit reading. Maybe that is narrow-minded of me, but that said an awful lot about the author’s assumptions and direction…
MagistraCarminum
Praying here, and anxiously awaiting the news!
MagistraCarminum
praying will intensify! Give A. my love!
TulipGirl
Continuing to pray. . .
Rebekah
Hooray!
Amy
Yay! Congrats, glad Isai is doing well.
Gus/Adri
He’s beautiful – and handsome! Far more than just a baby. 🙂 Look at those bright eyes!Congratulations all around.Gus and Adri
Gus/Adri
“Jose = Spanish for Randy” — yeah, right! At least that’s good for an early morning chuckle.And congratulations to all!The E’s
Gail and Keith
Oh, he’s so cute! Send more pictures!!!!!! Gail
Rebekah
How precious!!!
Seth
Isai = Spanish for Jessie, and Jessie is derived from an archaic form of Seth. Therefore, Isai was named for his uncle!
David
Congratulations G-Pa, I hope you will not be teaching your grandson Spanish!We are praying for Adria and Isai.Dave and Chris
Staci Thomas
He is really, really adorable. Wow! Can’t wait to see more pictures!
TulipGirl
Rejoicing with you!And prayers for the baby’s continued health and a quick recovery for Adria (and may she listen to her mother to take it easy!)
TulipGirl
How sweet!
MagistraCarminum
He is beautiful!
TulipGirl
Boys are fun! Did they know Isai was going to be a boy before he was born?
Randy Greenwald
No, they went into this in the old fashioned way.
TulipGirl
Just popping in to let you know we’re continuing to pray. . .
Gail and Keith
Isai is still adorably cute! And we continue to pray for this precious gift. G
MagistraCarminum
He’s beautiful, and we’re continuing to pray. There was such a gap since the last update, I almost had to try to reach you by phone (horrors!) to get an update. Keep those grandfatherly posts coming!
OLeãoRampante
It’s a rather nteresting way of seeing things. A wonderful and solid opinion.Kind of a surrealistic view, as, in fact, Dostoievsky was.I can point Salvador Dalí as one of its followers, but mainly on painting, of course.Congratulations from Portugal!
Gail and Keith
Keith and I saw this movie and loved it. It is a tender love story, funny, heart stopping, action filled, sad, with panoramic scenery and you find yourself caring about the characters. I noticed the story was not lost on the young movie attenders as more than once we heard an “awwwww” breathed from some young voice in the darkened theater. G
The Domestic Intellectual
I’ve read it from start to finish and HIGHLY recommend it. I really think it should be read in a discussion group format so that you can get additional perspectives. In addition, I think it would be great reading for couples (married and considering marriage) as they examine their vocation in light of the cross and culture.Will be reading it again with my Beloved Physicist.
Anonymous
What a sweet post and a beautiful photo! Happy Birthday Barb!Staci
Anonymous
What a movie. What a movie. What a movie. I could go on and on but I wouldn't do it justice. And yes, I cried. A couple times. Staci
Randy Greenwald
Awh, another softy.
Gail and Keith
Oh, how sweet! What a lovely picture of Barb. Happy Birthday to you Barb.G
Seth
So are you saying that my mother is fermented?
MagistraCarminum
Happy birthday, Barb! And welcome home!
Randy Greenwald
Seth, you say that as if fermentation is a bad thing. She is bubbly, and especially fun when uncorked. Fermentation brings out different flavors and colors that only can be seen over time. Oh that we would all age so elegantly!
TulipGirl
*mush, mush*
Randy Greenwald
mush, mush? Isn't that a command for a team of sled dogs?:-)
Gus/Adri
How about "crustless quiche" for the appetizer; I have the recipe. For dessert – mini cinnamon rolls from Cinnamental.–ae
Anonymous
If you are considering liquid refreshment with your appetizer: maybe a dry martini?
snowbot
I make oxymoronic drinks/desserts all the time at Starbucks. How about:Venti 8-pump Nonfat Extra Whip White Mocha.Venti with Whip Caramel Frappucino Light.Or, here's one I made today:Nonfat Orange Mango Vivanno (protein smoothie) with Whip Cream and Caramel Drizzle.
Phil
Anything containing tofu is probably oxymoronic in principle.
Geoffsnook
Sounds cool. Haven't done the book on tape thing yet. Maybe I'll do it one day. Sounds like a good one to start with.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks for the help!I'm not sure I could handle a martini, but a proper dry wine would seem just as appropriate.And a nonfat extra whip mocha? Yes, I believe that fits the bill.And tofu… now there's one. We use quite often a 'meatless' meat product for our chili and lasagna. Made from tofu. Keep the suggestions coming!
TulipGirl
The last time I read the trilogy was. . .goodness, was it really 17 years ago?! But I read The Hobbit aloud to the boys. We really like the songs. *grin*I always thought I was a visual learner, and maybe I am. But the past few years of listening to lecture and sermon MP3s has me questioning that. I seem to be able to remember and integrate information better when I hear it, but able to recall and verbally respond with information when I read it. In other words, don't ask me the details of what I've listened to lately — just the broad picture!Many of the school books the boys are using are available at librivox.com (free audio books, classics!) Since they are all reading a lot of the same books in spite of the age differences, it's helped to have both audio version and text versions available. My mom sent the boys her ipod for their school audio books, which was quickly dubbed the MoPod, since they call her Mo.
Gus/Adri
So glad you are [finally] reading – and enjoying – it. You may decide to read it more than once; it's well worth the time.–ae
MagistraCarminum
I stand in the halls of shame with you, Randy, having never read AK. I must admit I'm not much of a Russian novel fan…I have read Tolstoy's Redemption and Dostoyevsky's Crime and Punishment, and while they were worthy, I don't tend to run to such novels.My other shameful admission: never made it through Brothers Karamazov. I have tried. In three attempts I've never made it past the first 100 pages.
Elsa
Oh good! Anna K. is currently one of my favorites. I've read it four times (sort of accidentally, and not because the first reading was astounding), and I've found it very interesting how my perception of the various romances has changed since I first read it in high school. I hope you have a good translation; I like the one by Pevear and Volokhonsky.
Randy Greenwald
Let's see: Elsa and Adri have read it multiple times. That averages out so that Chris and I don't need to….And, Elsa, thanks for the translator recommendations. I'm reading it in the original Russian, actually…Right. No, I bought the least expensive paperback from Amazon that was not branded 'Oprah's Book Club'. Translator is someone named David Magarshack. Hope it's good!Chris, I would agree that the BK takes some getting into. But CP — that is a great book, and pamphlet size by Russian standards!
Anonymous
The last movie left out the end of the story, which (to me) was the whole point. The Hobbits went on the journey (unknowingly) to toughen up, so they could defend/liberate their own beloved Shire. The adventure made them able to stand on their own. (Not a Biblical view of things at all, but this was more a good vs evil thing than God vs Satan) I was very disappointed with the end of the movie trilogy.
Randy Greenwald
Agreed. The end omits some very important aspects of the story.
Bill Martin's Personal Ramblings
I think you have chosen the correct term. The antonym has grave implications.
MagistraCarminum
I think musicians will keep their jobs, don't you?
Randy Greenwald
Absolutely!
TulipGirl
While the stable of cool templates is limited with a free account, you -could- switch to wordpress without buying a domain name or hosting. You can still make banners and customize quite a bit, even with a free account. (Oh, and behind-the-scenes is a lot more fun than blogspot, imo. I was loyal to Moveable Type for years, but WP won me over. . .)Sheesh. . . I'm really not as geeky as I sound. . .
TulipGirl
Grave implications? *groans*
Randy Greenwald
Oh, come on… admit it… there is an inner geek that revels in these things! We like you that way. And being one of the PCA's most prominent cloggers secures your reputation.Thanks for the inside info. I'm being tempted, lured, seduced, but it may be that the grass is simply greener.
Randy Greenwald
Whoa! Guess what, TG – two years ago, I come to find out, I tested this at WP… I still have an account. May see changes soon… 🙂
TulipGirl
I was hoping that was you. . . I typed in "your" url at wordpress and saw it was taken. I would have been sore disappointed had someone else claimed it.Still cloggin' away,TG
Seth
*dies laughing*
Seth
Designers and Architects will definitely be gainfully employed in heaven.
Anonymous
Yeah; know what you mean. The cashier at that store you mentioned asks, "Do you want to contribute to _____?" – whatever it is; can't remember exactly now.I've thought of saying, "We give at church," but that's not strictly true at least for the named charity. However, our church does help the needy through a reliable local organization staffed mainly by volunteers – certainly not people who pocket a good percentage of contributions.
Dwight L. Dolby
My teen-age boys went out to see this movie and came back with mediocre praise. My daughter (11) hosted a sleep over with a half-dozen girl-friends and they all loved it. Last night I watched it with my wife and I loved it too. I don't mind half of Paris being cleaned-up. You have to be a dad or a daughter to really appreciate this one.
Gus/Adri
It can be used with malicious intent. That's why we need a nanny state!ge
TulipGirl
*L*
Carolynn
I would like to point out that everyone takes what they need from a sermon. I know in our family we get exactly what we need from them. There have been times when we have had a bad week and looked at one another thinking Sunday is going to suck cause we know it will come up. Randy you are right on in my book and how ever you intend to come off the work of God is done in our life thank youCarolynn and Joel Lengyel
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, Carolynn.
Gail and Keith
Congratulations to Seth on reaching his goal!
MagistraCarminum
ah Seth, and have a wonderful week!
TulipGirl
Have a wonderful time! We'll miss you. Can't wait to see the pics!
Gus/Adri
Fresh asparagus; soft-cooked eggs; chocolate; ice cream; books. And maybe for the sake of nostalgia a little corner of that heavenly state with the four-letter name. No, I don't mean Ohio 🙂 nor Utah. –ae
Gail and Keith
The writer asks a question worth pondering–what would we do differently if we REALLY thought the unborn were persons.Keith
MagistraCarminum
Great photo! I think I know everyone but the couple standing behind Barb…
Staci Thomas
The Tim Tebow quote is absolutely hilarious.
Staci Thomas
Impressive. Love the background music. You are on to something, here. Did it rain EVERY day that you camped?
Randy Greenwald
No… it was beautiful the rest of the week. Absolutely perfect. When I get a chance, I'll post another video. This is too much fun… makes me want to get a high quality video recorder. This was filmed with my still camera…
MagistraCarminum
Lovely! Keep the video coming! But next time, remember to lower your aim enough to give us a shot of your dear wife's face, not just the top of her head…;-)
A
I love, love, love this family photo!
Staci Thomas
First of all, I played Ring Around the Rosy in its original version no less than 354 times in the pool last week with my kids. And each time I sang it, I remember the morbid origins of the song. So, for the last 238 times I played it, I changed the words to "we all fall up". I. just. couldn't. take. the. death. any. more.Secondly, thanks for the book recommendation. Speaking of death and tears, yesterday I read aloud the chapter in Little Women when Beth dies. And I sobbed while reading aloud. So, you are much cooler than I in that you had a tear and I had sobs. Off to get that book…today! Sounds wonderful. Thanks again for sharing.Staci
Randy Greenwald
Book recommendations are always a risky thing. How many times have I commended a movie only to have someone come back to me and say something like, "I can't believe you liked that." That said, once you read this book, let me know what you think. I warn you: Edward is not a very likable character!
Elsa
Have you ever read the short story "Perfection" by Mark Helprin? It's one of my favorites. It's about redemption through baseball (!) and is a fictional account of the Yankees in the time of Mickey Mantle. It's the centerpiece of a collection called _The Pacific and Other Stories_, all of which is worth reading.The story can be found here: http://www.cardinalnewman.org/s/206/images/editor_documents/Scharfen/Perfection.helprin.doc The link will open a Word doc, by the way.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, Elsa. I've been wanting to read something by this guy, so a story about baseball seems an excellent place to start. As soon as I get through Anna Karenina, of course!
TulipGirl
Putting it on my wishlist. . .
TulipGirl
So great!
Bill Martin
You're right about the salad: Barb's art is fruitful (and nutritious)! And I love Rainbows for a Fallen World. I used it for an aesthetics course and found it very insightful. Thanks for the link!
Randy Greenwald
Well, Bill, if you own it, and need some cash, see what it is selling for:http://www.alibris.com/booksearch?binding=&mtype=&keyword=rainbows+for+the+fallen+world&hs.x=0&hs.y=0&hs=Submit!!
Gus/Adri
When I think of the new earth I think of the garden of Eden. Will we have agriculture and animal husbandry specialists? On the other hand, if the 'new city' dwellers have all food supplied automatically, there will be no need of them.gus
Gideon Strauss
As a Seerveld fan, I loved this! (Thank you to Alexandra Kuehne Bush, who pointed me here.)
A
*LOL*
Gail and Keith
All I can find is that it was in a short story written by Stein. One link says he wrote the story just do he could use the pun. Now you've got me curious! G
Gail and Keith
Oops, I mean Asimov. g
Randy Greenwald
That's all I could find as well. We may still have the book around the house somewhere. I could go back in time to when I read it, but I could not get back, I fear.Or something like that.
The Domestic Intellectual
Had to share this with the Beloved Physicist!
Randy Greenwald
I was afraid you'd do that… (!) I probably got the time travel stuff all messed up!
Gus/Adri
My research, faulty as it may be, led me to the magazine Asimov's Science Fiction, not a book.-ge
MagistraCarminum
Awww- I remember them from the first time around! Congratulations, Randy and Barb!And how did you transfer the old tapes to something electronic? I know it was on a cassette!
Gail and Keith
Yes, the girl in the picture is stunning as she still is today. Congratulations to you both and thank you for sharing this special memory of 7/8/78. G
Gus/Adri
Why would you need to borrow a child in order to read aloud? The following is from WORLD 5/3/08; Susan Olasky did the interview:"At about six Peterson [Eugene] builds a fire in the woodstove, and he and his wife begin preparations for supper. Then they read aloud for an hour and a half. They are currently rereading for the seventh time The Chronicles of Narnia. (The first three readings came as they read the novels to their children.) They read other novels and memoirs: George Elliot, Wallace Stegner, and Barbara Kingsolver. (They give every book 50 pages before deciding whether to continue.) When they're done reading, they finish dinner preparations, eat, and go to bed."I'm with you on Freddie Goes To Florida. Seems I've read that some view it as (one of the?) best of the series. And I'm not surprised Colin likes the Little House book. I read all of them to the boys when they were about that age; each was thoroughly enjoyed.–ae
Adria
Congratulations Mom and Dad. I am ever thankful for the example you showed us of a committed and loving marriage. It is something that I am forever grateful for, and that Gama an I are blessed by. Thank you! Love you guys.
Gus/Adri
I think Gehry tried to justify himself. He should have apologized to the man he humiliated, not to the reporter.-ge
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, A. That means a lot to me/us. We love you!
Seth
How cute! I have to say I was surprised by how thick the Michigan rolled off of Mom's tongue… Amy and I echo everything that Adria has stated already. We love you both very much. Wow. 31! It is so cool. Amy and I are coming up on 6, very quickly!
MagistraCarminum
Six is getting credible Seth. I remember that one, too! I remember the rain storm, and trying to get the helium balloons without getting them wet, and making bazillions of little key lime pies. And I remember Barb's niece, at around age 6, telling me, "A little deodorant, and you'll be good to go." :-)Dave and I celebrate our 29th next week.
Seth
I believe that Gehry handled the situation very well! Although I do not know the specifics of what the man was questioning, I have heard others start to grandstand at the expense of the speaker before. I am not saying this because I am a great Gehry aficionado, I too have some issues with his work. But I am not about to rebuke the man in public to prove what a great architecture critic I am. As a designer, I know the element of my soul that gets put into my projects, and if someone were coming after my work I am not sure I would have stopped at "Pompous".
Geoffsnook
Wow, sounds like an interesting read. You should get Staci to read it. If she does, she'll have to read it in a week and can tell you about it!
Randy Greenwald
Dear Staci,I'm sorry that Geoff has dissed you here. We know you read faster than that.Randy
snowbot
I do believe that his front bangs are doing a flip right at the eyebrow level, thus creating said illusion.I am looking forward to this film.
Adria
I agree with snowbot. At the last moment he moves his eyebrows and you can see them separate. It does look funny though. 🙂
MagistraCarminum
I think you have nailed it- cool optical illusion, though! I can't wait to see the movie…
TulipGirl
*mush, mush*
Gus/Adri
It's good that we still can find churches that are 99 44/100 Calvinist–also 99.44% pure soap;-)-ge
Gus/Adri
To make it simpler and eliminate the wind effects (you didn't specify that there is no cross wind), assume further that you are traveling in a vacuum! But this is your trip, not mine.-ge
TulipGirl
(For those who are curious, the Psalm 92 sermon is worth listening to and can be found here.)
Rebekah
The kind of retraining he references is a bad idea–I would concur on that assessment. I met a displaced worker on an airplane who was being retrained after her factory closed, and the industry she was being retrained for didn't sound very hopeful.The private sector and foundation community is getting involved in intelligent planning for retraining of displaced workers–and general planning for gaps in the workforce.They're connecting the government, industry, and the training sector, so that everyone involved in the process is communicating knowledge, so they know where the existing worker gaps are, and where the gaps will be 5, 10, and 15 years down the road.The worst thing to do for a worker is to train someone for a job that they won't be able to find.
Gail and Keith
Who in their right mind would throw a peanut M&M out the window in the first place! G
Randy Greenwald
Hypothetically, me. Hypothetically, of course. Which, hypothetically, raises the whole 'in their right mind' question. But it was all in the hypothetical interest of science.
Gail and Keith
Okay. You're off the hook. Inquiring minds do want to know and we'll accept this excus…er, reason as a valid one in the interest of science. G
The Domestic Intellectual
Thanks for sharing this. I was encouraged by the article from Whitehead. It is hard to admit when you feel grief is near your heart, especially when you are not facing the type of wrenching loss that he describes, but it is a reality nonetheless.
Rebekah
what can we say–all other sports want to be like us?!
Gail and Keith
And, wasn't Crawford's catch amazing!Here's hoping the Rays get off to a rousing start in the 2nd half of the season. Whoever wrote that caption must not be a sports fan. And, yeah, I cannot wait for hockey to begin, nor can I wait for college football!
Gail and Keith
I've just been reading in Acts Stephen's, Peter's, and Paul's messages to the crowds. Gets me all excited!
Staci Thomas
Dr. Pap, professor in the Civil Engineering Department at Virginia Tech, could answer these questions for you. He could even teach you how to solve them if you enrolled in his class called "Dynamics", a required class for students who have a dream of becoming Civil Engineers. The problem is that if you go and have a bunch of kids, you'll forget the formulas that you never thought you'd forget and you won't be able to provide the answers to these questions.Staci
Staci Thomas
Nice, you two. Way to go and talk about a girl behind her back when she isn't paying attention. :-)I've been following the hype surrounding this book. I read Bloom's review and in today's Times several people are responding to the review. Interesting stuff. Once I absorb that book about full quivers, this one is next on my list.Staci
Staci Thomas
So glad you are enjoying the journey!
Randy Greenwald
I, too, read the letters, and if I'm reading them correctly, none, really, take the position that perhaps there really IS a transcendent God. Curios.
Randy Greenwald
For what it is worth, the track of the M & M, against all logic, appears to maintain a fairly linear course once exiting the van. But, sigh, short of enrolling in a course at VTU, I'm condemned to never knowing for sure.
Barb
I would have to say that "Family Man" is probably my favorite of his movies. I generally like what I've seen that he's done, but looking at his bio reveals that there is much I've not seen. For those of you who are not familiar with "Family Man", think "It's a Wonderful Life" with a twist.
Rebekah
"Gone In 60 Seconds," "Gone In 60 Seconds," "Gone In 60 Seconds," "Gone In 60 Seconds," "Gone In 60 Seconds," "Gone In 60 Seconds," "Gone In 60 Seconds," "Gone In 60 Seconds!!!!"That wasn't a typo, it really is that good. Some movies aren't "good," but they're really good at their genre, and this is a super heist/action movie.
Randy Greenwald
Safe to say you like it?! 🙂
The Domestic Intellectual
My favorite was the first National Treasure. His deadpan was hilarious and he totally reminded me of my cousin Brian!
Geoffsnook
Awesome opportunity Randy. May more of us take steps of faith like this and go to them and instead of waiting for them to come to us.
TulipGirl
". . .in an age when the world does not come to the church, the church needs to go to the world. That is the punch line, if there is to be one."Hm. Something for me to think about and remember.
Randy Greenwald
Hey, T G – this is the kind of place your hubby would LOVE to hang out!
Matthew
For pure entertainment and watchability (is that a word?) factor I am going to have to say "The Rock" if we are talking his best performance then "8MM". I am not a huge Nicolas fan because even though his roles are diverse he acts just about the same in most his movies.PS "Matchstick Men", "National Treasure" and "Bringing Out the Dead" almost made the list.
Matthew
Rather intriguing movie poster.
The Domestic Intellectual
I would guess "7 Pounds" was one of them… not sure of the other at the moment.
Randy Greenwald
A good, and accurate guess. You win 1/2 of the grand prize… which is, well, nothing. Pride. That's it. The pride of being first.That film had been on our list for some time. So, it was on tap for Friday. Then, randomly, I picked another movie from the local Blockbuster which, ironically, alludes early in the film, to the expected death of the male lead. Anyone want to guess what that movie was? I guarantee you, it is more obscure than Seven Pounds, but it has a recognizable lead. And it has at least sufficient press to be carried by a local video store.Guesses, anyone?
The Domestic Intellectual
Would the other be Benjamin Button?
Randy Greenwald
An interesting guess. I've not seen BB… it is in our stack for tomorrow night. If it qualifies, then that will make our movie selection even weirder – three in a row.Keep guessing.
TulipGirl
We had a discussion about Movies and History at ThinkTank last night. It was very interesting. . . however, in the midst of it, I realized how few movies I've seen. (Or, at least, remember. . .)I'm surprised that I actually saw the first one mentioned.I don't have a guess for the second one.
Geoffsnook
Randy,I think my favorite Nicholas Cage film is one that is more obscure but one of my top 5 Christmas movies called "Trapped in Paradise." It also stars Jon Lovitz and Dana Carvey as they attempt to rob a small town bank and then feel really bad about it during Christmas time.
Greg
To start with, let's ignore gravity.Then, when you throw it, for the first few inches it flies straight towards the window, slowing down slightly because of air friction. The force on the M&M is in the opposite direction to its motion because (from the M&M's viewpoint) that's the direction that the wind of its motion comes from.Now, as it goes through the open window, it suddenly goes out into rapidly moving air. All of a sudden, the wind that the M&M sees is mostly sideways. So, air friction starts pushing it towards the back of the car.Air friction is still doing the same thing — it's still slowing down the M&M relative to the air, but now the air around the M&M is moving rapidly backwards (relative to the car).So, from your viewpoint, the M&M starts a smooth backwards curve as it goes through the plane of the window.From the viewpoint of someone sitting on the roadside it's a little simpler.The M&M starts out moving forward at 60 mph in the car, then when you throw it, it's moving diagonally forward and sideways in a straight line.Once it goes through the plane of the window, it just slows down, that's all. Of course, the thing is, the car doesn't slow down, so the car gets ahead of the M&M.If you turn on gravity, it gets a bit more complex, but only because the M&M is now accelarating downwards.
Greg Kochanski
I looked at his website and glanced at a few of his papers. He seems a bit of an oddball, but the papers I read seemed to be good science. Seems like a good chance that he wrote an interesting book.
Randy Greenwald
Thank you, thank you, thank you, Greg. I'd love to know who you are, but you write as if you know what you are talking about, so you've persuaded me! Thanks.
Matthew
Makes non-resident family miss game night..
Randy Greenwald
Ah, yes… we miss our non-resident participants. Especially this one, the one MOST responsible for making our game night an institution by never letting us miss a night.
Geoffsnook
Randy,What a perspective to have. How freeing! I just need to pray about whether or not God wants me to read it. Hmmm…..
MagistraCarminum
I almost posted about this yesterday…excellent points, Randy! I once argued abortion with my own dear mother, and she ended the debate by saying that I could prove to her that abortion was murder, but she found that murder justifiable. I was left simply speechless after that.
Randy Greenwald
You deserve a reward for reading all 800+ words! Short posts ordinarily get read; long posts get 'glanced at'!
Joel
I love that song but it is funny the song it's self soothes me but the lyrics are mournful. That may be like most of life you not just one emotion but a symphony of feelings all doing there part to move you.
Gail and Keith
and now the bubble is burst! Poof!
TulipGirl
Oh, no! Haven't gone camping with my boys.
TulipGirl
I love the image posted, "ignore the man behind the green curtain." I had a friend who was going to use that as a theme for a blog / site on Joseph Smith. . .You're so organized. . . Half of my blogging thoughts occur while I'm driving and I don't have a great capture system set up for those ideas. And so. . . I just wait until the muse strikes and I have the laptop.It's odd, though. . . Since we have wireless at home and at Sbux and Bella's, I've never really thought about the what-ifs of wanting to write without an internet connection. I don't usually have the computer without a connection of some sort.
Matthew
Yeah camping!!P.s. I actually wrote this comment 2 days ago but had it post now to appear as if I just wrote it. Cool eh?Matthew
Randy Greenwald
Yeah… pretty cool. Smoke and mirrors!
Randy Greenwald
Down here where I live they have these things called traffic lights. Sometimes I actually stop at them. And when I do, and have an idea, well, grab a pen and the back of a receipt, a napkin, or a candy wrapper, and the idea is captured!
Rebekah
i'm going to memorize that for the next time i run out of gas.
MagistraCarminum
I thnk you ought to be careful what you wish for…
Randy Greenwald
Read love = I'm curious about. I'm really not longing for this; just expecting it.
MagistraCarminum
We agree with you on both films! Hated Benjamin Button, and really enjoyed Inkheart!
The Domestic Intellectual
Haven't seen Benjamin Button, but a few friends went to see it and thought it tedious, so I decided to just skip it.I also loved Inkheart! I didn't read any reviews, but saw a clip on the plane when I flew to England in May and had to see it.My sister and I rented it last weekend and were not disappointed! The casting was excellent and Helen Mirren's character was priceless 🙂 I want to be like that when I get older!
Joel
You have to love the youth of today. Reminds me of the movie Collateral "I didn't kill him. The bullets and the fall did."
Seth
Amy and I loved Inkheart! We saw it in the theaters, and again when it came out on DVD. There aren't many movies that I would enjoy a 2nd or 3rd time, but Inkheart was one of them.
Seth
I wonder if there is a detectable shift in the balance of philosophical content of children's books between the pre and post 1985 date. How could this shift the thinking of children, not just in their imaginations?
Gail and Keith
Science was not her strongest subject. Incon-theeve-ah-ble!
MagistraCarminum
I'm almost done with #55, and not loving it, but enjoying most of it. Has interesting historical events about German occupation of the Channel Islands during WWII. I have read ~19 of the rest of the list, just in case you were interested…
Randy Greenwald
Only 15 for me, counting my current read. However, #1 should count for 7 and #18 should count as three. That would bring me up to 23… 😉 Plus, I've seen the Godfather, To Kill a Mockingbird, Jaws, Shogun, and The Princess Bride, so that I don't see a need to read them. That should bring me up to 28!
Gail and Keith
I've read 12 of the numbered and since some of those numbered are series that is really more than 12, right? But, I've seen a good number of the movies. That has to qualify for something. Rationalization is such a wonderful tool! 🙂 G
Randy Greenwald
See, Gail, you are sounding like me now.
The Domestic Intellectual
Read 23 (counting series(s) as one) including currently listening to Dracula. It is an interesting list and I think I'll put it on my facebook profile for future reference. I saw that they had Middlesex by Jeffery Eugenides on there. Haven't read it, but I did enjoy The Virgin Suicides and consider it a worthwhile read. It is not often that you have books in first person from the perspective of an unreliable narrator.
Randy Greenwald
Well, being a Domestic Intellectual, I expect you to have read more than me… !I keep trying to expand my list. I've read two Steven King novels, neither of which are on this list. If I can count those I'm up to 30. Plus, I've read The Great Santini by Pat Conroy. if I can count that, I hit 31.If I keep it up, I'll find a way to surpass 100!
MagistraCarminum
Cheaters never prosper, Randall Ray.
TulipGirl
You NEED to read "To Kill a Mockingbird." While the movie is good, the book. . . well. . . it is a classic for a reason.
TulipGirl
The CPSIA makes me livid. It is stupid on so many counts.
Randy Greenwald
Yes, TKAM is on my list. I'll have to get on it. Perhaps in 2011 when I've finally finished Anna Karenina!
Staci Thomas
From this list, I'm currently reading:#1 – aloud to my children who just can't get enough of that invisibility cloak#17 – good beach reading with a great discourse at the end of the novel by the author who explains how learning to love opera is just like learning to love baseball…#33 – blech, but I'm doing it anyway#87 – which is fabulous, but for me takes more concentration than the beach allowsI love these kind of lists! I've only read 27 from this list. I love that Cold Sassy Tree is on here. What a great book, and I don't see it recommended often.Staci
Randy Greenwald
Per #1 – an invisibility cloak could come in useful for a child.Per #17 – does this mean I could learn to love opera?As to beach reading: if I go to the beach, it is with an eight year old, who is not content unless his dad is in the water with him. Beach reading is an illusion.Further, to those up north who romanticize such things – here in Florida the beach is hot. My experience of beach reading is sitting on a towel, sweating, feeling sticky and icky. My reading ideal is not the beach. It is in a chair by a large window on a rainy/snowy day.
Staci Thomas
He is one cute kid!
Gail and Keith
Get out of here! George used to play minor league ball! How cool is that! I gotta' talk to him about that! And Colin won a Dusty Baker autographed bat! Did he sleep with it clutched in his arms like Ralphie did with his Red Ryder BB gun? G
Randy Greenwald
Ha! Not quite. But when he showed George, he told him, "Don't drop it." When we got home, he put three pillows together on the couch and laid it on them carefully!
Geoffsnook
Randy,To Kill a Mockingbird wasn't a beach read for me; it was a "boat." I actually read that book on a chartered fishing trip. The fishing was terrible in the morning, so I got most of it done before the fish decided on an afternoon bite. Solid book
Geoffsnook
Wow,Definitely a good week for pastors to see a game, eh?
TulipGirl
Wow! How fun!
TulipGirl
Since I'm constantly around people in their 70s, 80s, and even 90s who are active (though maybe slower) and involved in life — 50 really IS young. And I feel like a babe in the cradle in my mid-30s.
TulipGirl
looking forward to this. . .
Staci Thomas
Beautifully written review, I must say. Relevant. That is the most gorgeous thing about the book. Oh, so very relevant. Glad you enjoyed it as much as I did.
Gus/Adri
We are so glad you finished; it was well worth it. Also glad you are considering a second reading. Agree with Staci re your review. –aeStarted reading four short stories by LT including The death of Ivan Ilich, given to me by David R.-ge
TulipGirl
Love this.
Staci Thomas
A non-Christian friend of ours spotted this article and sent it out as a link to many people. He wasn't sending it out in a positive light, either. Very sad, indeed.
Anonymous
Mr Copeland and his supporters need to read Hebrews 11 and see all the faithful men and women mentioned there, especially towards the end of the chapter. They were mocked, flogged, imprisoned, stoned, sawed in two, destitute, and homeless. That doesn't sound like health and wealth to me. Tom
Rebekah
Nooooo!!! The books I loved so much as a little kid aren't going to be available when I have kids. It sounds weird, but I buy books I liked when I was a kid NOW, so that I'll have them at some point in the future…
TulipGirl
Grrr.
Adria
I agree with you on this dad, and I would really love to know what the bill looks like that is actually being considered.
MagistraCarminum
Randy- not sure the 3-minute piece you linked is what you heard: doesn't seem very illuminating to me. Did you notice the reporter's comment that, "Britain would love to have the cancer cure rate the US has, but not at the cost of dropping in its approval rating (which is 18th in the world compared to 36th for the US)."? I'm sorry. Give me the cancer cure rate, and approval rating be hanged.And I think part of the problem is that the bill as proposed is huge, and in a constant state of flux, and part of what frightens me is that I think it will be like the budget was– pushed through with no time to read it, much less debate it. I find the whole mess rather horrifying.
Randy Greenwald
Chris, you are correct. I linked to the wrong story. Oops. But do remember – my point in the post is not the merits or demerits or wisdom of the program, but the sense that proponents and opponents alike will resort to non-truth in order to win.
MagistraCarminum
Yes, Randy. And that is both sad and disheartening, but true I'm afraid. May we be people of Truth, not politicians for "truth".
MagistraCarminum
It's just a momentary Southern-drawl…Lai-ahs…
Anonymous
The book is a favorite of mine. It evokes both laughter and tears. I love the lessons the children learned from Atticus and Calpurnia on showing respect to all persons. I re-read it recently and I'm certain I'll read again — and again. I've heard of people who read it once a year; not a bad idea.
Rebekah
It's a beautifully written book–the comic elements that the author puts into such tragedy are remarkable. It's such a sad book too–so much hasn't changed. We have too many many that sit in prison for crimes that they likely didn't commit. It's easy to think that a broken justice system is a thing of the past.
Randy Greenwald
A good reminder, Rebekah. Thanks.
Gail and Keith
Ditto, to what everyone else said.Saw the movie long before I read the book and loved both. G
TulipGirl
The first time I reread "…Mockingbird" as an adult, I totally saw my own father in Atticus. A few years later, I read it again and it wasn't quite so pronounced. . .I'm looking forward to reading your comments on Ex Libris, as I've read Fadiman's "The Spirit Catches You and You Fall Down." (And I so regret that title was used for a book on cross-cultural medical and family issues, when it would be perfect for a contemporary history of the Charismatic movement!)
TulipGirl
So, I guess everyone will be there Monday, huh? *grin*
TulipGirl
Oh, just came across some current research on social marketing, specifically in the context of blood donations. And you are a perfect example of their findings. In a nutshell, one of the five recommendations was, "(5) tostimulate word-of-mouth among reference groups using member-get-member programs whereby current donors bring new donors to the system."
Randy Greenwald
Where do you stumble across THAT kind of info??!Barb just pointed out to me that the first Monday of September is Labor Day… I fear the center will be closed…
TulipGirl
I was poking around some scholarly journals, collecting research for a few papers this semester. That one caught my eye. . .Hmm. . . guess we'll have to miss Labor Day — but tomorrow is the last Monday of August! (Unfortunately they don't open until 10am. . . and I have somewhere to be at 11. . . Guess I'll have to miss the Somber&Dull blood party.)
MagistraCarminum
Very wise words, indeed!
Joyce
How true! Children need to know praying is a very good thing!
TulipGirl
My mom has told me just how important prayer is in raising children. I know that, like other gentle words of advice she's given in the past, that I'm acknowledging them and agreeing — but not truly understanding. . . I have a feeling that as the years go on, I'll pray more and understand more.One thing that I am oh-so-thankful for is knowing how my paternal grandmother prayed for each of her children and grandchildren every day. Faithfully. And I can see the fruit. . . even though many of us are still struggling, still finding our way in faith.It has been an illustration to me of the covenant family. . .
TulipGirl
You mac people. . . *eyeball roll*
TulipGirl
(I bet you and Mr. Derr will be all geeky about it this Sunday, too. . .)
Randy Greenwald
I, for one, will behave myself. I really don't like to make a big deal about owning the greatest operating system in the world….wink, wink
Gus/Adri
does snow leopard speed up things as they claim?gus
Randy Greenwald
Doesn't matter, Gus. I'm a member of the cult and I've GOT to have it. It's not been delivered yet… I'll let you know later.
Randy Greenwald
Good news! The Lakewood Ranch blood center IS open on Labor Day, 1000 to 630. I'll probably be there sometime between 1230 and 130…
MagistraCarminum
One of my favorite book quotes: "She herself was a victim of that lust for books which rages in the breast like a demon, and which cannot be stilled save by the frequent and plentiful acquisition of books. This passion is more common, and more powerful, than most people suppose." -Robertson Davies, _Tempest-Tost_
Gus/Adri
Is Ex Libris now on your lending library shelf? It sounds like one I'd like to peruse.–ae
Randy Greenwald
I had somewhat tamed the beast – telling myself NOT to buy books that I had no realistic intention to read. I would put books in my Amazon wish list or shopping cart until the impulse waned. Reading Fadiman has destroyed that self control. Went to a used book store yesterday and walked out with three books I don't have time to read. (But, I only spent $8!)
Randy Greenwald
ae – You'd love to peruse it. It is, alas, not mine. I had it in hand last night as I was leaving Chick-fil-a with the boys, and there was Staci in the drive-thru. She has now inherited the book. I'm sure upon gentle request she'd be happy to let you peruse it!
Gus/Adri
LOL!–ae
MagistraCarminum
LOL! I think Brothers K is a bit ambitious, even for Colin! 😉
Rebekah
Cute!I've read every Hardy Boy's book, and the B'bill siblings even set out to write our own Hardy Boy's book–we had two different drafts in progress at one point. They are terrific, and every child needs to read them!
Randy Greenwald
Great! So now that you are done with the Brothers Hardy, are you game for the Brothers Karamazov?!
Staci Thomas
Furthermore, if you did have an iPhone and if you were in Ohio this week you would join my husband in wanting to put the thing under the wheel of his airplane before it took off. The amount of dropped calls and poor service connections while he is in Ohio is endlessly maddening. While trying to make connection with his client today, it dropped five times. The New York Times describes the problem here:http://www.nytimes.com/2009/09/03/technology/companies/03att.htmlStaci, who uses her iPhone as a laptop and because no one calls her she is oblivious to bad service connections…
Staci Thomas
Hilarious….
Staci Thomas
What a gift…to be free from cooking dinner and receive a book at the same time! I'm almost done with it, Adri. I'll pass it along on Sunday.Staci
TulipGirl
*g*
TulipGirl
Thanks for the review. . . I really like what I've read of Fadiman in the past. And I think I've fallen into the false belief you mentioned — that buying books feels like buying time to read them. . . I guess it is not so.
CindyC
My grandma always said "God helps those who help themselves." I think this means prayer and working diligently at something bear fruit over time. It's the "over time" thing I get hung up on!
Staci Thomas
I completely agree with this. The response by Republicans on this news item is leaning toward the ridiculous. The five of us will be watching on Tuesday as well. My children can certainly benefit from someone as important as the President of this great nation telling them that their education is important. And if we sense a hidden agenda in the speech, well, we'll try to figure out what it is and craft an articulate response. Staci
Randy Greenwald
Leaning? You are more gracious than I.
MagistraCarminum
The only reason not to jump ship is so you can vote in primaries…unless you live in a state where anyone can vote in primaries. Here in NM, you have to belong to a party, and then vote in the primaries for that party. The Republicans are not a group I care to defend. But often, the individuals are still my best choice.You might be intrigued (as I am) by the writings of Stanley Fish. I agree with him up to a point…and then mostly end up disagreeing with him because of his naivete concerning indoctrination… but his thoughts about education are provocative:http://tinyurl.com/5mpvb4
Randy Greenwald
How fortunate to have had a Grandma whose words you can remember. I'd take that a step further – that God helps those who are helpless. That is why prayer is so necessary.
Randy Greenwald
Yes, if you can find the place where I can buy a side order of time, do let me know!
Randy Greenwald
And, Staci – you didn't know that Chick-fil-A had such broad services, did you!
Matthew
The only question I have is why does this speech have to be given while these children are at school? Why couldn't he give the speech in the evening when parents could decide if they wanted their children to watch. I think what concerns most people is the fact that this is unprecedented. Independents are not only irrelevant they are normally further the extremes of left and right.P.S. I can't stand when people call the President a socialist. It makes conservatives sound horrible.
Randy Greenwald
Chris, it is with an eye to the primaries that I've stayed in so long. But I'm beginning to question the strength of that argument.And, Matthew, I can't figure out why anyone would have a problem with the sitting president speaking to school children. I believe on 9/11/01 President Bush was doing so personally at an elementary school here in Sarasota. The only thing unprecedented is the technology.Anyway, thanks for the comments, all.
Gail and Keith
People calling Obama's agenda Socialist shows that they do not understand what Socialism is. Okay, okay, I don't either, but the agenda Obama is pushing is not Socialist. I'll leave it to others to explain in short detail what it is and isn't.G
TulipGirl
I've heard lots of good things about dropbox. . . but haven't tried it yet.
Gus/Adri
I can see the utility for you who have several computers including your family. I can only see a possible benefit to substitute dropbox for my backup hard drive.gus
Randy Greenwald
Suppose you wanted to share a large file with a son in Europe? That's the usefulness.
Rebekah
I do need to crack the Brothers Karamazov!
Randy Greenwald
You and Colin can read it together – though he's pretty much hangin' with 'Hank the Cowdog' these days.
Seth
The passion and relevance of the speakers at TED conferences are one of the things that keeps me going back to them. They are able to paint a world where all things are interconnected, where everything matters to everything else. Although few would likely say it, I think that they are all yearning for heaven, a place without brokenness, a place where we can learn and strive and grow without ridicule or fear.
Matthew
I think the only problem I really had was the material that was sent to teachers before his speech. One of the things that they were supposed to have the children do is to "Write a letter to yourself how you can help President Obama" Yes you need to lend a sitting president support but isn't he here for us? Not the other way around?P.s. The white house revised the wording later but originally this that is what it said
The Domestic Intellectual
I just finished "reading" an audio version of Brothers K. I find the Russian names with their diminutives to be confusing so I have turned to the audio novel and enjoy that a lot more! Next on the list is Crime and Punishment.
Randy Greenwald
The Russian names don't get any easier in C and P. For C and P I recommend writing a chart listing a character's first name, nick name, and patronymic (last name), the page first mentioned, and a word or two about him or her. This is the way I kept everything straight! For a relatively small book, there are a ton of characters. I think it's worth the investment. Let me know what you think.
MagistraCarminum
My first thought is that if we were all Jesus, with his level of access to the hearts of others and his understanding of the Scriptures, church discipline would be much easier… :-PIt is messy and painful, and rarely clear-cut. When a public sin is obvious, the elders have no choice but to try and deal with it, or they neglect their God-given duties. However, don't you think most of the good work of church discipline should come from our bumping up against one another in our daily lives, challenging and encouraging each other to live more consistent, Christ-centered lives? This is the "informal" aspect of discipline, when one believer comes alongside another and says, in real love, "I see this is difficult for you. Let me help…" That is a beautiful thing.Now, I am one of those people who have what some have said is the "gift of exhortation". That means I am bossy, and articulate about it. My tongue gets me into too much trouble, and I need to take more care with my readiness to be "helpful" to others. I have learned that because my brethren have loved me despite my trying to 'fix" them. They have been brave enough to tell me the truth, and they have been a vital part of my life, so they have earned the right to do so. And I am so glad they have "disciplined" me in this way!
Gus/Adri
I agree that believers can and should exercise discipline on each other (gently). In the case of Judas, he was predestined to do what he did in the end. As in Joseph's case evil intents are turned around for good. We don't have that eternity point of view, so we–the church–have to act in the face of notorious behavior as in the Corinthian church.G
Cindy Marsch
Thank you for this post, shared through a friend and from another friend. I thought SOME of us should comment on it since so many are reading and appreciating it! 😉
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, Cindy. Very kind of you to break the silence!
christine
the phrase about being aware of the glasses they wear… appreciating your perspective on differing perspectives.
MagistraCarminum
Excellent thoughts, Randy! It seems to me that preaching, like mother/fatherhood, teaching, etc., is a calling which demands our faithfulness to the task as an obedience to God. Somehow we are to content ourselves with being obedient and faithful, even when no one is listening. I once heard faithful missionaries say just this thing after 20 or so years in Senegal had gained only one convert. I have always felt that if he could say that, I ought to be able to as well.
Randy Greenwald
Absolutely, Chris, bumping around is the best form of church discipline. That is what the bulk of the NT language encourages. It is the best corrective to sin.And formal discipline only exists for lack of repentance, does it not? Egregious sin does not lead to painful discipline if there is repentance.And, Gus, if we wanted to argue the point, we could play the predestined card on any situation, couldn't we? I'm not sure we can plead that Jesus did not come down hard on Judas because of predestination. And I'm not sure that the situations which we think demand discipline are so clear cut. I'm not sure we have thought as carefully about it all as we should. Covetousness, greed, pride, racism, anger, harshness and the like can be pretty serious sin, but we lay it all out for sexual sin. Why the distinction?I posted this only to consider the fact that perhaps there are times that we do not pull the trigger on discipline, and that in waiting, we are not necessarily neglecting our duty.
TulipGirl
Loaded, aimed, fired. . .
TulipGirl
It's been interesting to learn more tidbits of immigration history in the US from Hubby and his studies. . . Interesting to see the differences between times when the patterns were come to the US, work, return home, repeat. . . and the times when it has been flee the home country, assimilate, settle. Interesting to see the push/pull factors in immigration, the impact over generations. . . But like you said, these are theoretical ideas explaining what we see — and sometimes looking at these the individuals involved area lost.
Randy Greenwald
Absolutely, the debate about immigration is a thorny one. But while the debate is going on, there are people who are living their lives. And stories arise there. The political implications of the movie are there, but subtle, and do not get in the way of the story of a boy and a mom wanting to reconnect, and the sacrifice that allows them to do so. Thanks.
Elsa
I don't suppose you'll be passing through Indiana on the way back? Ben and I would love to see you. Plus there are some great used bookstores here!
Gail and Keith
What an interesting journey to date! Keep us posted as you have time. There go your triglycerides with that Westside Monte Cristo deep fried grilled cheese! 🙂 But, I'm sure your many miles of hiking here and there will work that off in no time. Give our love to your various kids along the way. G
MagistraCarminum
You would enjoy a stop in Bloomington… So would I! But we are getting a visit from dil#1's dad this evening, which will have to do. Sounds like a great trip so far… but you didn't tell us which book was being sought and if you found it. Bilbiophiles want to know…
TulipGirl
Ahhhh. . . I was wondering why the quiet here. . .And now curious about the 3 ft stack of books you and your crew have.
Randy Greenwald
How much fun would that be, to pass through Bloomington. However, the trip is already clearly mapped out. No opportunity to check out those stores, or your hospitality this trip. Thanks, though!And, yes, I think the fat content of my bloodstream did shoot up. I've got seven weeks until my next cholesterol test, so, there's time.And the three foot stack of books:for Colin – something like two dozen old issues of Astronomy magazine, a book on 'dragonology', and two Hardy Boys books.for Barb – Michael Connelly, Lost Light, The Narrows, The Overlook, and The ClosersJames Patterson, Cross, and Double CrossJonathan Kellerman, The Conspiracy ClubMichael Crichton, Airframe, Rising Sun, and Disclosurefor Randy – CS Lewis, Surprised by Joy and Till We Have FacesDan Allender, To Be ToldNT Wright, Surprised by HopeBarbara Tuchman, A Distant MirrorJoseph Machelli, The Starbucks Experiencefor Barb and Randy – Cormac McCarthy, The Road (Barb and I want to read it again; read a library copy the first time)James McBride, The Color of WaterP D James, A Mind to MurderThere. That about does it!And like I've mentioned before, to buy a book is to assume one is buying the time to read the book. Hah! Good thing, I suppose, this store is not near us!
Gus/Adri
Re Half price books in Bradenton – Sarasota: If you build it [they] will come.Re PDJames – really enjoy her writing; not certain I've read the one you bought. If you've not read her before, you are in for a treat.–ae
MagistraCarminum
This is yet another thing which proves that you and Dave were twins separated at birth.
MagistraCarminum
I'm impressed with your diligence. When I leave on vacation on Thursday, I will likely not post a thing for 10 days…
Anonymous
Our tax dollars at work. -:)
TulipGirl
Did Hubby ever tell you my philosophical musings on anarchy and speed limits?
TulipGirl
Yup. . . I've been there. Figured if anything REALLY important were to happen, a real, live person would tell me.Actually I was in that type of news bubble on 9/11. . . Just so happened we were somewhere with the news on, so we saw it from almost the beginning. . . saw the second plane hit.And my news bubble actually had me doubting it was really happening at first. Thought it was some sort of complex promotional for a new disaster movie.Sadly, I was wrong.
TulipGirl
What about your Starbucks card — don't you get a free hour a day? Or. . . no Sbux where you are? I shudder at the thought of paying for wireless access. (Well, ironically, except at home. . .)
TulipGirl
LOLOL!
TulipGirl
"And like I've mentioned before, to buy a book is to assume one is buying the time to read the book."That idea has stuck with me. . . And it really is part of my book-buying assumptions. . .Hopefully the hours on the road and time away from the usual routine will give plenty of time to indulge in reading that stack!
Gail and Keith
Right on all counts on the news. The Country continues in its mess here and abroad. On another note, Jeremy was given tickets to a Cubs game tonight, a reward for helping someone move. Temps to be 48-51 degrees and winds out of the north. He's wearing his winter, winter coat.G
Randy Greenwald
TG – we were in Caro, MI, population 22. No SBX. I'm exaggerating about the size, but it is not the kind of place SBX puts in a store.And, MC, you are obviously not COMPULSIVE about posting as I am!
Randy Greenwald
No, Hubby has never said a word. I'd love to hear. However, I have some thoughts to post on this next opportunity I get. There is a lesson to learn about the value of law and the misuse of law. When the a governing body legislates absurdity, there is a democratic drive if not responsibility to buck it.
Randy Greenwald
And the Reds host the Cardinals here tonight, with temps in the same range. I'd still love to go, but can't. Hope he has a great time!
Gail and Keith
That, is an awesome quote! The depths that God in His love goes to in order to bring His own to Himself. G
Bill Martin
If you become Under the Speed Limit guy, the State of Florida offers you a complimentary timeshare at a condo on the beach.
Randy Greenwald
Oh, they're all out of those, Bill. They only set aside 1,387,395,007 of those each year per county.
Gail and Keith
Kudos to Barb! Barb fought the law and Barb won! I have my own issues with the County and SWFWMD who seem bound and determined to do everything they can to put the small, honest businessman out of business. But that's a story for another day. G
Gus/Adri
Now we know: You CAN fight City Hall. Way to go, Barb!–ae
TulipGirl
Yay, Barb!
TulipGirl
I'm near tears, reading both articles. . .
Randy Greenwald
Pray for Ivan. He will be out of a job. He has set a new standard for quiet heroism.
Staci Thomas
Wow. Thank you for this!
Gail and Keith
Keith's comment exactly–what about pencils? When my sister was little she got jabbed on the nose near her eye with a pencil which left a tiny graphite dot when somehow a door shut on her and said pencil. I can see the movie now: The pencil wars!G
Adria
Yeah, I got jabbed with a pencil by a "classmate", in my neck, and have a permenant tatoo.
Randy Greenwald
Yes, and the above mentioned Adria was homeschooled. Figure that one out!
MagistraCarminum
This looks great! And you gotta love that Randy Newman score…
Adam Tebrugge
Thank you for your thoughtful comments.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks for reading and commenting.
Gus/Adri
I read the whole article and was overcome by a profound sense of sadness and anger.gus
Randy Greenwald
Here is the reason this matter is in the news, as expressed in the editorial pages of the Dallas newspaper.
Seth
Well, Adria, you should know better than to make me mad!
TheAuthorityFigures
Someone in the family named JLB and RGB recently purchased a 50 inch flat screen TV; bargain price, I understand. G
TulipGirl
That line at Goodwill? Yesterday was the LWR garage sale, too.
Staci Thomas
PLEASE tell me you picked up the book and turned OFF the TV, not just the volume.
TulipGirl
Ooooh! I really want to read that book! (Soon, soon. . .)I've hit upon the sad reality that I just do NOT multitask well at all. My schoolwork has shown that to me in sharp relief.Hubby teases me — after all, women are "supposed" to be better at multitasking. (One of the skills of motherhood?) And yet. . .
Randy Greenwald
Staci, I could lie and said I did the strictly literary thing, but, well, I didn't. Of course, don't you try to read while driving, at stop signs and such? Hmm.And as for multi-tasking, spoke with Tammy yesterday who tells me that every study out there says that it is impossible. Barb's skill is not multitasking, but the ability to concentrate and focus on the thing at hand to the complete exclusion of everything else. That, it would seem to me, is the skill that motherhood demands!But I confess – had it been the Rays playing, the book would have gotten little attention. As it was, the game was an 11-0 blowout, so demanded little from me.
Staci Thomas
Well, it's just that it was a choice between baseball and THAT PARTICULAR book. Not all books should be chosen over baseball. But the one at hand should be ingested at "the complete exclusion of everything else".
Randy Greenwald
So, The Elegance of the Hedgehog trumps the Phillies vs the Dodgers. Would it have trumped VT vs. Georgia Tech? I mean, just how good is it?!
Louis
I have long expressed this same opinion. I just have a very hard time ceding this rather final decision to the hands of government. God is sovereign over all, but we bear responsibility to act responsibly!
Gus/Adri
Now that I know the name of the book in question, I'd say it would trump most anything – but then I'm not a sports nut – er, fanatic. But yes, it's a great story and I hope to read more by this author. –ae
Rebekah
I have found that people find a strong Christian witness palatable if they see it connected to a strong commitment to social involvement. I recently heard example of this at a secular academic environment where a presenter was providing information on church-based economic development. The other participants were receptive to the Christan perspective because the presenter was doing things that were ameliorating suffering in the world.
Randy Greenwald
Church history makes your case, Rebekah. This is why I've been praying for a long time for someone to give HPC leadership in this area. Perhaps others can pray for us as well?
MagistraCarminum
Gee- you mean they'll know we are Christians by our love? What a novel idea…Praying for all of us to take more leadership in relieving suffering…
Gail and Keith
I have to agree with the quote though nearly every one of my siblings and friends own a dearly loved cat who is part of the family. That's fine, as long as said cat stays in their house and not mine!
Gus/Adri
The only cat we ever had was a stray that one of our boys took pity of. After we spent money for sterilization, etc., she eventually went back to her old ways and was never seen again. She was not missed.G
MagistraCarminum
And there are also some excellent sermons here: http://bapca.org/sermons/ AMke sure you check out last week's- it may surprise you!
MagistraCarminum
Oh0 and there is another by him on 5-3-09, that was also very good! 🙂
TulipGirl
Oh, that IS sad.
Gus/Adri
Am glad I read the blog in the original, and therefore full context.Also, her 22 Oct 2009 05:48 pmThe Limits of Presidential Power, brought to mind the civilized politics of the times when I served in the executive branch and were reminded from time to time to abstain from partisan politics in our public personas.Gus
MagistraCarminum
Interesting article, and we enjoyed The Rookie. But thanks for letting me pass on Aerosmith. Just thinking about it brings frightening images of big hair…We have always told our kids to evaluate their gifts and passions as abilities God built into them, and encouraged them to follow after those passions with the belief that God wouldn't have given them those passions and gifts without having a plan for using them. It's easy for youngest son, making his way in the world as an electrical engineer who builds computers on the side. It is and will be a more interesting journey for the elder, a classicist working on his doctorate with little hope of ever making much of a living. But I am excited to see what God will do with him anyway.And as for me, I sometimes wonder if I have lost my dreams, or if my expectations have simply become low enough to meet my reality. Wow. That sounds bitter, and I don't mean it that way… I simply am unsure what to dream about at this point in my life. Is this a mid-life crisis, I wonder? Or maybe just hormones running amok…
Randy Greenwald
Well, then, we've been successful in getting one who may have lost touch with the dreams God gave her to think! So, as Steven Tyler would say…
Val P.
Can I just play Aerosmith and skip the Rookie?Good article. Just had a womens' Bible study this morning where we were encouraging each other that we are never safer when we are in God's hands, so don't be afraid to step out of the comfort zone, love and forgive each other, and shine His light to the world.This would have made a good illustration!
Randy Greenwald
Sure, Val… just make sure you turn it up really, really loud.And yes, the best illustrations always show up the day (or hour) after you need them!
Gus/Adri
And to think: we remember the days when you were a complete TEA-totaler! –ae
Gus/Adri
¡Feliz cumpleaños!, sweet Jerusha!The Espinos
Randy Greenwald
There is a connection between my coffee drinking and the next post – regarding my daughter – which I'll need to share in this space sometime.
Staci Thomas
Love it!!!! Great cake, J's creative mother!
Staci Thomas
Wow. This is one of those times I received MORE than what I asked for. That doesn't happen very often.I still think quarterbacks are, in general, more cheerful than pitchers. I'll be watching the WS and collecting data for statistics.Staci
Randy Greenwald
That's it – watching the World Series is a project of anthropological research. Therefore, the time invested is justified.
TulipGirl
I love the Rudolph's work. . . Hmmm. . . I think I need to drop some hints to Hubby about the need for a new mug for me for Christmas.
Gail and Keith
Happy birthday to Jerusha!"Sunrise, sunset, sunrise,sunset,swiftly fly the years….."When did she get to be a beauty?When did he grow to be so tall?Wasn't it yesterday when they were small?" Fiddler on the Roof. Great cake, great picture of your beautiful daughter #3 G
Gail and Keith
I'm blessed to have several pieces of the Rudolph's artwork. Both artists create unique and one-of-a-kind works of art. Definitely visit their studio. They are gracious people. G
Randy Greenwald
Thanks for the lines, Gail. It was yesterday. I'm astounded.
MagistraCarminum
Thanks, Randy. Excellent interview!
The Domestic Intellectual
Thanks so much for sharing this. I've read a bit about him in the last few months that was very encouraging. I first "met" Medea when I made a campus visit to Berea in 2003 and thought she was hilarious! But then, I come from a background of large, dominant women, so she made sense to me.
Randy Greenwald
Something about the phrase 'large, dominant women' makes me smile and chuckle. Being 'large' and 'dominant' is not what makes Madea appealing, however. I think it is rather the fact that those around her know that she really cares for them. What do you think her appeal is?
Gail and Keith
Tyler Perry's movies not only portray redemption, but also the need to forgive, not only for the sake of the person asking for forgiveness, (and even when they don't) but also for the sake of the person doing the forgiving. Forgiving brings freedom to the forgiver. Madea is irreverent, but also provides comic relief in the very heavy themes that Perry brings to the screen. Madea has a caring heart though her methods are often unorthodox. I love every single one of Perry's movies and they are on my "wish list" formy very small DVD library. Those movies were what got me through a very severe week of anxiety attacks. I laughed, was sad, angry at the evilness of characters portrayed, but also rejoicing at the redemptive story. G
Randy Greenwald
God uses art for redemptive purposes – not just sermons. Pretty cool testimony, Gail.
Staci Thomas
This. is. a. very. very. very. good. post. Thank you for it. What a helpful (and no calorie) Halloween treat.Staci
Gail and Keith
Yes, evil comes from the heart. I find Halloween troublesome and as G. said in his post, condemnation should not come down on either party, the participators nor the non-participators. Maybe some day a discussion could be done on the difference between celebrating Halloween/All Hallows Eve, (I know the origins of both) and Christmas which we Christians centuries ago began celebrating at the same time as the pagan Saturnalia. Maybe I should find Saturnalia/Christmas troubling. G
Gail and Keith
I should have said, "I know the difference between All Hallows Eve and All Saint's Day. G
TulipGirl
"I am more afraid of my own heart than of the pope and all his cardinals. I have within me the great pope, Self." — Martin Luther
TulipGirl
You know, sometimes I wish there was a "thumbs up" icon to click on blog posts like there is on facebook. I don't have anything to say, really — just, I liked reading this post. (And liked reading that my pastor is intentional in prioritizing his time.)
Randy Greenwald
Being intentional and successful are not the same thing!
Rebekah
"…we cannot manage time. We are only given a set amount of it and we don’t control it." So true that is in my life…!
Gus/Adri
Ooohh! It hurts when the kids know more than you do! Get used to it; it will probably happen repeatedly from now on. But as long as he still thinks you're a great dad….;)–ae
Val P.
Yes, they added an ocean and subtracted a planet to even it out. Of course, when I was taking world geography, Asia had 4 or 5 countries and Africa had 13. Just glad I'm not having to sit in geography classes today.WAY too many countries and capitals to memorize!
Gus/Adri
I know; they made a new ocean to keep the three big oceans from fighting about their longitudinal boundaries!ge
Rebekah
aaaah well, one day, the curse will be rolled back and thorns will no more infest the ground! guess these are signs of the already-not-yet conundrum…
Randy Greenwald
The Great Sports Theologian could not have put it better himself!
MagistraCarminum
Praying for your neice and her husband. That was one of the first things that occurred to me when I heard about this yesterday. Going to read the Fallows article now.
Randy Greenwald
Chris,I'm sure that my niece and her now 'ex-' husband would appreciate your prayers, but neither are anywhere near Ft. Hood anymore. No, I'm referring to someone else!
MagistraCarminum
Question: is grace the same thing as condoning sin? We are told to give the grace that we have received, but that we are not to condone sin in our midst. There must be a way for us to do both of those things if God's word directs us to do both. I think we tend to see these as contradictory, when in reality they ought o be complimentary.
MagistraCarminum
Yikes- sorry to be so far behind the times. I'll pray for whomever you know there.
Randy Greenwald
Perhaps it would help you to divide the question and define some terms.1. How do we as church members NOT condone sin? What behaviors do we engage in which prove that we are NOT condoning sin? If gay man attends our church, hears our preaching, shares a meal with us, are we by loving him 'condoning sin' or showing him the same love that Jesus shows us? If we are to NOT condone sin, are we supposed to tell him that he is a sinner? My question is this: when did that become our job?2. Who is the 'we' in your comment? There is a role for the officers of a church to exercise discipline over the church's members, so that in that we are not condoning sin. But does this job/right/responsibility belong to individual Christians? How quick do think Jesus was to pull the trigger of sin and condemnation on all these sinners and tax collectors who loved to be with him?
Gail and Keith
I see your points. We show love and grace toward believers and non-believers. A friend who is now walking with the Lord had for some time been engaging in a lifestyle not consistent with how one who names the name of Christ should walk. Yet, during this time his church leader held him accountable. He was a member of the worship team. Had he been thrown out, one wonders where he would be today. I am so thankful for the wisdom of this pastor.At the same time, I think of the Half-Way Covenant the Puritans (now Congregational) practiced in the 1800's, allowing non-believing spouses, and family members of believing members to join the church, but not fully partake in the sacraments, i.e. communion. Over time the church became diluted and left its first love. There is a fine line to walk between the Scriptural command for grace and adherence to the commands of Scripture to purity. I suppose I'm talking two different issues here: those who are members and those who are not, but seeking. G
Randy Greenwald
Worthy reflections, Gail. And yes, there is a distinction between church membership and not. But I would add that there is a distinction to be made between the role of officers and the role of members in dealing even with a member who is evidencing public sin. And part of the problem, of course, of the 'half way' covenant, if I remember correctly, is the blurring of the distinction between church and state. To vote, you had to be a member of a church. That's a whole 'nother thing!
MagistraCarminum
My quick response:1. We as members of the body of Christ must resist condoning sin. In the example you give of a gay man coming to church, yes, we are to love him, to be hospitable, to befriend. But when he asks, "Why aren't there more gay people here?" we need to answer honestly that he is choosing to sin in that area of his life. Or, more likely, if asked what we believe concerning gay rights, we have to speak the truth in love. That is different from exercising a Pharisaical or judgmental spirit, though of course, some may do those very same things from a judgmental spirit.2. The above is what I mean by the "we" of church members. Elders must preach the truth and exercise discipline among members.Personal story: in the midst of a tough time for us several years ago, a beloved relative sent me a registered letter, telling me that she was a lesbian, and she knew that I would hate her for it. She said she didn't want any of my "bible crap", and that if I wanted to continue a dialogue with her, I would have to contact her. She broke my heart by flaunting her rebellion towards God in this way, and by putting me on the spot. After praying about it, Dave and I sent a registered letter back to her the very next day. We told her we were not interested in a dialogue with her, we were interested in a relationship with her because we loved her. We explained to her that Christ's love for us requires us to love others who are sinners just like we were. We also explained to her that she would have to be willing to accept our love without being given our blessing, because our loyalty to Christ demanded that we could not condone her choices. I figured that may end her side of the relationship. However, within a half hour of receiving that letter, we received a call from her, and she was very grateful for both our love and our honesty. And our relationship continues to this day. I don't always put my money where my mouth is, but that time I believe I did. And I think that's how we love and build relationships with people without condoning their sin by either the implicit approval of silence, or by confusing our duty to love sinners with our obligation to see sin clearly.Well, maybe that wasn't so quick after all.If I see someone heading to sin, and fail to warn them, their blood is on my head. Isn't that biblical?
Gail and Keith
I totally agree that the role of disciplining falls to the officers of the church. It's not in the Flocks job description. G
Randy Greenwald
Quick, honestly quick, response:The relationship with your friend predated and underscored your honesty. Love comes first. Then honesty. But it takes time to build the love.
MagistraCarminum
Amen.
TulipGirl
Trix are for kids.
TulipGirl
The question was written: "Is it possible for us in the church to show too much grace to unbelievers?"The first thought it provoked for me was the corollary: "Is it possible for us in the church to show too much grace to believers?Gail alluded to this with the comment, "We show love and grace toward believers and non-believers. A friend who is now walking with the Lord had for some time. . ."How often is it easier to show grace to "sinners" outside the church and harder to do so to sinners within the church.To me, it seems the only danger of "too much grace" is when we are excusing away sin in our own lives instead of (by the Holy Spirit) recognizing that it really is SIN in our lives and we are in great need of "too much grace" from God.
Randy Greenwald
TG, your comments are so insightful. Thanks.To all, I think it interesting, and my original post somewhat set it up this way, that we do as well tend to focus on setting our sights on certain behaviors we determine are sinful – sexual behaviors, in particular. If we are not to condone sin, are we to call people out on greed, idolatry, anger, anxiety, pride, covetousness, and the like? When do we become such an oppressive society that none but the neurotic want to be among us?None of us want to treat sin lightly. There is a time and a place for people to point it out in my life, and that is an act of love on their part, and I am better because of it. But generally, our conscience is sufficient to expose our sin. What we need the church for is to demonstrate gospel love to us, and to in that point us to Christ.That is what I'm grasping after here.
Rebekah
We need a group picture of the family enjoying Trix together.
Randy Greenwald
Not gonna happen. That would require sharing.
MagistraCarminum
LOL! You've got me there! 🙂
TulipGirl
Hunh. Hadn't seen this before. Hubby tends to favor your style. Punctuation outside of quotation marks drives me nuts. Ah, well. Always good to know when there is a method to madness.
Randy Greenwald
Yes, there is method. But there is madness, too. And, for me, a ton of inconsistency. Sigh.
Gus/Adri
At first I thought it could mean that you should not expect to eat any of the food on the shelves — but then, there is no food on the shelves.So maybe it means buyer/owner is only to refer to it to make sure his fridge interior looks exactly the same; also that he not allow his children to use markers, crayons, paint… to color in the spaces. Or especially not to draw pictures of food on the shelves. That's my best guess. But will add: I'm always amused by recipes for dips/spreads that include chips/crackers in the ingredients list and then the instructions say, "mix everything together except chips/crackers…" :-)–ae
Gropius
One day, bloggers will rule the world & will have the ability to control all illustrations on boxes. I'm surprised this box didn't include a disclaimer "not for human consumption."
The Domestic Intellectual
I've always loved short stories, and when I was studying creative writing I was pretty sure that it was the only fiction genre that I could ever write for 🙂
Randy Greenwald
Great! Can't wait to see your collection of stories published!
MagistraCarminum
It is a strange but brilliant story. Did my DIL or son send you to it? It is one of their favorites, and they insisted I read it on my last visit to their house 🙂
Randy Greenwald
That would be the DIL!
The Domestic Intellectual
Just picked up a copy from the library yesterday and started it on the train home. I have enjoyed it thus far and find her a very engaging writer. Looking forward to how it all unfolds.
Gus/Adri
I also loved the book. –ae
TulipGirl
Oh, I must, must read this.
Staci Thomas
Gourmet Rhapsody, which is her next book, is outstanding as well. Her ability to put words together is astounding.Staci
MagistraCarminum
Oh, I don't know about this only being funny to three of you. There are a couple of people in my family who could have HAD this conversation… LOL!
TulipGirl
*groan*
Randy Greenwald
Yes, TG – we are three groan men.
Randy Greenwald
Oh, and to bring this full circle, the 'poster' known as 'MagistraCarminum' has a husband named 'Dave'. (See body of the post.)
Seth
This post may be coming a little late (haven't read you blog in a while, sorry Dad…), but there is another quote that I think is pertinent."nothing unifies like a common enemy and we’ve got one, sure as hell he may be living in your house he may be raising up your kids he may be sleeping with your wife oh no, he may not look like you think"– Derek Webb
Seth
I would have added some comment about onions, but that would have layered it on pretty thick…
Kyle
Excellent! Thanks for the reminder of the false dichotomy, friend. Sure would be nice to be able to drive down and grab lunch, or a cup of coffee. Maybe Nashville?
Randy Greenwald
Lunch would be nice. But I wasn't the one who moved 1000 miles away! GA has been off the radar screen for some time for $$ reasons. Someday, brother. Someday.
Staci Thomas
My mom has raved about this book for years. She keeps encouraging me to read it. It is going to the top of the list now.Staci
Gus/Adri
Thank you for the reminder; I read the book some years ago but had forgotten much about it.This quotation from novelist William Styron (1925-2006) seems fitting: "A great book should leave you with many experiences, and slightly exhausted at the end. You live several lives while reading it."–ae
TulipGirl
Your posts have been missed. . .
Gus/Adri
I lov-a da coffee hubby just brought me, first of the morning. And neither of us is Italian/New Yorker.We'll have to try this new place; thanks for the review.–ae
Randy Greenwald
Ah, now maybe I understand the name!
TulipGirl
Will have to check it out. . . I know ThinkTank has been considering a new venue due to space/noise considerations.I'm interested in hearing what people think about this: "This, then, is the secret of 'buzz': replant, relocate, rename, remake yourself, and do it with a deep commitment to quality. Of course, what is 'buzz' other than friends inviting friends."The "fun" part of my job includes some of the internal marketing strategies where I work… As you alluded to, the "buzz" that gets one person to recommend us to a friend. Much of that is linked with what is considered either good customer service or "relationship building." For me, I do genuinely care about the sweet or quirky people with whom we do business. (But I still smile and remember to call by name the ones I wish would leave and never return… *blush*)
TulipGirl
This is where I want to go with Hubby for our Friday afternoon datelet.
Randy Greenwald
After which, of course, a cup of coffee at Lov A Da Coffee…
Randy Greenwald
That service, using a name, remembering, all of that is a part of what has made SBX standout.I think this place might have some merit as a venue. Check it out… but perhaps check it out on a Wednesday night! I'd be happy to be sent on a reconnaissance mission…
Gropius
Wow, that's very cool. I haven't seen the robins yet this season & live in Bradenton as well. Hope they'll visit my backyard soon.
Randy Greenwald
I actually rarely see them – it was a treat.
TulipGirl
We missed it. *pout*
TulipGirl
Hubby checked it out today — heard he ran into you! *L* Sounds like you have a new "office."
Randy Greenwald
One to add to the list!
Gus/Adri
It's on our list also. My SIL reported seeing it and how good it is. WORLD had a good report on the family's story itself, as well as favorable report on the movie.–ae
Gail and Keith
Saw it. Liked it. Recommend it. G
David
Randy, we watched a movie that touches on a similar topic that I think you would like. It is called Vitus. He is a child who is very gifted and his parents try to push him too hard. The outcome is quite interesting. I highly recommend it. Dave
Gus/Adri
"All's well that ends well."The E's
Gus/Adri
Did ADD exist in the medical diagnosis list in those days? I thought ADD was the diagnosis du jour, almost like a badge of honor. -ge
Randy Greenwald
ge – your tone suggests that it is not real. Do I hear you correctly?
Gail and Keith
Excellent points. The same can be said concerning the ethnic/racial jokes that abound. G
Gail and Keith
Oh, it is real. Ask the ADD person who must learn to live and function in a mostly non-ADD world. They travel to the beat of a different drummer. They're not wrong. Reminds me of that old hippie phrase from the 70's "what's normal?" G
TulipGirl
I know a grandparent who was dx'd in her 50s with ADHD. Even having the skills to cope and process, have the diagnosis meant a LOT. . . It helped make sense of many situations from growing up, including the complicated relationship with her father. So. . . sometimes there is a benefit to a diagnosis, even when a person is functioning fine. Though it seems neurotypical is the rarity these days, and various thinking / processing atypicalities are the norm.
TulipGirl
Lov A-da Coffee finished setting up their networking room today in time for ThinkTank to meet. . . and it was a unanimous decision to meet there in the future. Thanks for letting us know about it!
Jeremy
Ha! That's fascinating…. I think it illustrates very well why philosophers should keep their hands off of language! I suppose, if you wanted to follow the spirit of E-Prime, your last sentence should be something like, "It continues to exert a classic influence." This doesn't make any attribution of immutability…. However, I think this point highlights one of the conceptual problems of E-Prime, which the article alludes to, but I think is actually quite insurmountable: what E-Prime really has a problem with is predication in general. How can you assert something about something without implying that the assertion has lasting validity or immutability? This runs through the entire structure of language, and is not conveyed simply through words like "to be" or even "seem" or "appear." For instance, in the sentence above, "It continues to assert a lasting influence," most of the sentence is quite semantically vacuous, except for the adjective "classic," which implies a condition that semanticists, I think, would have to take issue with. So that's why I say, those people are weirdos who should go live with other weirdos and talk however they want to, and leave the rest of us alone 🙂
Randy Greenwald
You're a hoot, Jeremy! I'd hate to encounter you in serious debate on the opposing side! But you know, we are both weirdos of a sort in the fact that we even read the article to begin with….I think the e-prime idea is a fun thing, like a math problem, which means nothing in the real world. You express philosophically what good writers know to be true from the get-go. Rule #17, is it, of Professor Strunk: "Omit needless words." E-prime, of course, is a help with rule #11: "The active voice is to be used." Oops. Use the active voice.
Val P.
Actually, though the author claims to have used E-Prime throughout the article, he uses "will" and "I'll" which is the future tense of the verb "to be".It is classic? The article exudes its own temporal continuity.Language is, and has always been a living thing. (There, that should have E-Primers rolling their eyes.) The whole thing reminds me that the fictional Klingon language was originally conceived (prior to E-prime's ascendance) as a language which had no verb "to be". Then in one of the movies, the main Klingon character has to recite Hamlet's "To be or not to be" speech in Klingon and the whole language got a philosophical update.When I was in High School, we were actually taught to use passive voice. Now it's an error caught even by word processors.Pity the poor English teachers.On the other hand, God comes declaring that foremost among living beings, He himself is the great "I am." Reason enough to keep the verb of existence around for a while yet.
Gus/Adri
It shows exceptional quality as an example.-ge
TulipGirl
And. . . what inspired this experiment?
Randy Greenwald
Might 'curiosity' be a sufficient answer?
Elsa
To cut down on waste, I always save my bacon grease. It works great for stir-fry, fried rice, and (of course) eggs.With Ben in the house, cutting back on bacon-purchasing is unrealistic.
Gus/Adri
Were you trying to find out how much saturated fat you eliminated?The grinch ge
Staci Thomas
You need this book: A Thoroughly Painless Guide to the Best of the Bard: The Friendly Shakespeare by Norrie Epstein. I adore, adore, adore this book. If you'd like to check it out before you order, let me know.
Randy Greenwald
Ah, there is something so wrong with this picture. The engineer from the Virginia Polytechnic Institute giving suggestions regarding Shakespeare to the 'English' major from Michigan State University. No need to see it. Your recommendation is sufficient. Ordered.Anyone else?
Staci Thomas
The suggestion stems from the Quartet in C Academy's Continuing Education Program. VPI's English department did not know a whole lot about Shakespeare, trust me.
Bruce
"God chose what is foolish in the world to shame the wise, God chose the weak in the world to shame the strong, God chose what is low and despised in the world, even things that are not, to bring to nothing things that are."
Seth
I really liked it. The story was pretty simple and predictable, but I think it worked well. The CG was not quite "perfectly" photoreal, but it got DARN close! The scenery was absolutely beautiful, and absolutely believable. The humans are evil mentality was a little heavy handed, but to be expected. Overall, I think the simple story was needed to facilitate the featuring of the amazing special effects. It is worth seeing on the big screen. There's my two cents.
Kathryn
I have mixed feelings, on one hand, it was a really pretty movie and the 3D worked, but the story could have been a lot better and more nuanced. In general, I have multiple issues with both the 'noble savages' trope and the 'white man saves the day for indigenous people' trope and both are on display without much subtlety. Not to say that I don't think it was a fairly good movie overall, I just think it could have been a lot better. James Cameron created this fantastic world and then it felt like he threw a bunch of worn out tropes together to create a story because he knew he had to have some kind of plot. If you do see it, definitely see it at Royal Palm on the digital screens,
Randy Greenwald
Thanks K and S. You guys are so good at assessing this stuff. The thing is, what matters to me is the story. I'll take scratchy black 'n' white if the story is good. I have heard from multiple sources that the film is visually stunning, but story is lacking or, as you put it Kathryn, played out along questionable lines. I can't see myself going to see this at the theater… but it sounds like on DVD and my 27" TV it's kinda gonna lose something!Thanks for the report!
TulipGirl
Okay. . . for the first time you have me a wee bit jealous I don't have a mac. And just sorta wanting one (though until now they've just driven me nuts.)
Gail and Keith
Don't try this at home,kids! 🙂 G
Randy Greenwald
All in the interest of science…File it under 'Pastoral Pyromania'.
MagistraCarminum
You really ought to serve a church in Los Alamos. You have a definite case of what we call LAPD: Los Alamos Personality Disorder…
Randy Greenwald
I consider that a compliment.Except for the 'disorder' part of that.And Gail, I don't DARE try this at home myself. I have a wife…
Gus/Adri
I hope "seriously iffy" also applies to the length of the Christmas Eve service. –ae
Randy Greenwald
Service will be no longer than 93 minutes from the time we light our candles. I guarantee it. (Seriously, sixty minutes is tops.)
TulipGirl
"Service will be no longer than 93 minutes from the time we light our candles."*LOL* That settles it. . . we're opting for a shorter service! (Just kidding — though we will be at the IL's church in Venice Thursday night. . .)
Matthew
Dad, This has nothing to do with your blog but I was looking at the picture you have on here of you as a baby and it looks scarily like Isaiah. It also looks like another one of your sons and I don't mean Colin.Matthew
Matthew
Make that two of your Sons and I don't mean Colin.Matthew
Discoshaman
Btw, thanks to you I was dropping knowledge at the ILs Christmas Eve service. They just looked at me weird when I said the candle could burn 93 minutes. . .
Randy Greenwald
Matthew – it's either Photoshop or genetics. You guess! If it's the latter, then you and Isaiah have some worrying to do!
The Domestic Intellectual
Another good "beginner" book on disciplines that is very easy to read and still fruitful and deep is Charles Swindoll's Intimacy with the Almighty. I got it as a gift for my 18th birthday and have read it at least 8 times. At only 80 pages, it is a quick read while still giving you a lot to chew on.
TulipGirl
*L*
TulipGirl
This looks like a great list. . . but, I couldn't find where you posted it on gohope.net ?
Randy Greenwald
Specifically here:http://www.gohope.net/56686However, clicking on the links in the original post will access each of the referenced items.
TulipGirl
Ahhh. . . thanks!
Gus/Adri
Similar messages among family members in places far colder than Bradenton; and some far warmer, e.g. Panama.G and A
TulipGirl
I'm having trouble believing how LONG this cold snap is continuing. *brrrr*Grump.
The Domestic Intellectual
I gave this to my Jon for Christmas 🙂
Staci Thomas
Well done, Randy. Well done.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, Staci. And TDI, it would make a fun book to read together. You might find it to be 'A Book about Us'!
Randy Greenwald
Well, I have no idea what this previous comment says, it being mostly in Chinese characters, but the words which show up with English characters suggest that it is not a comment I would want to keep if I could read it. So, I'm hiding it for now. If the commenter would like to send me an English version, perhaps we would consider keeping it.
Geoffsnook
Randy,I need to get this book. I'm 3/4 finished with the Agassi book. Solid. So this is my next purchase!
TulipGirl
Amazing!
MagistraCarminum
We love that movie 9and the book it came from!) Haven't seen it since we were "chess parents" with our guys playing in tournaments. What fun! I can just picture you and J. playing your blitz game!
Matthew
That's awsome! Did the daughter enjoy it as much as you? Also are you planning on starting at 50 and going down from there? Ps I am offically a subscriber! I feel like I'm spying on your life
Randy Greenwald
Welcome, Spy.You will need to ask the daughter that question. I think she did.
Staci Thomas
Funny, as the only people I know who like this book are in their early 20's. That says SOMETHING, don't you think? As I am nearly 40, I'm just going to stick with Piper and Keller and call it a day. My 92 year old grandfather really likes Tozer. Good to know that, ultimately, we are all reading the same thing.
Randy Greenwald
Says something? about Chan? about the book? about me? about those in their early 20s? Something of all four? Piper, Packer, Keller are oatmeal or meat and potatoes. They stick with you. But sometimes we need a jolt of caffeine to stimulate the meat that these have put on our bones. Chan is the Mountain Dew.
Anonymous
Yes indeed; I also need a broader perspective. The annoying mess yesterday when a small container of spaghetti sauce went SPLAT! on the kitchen floor – and took only a few minutes to clean up – is nothing compared to Haiti. I didn't think of the comparison then, but thank you for bringing it to my mind with this post.
Staci Thomas
I think it says something about the way the generation after me is reading. Your description of Chan asking you to stop and look at a video on the Internet makes me cringe. My 20-something year old cousins who loved the book would not cringe, and in fact, they would go do it. They like to be easily distracted. The times, they are a-changing.Love the Mountain Dew analogy. That little plug just may cause me to pick this thing up.
TulipGirl
Yeah, and twitter is like a million people all speaking fast and nonstop, like my boys.
TulipGirl
*grin*In a couple of years, maybe we could add a little bit of brass to the musical repertoire on Sundays.
Seth
looks like I'm going to have to start calling him "Dizzy".
Randy Greenwald
A bit cheeky, isn't he!And as for adding brass… with a loose definition of 'couple' I could accept that.
Staci Thomas
Bauer tells her juvenile audience in The Story of the Ancient World that Ashurbanipal wanted everyone to remember him because he was afraid they would forget about him. It is for that reason he created such a huge library. I need to go back and look at the section in The History of the Ancient World to see what she says there. Ashurbanipal was no John the Baptist. 🙂
Staci Thomas
Oh, how incredibly adorable. The cheerful nature of the instrument fits his personality!
Gus/Adri
Perhaps a quotation from Louisa May Alcott is fitting here: "She [he] is too fond of books and it has addled her [his] brain." –ae
Randy Greenwald
She makes no commentary in this book about Ashurbanipal's motives. I'm only inferring here that they may have been similar to Gilkey's. Apparently, though, if what you say is true, Stacy, my inference was correct. The books were only a means to an end, and that end in both cases was one of wanting to receive some kind of affirmation from others. Ages pass; people remain the same.
Gus/Adri
I want to start calling him Winton.G
Seth
By the way, dad, can I have 20 bucks?
Randy Greenwald
Sure. Fine with me. Who you going to get it from?
JulianZ
Hi Randy – your wishes (or biggest fears) came through – please check out http://www.churchrater.com.ChurchRater.com is a new website that allows church seekers and members to rate and discuss their experiences at churches all across the country. It is run by a team that counts a former Pastor and a current Duke Divinity student among its ranks. I am curious to hear what you think about the concept and the implementation on ChurchRater.com.
Rebekah
Sometimes when you're disconnected from Biblical literature, you miss it either because you're 1) unaware of it 2) hostile. Doing so you truly do miss the richness of the influence of Scripture in Western thought and culture.
TulipGirl
If you do like Shakespeare (or want to like it more), I have to recommend Lamb's "Tales from Shakespeare."Free text:http://www.mainlesson.com/display.php?author=lamb&book=shakespeare&story=_contentsFree audio:http://librivox.org/tales-from-shakespeare-by-charles-and-mary-lamb/(We claim relation to the Lambs, on my paternal grandmother's side. They were a bit crazy.)Locally, there will be some Shakespeare performances in the next few weeks (again, free!):http://www.ncf.edu/news/?p=3361
Randy Greenwald
Crazy? I'd say so. Mary murdered their mother. Wrote the book while on leave from the asylum…http://randygreenwald.com/2009/05/of-murderous-sisters-and-circadian.htmlThanks for the connections.
Randy Greenwald
And you are related? Yikes!
Anonymous
You jab at others for recommending books which you then MUST purchase/read – or at least add to your list. Yet you are as guilty; I'm beginning to think you are on commission from amazon or BAM. 🙂
Randy Greenwald
For full disclosure, yes, if you click through and buy a book, Amazon gives a pct. to me. I've made like $3 that way. Barb and I are planning a cruise with the proceeds.
MagistraCarminum
LOL! This goes in the annals of great examples of self-deception, my nerdy-geeky friend!
Gus/Adri
If you're "still not sure" – even after consulting your daughters – then how can you have the confidence to categorically state that you are NOT a geek or a nerd?–ae
Randy Greenwald
Uh-oh. You have stuck me in a logical conundrum. Oh dear.
Seth
geek Pronunciation: ˈgēkFunction: noun1 : a carnival performer often billed as a wild man whose act usually includes biting the head off a live chicken or snake2 : a person, often of an intellectual bent, who is disliked3 : an enthusiast or expert especially in a technological field or activitynerd Pronunciation: ˈnərdFunction: noun1 : an unstylish, unattractive, or socially inept person; especially one slavishly devoted to intellectual or academic pursuitsThere. Thanks to Mr. Webster and Mr. Gore, you can now make an informed decision as to your state of geekhood/nerditude. I can safely assume that you do not fit the first definition of geek. I will leave the rest to you.By the way, does the fact that I looked this up make me a geek, or a nerd?
Randy Greenwald
"What's that make you?" says the tree to the apple, lying quite nearby…
TulipGirl
""What's that make you?" says the tree to the apple, lying quite nearby…"LOL!
TulipGirl
Btw. . . this might helphttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N9qYF9DZPdw
Gus/Adri
2 : a person, often of an intellectual bent, who is dislikedThat doesn't apply to the man in question. I refer to the latter part of the definition, not the man's intellect!–ae
Randy Greenwald
Hey TG, Thanks for the video. I'd heard the song, but not seen the video. Got a laugh out of that!Now I want a 'White and Nerdy' sweatshirt.
Randy Greenwald
Oh, yeah…http://www.weirdal.com/w&nhoodie.htm
Elsa
Hmm. I'm pretty sure I didn't recommend that book to you, since I've never read it! I guess I'm assuming I'm the only book-recommending Elsa you know, but I've found that to be a pretty safe assumption thus far.
Randy Greenwald
You are kidding, right?! Oh boy, let the mystery begin…
Elsa
Now, I'm confused, because I DID recommend Sand Mountain. Weird.
Randy Greenwald
Somehow, I linked those two recommendations. But I can find nothing documenting that. Oh, well.
TulipGirl
Ah, now THIS was the title I was trying to remember and couldn't. . . (I bought it from Amazon, used, the older copy. . . They had several under $5.)
Bill Martin
Flannery O'Connor shared the appreciation for the genre (in literature) and took it one redemptive step farther. Very enlightening, Randy.
Bill Martin
His book on Matthew's gospel is one of my favorite. Wish I were a younger man too!
TulipGirl
Ooooh! This looks interesting.
adrianna
Did you know All Over… is also a movie? When I got to the library to pick up the requested item, I learned that by mistake I'd ordered the movie. Left the two volume videos there and will wait for the book.–ae
Randy Greenwald
That's odd… IMDb doesn't show any movie for it. I believe what you must have been handed was the sound recording, probably a box or two full of cassette tapes. Glad, though, to hear you are going to read it. Let me know what you think.
TulipGirl
Creepy.Though, I know there is a significant part of psychology that is focused on studying patient compliance. . . So I'm not surprised.
TulipGirl
PCA still has no logo? Is there a story behind the HPC logo?
Randy Greenwald
Answer to first question: As far as I know, the PCA does not. Particular agencies within the PCA do, but the PCA does not.Answer to second question: Yes, there is. Short form – a committee chose it based upon some submissions from a designer.
MagistraCarminum
This was the tradition in the Iowa of my childhood as well. Not very Southern, but very old-fashioned… and it is a lovely pause of respect.
Staci Thomas
My grandmother died in Georgia four years ago. She lived a few hours north of Valdosta. The drive from the funeral to the cemetery was about 30 miles. The funeral was on a beautiful, sunny Sunday afternoon. The drive from the funeral to the cemetery was on a twisty and hilly, two lane road. Every single car that was in the vicinity of the funeral procession stopped. Every. single. one. It was so incredible. I had never experienced anything like it. It was such a gift on a very sad occasion, for my grandmother's death was painful and difficult. The peace that everyone says accompanies the last moments of death occurred as we saw all of those people stop. It was such a gift and I will never forget it. Those people who stopped had no idea what gift they were giving us.
TulipGirl
Got it in the mail today. . . and this will be my lunchtime reading for now. Thanks for mentioning it in the sermon and here.
UnaCrane
I'd like to say it's me, but I only just found this blog today. On the other hand, I'd like to say it's me, just to tease you.but it's not me.oh well….
Matthew
I am your second son but how is it I do not remember this at all? Well dad you can take comfort in the fact that I am not permanently scarred =)
Randy Greenwald
Go to therapy, Matthew. I'm sure we'll find this somewhere in your psyche.On second thought, don't. Let's just say I made it all up!
TulipGirl
*L*
MagistraCarminum
Beautiful story!
TulipGirl
Wow! How cool! And now I can say, "I knew her when. . ."
Anonymous
you know, it is sort of funny how the publisher remain faithful to jenny's original typo, hipanic society chi
Eva
Thank you, Randy. It is 5:59 AM. I have been up since 4 AM with a toddler who thinks it is entertaining to keep calling out to Mommy and Daddy. Parenting techniques have been on my mind for two hours, and the sun isn't even up yet. As a fairly new parent, I usually don't know if anything I am doing is right. It's encouraging to see a message that confirms our (my husband and my) rejection of certain "biblical" principals. We spank on occasion, but not with a rod–which others have been horrified about, saying we will do lasting damage to our child for using our open palm on her little bottom instead of a spoon, stick, or belt. "The hand is meant for blessing," they say. But I wonder, isn't discipline sometimes, if done in love, a blessing?
Randy Greenwald
Eva, I understand those hours of frustration, especially with an infant. It was at such times that I came to see the fearful darkness of my heart in what I would contemplate doing to get the child to quiet! My hermeneutic problem is with those who insist that 'the rod' in Proverbs MUST mean that we are to use an object like that and 'beat' the child. No… 'rod' here simply means 'discipline'. Yes, we are to discipline – to lovingly train – through means creative and specific to the child and situation. God's discipline throughout scripture was creative, varied, and specific to the situation and person. So must ours be. God does not treat us in a Skinnerian fashion; neither should we treat our children. But, hey, easy for me to say! My youngest is nine and soundly asleep.
Staci Thomas
H.I.L.A.R.I.O.U.S. And impressive.
MagistraCarminum
Laughing about a baseball vid- who would have thought?! Very funny!
David
Randy,I remember a quote from Roger Nicole, professor from Gordon-Conwell, given at a conference in Philadelphia. When asked about his huge library and if he had read all of the books it contained, he replied "Many books are to be referenced not read" (or something to that effect). So I think the tongue in cheek reply to your brother really isn't too far off!
MagistraCarminum
I'm sorry, but i can't look closely at this until I have mine filled out…
TulipGirl
Rumor has it that Hubby will be getting me a Christmas-birthday-going-away gift of a Rudolph mug.
Randy Greenwald
When you get it, make sure you aim carefully when setting it on the table. Remarkable mugs, but they do not remain suspended when their center of gravity is off the edge of the table…
TulipGirl
Packing books tonight and came across that one. In the fall, the boys will probably be studying that time period, so I'm planning on reading this book then. Thanks for the recommendation.
Nathan
You accuse the Pearls as being false teachers for teaching correction through spanking. So I assume you think spanking is wrong?You said, that because of your evil nature, you can't be trusted to discipline your children with the rod as the Bible instructs. Is that your hermeneutic? Ignore the Bible's teaching on child discipline because you are too evil to do it correctly?Maybe you could offer the other verses on child discipline that you follow since you aren't comfortable with Proverbs 13:24; 19:18; 22:15, 23:13-14; 29:15.
Randy Greenwald
Nathan, quickly a few comments:No, I do not think spanking is evil. I do not oppose it. I do think that it is evil when it is tied together with a 'continue spanking them until they reach complete submission' mentality.The hermeneutic error is to assume that the reference to 'rod' in poetic books is to be read as 'corporal punishment' exclusively. The point is that there is to be parental discipline and correction lovingly administered. The paradigm is not to be BF Skinner but God, who disciplines his children in a myriad ways and sometimes even lets them sin and suffer the natural consequences of that sin.
The Domestic Intellectual
thanks for this post. Postman's insights are challenging, but helpful. I am in desperate need of re-evaluating technology and my life, but have been avoiding making the time to think about it.
Nathan
So the whole book of proverbs should be taken figuratively? So, when Solomon says to use the rod, the rod is a figure of speed that means to discipline without using a rod?I don't know who Skinner is, but it seems you are rejecting spanking simply because he taught it.You say we are to reject the literal teaching of Solomon and instead choose to discipline our children in the way we see God discipline his people in the Bible. Would that include giving leprosy to our children, like God did to punish Miriam? Maybe we should inspire bullies to beat up our kids, since God inspired wicked nations to attack Israel.I can't think of any others examples, but I don't recall God ever putting anyone in time-out or taking away their dessert for a week. Maybe you could point me to some specific examples of God's discipline that you think we should follow? So far, you haven't provided any alternative to spanking.
Gus/Adri
Beautiful!the E's
Adria
Thanks Dad!
TulipGirl
That's a great cartoon. . .We've gotten rid of most of our bookshelves, but not all the books are packed yet. So, ummm. . . wow. . . it's like wading through a sea of books.Amazon now has an international Kindle. Yes, I'm tempted. But, I'm also frugal, and hate that you can't buy Kindle books at a used book store for a fraction of the price. . .
TulipGirl
Amazing.
Geoffsnook
Randy,Good reminder. But that won't preach on the Christian channel.
Randy Greenwald
Probably not. Problem is that it doesn't preach in the channel of my own heart as much as it needs to.
Staci Thomas
Outstanding. Stunning. Overwhelming.
MagistraCarminum
Very exciting, but one must wonder if the launch has anything to do with April Fool's day….
Randy Greenwald
April Fool's Day? I thought tomorrow was Maundy Thursday.
Anonymous
Suffice it to say I'm not thrilled with the change. All that bright yellow and green is hard on the eyes. Besides, I happen to know how you feel about those "happy all the day" sentiments. If you immediately change back to your previous title and colors, we can say this was "a one day wonder." Or a good April Fool's joke.
Randy Greenwald
Dear Mr. or Ms. Grumpypants Anonymous:Get sunglasses.Don't worry. Be Happy.Sincerely, The Staff at Happy and Bright
Anonymous
it's April fool's day
Matthew
Wow, I for one love the smilely faces. Dad I think it's fair to say that you are out of control. This is a April fools day joke right?I mean not the green and yellow are not good spring colors and all…Posted from my iPhone so I am not responsable for any spelling or gramatical errors.
Randy Greenwald
Boy. I try to change my image and become more positive, and everyone things I'm joking. I'll need to work harder at this, for sure.
Adria
So… you got me. The first time I read this post, I didn't read through the names of the books, just glanced at them. I thought this was real, until I saw Aunt Chris's post on facebook.
Anonymous
Oooh-h-h! Big sigh of relief this morning at your return to sanity.
Randy Greenwald
Return to PUBLIC sanity is not the same thing as return to REAL sanity. Just warning you…
Anonymous
My guess is Joel Osteen.
Anonymous
Tom Cruise, of course!
Anonymous
Tom Cruise…
Keith
Yeah, Joel Osteen.
Val P.
I just saw this announcement – a bit late, but not too late. Just wanted you to know we'll be praying for both you and Hope during the transition. It's never easy, but we know God will see you and both churches through the process. Hugs – Val P.
MagistraCarminum
Beautifully put, Randy. Thanks for sharing.
TulipGirl
Praying for you and your family, Hope and Covenant, and this time of transition.Grace and hope,TG
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, all.
Keri
Oh…that's gonna be a lot of dough!(you almost had me!)
MagistraCarminum
LOL! LAPD duly confirmed. Not too surprising!
David
Nice experiment, but you failed to put error bars on your measurements. Also, did you calibrate your thermometer before your test? Why the difference in the temperatures at time zero? Did you take the temperature of the mugs before liquid was added; were the mugs preheated? Inquiring LAPD minds want to know!PS skinny is always best!
Randy Greenwald
Error bars: not necessary – I don't make errors.Thermometer was calibrated at factory. However, actual temps were not as important as rate of decline.Each mug was at room temperature when liquid was added. I suppose each would have immediately absorbed an initial amount of heat, depending on the mass of the mug. That is why I started measurements at 1 minute, and then tracked the decline. My deficiencies are duly noted. My LAPD is obviously not sufficiently advanced.
Seth
The question is this: is the rate of decline linearly proportional to the surface area of the hot liquid? While the larger cools faster, does it's drop in temperature slow over time? I would assume that the transfer of heat into the atmosphere would slow as the liquid nears equilibrium. Is the rate ofchange of the rate of change a constant? As we can see from this experiment, LAPD is a genetic trait.
TulipGirl
You crack me up.
Nigel and Cheyenne Rudolph
so, actually, the real test as to the heat retaining qualities of the clay itself would best be determined not by how wide-mouthed or shallow-girthed the mug is, but by the use of several different clay bodies at their vitrified state. one would also need to consider the thickness of both the clay walls as well as the type and thickness of each glaze. of course, each mug would need to be the precise equal (in form) of the others being tested…let me know what you come up with in your second round of testing.
Randy Greenwald
Such testing, of course, cannot begin until I have a whole supply of said mugs from the supplier…
MagistraCarminum
I am so disappointed- we are still hold-outs, and find your change over to the dark side so sad…
Ruth MacC
Hi there,I am from Ireland and I was converted almost nine years ago. I had a 3 yo son and had no idea how to train him up in a way that would please God. I asked my pastor and his wife how they reared their two boys and they gave me good advice. I am very sad to hear of this book and the pain and suffering it seems to have caused….It's good for Christians to comment about what has happened. Well done. Ruth
Gail and Keith
"A rose by any other name would smell as sweet." Write the book. Don't let a name stop you! G
Geoffsnook
I like the J.R.R. better but there is probably only one J.R.R. and that belongs to Tolkien. So I'd come up with another letter.I don't like my initials either as a theologian. So in addition to not being as smart as those guys, my initials preclude me from rising to prominence in the theological realm!
Randy Greenwald
Wait a second, Mr. H. I think "G. C. Henderson" would look right nice on a book spine.And, G, there may be a few other things in the way of that besides the name!
Anonymous
Why ask someone to lend you a J? Just give yourself one, following the example of the parents of our 33rd president who gave their son the letter S.If if was good enough for Harry….
MagistraCarminum
So sorry, Randy! Just what you need. I have had two such friends, unfortunately!
TulipGirl
Oh, dear. So sorry to hear about that. Sigh.
Gus/Adri
Ouch! To the mouth and the pocketbook!The E's
Randy Greenwald
Ah, now you are getting to the source of the REAL pain. The RC is followed by a crown to keep the tooth from cracking further. I think it stems from repeated blows to the jaw from my boxing career.
Anonymous
Root canals aren't so bad. It's his "long"time friends, Mr and Mrs numbing needles that you have to worry about 🙂 Tom
Jenny
My favorite part is introducing these friends to my 7 and 8 year kiddos. James has two crowns (one on his root canal) and Darby is scheduled for an upcoming root canal. Sigh – amen for military dental insurance.
Randy Greenwald
Mr. and Mrs. Numbing needles were so rude to me that it was a pleasure to meet Mr. Root Canal.But I'd never want my kids to meet these guys. Ugh.
TulipGirl
In spite of the pain to the pocketbook, it is healthier (and cheaper) to save the tooth with a root canal and crown than it is to extract and replace with an implant, bridge or partial. (And I still don't floss enough.)
MagistraCarminum
I don't feel your pain exactly, but i can imagine it…And maybe the "awful" AZ law doesn't look as awful to those of us living in the border states, who have talked to ranchers who have thousands (not hundreds) of people pass over their land in a decade, who live in a state where everyone can get driver's licenses, and where police are not allowed to ask for documentation. Our immigration policies stink, and need to be over-hauled. But one can hardly fault people for trying to secure their borders against an onslaught. Ducking now as tomatoes start to fly my way…
Randy Greenwald
Duck away. But some are pretty good aims.We lust for security and stability and safety. I know that. But the dominant power in any culture will not hesitate to assail the rights of any of the powerless in order to gain that. And that is a tendency that we need to stand against.We decry big government when it seems to be set against our own freedoms. But we hail it when it seems to only cause a lack of freedom for others. We should never let our own lust for security be a motive to strip freedom from others. There i no question that the immigration issue needs an overhaul. But to do so in a way that makes someone subject to special attention because of his or her race is a step backwards. And, by the way, don't think that this is written from a racially monolithic place. The predominant language spoken in the Walmart a mile from my home is English, but just barely.So, yes, I think we can fault people if their trying to fix something goes far in the wrong direction.
Ruth MacC
So true…
Gail and Keith
Very well said, The Reverend Mr. Randall Greenwald!
Anonymous
As a Naturalized American Citizen, I must make my comments. We are a nation of immigrants and we have laws governing proper immigration. That is why I SUPPORT THE ARIZONA IMMIGRATION LAW 100%.Are we forgetting that horrible terrorist attack in New York? Our Nation was attacked, we must protect our country! The Home Land Security is responsible for that and be it at the Atlantic border or the Pacific or the Canadian,no person can enter the United States without the proper security clearances and documentations. Are we racial profiling against the Europeans or Asians or Canadians? No! This the law. We always welcome immigrants but not illegal lawbreakers.For some reason this very same law is being ignored on the south border and this puts our security at risk. So the State of Arizona is trying to correct it. More power to them.Paul Der USA Citizen.
adrianna
The part about extinction I remembered from reading to my youngsters years ago. How they laughed! After the book was mentioned in a recent sermon illustration, I decided it was time to reread; got it from the library and found it just as enjoyable the second time around. –ae
Paul Der
With all due respect, the issue here is not our emotional feelings, it is our National Security. Our borders must be secured and the laws concerning immigration must be respected by all. By upholding these laws, this protection is provided on three borders but completely ignored on the Southern Border. This is illegal and threatens our National Security, the laws must be upheld equally for all our borders. This is what Arizona is trying to correct.Paul Der
adrianna
As the mother of only male children, I protest! And where would we older generation folk be if there were no pretty, intelligent, hard-working daughters for our sons to marry?In the land of no grandchildren – that's where!
Randy Greenwald
Your wallet would indeed be lighter – that I give you!
Paul Der
I will be happy to answer your question "who in our day would correspond to the sojourner" in our country? The immigrant! Many years ago we lost our home, our life was in danger,and we had to escape, seek shelter, a new home. And we were accepted and welcomed by the United States of America. Praise the Lord!God's concern for the mistreatment of the Widow (widow and widower) , the Orphan and the Sojourner is spelled out in several places in the Bible and God makes it clear that the condemnation of the wicked will be severe. A specific example would be Matthew 23:14, Christ is not smiling here, He is very angry.Paul Der.
TulipGirl
That is interesting. . . Especially since this group of PCA churches seems so diverse. Is the longevity mirrored among the ruling elders as well?We'll be visiting a PCA church here in VA tomorrow. It's not easy. Can't tell as much as I'd like from a website and listening to a sermon MP3 or two. Hubby and I have talked about what we want in a church here. . . but. . . it's hard to change, you know? Added to that, we know we'll be here a limited amount of time, but not sure how limited. So, I almost want to just visit one and as long as it is "okay" just stick with it.Anyway. . . (Oh, and for any other pastors reading this — it is really important to keep your website current. A sample bulletin from manymany years ago? Makes it hard to know if it reflects the church currently or not. . .)But then, maybe not everyone tries to scope out a church before they visit like I do. . .
TulipGirl
Good. Been checking in.
Anonymous
Oh, don't worry… all six – or is it up to seven now? – of us readers will be here when you get organized/settled.
Staci Thomas
Certainly, being a pastor's wife cannot be an easy job. I don't even know just how hard it must be because I've never been one. As the daughter of a ruling elder's wife, I know that that position can also be a thankless job that is not paid or appreciated. I know that I have fallen short of expressing my appreciation to the wives of both pastors and elders in the churches in which I've been a member. I'm going to try to be better about that. Thanks for the reminder.
Randy Greenwald
I hope everyone understands the irony in the title. I don't REALLY believe that one can quantify job difficulty or loneliness or isolation or emotional drain or whatever. Staci's right – a ruling elder's family has its own, sometimes similar stress. Another wrote me on FB pointing out the particular loneliness of HR directors. Bottom line: the smiling faces we see on the street or in church may mask sorrow that we may not know.
Anonymous
Have given it to a grandchild on the basis of high recommendation from a friend. I have not read it myself, but love that she sees Christ in the Old Testament.
TulipGirl
This is one of our favorites. It's not uncommon to get teary-eyed if I read it aloud. It's our standard gift for baby showers. The church we visited last Sunday gave it to the parents of the infant which was baptized that day.
Randy Greenwald
I love the baptism gift idea. Thanks for sharing!
MagistraCarminum
Sure wish we could be there. And how was the camping trip?!
Mickymar
I think a geek is a computer savvy person, where as a nerd may be a funny dressed person, well you are right I think there is no difference. I thought I had a thought. Gift Baskets
TulipGirl
I know you said posting would be slow, but. . . Updates?! We want to know how things are going!
TulipGirl
Love the pic of you and Barb on the “about” page!
Jenny
That photo is great Randy!! I’ve spent the last 5 years muttering about the fact that the city I grew up in had a perfectly gridded city road system with LOGICAL numberings and St vs AVE delineations. ATL is just like Orlando. All the little towns ran together into a BIG city and the roads make NO SENSE!!
Chris in NM
Excellent thoughts as always, Randy. Time to met some editors in Oviedo or Orlando…
Randy Greenwald
I’m working on it… 🙂
Adri
I was going to suggest you not look for a post office as such, but for a smaller facility, I think called a contract station. We use the very convenient one at a nearby Shell station, or another at a mini-mart near the library. Usually shorter lines, and efficiency is good.
Chris in NM
Well done!
Staci Thomas
Good thing you have technology…it will fill in the physical paper holes. Speaking of, what are the chances of hearing a Randy Greenwald sermon this Sunday via technology?
Randy Greenwald
Oh, about 2 to 1, I’d say. Technology has conspired against us for a couple of weeks. Sorry.
Chris in NM
A great guy, wise beyond his years at the time, gave me this book and I have read it several times since. Thanks for reminding me of this great passage today.
Another Hypocrite…
Randy Greenwald
That must have been a wonderful fellow. I think I know him. I wonder what ever happened to him?
Chris in NM
Make that three…
TG
*grin*
I know y’all are going through a lot of transitions, too. . . it’s good for me to have some “consistency,” in hearing the same voice proclaiming the Gospel that stays the same no matter where we go. . .
Geoff Henderson
I know how you feel. I’ve lived in three different places since I moved to WV, and it can get hard to keep up.
Routine can be a good thing.
Staci Thomas
Magnificent…on many levels. Thank you, as always.
Staci Thomas
The Road was great. It was faithful to the book. The Last Station is sitting on my desk, itching to get out of the Netflix sleeve. I’d watch The Road first, and then follow it up with something a bit more cheerful.
Michael Sacasas
I have to agree, that is a very nice commute time, I’ve been enjoying it all summer! : )
Geoff Henderson
Randy,
Glad to see you adapting.
Though I have an office in a building with realtors, airforce, and some other businesses (which is pretty cool), I actually have a study downstairs in my basement as well. Of course, I’ve yet to use it. When I work from home, its usually on our bed! No Starbucks in “The Valley.”
Jenny
HI Randy – Kevin and I both read that WSJ article. We looked at each other and said, “What is HAPPINESS?” To quote T Keller, “What is personal fulfillment, and WHY personal fulfillment?” Serving the idol of self, does not fulfill any more than serving an idol of family.
Randy Greenwald
I know all about serving those idols!
Randy Greenwald
I could not be called to a place without SBUX. God would not do that to me…. Would he?
Adri
Cool!
TG
Lovely! Hubby promised me a Rudolph mug for Christmas. It is yet to materialize. . . But I know he’s good for it. On our next trip to B’ton I will make SURE to get mine.
TG
Reading this at a Bucks of Starriness as I type. . . and I was thinking, “But, wasn’t Pastor Randy’s office the coffee shop on Cortez Road or SR70?”
*grin*
But, I know there is a time for quiet, meditation and study without the buzz of conversation and interruption. . .
Randy Greenwald
That could be you, by the pool, Adri.
Randy Greenwald
Ah, we have many offices. I’m typing this at one of them: the bookstore at RTS.
Michael Sacasas
Welcome to the posthumanties. Here’s the something like a founding document:
http://www.stanford.edu/dept/HPS/Haraway/CyborgManifesto.html
Randy Greenwald
1991?? Wow. I’m WAY behind the curve.
Chris in NM
Ouch! It must be a painful thing to live as a preacher, always reading such convicting things…
Randy Greenwald
The real occupational hazard is reading such things and ONLY thinking they apply to others, forgetting to apply them to oneself.
Adria
We enjoy a similar placed up here called McKay’s. It is huge and does the same trade in process. I got Isai a bunch of books last time we were there.
Chris in NM
Awesome!
Delaney
Don’t forget Jane Slayre!
JokiLoki22
That’s a position I love to be in.
Michael Sacasas
Yeah …
Randy Greenwald
Yes, I saw that.
Adri
Please suggest they open a branch in B’ton. Best used books place I know of here is Goodwill on SR 70, but that’s donations, not trade.
TG
“Eight Ways to Totally Screw up Your Kids and How God’s Grace Can Fix the Mess“.
Now THAT’S a parenting book I would buy!
My mothering mantra for many years has been “God’s grace and a mother’s love cover a multitude of screw ups. . .”
But for me. . . I have needed to screw up with my kids. I need to have that daily reminder of how dependent I am on Jesus.
TG
And, yes, my boys have read the first two. (And the originals, as well.) Not sure if we’re ready for AK yet. . .
birthinukraine
Thank you, so so true!
A funny from my SIL, mom of 2 very small boys: “We don’t save for college, we save for therapy.”
Randy Greenwald
Ha! Yes, we often tell our kids that they are going to need some serious therapy once we’re done with them…
Randy Lovelace
Hey Randy,
I love my iPhone4, and I can get it to reduce the signal. What drives me nuts is all the wasted time the media has spent reporting a problem about a cell phone. On in the west do we have the time to complain about such things. For a good laugh please check this out if you haven’t seen it yet:
Speaking about too much time on my hands, do you have any movie recommends? My queue is low.
Randy Greenwald
Hey, Mr. Lovelace, so good to see you ’round these parts.
Sorry about your queue. I’ve got posts in the works, but I’m at a new church and, I think you know, that can be all consuming!! You may be on your own for a while.
Faith Brooks De La Cour
Thanks so much for sharing this about the impact our Dad had on your life. We can attest that he prayed not only for you but for many people. The last gathering we had as a family, almost two weeks ago, we asked Dad to tell our children what his prayers were for them. What a blessing to have been able to hear that. Two days later he was unable to communicate clearly.
Maybe you will be the one to carry that praying torch for others?
Randy Greenwald
Faith, that is the challenge, really, isn’t it. I can attest that my prayers are more faithful for more people now because of his and others’ testimony.
Thanks for your comment and your challenge!
TG
*tears*
Staci Thomas
Where is your “like” button?
Chris in NM
You are right that “Christian” application of the law is no more perfect than the Christian wielding it. But law is, itself, a gift of God to fallen man, isn’t it? I shudder to think of rule by something other than law: rule by whim of rulers or desire of the powerful or elite. May God save us from ourselves on both ends of the spectrum, and in the middle!
Adri
Well, I can see why they call it Little-Big rather than type the entire name each time!
But do let us know when the event is scheduled; we want to be there.
Randy Greenwald
Perhaps rule by wisdom, Chris? I’m sensitive to your love for the law – I am as well. But I’m also fearful of those whose exegesis leads them to two assumptions: 1) I can rightly interpret and thereby apply that law across broad spectrums of society, and any who differ with my application are thereby not being biblical, and 2) Applying law in this way will bring happiness to that society. I see little humility among those who argue for Biblical law, a humility willing to think that they might not be quite right. And in it all the attribute of wisdom seems to be overlooked.
And Staci, thanks for volunteering to rework the code on this site to add a ‘like’ button. When would you like to start? 🙂
Adri
You mean the book, right? I’m all for it!
Fiona McQuarrie
Hilarious!…I love that kid! I’m not so sure about his dad though…He’s such a bad influence! 😉
Renee
That’s it alright!
Mary
I, too, get frustrated with forwarded e-mails you describe. I also feel very frustrated when I receive forwards from many “sisters in Christ,” (friends) which say I must pass on to 10 others while the clock ticks away, so that I may receive a surprise “blessing” by a certain time tomorrow. Why are pastors not telling their people to knock off this type of forwarding and that it is not Biblical? Please include, too, the ones that say if you forward, it will show you are not ashamed of Christ! Aarrrgggghhh!!
Laura
I love that picture of Colin. The Lord is going to use him in a special way someday.
Chris in NM
Colin is certainly following the example set before him. Isn’t that rather frightening for all of us as parents?! What a cutire he is…
Geoff Henderson
Good material! Would love it if the Red Sox were able to be in a division where they might have a better shot at competing with teams that have high pay rolls like the Rays.
Michael Sacasas
Loved it! Nicely done even if it missed out on the ellipsis.
Chris in NM
Love it, ya know?
Chris in NM
So many books and so little time… 🙂 Sympathizing!
TG
The book. .. the coffee. . . either way, good stuff for kids!
Chris in NM
Enjoying your thoughts on writing and wishing I had time to write in return…
Staci Thomas
Great thoughts, my friend. Really, really great. Keep ’em coming! I’m allllllllll eyes.
Chris in NM
Amen. beautiful, true thoughts to start my day! Thanks!
Jenifer Hanson
Randy, thanks for this reminder. It is so easy to forget that we can change our days by shifting our perspectives. By the way, I still love the name of your blog!
Renee
I want to thank you also for this reminder. I have struggled (as you know) these last 8 months with my health – and the loss of my pastor 😉 to another congregation. Now that the issues with my health are improving, I can reflect on God’s graciousness & goodness.
I have found a support group on facebook with people who have or are suffering from the same health affliction that I was. Some of these people have/are suffering for YEARS with this problem – me only a few months. Some of these people do not have the knowledgable doctors that I have been blessed with. They have had to travel thousands of miles – while I only had to drive 50. I praise God for my improving health and the prayers others, and I can now look back and be grateful for all those whom God has place in my life to affect a ‘cure’ for this problem. I hope to, that now I can be of support for others. Miss you lot’s Randy, Barb and the rest.
Matthew
I couldn’t agree more.
Jenny
That’ll preach! …or will it?….hmmmm
Geoff Henderson
Well said. I love that a Mormon can be a Christian spokesman.
I may be going to hear Wayne Grudem in Huntington speak on social justice and politics and what not. Will let you know his insight if I do.
Keith
I’ve enjoyed Larry Osborne’s books on this subject (unity among church leadership), particularly his newest, Sticky Teams.
http://www.amazon.com/Sticky-Teams-Keeping-Leadership-Staff/dp/0310324645/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1283454476&sr=8-3
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, Keith. I’ll need to track this one down.
nigel
It is a pickle, thats for sure. It seems so often this happens though. Why do folks use something so personal, something so intrisic, as faith or even “religion” in a broader sense, to manipulate people towards a particular political thought? kind of a rhetorical question I know and I know I’m sort of jumping in the deep end here with my first post on your blog, Randy…but it’s been one of those days. But what did Jesus say about these issues? He surely encountered them daily. There is that scene in the movie Cold Mountain that comes to mind…when Inman is riding with the Reverend and Ada Monroe in the wagon, they are speaking of how it must make God weary being called down on both sides of the argument in regards to the civil war/slavery issue. But it seems to me, a true layman, to be a similar situation, doesn’t it?
Randy Greenwald
Comments are all well taken.
Nigel, I think it is impossible for our religious convictions to NOT influence our political positions. What I think we both agree on is the danger of wedding those positions so closely to our religion that we use religion to manipulate the positions of others. Your reference to God being wearied is well taken. I think what I lament is that then like now the issues are so important but the public square so toxic that one cannot raise questions about anything without not only his politics coming into question, but his Christianity as well. That bothers me a ton!
sociosound
Good post and GREAT points!
Joshua
The difference between the two is simple, I think. The first stories (Inception, Shutter Island) bring up the very valid point that guilt must be dealt with.
Christianity, instead of having us simply “pass off” the guilt or create another world where guilt goes or any of the really cool stuff that DiCaprio does in the movies, shows us exactly who we can give our guilt too and that we receive Grace and Love in return regardless of what the guilt is for.
Adri
“from Bradenton, south of Tampa Bay, to Orlando, 150 miles west.”
You better have another look at that google map! 🙂
Randy Greenwald
Oops. Thanks. I’ll fix that!
llondy
A good response to clear up some ideas about how a regenerated person and a non-regenerate person can both do positive things for mankind. I think that it is only the grace of God that allows this through his love for the world in general. God indeed does work everything for his good including the acts of evil men even if their desires and goals are different. As reformed people we focus on total depravity and how spiritually dead people are, but focus little on how God brings so much good out of such a failed state. Only by his grace
Adri
Not only does she defend Calvinism, her writing is magnificent. Personally, I liked her later novel, Home, even better than Gilead. Home was written later but some reviewers describe it as “not a sequel but a sibling” to Gilead; it deals with the same families.
In a September 2008 New Yorker article James Wood writes: “…But Robinson is illiberal and unfashionably fierce in her devotion to this Protestant tradition; …she loathes the complacent idleness whereby contemporary Americans dismiss Puritanism and turn John Calvin, its great proponent, into an obscure, moralizing bigot….She tartly reminds us, ‘Americans never think of themselves as sharing fully in the human condition, and therefore beset as all humankind is beset.’ …The belief that we are all sinners gives us excellent grounds for forgiveness…and is kindlier than any expectation that we might be saints, even while it affirms the standards all of us fail to attain.'”
A.O.Scott of the New York Times (September 2008) said of Home: “It is a book unsparing in its acknowledgment of sin and unstinting in its belief in the possibility of grace.”
Gilead is on my “to re-read” list.
–ae
Chris in NM
Excellent point, Randy. And when I have the pleasure of hearing you preach 9either in person or online) that is what I take away. Hope your lord’s Day is a restful one!
Jenny
I have SO many stories like that.
Mostly I just sound like an idiot in my text’s to my husband requesting grocery items like:
fat freeze cheddar
Pests – instead of Pesto
Cascade – which is known as a dish detergent faithfully brought home by my husband when I WANTED Cascadia Farms cereal.
etc…etc…etc…
Randy Greenwald
Oh, but what we might be able to do with ‘fat freeze’ cheddar!
I’ll work up a marketing campaign immediately.
Chris in NM
Sounds wonderful to me. I am a slow, plodding reader. And without several things in several categories going at once, in little bites, I would never accomplish anything. I’ll have to post my “reading schedule”. Good idea 🙂
Randy Greenwald
A plodder. That’s me. Thank you, gentle commenter.
Staci Thomas
After You Believe is so fabulous. I repeatedly return to it. Glad to see it has made your list. You already know how I feel about Olive and Susan.
Randy Greenwald
Staci – if you’ve not read Lovelace, put it on your ‘serious’ list. I highly commend it. After You Believe has received positive reviews from some surprising quarters, and so, though I’ve not started it I’m looking forward to it. And thanks for directing me to Olive!
Jenifer Hanson
Thanks for sharing the article, Randy! This statement, with the preceding paragraph, really struck me: “What is really lost when this happens is the self-invention of a human brain. If students don’t learn to think, then no amount of access to information will do them any good.”
In Franny and Zooey by Salinger, Franny goes on a tirade about how no one ever suggests that the end result of learning is to gain wisdom. That on college campuses, wisdom is never even mentioned. People are just building up little stockpiles of information, without any thought to the purpose.
These two thoughts seem connected in an important way — what is it we are actually instilling in our students? What scares me isn’t that we are not omniscient…it is how many of us participate without careful intent.
Staci Thomas
I’ve not read any Lovelace. It’s on my list. Thanks.
P.S. If you’ve not read Bauer’s latest blog posts about taking her son to Italy and Greece, you should.
Adri
Interesting; had not heard about this discovery. But, being the eternal optimist, I’m totally believing your story. In other words, would I ever doubt you? Would you ever lie? 🙂
~a~
Randy Greenwald
Never. I vow to remain perpetually somber and dull.
Jenifer Hanson
Reading this post took me back to high school, when I would be having a difficult time emotionally and you would say just the right thing to help me gain perspective. It spoke directly to my heart tonight, when I really needed to be reminded that fear is not the sheltered place I want to live within. Hope is a wonderful, terrible step forward into the open. But the open is the only place I can become the person God intends me to be, of that I am certain (though there are so many other things I still don’t know!).
I can’t fully identify with the sports thing, but I appreciate that you share it – I rarely read one of your blog entries without displaying some emotion, and often it is laughter (the best kind of laughter, too — not the kind where I’m laughing AT you). Thanks! Jeni
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, Jeni. It is encouraging to know someone is reading; it is further encouragement to know someone is being encouraged by it.
High school, though, I fear, was a few years ago now… 🙂
Mike
As an avid Minnesota Twins fan (my friends call it an obsession), I truly understand the fragility and frightfulness of Hope! Good thing I am a faithful person though. The Twins often shatter my hopes (especially in the post-season.) God, on the other hand, doesn’t.
Now, don’t even get me started about the Vikings…
Randy Greenwald
Oh, ouch. That’s painful. I really wanted the Rays to face the Twins. Yankee arrogance needs to be addressed! But I do confess having a hard time cheering for a Favre/Moss combo! But I do appreciate your suffering…
anonymous
I’m a faithful reader; infrequent commenter.
Randy Greenwald
Oh, I don’t know, I find that among commenters, “anonymous” is one of the more consistent participants.
TulipGirl
*grin* I didn’t get as far in his SysTheo as I would have liked. Something about short attention span coupled with intense loyalty to Berkhof. But recently I wished I had my copy of Frame’s SysTheo (alas, in storage. Just like all our other books. And I’m on parole at the library. again.)
But footnotes like that? Make the good reading all the better. *grin*
Geoff Henderson
Randy,
Your welcome bro! Scott Puckett posted it on facebook, so I really “stole” it from him. Really cool thoughts from Gordo.
Mike
Its way more than an ordinary game, it’s an experience of sheer joy!
1 Shout for joy to the LORD, all the earth. 2 Worship the LORD with gladness; come before him with joyful songs. Psalm 100:1-2
Connie
Thanks for your post! Here is an excellent article by Steven Lawson from “Tabletalk” mag. entitled, ‘What is Truth?’ to add to the list. Blessings!
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, Connie. I’ll need to check it out.
Jenny
Hi Randy – I’ve been pondering your post for a couple of days. I was considering posting a nice little comment – but then you BETRAYED me. (chuckle)
Actually, I mused in my head whether the “magic” and “miracle” of a sport like baseball isn’t solely the stats, the excitement, or the post-season possibilities – but sharing all of those elements with your grown and no so-grown children. Would it still be AS wonderfully magical if you didn’t get to have this shared hobby with your sons; that gives you a great excuse to spend time together?
Just a thought from an avid NFL fan. GO COWBOYS!!!
Randy Greenwald
Good point. Yes, I think part of the magic is the shared component of it. But don’t you dare equate the grace of baseball and the violence of football. 🙂
Eva
Thinking about politicians and truth, all the campaign ads come to mind. A great website to check out to find out what exactly in the ads is true and what just plain is NOT is http://www.politifact.com/florida.
Randy Greenwald
Not going there… don’t want to get any more cynical!
Adri
Glad you explained the rum running. I was concerned, thinking it would go from that to a still to bootlegging, the IRS… and who knows what else. 🙂
Randy Greenwald
“…and who knows what else.”
NASCAR.
TG
Downloaded the beta version. . . last time you hawked it, it was only for Mac.
anonymous
WHY do you keep adding to my list of “must read” books? It’s already too long.
Staci Thomas
Fabulous review. I love your point about it being non-heroic.
As you’ll see, I liked it much more than you did. The non-writer that I am, I noticed (but barely) the “non-linear narrative” but it didn’t bother me too much because I was too impressed with the prose. I’m simply stunned by the talent, so I probably ignore the stuff to which I’m supposed to pay attention. Maybe my experience with it was more enjoyable because I read it the old fashioned way.
Again, lovely review.
Randy Greenwald
So here is how we respond differently: the guy writes better than I and so I try to find some way to be critical and bring him down a notch or two closer to me. You see the same thing, and knock yourself down a notch or two and become critical of your own critical faculties. Do you feel a scolding coming on?!
It may be that because you are so much younger than I am (!) that you track better with this narrative style. Savvy?
Michael Sacasas
So question: how does point 1) relate to your comments in the two closing paragraphs?
Thanks for posting these reflections.
Also, thought these two might be of some interest:
http://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2009/03/resisting-the-kindle/7345/
http://www.thenewatlantis.com/publications/people-of-the-screen
Randy Greenwald
Oh, probably my own, typical ambivalence.
I find myself considering for my iPhone/Kindle books that I don’t expect to have a significant attachment to! There is a convenience which I will enjoy, but I cannot see now being drawn to it as a primary means of reading.
Thanks for the links.
Randy
Jenny
Kevin and I tried to read and deep and important non-fiction book on our iPhone Kindles and found ourselves frustrated. Tom Sawyer was no problem, but trying to follow the argument of a thought with only one paragraph on display at a time was somehow disjointing to my brain. It could have simply been a badly written book. I kept wanting to write notes in the margins where I disagreed or agreed with the author. I know that is somehow possible with the app- just very cumbersome.
Randy Greenwald
Precisely. It is possible, but cumbersome. However, I’m reading “The Taming of the Shrew” on it right now, and finding it wonderful. There are so few distractions with footnotes and such. So, I just read. But, yes, there is much I would not read on it. I picked up a real Kindle at Staples just a few minutes ago, and the display is larger and it is very light. Of course, it’s probably heavier once you get a hundred books on it…
Geoff Henderson
Well said Randy.
BTW-I just finished the first political based reading I’ve done in a long while, by reading “Republocrat” by Carl Truemann. Definitely a thoughtful piece of good writing that challenges FoxNews fanatics and critiques the left for its inconsistencies as well. And it was short.
TG
You’re welcome! (J/K!)
Glad someone is showing gratitude to you and the Mrs.
Adri
Please, NO! We can’t afford to lose a good friend in such a terrible accident! Is it her own paperback book? Here’s a suggestion: take a razor blade or very sharp knife and cut the book into halves or even smaller parts. Use packing tape to hold the pages in place like a binding. She can even use card stock and her Print Explosion program to design her own new covers.
Or, if it’s certain the book will not be read again, tear off the pages already read and discard them. I could be wrong, but I believe this was the initial intention of paperbacks.
ae
Randy Greenwald
Alas, paperback it is not. First edition, first printing hard cover.
And a former librarian suggesting defacing a book. I’m shocked. However, I appreciate the love for the wife!
TG
Several friends of ours (especially homeschooling friends) are trying to persuade me that the Kindle or ipad is the way to go — especially for classics. You can get most classics for free in digital form, and then we wouldn’t have to ship them overseas. . . I see the allure, but. . . So hard to let go of the real, physical book, even if it is the ideas inside that give them worth.
But, along with reading in bed, I’ve been using the youversion Bible app on my phone since Kathryn introduced it to me. Now, when I’m having trouble sleeping, reading the Psalms by phone light is easy and peaceful and doesn’t wake Hubby.
chrisinnm
Well, I find the whole worship of celebrity even less attractive in a Christian setting, where we ought to know better. But i watched, and you are right. They do say the ESV is reliable, has good scholarship behind it, etc. But the whole point here is to create a need to use the bible that the famous guys use. i can’t help but think this must grieve God.
Randy Greenwald
Really? I’m only bothered because they didn’t ask me…
I’ve grown more critical of the ad overnight. I love Crossway and am devoted to my ESV. But there is no difference in this ad than any featuring Tiger Woods and Buick. What really do these guys know about the quality and value of the ESV? No more than Tiger Woods knows about Buicks.
I honor these peoples for their contribution to Christ’s kingdom. I’ve learned much from many of them. This, however, does little for me.
Gail Brightbill
Bauer is an English professor, not a history professor. In her attempt to cover an extensive time period, she does not begin to address the causes and effects of historical events and how one affected the other. There is much she glosses over. Bauer’s books would not be the history textbook I would choose to educate my children.
Mike
As someone who did not make it to the family Thanksgiving (because of weather) with a family who loves to be together, I struggled with having a great holiday despite not being there. Thank you for some perspective Randy! I’m going to go and look at the photos emailed to me again. I love my family!
Chris in NM
Amen!
Jeff Brown
The limitations of history writing, as you have described them, are one reason why reading fiction from other time periods is so valuable. In some ways, you can learn more about 19th century England by reading Austen and Dickens than you can by reading a history of England.
Randy Greenwald
That Bauer is an English professor should be seen as no strike against her, really. Neither Barbara Tuchman nor David McCullough are historians by trade, but because they are writers, they write about history in a captivating way. I’m persuaded that even they would falter in the telling of a history of this scope. That she glosses over much is precisely my point. But it is not her fault; it is the nature of the beast. She MUST because the scope is so vast. I’m positively impressed that she does it as well as she does given the limitations inherent in the project, limitations obviously not imposed upon the writer of fiction whose focus, as Jeff points out, is narrowed upon a particular time and place.
Staci Thomas
I am enormously grateful for Bauer’s work. As someone who had a horrendous history education, she has made the subject accessible to me in a way I never thought possible. If I waited for what seemed to me a more complete history of the world to be published, I don’t think I’d have ever fallen in love with the subject. I’ve read the first two volumes of her monumental task. They whetted my appetite so that I am better able to teach my children history. Furthermore, the excitement Dr. Bauer generated in me for history is spilling over onto my children. Do I use these as my ultimate source for teaching history? No. But this undertaking has provided me with a great foundation.
Gail, I’d love to hear what it is you WOULD use to teach your children history.
Jeff, great point about the value of reading fiction.
Connie
🙂 I understand completely!
Eva
I too like to work at coffee shops when working on a presentation–mostly because for the most part there is no one there tugging on my leg, wiping their nose on my shoulder, asking me to hold them, or screaming, “Mama!” from the other end of the house. But the ubiquitous lady with the annoyingly loud voice is always there–somehow she always finds me. So, I have discovered the annoying-lady antidote. Bring a set of headphones and go to http://www.simplynoise.com for some good old white noise background. (I tried classical music, but it was too distracting because it clashed with the coffee shop music.)
Randy Greenwald
I think I’d need to go all the way and get noise canceling headphones. But those are too expensive. Thanks for the noise site. I may just have to avail myself of that some day!
Chris in NM
Roger Nicole was the inspiration for our large library. He said books were to be referenced, not read, and collected as a legacy for one’s children. I heard him say that long before I had children. I wonder if mine will consider these 3,000 volumes a legacy or a curse sometimes…
Definitely somebody to eat a meal with in heaven…
🙂
Chris in snowy NM
Randy Greenwald
Not read? That begs for clarification.
Randy in sunny FL
Chris in NM
I think he was answering the objection, “Why do you have so many books- you can’t possibly read them all!”
Randy Greenwald
My brother once looked at my (paltry) library and said, “Have you read all of these?” I told him honestly, but a bit tangentially, “Some I’ve read twice!”
I prune my library regularly ridding it of volumes I no longer have any use for as reference.
Staci Thomas
Looks wonderful. Thanks for the recommendation. It is going to the top of my list now.
Edward Koehler
I too will see True Grit, and hopefully grasp that Presbyterian-Protestant ethic that is so fun. Kim Darby, in my opinion, was the best part of the original. I can’t wait to see what the Coen’s do with their Mattie Ross. Somehow a 14 year old girl version of Everett from Oh Brother is coming to mind.
Kedric
It’s been reported many times that this exodus started in 2003 at the same time the US invaded Iraq. And as Carl Trueman pointed out in his recent book, there were very likely Christians in the Iraqi army fighting against the US. What are we to do with that?
Adri
Wow! Those are powerful words, and wonderful to ponder at this season. Jesus is more than just a sweet baby in a manger.
–ae
Randy Greenwald
“What are we to do with that?”
I await your answer!
Ruth Anne McDowell
Relished it …still resonates. Any more recommendations?
Randy Greenwald
Um, yes, as a matter of fact. See the post for 12/21/2010!
Matthew
That’s a grand slam of course.
Randy Greenwald
No, that is currently under review.
Michael Sacasas
Stanley Fish may be of some help here!
http://opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2010/12/27/narrative-and-the-grace-of-god-the-new-true-grit/?hp
Randy Greenwald
Hey, Mike, thanks for the link. I’ve got to see the movie now!
Susan C
Thanks for a much-needed chuckle!
Connie
Amen!
Jenifer Hanson
I visited you in Bradenton once. In the mid-1980s (’85 or ’86). As soon as I read the title of this entry, “The Hills of Bradenton”, my curiosity was piqued. Even with one day-trip to Bradenton more than two decades ago, I knew there were no hills!
Seth
Ummmm… Hills? Really? Either Andre was seriously messed up while in Bradenton, or his ghost writer has never been there.
Randy Greenwald
Seth – I think both were true. But I’m still surprised that someone did not catch that.
Chris in NM
I laughed when I read about the hills, too. Was he meaning over-passes? They were the closest things to hills…
I remember reading a Tom Clancy novel that was partially set in Los Alamos, and just guffawed when an important plot twist depends on the hero leaving the Lab and arriving at the mall 10 minutes later. The MALL? Really?!
Fact checkers ought to be local…
Jenny
By the way I always loved the smell of the orange peels. They always reminded me of orange iced cookies baking in an oven. It was the big “homecoming” smell on each trip back to Bradenton from Chattanooga. You new we were close when you could smell the oranges.
Randy Greenwald
I should note that the quote is found on page 77 of the book. And I should also say that the book is a fun read and an interesting insight into the loneliness of the pro tennis tour. Having been sick and therefore unable to sleep, I’m nearly done with it.
Eva
They must have been emotional hills. Very, very steep ones!
Randy Greenwald
There you go. That must be it. These are metaphoric hills we are talking about! Yes, that must be it.
Kathryn
Clearly the book was ghost written.
Randy Greenwald
Yes, indeed. And Agassi makes no secret of that. In fact, apparently, he wanted his writer’s name on the front cover, but his writer refused. Anyway, more about that tomorrow.
Adri
Haven’t seen any hills in the 15+ years we’ve been here; have liked the smell from the oj plant.
Wonder if he ever practiced at the courts in our development; they now have to be locked to keep out students who want to practice for tournaments; apparently IMG has not enough court space. 🙂
Amy
I LOVE the smell if the Tropicana plant! Maybe the “hills” he’s referring to are like developments or something, not Literal hills.
Geoff Henderson
I used to think (embarassingly not too long ago at all) that all books were actually written by their authors: those whose names are attached. And it was almost like a Santa Claus let down. I guess its better to probably view them as a biography written from an autobiographical point of view.
But I do appreciate, along with you, Agassi’s honesty. I really respect this joker. An interesting lad for sure. And I thoroughly enjoyed a book about Tennis, even though I don’t like Tennis. At all. And the parts about Bradenton brought back memories as I read them in the actual snow covered hills of West Va last year.
A great read, regardless who wrote it!
Randy Greenwald
What I appreciate is that Agassi made no attempt to hide that he had help.
I came away from this book the same way I came away from Zinger: marveling that the line between being really good and being at the top of one’s game in professional athletics is often mental and not physical.
Interesting.
Staci Thomas
This is SUCH A great story. Love it.
Staci Thomas
This is very funny. I run. And often, at 5am, I am running up and down the I-75 overpass on Linger Lodge Road so that I can purposely run hills. I will also drive to St. Armand’s Circle and run that bridge, again so that I can get some hill work in. The only hills in Bradenton/Sarasota to be found are man-made. Trust me, I’ve looked.
I love your attention to detail, Randy. I would probably have glossed over this error.
Staci
Randy Greenwald
Uh, yes, attention to detail. That is, attention to other people’s mistakes. It is not a gift!
Jenifer Hanson
I have kept a diary or journal since 1973. I haven’t the discipline or the inclination to write every day, but I do write often. For me, one of the reasons for doing so is that I haven’t other outlets for deep reflection. And I find that, when I don’t take the time for reflection, I feel cast adrift in both my own life and the universe. The minutiae (such as writing about the first crocus, etc.) helps to ground the reflection in a time and place. Prayer and meditation may provide this outlet for others, but journaling is what does it for me.
Its funny you asked that question today, as I just finished a short blog entry to publish tomorrow about my diaries/journals.
Randy Greenwald
See. This confirms my theory. INTERESTING people keep diaries.
Thanks for your thoughts, especially about the minutiae, a word I could not spell before now. It does seem to ground the extraordinary in the ordinary rhythms of God’s world.
And where does one find your blog?
Mike
I do not journal and probably won’t ever start. HOWEVER, I dabble in photography and find it fills the same sense of grounding Jeni references. Especially now that I use a digital format, I can take hundreds of pictures of “nothing” and catelog my reflections. Yes, there are the obligatory photos of friends and family, but the majority are of the minutiae, the somber and the dull. My thousands upon thousands of digital photographs are my journal, albeit without words.
Randy Greenwald
Nice slippage of the ‘somber and dull’ into the mix! Thanks for the observation. Artists do reflect their hearts in their work. Sounds like what you are doing.
Jenny
WHY are you tempting me to LUST??? I WANT IT! Can I justify this as a pre-move inventory tool?
Randy Greenwald
Absolutely. Good for insurance. In case you lose something… 😉
stacithomas
I have it and I LOVE it. It is most helpful when I can’t remember if I bought a book for an older kid that the younger kid needs now. It is an incredible homeschool help, for sure.
What I find incredibly interesting about this post is that you own a book by Gail Sheehy, and that it is called Character. Funny, that tidbit is. 🙂
stacithomas
Okay, wait. I just re-read because I couldn’t believe that you have that book. And I’m right. You don’t have it. You have Karamazov. This makes much, much more sense. All is right with the world now.
Note to self: SLOW DOWN.
Randy Greenwald
I was about ready to correct you. To tear you into tiny little shreds for your carelessness and oversight; to lash out at your snide implications. To think that I had character. Sheesh. What could you have been thinking? So glad you’ve discovered that, in fact, I don’t possess character.
stacithomas
So glad my carelessness occurred. Your response made me laugh!
Jenifer Hanson
I stumbled upon the single vs. double space controversy last week and was astonished! I was taught (in typing class) to use double spaces, and they were in use when I was a book editor immediately after graduating from college. It is a difficult habit to break. However, I will bow to current practice on this.
Comma placement is another matter altogether. I agree with the author quoted above. And I will continue to be rebellious on this one!
Randy Greenwald
Yes – and your rebellion is for the cause of truth! Go for it, girl!
Mike
When you figure out a way to train these middle-aged thumbs to stop their well practiced ‘tap – tap’ post period, I will concede and conform. Until then, there is asolutely nothing I can do to help you. Fortunately, in standard HTML, any number of spaces typed results as a single space. You will never see the three double spaces in this post and I am off the hook!
Randy Greenwald
I’m inherently lazy. If a sermon is, say, 4000 words, that is, lets say, 400 sentences, just to make the math easy. The difference between one two spaces is 400 key strokes. If I write 50 sermons/year, that is 20,000 key strokes. If I do that for forty years, that is nearly 1 million key strokes. And that is just sermons. If each keystroke sends an impulse of electricity, just think of the amount of energy saved.
Go green. Train your thumbs. 🙂
Mike
I am more a creature of habit than I am inherently lazy. (People who know me would argue I am equally both.) I will remain a double spacer. I actually think it’s easier to read, but that’s a whole other argument.
Pray for me, Reverend.
P.S. I 10-key by touch proficiently. Surely that exonerates me?
Randy Greenwald
You are absolved, my son.
Connie
Hmmm.
Hopeless. Yes, hopeless.
A word for double-spacers: While submitting papers for a writing course I once took, my paper would be bloodied if I single-spaced between sentences. However, I have since been forced to change this habit due to counsel given me by my college-aged children. When asked to proof a finished paper on their behalf, I would make comment on their need to double-space between sentences. That, I was told, was outdated editing advise. Sigh. What’s a mother to do? On the other hand, a writer can do whatever they want!
Randy Greenwald
Your children, you see, will keep you hip and cool.
Matthew
DVD? Ever heard of Blu-Ray!? Anyway I am glad that were about to get some good use out of it =)
Randy Greenwald
Blu-Ray – isn’t that kinda like beta tapes? 🙂
Jeff
Randy, I agree with you on the smart quotes and the two-spaces issue, but really, putting commas after closing quotation marks? You do realize you are going against both the Chicago manual and Strunk & White on this one, right?
Eva
Hilarious!
Eva
You think the double-space issue is controversial. You should hear the outrage caused by the new grammar books that teach children where to place the apostrophe after plural possessive nouns. The grammar book I used in Virginia–from a very established educational publisher–is now teaching children that all possessive singular nouns–even those ending in ‘s’–should be followed by an ‘s. Therefore, we would no longer write “James’ book,” but rather “James’s book.” The one exception to this rule printed in the grammar book? Jesus. Anything owned by Jesus should still be written Jesus’.
And, as I go to send this, my husband the editor is telling me that this is not a new rule, it’s always been this way, and most people have just learned it incorrectly. Apparently James’s is and always has been the correct way–even though my computer is carving angry red zig-zags under it every time I write it. So now the question becomes, why is it different for Jesus???
Seth
21. Invite son and daughter-in-law to awesome movie night.
Randy Greenwald
You are invited. Any Saturday night. Or come March 5 when we watch Inception with a bunch of others. I expect you, now.
Chris in NM
I can picture it all! 🙂
Randy Greenwald
That’s because you know me too well.
Keith
FYI – there is a new, similar program available via the Mac App Store called Bookpedia. As a former Delicious user, I prefer Bookpedia, and it’s half the price…
Keith
just saying! in case anyone out there is considering the purchase. But Delicious Library is also awesome. The only reason I bought Bookpedia was because I accidentally deleted my copy of Delicious during a computer transfer.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, Keith. Would have been nice to know BEFORE dropping the $40 on Delicious! I would like to know why you prefer one over the other.
stacithomas
“She knows, of course.”
Love it.
Geoff Henderson
Thanks for the post. I do like Justin Taylor, but certainly am not a fan of everything he puts up. Some stuff I can predict what it will say without even reading it. This would definitely fall under that same category, though even the excerpts surprised me a bit.
Sanctity of life Sunday. Hmmm….Our professor Al Mawhinney said, “I’ve heard the same sanctity of life sermon for the past 20 years!” He was right.
I don’t think those sermons do much of anything other than make the preacher and congregation feel good about themselves.
It is definitely tough to figure out the best way to address these issues, but we definitely can’t blast others for trying to be faithful.
Randy Greenwald
Of course, she knows. And she was gracious enough to wait until I ASKED for the manual. There’s some smarts in that girl.
Randy Greenwald
I am a smarter man than you might have assumed. I will NOT step into the middle of a family feud. You guys duke that one out.
I will say to Jeff, though, that I am FULLY aware that the quote issue is outside the bounds of the style manuals for American publications. Wisdom and good sense are sometimes found elsewhere!
stacithomas
She is smart and gracious, for sure.
I’m just not sure I can handle dealing with only one space between sentences. It is throwing me. I feel stress approaching. I had a completely peaceful life until that blog and now I keep staring at the spaces between sentences in everything I read. Thanks bunches. 🙂
Randy Greenwald
‘Tis my calling in life – to impose stress and guilt. But I have great confidence in you.
anonymous
You never know; it could be $5 off a million dollar man. Still wouldn’t be much of a bargain though, would it.
Chris in NM
LOL! Send it in to WWWoW, Sic section 🙂
Posky
That’s a pretty good deal, but I know a plenty of women who paid much more and still didn’t get husbands worth $5.
Penni Holt
Judge not (lest ye be judged).
God is love.
Randy Greenwald
Good nominees!
Elsa
In the “mis-used by those familiar with the Bible,” I immediately thought of Matt. 18:20. It’s not so much seriously misused as taken out of context. I’ve never heard it used in a way that reflects that it is particularly about church discipline.
Randy Greenwald
That would be, “Where two or three are gathered in my name, there I am among them.”
Good call.
anonymous
I agree with Penni; that was my choice but she got here before I did.
Randy Greenwald
Hmmm. That’s a bit weak. Can’t think of ANY others? !
Simone Benedict
That is funny!
Eva
Love it! Send it to Leno and see if he’ll send you a t-shirt! 🙂
Randy Greenwald
Leno is on past my bedtime. How about you do it?!
Eva
The custodian at school told a woman that she needed to have faith in herself because “faith can move mountains.”
Others:
“Eat, drink, and be merry for tomorrow we die.”
“[The love of] money is the root of all evil.”
“The Golden Rule”–a favorite of all elementary school teachers.
“Pride goes before a fall”
“I am the light of the world” (Michael Jackson sang that as a lyric in the song that was released posthumously. He was singing about himself, I think.)
I’m just getting started–I like this challenge! 🙂
Eva
Oh, and here are a few more…
“Out of the mouths of babes…”
“There is nothing new under the sun.”
“Spare the rod, and spoil the child” [paraphrased]
The blind leading the blind [paraphrased]
Randy Greenwald
Wow. You ARE on a roll. The real challenge, of course, is whether WE then have a PROPER understanding of these ideas!
Eva
Sorry…two more came to mind this morning. Tell me when to stop.
The other two are:
Betrayed with a kiss.
An eye for an eye.
Randy Greenwald
Who am I to squelch inspiration?
Jenifer Hanson
I’ll take parents with your “disabilities” any day, Randy: thoughtful, loving, encouraging of individuality.
I work in residence life on a college campus, so I see first-hand the results of different parenting styles. Our halls are full of students whose parents were loving but misguided. Who allowed the sleepovers, but did not allow the children the opportunity to develop the skills mentioned by Brooks (above) because the parents stepped in to resolve every problem, to smooth every bump their children encountered. Some try to do it even after their child leaves home – honestly, colleges may end up developing disciplinary codes which address inappropriate behavior of parents who insert themselves into roommate problems, who harass their children’s “enemies” on Facebook, and whose idea of “problem solving” is to threaten and harangue until their child gets his/her way.
So I find myself of two minds about Chua. If I were a parent (which I am not) I am fairly certain I wouldn’t adopt her style. However, there is something to be said for parenting which establishes, and holds to, expectations. Even difficult to meet expectations. And which clearly establishes an adult role for the parent which can be clearly delineated from the role of the child.
Randy Greenwald
Wow, Jenny, that is so thought provoking. Your perspective is one that uniquely has a view of the ‘product’ at the far end of parenting. You should write a book! My observation is that children are, uh, organic. They are not mechanistic. Raising them is more art than science. A mistaken brushstroke here or there cannot easily be painted over, and so dictates the placement of subsequent brushstrokes. Thanks for helping me reflect on this.
Jenny
I had been so guilt-ridden and overwhelmed by Chua’s interviews and articles. THEN, my kids come home from school and by the end of the evening (and a glass of red wine) I fall quite happily into my G.A.D. parenting method. Give A Damn. In the end (product) they will be the man/woman God is calling them to be (and this WILL include suffering and trails) whether I remember to make Darby practice piano or have James do his 100 math facts in 5 min AGAIN.
Randy Greenwald
Two Jenny’s responding to the same post. How serendipitous is that?!
Jenny II, I’m looking forward to your book, and hope you are able to keep “G.A.D” as the title!
Jenifer Hanson
Baseball fans are all alike! You’re the third (so far) baseball fan in my acquaintance to follow comments about the Super Bowl with a plug for the upcoming season.
Randy Greenwald
It’s a conspiracy. But you should get it. You live in heaven. I mean Iowa.
anonymous
Strongly suggest you figure out what else 2/14 is about; unless you want to be in the doghouse or assigned another kitchen makeover — or worse. I’m just sayin’.
Randy Greenwald
I’ll get on that right away. Doghouses stink.
Mike
1. Agreed. Spot on Randy!
2. No Publix in Minnesota – no sweepstakes winning for me.
3. ABSOLUTELY!
4. Watched game with my teenaged sons, therefore had a different perspective. At least everyone kept their clothes on! I say best half-time show in years!
Oh, and GO TWINS!!! (Yes, we are all alike.)
Randy Greenwald
My 19 year old daughter agreed with me about the Peas. But I can say this: at least they were not lip syncing – that was pretty clear.
Jenny
May I add that they DON’T eat “fish curry” in Tibet?
Randy Greenwald
Missed a person or two on THAT focus group, didn’t they?!
Chris in NM
On the one hand, our wanting to straighten every stick is a result of our fallen nature and our desire to have our heroes more perfect than we are. But I think it goes even deeper: we desire perfection because it is imprinted in our hearts. We know it exists. (Romans 1 tells us this is true.) But in our fallen condition, we are looking for love in all the wrong places (in our heroes instead of in our God.) This brings to mind one of Calvin’s most famous quotes: our hearts are idol factories.
Thanks for the good thoughts this morning!
Randy Greenwald
Good observation. I realize that the idols we serve are often invisible to us, though visible to others. We so much need and honest and loving community to help shepherd us.
Jeff
Randy
I miss being crooked sticks together! Great post and so encouraging. Miss you bro – Go RAYS!
Jeff
Randy Greenwald
Crooked, of course. And knotty. 🙂
Craving BBQ, I am.
stacithomas
Whoa. So needed to read this today. These words are such a balm for my soul. Thank you, thank you, thank you.
Randy Greenwald
So nice to meet flawed people, isn’t it?! Better yet to know we are favored by an Artist.
Chris in NM
When asked at wedding showers to write advice for the bride-to-be, I often include this very idea: no separate accounts. The times we have observed this, it is often to the detriment of the couple. The other things on my list include:
~Laugh at yourselves
~Try to outdo one another in forgiveness
~Pray together every day, even if it’s brief
~Plan on giving 100% to your marriage, and not tallying up what the other person is giving
~Always tithe first
~Buy good pots and pans- you’ll never regret it
I am sure this is a little treat most of the menfolk miss out on…
Randy Greenwald
So, these poor gals go into their relationship trained and properly encouraged, only to run into brutes who can’t laugh at themselves, etc.? What cruelty you are foisting upon them by letting the menfolk miss out.
Chris in NM
I am not the one “letting” the menfolk miss out… Maybe the menfolk need to improve their own pre-marriage traditions! 🙂
Eva
I agree with so much of what you have to say, Randy, and yet I do want to point out another aspect. We live in a time where listeners do not LISTEN. We hear the first three words, and we jump to (usually negative) conclusions. So, instead of being able to deliver a meaningful speech that lays out whatever goal a politician wants to achieve, he/she must be prepared to be interrupted, berated, and belittled by the listener before even being able to make their points. In the Lincoln era, politicians were allowed to debate and discuss for more than one-minute sound bytes. No, one minute is about all we as the listener can handle if the speaker is saying something we disagree with. Then we interrupt.
When do we shut up and listen? When it is a movie, a play, a piece of music. When it is theater in some way. Maybe that’s why politicians carefully select their audiences. So that they will actually be allowed to speak.
Randy Greenwald
True. The setting of the politician’s speech is a part of the communicative apparatus. In fact, it may be more important than the actual words. So I get that. And I am sorry that we do live in an era in which sustained presentations are not permitted. But when someone chooses a setting to do something that is ultimately meaningless to give the impression of doing something meaningful, that dishonesty of it pushes me over the edge. So, I suppose, ‘theater’ is not what is at issue in my mind, but fiction put forward as fact.
Susan
Hi, Randy! Just wanted to tell you that Ed and I miss you and everyone at Covenant. I’m so glad I get to read your blog, but it’s no proper substitute for hearing you in person. Our loss!
Randy Greenwald
No, we are the ones who have suffered loss. But I trust you are settling in well. I will pray that you find a good church, which, in part, will be a church that needs you!
Kedric
There was always some older college basketball commentator who used to say “a child will lead them” to refer to a freshman who was playing well.
anonymous
Good thoughts, especially on the difference between romance and love.
Love the cartoon: “your noxious face”? And the only problem he sees is that it doesn’t exactly rhyme with “green toxic waste”?!? Too funny.
Matthew
I wonder how that series dealt with the fact that JFK was almost certainly cheating on Jackie with Marilyn Monroe among others.
Randy Greenwald
Good point! But, hey, so romantic…
Chris in NM
I have often pondered the way we can look back at the Old Testament writing and see Christ everywhere, but we seldom look back and see the Spirit everywhere. I think we ought to read the OT in light of our Trinitarian view, too!
Mike
Amen!
(That prayer would make a great song.)
Randy Greenwald
Well, Fee has provided the lyrics. You get busy on the tune.
Penni
Great minds think alike. See Spurgeon’s “Evening” devotional for 16 Feb. “Common, too common, is the sin of forgetting the Holy Spirit.”
Randy Greenwald
Or, occasionally, average and inferior minds intersect with the thoughts of great minds. More likely in this case!
Jenifer Hanson
Randy, I think this is an admirable and do-able goal! I know several people who’ve used the “Couch to 5k” training program successfully. Please provide periodic updates – one thing I believe is you can never have too many cheerleaders when you’re pursuing a fitness goal. I realize that’s not usually your style, but running a 5k isn’t something you usually do, either!
Randy Greenwald
Cheerleaders are always helpful. I waited until now to say anything in case I gave up before I really got started!
Adri
“Today I combined funning five minutes with walking three.”
Oops! This is how it showed up when I read the post; looks like now you’ve corrected it.
I love it! And am trying to figure out if it was a typo or a Freudian slip. Funning sounds like the kind of exercise I’d enjoy.
Go Randy! – and your companions!
Randy Greenwald
Yes, I let that out the door before passing it by my copy editor. She has since fixed it. But yes, funning sounds like something I could get into!
Jenifer Hanson
Randy: Today’s post is exemplifies the reason I read your blog. And you have touched on the very difficulty with which I struggle – finding a church home where broad thinking and a liberal education are valued rather than suspect (or worse, reviled). You’re thoughtfulness reminds me and calls me back to what living my faith CAN be, but isn’t. You’ve probably wondered why I comment so often, but, truly, sometimes what you write is like rain on parched soil.
Randy Greenwald
I think you are right – in some contexts it is communicated that having respect with those with whom we differ is in some measure a grand compromise. I’m sorry you feel so isolated. But there is a solution. Send your resume here:
University of Central Florida
4000 Central Florida Blvd.
Orlando, Florida, 32816
You get the job, we’ll take care of the rest. 🙂
PS: I should add that it will be in the low 80s today and clear.
Staci Thomas
*****GASP***** OF COURSE there will be attitudes in The New York Times with which people disagree. We are living in a fallen world. Perhaps this individual was afraid of the backlash he would get from telling his audience that he reads it.
It is this VERY attitude that pushes people AWAY from Christianity.
I loved The New York Times as young woman running FROM Jesus and I love The New York Times as an older woman running TOWARD Jesus . I read it every day despite an extremely busy schedule because I believe it is important for the sake of Kingdom building to which I have been called.
I have lost count at the number of times I’ve been able to have Christ-centered dialogue with non-Christians simply because I read the same article they did in The New York Times.
Thank you for this post.
P.S. Did you see Tim Keller’s interview in The Atlantic? Somewhere – years ago – I wrote down the periodicals that Keller reads weekly. I believe Rolling Stone was one of them. 🙂
Staci Thomas
I’m halfway through it and I highly recommend it. So far, I think it is his best yet. Chapter 1 is stuck to me like dried pancake batter than I can’t chisel off; I’ve read it three times. My kids think it very cool that he, as he says, “borrowed” the title from the Harry Potter series.
BTW, the Westminster Seminary Bookstore has it 60% off this week only.
Randy Greenwald
On my list.
And to prove that he is not an idol, he was here, talking about his book, and signing copies, and I did not attend.
That or a forgot to put it on my calendar.
Jenny
Very interesting. I identify greatly with today’s blog. My favorite news comes via the radio (ie: NPR). I am often amazed how much the phrase “I heard it this morning on NPR….” can open great conversations with complete strangers and non-believing family members, while at the same time it can shut down most most post-church service chit chat.
Randy Greenwald
That’s the thing. Why is it that people in the church have such a weird relationship with what I think are highly reliable news sources? And why is Fox the darling of the conservatives if it is really ‘Fair and Balanced’? Ah, keep disrupting people’s worlds with your ‘NPR’ talk. That’s a good thing.
anonymous
I’ve heard the shrill voice of doubt: “God won’t love you because…” or “Do you really believe…?” It’s the accuser.
Then Jesus in a quiet voice – like a mother lowering her voice so her children will pay attention to hear her – says, “I will never leave you”; or, “Nothing can separate you from the love of God which is in Christ Jesus our Lord.”
Then comes mercy, peace, and love, multiplied. Cf Jude 2
Ruth Anne McDowell
Mercy, what would expect from a besotted Emma Thompson fan?? She is pretty marvelous, isn’t she?
Ruth Anne McDowell
I. e. What would ‘one’ expect…
Randy Greenwald
Guilty as charged. I confess.
Jenifer
Glad you shared!
Doesn’t let you walk? Its impressive that you are running the whole thing, Randy! At least, I’m impressed! Glad you shared.
Siobhan
I love your title. Don’t worry that you don’t feel like a perfect parent. I was a teacher for three years and I always found that the parents who were sure that their parenting was beyond reproached were the ones who had the most obnoxious or damaged children!
Randy Greenwald
Thanks for the encouragement!
Ruth Anne McDowell
Amen! Here’s to being earthworms…grace upon grace.
Jenny
Honestly Randy, I sometimes feel the most inadequate when I look at Kye and he is SUCH a handful at only 16mo. I lose my cool. My methods aren’t working. Then I feel so quilt ridden that this child deserved to be adopted by a better person than me. I feel like maybe he lost out on the “adoption wheel of fortune.” Today I feel like your previous blog on the “voices” fits me in my single-parenting mode.
Randy Greenwald
Nah. Actually I think Kye won the adoption Power Ball Lottery. He’ll think so too, someday. But he will also do everything in his power to keep YOU humble!
Jeff
You’re not going to believe this, but I have taken up the challenge. I ran on Saturday and again this morning!
Randy Greenwald
Good plans are online. I’ve found that you don’t need to hire a ‘spunky lady’!
Jeff
Love Anne Lamott’s stuff. Earthy and real, like life.
Randy, I will often share your wisdom with others when I am reminded of what you said: “Most of my parenting challenges come upon me suddenly and without warning!” That one resonates every time. Thanks for your ongoing & steadfast encouragement bro…
Randy Greenwald
I’ll go down in history for that one comment. The rest of life is not worth living… My contribution is complete. 🙂
Jenifer Hanson
Thanks for sharing. Sobering, isn’t it?
Randy Greenwald
Very much so.
Eva
I teach in one of Seminole County’s public schools–one that happens to be in the absolute wealthiest part of the county. Yet, there are homeless children in my school, as well as students who have a home but no food to eat, no lights on, or heat in the winter time. And it is not just the students. Recently, I learned that one of my fellow teachers was choosing between eating and keeping her lights on. She works full time but can’t afford the cost of living on her salary. I know there are many skeptics when we hear about those who are homeless, but every day I see the hidden truth of the struggles people in our area face. And all too often, there are children involved.
Adri
Words of selection # 5 seem especially fitting in this situation; but it’s too late now. 🙂
Jenifer Hanson
Yeah, Randy!
Love your music selections! “Gonna Fly Now” is the theme from Rocky, and is especially fitting as I am flying off to Philadelphia in the morning. I hope to run up the Rocky steps at the Art Museum, which my hotel’s FAQ page informs me are a pleasant 30 minute stroll straight down the street!
Randy Greenwald
Sounds like fun, Jenny, but you can’t STROLL to the Art Museum, can you? Don’t you have to RUN and then reach the top of the steps in triumph?!
Staci Thomas
This is too funny! I’m going to steal some of them for my race tomorrow.
What an accomplishment to go from couch to 5.02K! That is very impressive!
Staci
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, but my shins are not impressed. Not in the least. I need new shoes, but don’t want to shell out the money for them. This is called a dilemma, I think.
Staci Thomas
Actually, there have been several recent studies/articles saying the cheap running shoes are just fine for runners, and that they don’t make too much of a difference in terms of injuries. Go figure. The magic treatment for shins is Alieve and bags of frozen vegetables (or ice) on them as you sit and watch movies. Works miracles, I tell ya.
Randy Greenwald
I like the sitting and watching movies part…
Eva
Oh, NO! We might be in trouble!
Mike
I hear ya, man. It’s not just news. My beloved Twins have moved all telecasts to a cable only station, eliminating Sunday games on TV via a local station. Guess I’ll be getting some fresh batteries for that old transitior radio. Oh well. At least THIS blog is still free to read! Thank God!!!
Randy Greenwald
I’ve been meaning to say something about that… 🙂
Jenifer Hanson
Randy, perhaps you should ask loyal readers for donations to help your content stay current and of high quality. I mean, if you stop reading a paper of the Times’ caliber, should we expect the content of your musings to reflect less well researched sources?!
Randy Greenwald
Oooh. Now that’s tempting. But then I’d feel this sense of responsibility. And then I’d worry about offending my contributors. And my content would be diluted. So, I’d better not go that route!
TulipGirl
That stupid marshmallow study. . .
Adri
Put it on your birthday/Christmas wish list.
Michael Sacasas
One can get 20 articles for free each month it seems. Also, for fun:
http://www.vanityfair.com/online/daily/2011/03/behind-the-paywall-how-new-york-times-articles-end.html
Randy Greenwald
Well, thanks, Mike. It seems, according to the Times, that I read UNDER the 20 article limit/month, so, for now, I’m FREE! Yeah!
TulipGirl
I had the kindle app on my blackberry . . . and really liked to for reading in the odd moments of waiting, or reading when I couldn’t fall asleep at night.
I no longer have my bb (withdrawal!) and do miss having an e-book at the ready. And with so many of the kids’ school books available in e-formats, I’m really thinking about getting a kindle. As we still had to leave 15 boxes of books in storage in the States, and as we have a plenty of room in our home but few bookshelves. . . I’m starting to think that it might be a good idea to adapt to technology with our current lifestyle.
I’m torn. . .
Staci Thomas
Received a Kindle as my 40th birthday present. I mark, highlight, and make notes all over the e books. I love the thing more than I ever thought I would. And I’m spending lots less on e books that I was spending buying the hard copies. I carry it EVERYWHERE, which is also much easier than lugging around the tote bag of books that I used to lug around. 🙂
Geoff Henderson
For everyone I’ve talked to who has a kindle, I’m hearing good things. However I’ve been looking at book prices lately and I’ve actually not seen THAT much of a difference in ebooks. Maybe a dollar here and there. Am I missing something? I’m in the middle of trying to decide myself. Tough decision.
Randy Greenwald
Wow. Kindle is bigger than Rob Bell!
Geoff, I’d perhaps change your first line to: “Everyone I talk to has a Kindle.” It’s seeming to be like that. And here, at the local SBUX, the Kindle or the iPad are ubiquitous. But your question is a good one. I don’t think there is an economy, though I would hate to take on a VT engineer on that question.
But I would concur that lugging is an advantage. I have the Kindle app on my iPhone and have read a couple books on it. Being portable and, like the other night when awakened in the middle of the night, being able to read like a kid in the dark is great.
But my main problem (other than loving to display books read on a shelf, like trophies) is the marking. Perhaps the Kindle has greater functionality here than my poor iPhone imitation. But can one put smiley faces, or frowns, or exclamation points, or duel angry question marks, in the margins? Can you circle important works, or really important words with deeply pressed double circles? Can you put vertical lines or horizontal lines, and combinations thereof? And can you return to scan the pages to see the places where the author most seriously grabbed your emotions? These are serious questions – that’s how I interact with a serious book, and I can’t see how it’s possible on a Kindle.
However, knowing how I can ALWAYS find some way to justify technology, I’ll eventually get one. I just know it.
Geoff Henderson
Yeah I do like to mark up books. I return to them less often than I should or would like to though. I guess what seems to be selling me is the non-tech, even non-facebook people who have embraced them.
Just like getting a flat screen TV, I’ll probably drag my feet for years before getting one.
Chris in NM
And here is another from a friend who is both an author and a missionary in Slovakia:
http://the-lundgaards.com/?p=2143
I guess it needs to go on my netflix queue.
Seth
Christian virtue: don’t think ‘Do Good Stuff’, but think on Jesus. And how best to love your neighbor.
Randy Greenwald
If anyone would be up to the challenge, you would be! Now, do you think you could fit my comments in there as well? Thanks!
Staci Thomas
But the knowing the rule are so much easier! (she whines)
Thanks for this. Read this book a while ago, but I had forgotten the quote. I appreciate your reminder very, very much.
Randy Greenwald
Absolutely. The rules are, or can be, so much easier. And, as Wright acknowledges, very helpful in their place.
Staci Thomas
Very articulate thoughts on this. Thank you.
I’m so troubled that some of the well known leaders are name calling, but it was encouraging to see Keller simply post his thoughts on hell WITHOUT the “He’s a heretic!” stuff.
John Wilson had an Op-Ed in Friday’s Wall Street Journal that wasn’t very specific, but he did point out that this is an issue that needs to be brought to the Evangelical table of discussion.
I do hope you read it and share you thoughts on it!
Randy Greenwald
As I have opportunity, I would like to speak to those voices who are claiming that the evangelical church is embarrassed about hell and therefore not speaking about it and that opens the door to heretical voices. My take is rather that the evangelical church has spoken too hard on hell with little room for grace and THAT has prompted voices to speak an alternative vision. Rob Bell is not writing his book because NO ONE thinks anymore about hell, is he? I rather think not.
Jeff
Even scarier: to think that my listeners might actually put my words into practice!
Staci Thomas
I hear a book in “My take is rather…”
Go write, find an editor, and a publisher!
Randy Greenwald
…and an audience. And right now, step 1 would be VERY hard, step 2, available at a price, step 3, clearly impossible apart from step 4. But I couldn’t even hurdle step 1. Sigh.
Staci Thomas
“Eeyore was saying to himself, ‘This writing business. Pencils and what-not. Over-rated, if you ask me. Silly stuff. Nothing in it.’ ” – from Winnie the Pooh, by A. A. Milne
Randy Greenwald
You are making this up, right?
jenion
Amen, Pastor Greenwald!
Staci Thomas
No, I’m not making it up. I’m not nearly funny enough to come up with something so INCREDIBLY appropriate. 🙂
Staci Thomas
You write, “Hell has been so gracelessly presented over the past generations…” I agree. However, aren’t people turned off by hell because, well, IT’S HELL, for goodness sake. Not a whole lot of happy feelings are associated with it, you know? I think it’s pretty easy to end up comparing going to hell with not going to hell and that’s where the graceless presentations pop up.
So, here’s my question to you: how do we present hell to non Christians in a grace-filled way? Where should the focus be in those particular discussions so that we don’t inadvertently end up preaching fire and brimstone?
Randy Greenwald
Great question Staci. My attempt at an answer is here:
http://www.cpconline.net/resources/multimedia/details/?id=95358
That
1) it is not the caricature we have grown up hearing.
2) it is the natural consequence of choices we make to escape God
3) it is what Jesus had to endure to make relationship with God possible
You can tell me if I succeed, and if I don’t, push me a bit. You’re a beast.
Rebecc
Sometimes it is simply how much you have slept, how hydrated you are, what you ate for lunch the day before and a myriad of other physical, emotional and psychological influences on your body. What people fail to remember is that our bodies are not machines, they are highly organized living organisms that react to our environment and psyche in a very complex way.
One of the things that I love about being a yoga practitioner is that there is an acknowledgment that your abilities and your body’s thresholds of strength, flexibility, etc. are extremely variable and change from day-to-day. Some days I can almost touch my toes, and others I am lucky to be able to touch my knees 🙂 But regardless of what I can do or how I feel, I can always find something to do on the mat that makes my body better, stronger and healthier.
Maybe on the days you can barely run you should just take a walk?
Randy Greenwald
“…our bodies are not machines…”
Now that is wisdom! Obvious, but really full of wisdom. The complexity of the human body is amazing and I really should celebrate the days it all comes together and not bemoan the days it doesn’t.
But just walk? What would I do with my pride, then? Oh, wait, that’s another category altogether.
jenion
I listened to your sermon, the first I’ve heard from anyone in a while. Thanks for posting the link, Randy! I think you hit the nail on the head when you said the rebellious, untamed heart is the real issue. Or maybe I think that because I have such ambivalence within my own rebellious, untamed heart. In either case, as a listener I thought your arguments were well presented — you managed not to “scarify” hell while presenting it as a real consequence of choices we make. The God you speak of is multifaceted enough to be both loving and capable of allowing Hell.
Randy Greenwald
That’s high praise, Jenny. Thanks.
Geoff Henderson
Good point Randy. Nice Redemptive-Historical approach to heaven’s population.
Seth
I would have paid handsomely to have seen your face had Uncle Jerry pulled it off…
ChrisinNM
What a wonderful story! I never knew Roger (only met him briefly at your wedding, but Jerry still looks the same. You are making me long for my family… the siblings or the kids/grandkids. Either will do!
TulipGirl
*grin*
Y’all really have such a family resemblance!
Carol Arnold
I so agree. We used to use nice big loaves of round French bread, tearing off chunks. Then someone complained about “eating what others had touched!” (But maybe all those people have left.)
Carol Arnold
You’re the “baby” in this photo? I would have never guessed!
Randy Greenwald
Yes – a ‘big baby’!
Seth
It reminds me of an ad campaign with an iconic tagline: “I’m not just the President of Hair Club for Men, I’m a client.” While this may sound corny and has been ridiculed world wide, I’m sure it rang true for many insecure men, who drew strength and dignity from one man’s honesty and vulnerability.
Randy Greenwald
Interesting connection. But I think you are right – this is in the same vein.
Mike
“a story of the rule-keeping Pharisaical control-freak coming face to face with the grace of the gospel”
Now I have to explain to my coworkers why I’m laughing hysterically while sitting alone in my cubicle, supposedly working.
Randy Greenwald
Ha! I hope you gave them a good explanation!
Geoff Henderson
Jean Larroux is definitely in my Top 5 preachers. I have only heard him once at Huntsville, but I love that joker!
anonymous
That is a bummer! I read it some time ago, enjoyed it, and believed it to be true. Recently passed it on to a child who wants to read it. Call me Disappointed.
Randy Greenwald
Takes something away, doesn’t it, to find that you have been duped. I’m just afraid that soon, someone will expose The Lord of the Rings as fiction. That would be a grave disappointment.
Adri
In a similar vein is The Price of Stones by Twesigye Jackson Kaguri, a Christian who with his American-born wife built schools in his native village (and surrounding villages) of Uganda. We also saw a remote video lecture from a Christian college with him telling their story. If I ever learn that parts are fiction, I’ll indeed be very sad.
By the way: I think you need a reality check on Tolkien’s works. 🙂
–ae
Randy Greenwald
You are asking me to doubt the history of Middle Earth?
Eva
I heard an interesting interview about this on NPR (although I forget who they were interviewing.) The point that was made is that in today’s market, fiction is hard to sell. People are buying nonfiction and memoirs more than fiction, so publishers are not seeking works of fiction. For this reason, authors of good stories are intentionally (or, sometimes at the prodding of the publisher) making a good work of fiction appear to be a memoir. I can understand this. I am, however, disturbed that Mortenson may have been making a huge profit off of his charity. I don’t know that he did, and I hope that any money that did come in was funneled to those in need. I read his book and enjoyed it.
Randy Greenwald
You can understand it, as can I. But is it okay to pass off fiction as memoir as long as huge profits are not made?
Rebecc
I actually think it wouldn’t be hard. In many places there are trees that grow right up to the rim and if you were driving off-road or something like that you could easily go right to the edge. If you are not paying attention, are under the influence or controlled substances or it is dark, it would be even easier.
TulipGirl
That is disappointing. . . the world is so broken. . . there is no need to exaggerate and fictionalize the brokenness. . . especially when it can be a call to reflect God in reaching out to help bring redemption and restoration.
I bought the book to read the last time I went to visit my grandmother, forgetting that I never actually get to read on those visits, which are always good but tiring.
David F. Ridenhour
thanks, Randy, for posting this. These are good things to remember, as I myself found my heart ripped with mixed emotions this morning, as the clamor on both sides tried to make sense of this. grace & peace to you…
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, David. I don’t, of course, expect everyone to agree with my take. But I’m glad one has!
David F. Ridenhour
we should chat sometime. we have many a mutual friend down there at CPC. I think we are friends on facebook…. drop me a note and perhaps we can talk in a medium that even Mike Sacasas would agree constitutes “talking”.
Michael Sacasas
David, that must mean you’re going to be in Orlando soon. : )
Mike
Brilliant! Well said. Thank you.
Mike
P.S. I hope you don’t mind, but I shared a link to this blog today on my Facebook wall. I hope everyone who sees it will read it. Take care, my friend. Again, thank you.
Randy Greenwald
I appreciate your confidence and kindness. Of course I don’t mind. Thanks.
Diego
Thanks Randy for such a well written post. In spite of the death of Bin Laden, my thoughts focused on the woman that was used as a human shield. She too died in the raid, even though people were not celebrating that, it was also a part which receives a passing note of the whole event. Her death got bulldozed over his death. It is things like that and others that make this whole thing very unpalatable to me. Yes I do feel better that justice was done, but I see no reason to “celebrate” in it. We are still at war, our men and women are still out there and I hope and pray that they are brought home as soon as possible.
David F. Ridenhour
thanks for this, Randy.
chrisinnm
Ahh. One of my old favorites.
Eva
Great song!
Chris in NM
Amen and amen!
Chris in NM
Rejoicing and crying with you. What a picture this is of God’s providential moving of men and events. And i know what a blessing you are to both places, to all the people who have been blessed to sit under your preaching. (And some of us sit there occasionally virtually, and are blessed!)
Wishing we could have a cup of tea together, and good talk.
Randy Greenwald
I’m ready for that cup of tea, coffee, or whatever. Tell us when and where!
Jenny
I am crying as I read this post. Responses swirl in my head, but none come out coherently. So much of who I am today was formed and molded by God’s gracious utilization of the people of Hope Pres. My very faith is a product of the love and interest of the body of Christ in that small church in Bradenton. How do you simply say “thank you” for lives invested in the very core of yours?
I certainly get overlapping worlds as well – how do I even try to explain that my childhood pastor is now my husband’s good friend, who allowed my husband to be his intern in Bradenton, but now pastor’s our seminary church in Oviedo. – see confusing isn’t it?
Randy Greenwald
Tears are appropriate, Jenny.
Of course, you know that Cowpers original lyrics read, “God moves in a weird way…” but that his buddy Newton rejected that on poetic grounds.
He tried “confusing” too, but settled on “mysterious”.
chrisinnm
Hope you had a wonderful time! Can’t wait to hear some stories and see some photos…
We are not having such a good time here, but are secure in God’s hands. 🙂
tulipgrrl
Glad you renewed your domain name! This week was our reminder to renew Hubby’s. . . the one that has been dormant for 6 years. . . but we do it anyway, just ’cause we don’t want any creepy people owning it.
Missed y’all. . .l though I always love the camping pics and stories.
jenion
I think you SHOULD go for the 10K! (Sorry, I’m not one to talk you out of it, even though I’m not a runner and won’t be any time soon!). I’m riding one day of the famous RAGBRAI (week long bike ride across Iowa) – 75 miles from Grinnell to Coralville, IA on July 29. Sunday, I experienced an I-A.R.M. Amazing what clouds, thunder and lightening do for your time when a safe, dry place is just over 10 miles away! Congrats on being back to running.
Randy Greenwald
If you are half as encouraging to the students you work with as you are to me, they are specially blessed.
Chris in NM
So glad it didn’t become a F.A.R.T.
Randy Greenwald
And here I was trying to keep this a family friendly blog…
dwightdolby
Well, I obviously need a “G.T.B.M.” (get-to-bed-motivator), but I’m on vacation and very little motivates us when we are in such a state. However, contemplating a 10K run means something is going in the right direction for someone. And just to consider that – is moving me toward the stairs. I’m always glad to read your blog, even if its the last thing I do (like tonight). Happy trials, I mean- trails!
Randy Greenwald
Happy trials – sounds like a sermon title! As to GTBM, I can’t help you there. And 10k? New gal at church just ran a 50K run in Kansas. Ugh.
Jenifer Hanson
Beautiful photos! It was 101 with high humidity here yesterday, close to the same today. I am training for my 75 mile bike ride and rode for 5 hours yesterday (2 today). I’m beginning to think that old people taking up energetic sports isn’t such a good idea after all! (AARP has sent me my discount card, so I qualify as old, right?)
Randy Greenwald
A gal in our church just returned from Kansas, where she ran a 50k race. Inconceivable.
Burn the AARP card. Pretend it does not exist. But accept senior discounts when offered…
Adri
To Jenifer – and Randy — RAGBRAI is interesting. Being an Iowa gal I can tell you what the acronym means. Have never participated but have seen the cyclists whiz through my hometown on a July 4 weekend a few years ago.
Scott Kroeger
Dr. R. Laird Harris used to say, “Red letter editions…bad theology!”
Randy Greenwald
Apparently not many listened to him!
Chris in NM
More’s the pity about not listening to Dr, Harris. We had a terrible time several years ago finding an inexpensive pew bible edition that was NOT red letter. Amen from me!
Kedric
“It is doing despite, not only to the Spirit of God, but also to Jesus himself, to regard the teaching of the Holy Spirit, given through the apostles, as at all in ferior in authority to the teaching of Jesus.” — Machen
rubiescorner
The word “hell” caught my eye. I read your article because I wanted to see what you would say about it. Please continue writing.
dwightdolby
I appreciated your post as I hadn’t heard of his death or his particular influence on your life. As is often the case, I find your reflections informative and helpful. Thanks for writing.
chrisinnm
I love that boy of yours. Praying with you all.
Mike
Amen!
Roberto
I’m sorry. I don’t know what these links are. I copied and pasted into my browser, then it asked me to download something. I did. Clicked on the download and finder said i don’t have anything to open it with (i have scrivener installed on my mac). am i missing something?
Randy Greenwald
I’m sorry. They are supposed to be. Let me look into it.
Roberto
I’m lost. finder asks me what program to open with, and scrivener is not listed there as a possibility. are these the templates?
Randy Greenwald
I’m so sorry about the difficulty. But thanks for letting me know. The update in the post should take care of the problem. At least it worked for me. Please let me know if it does for you.
Hope this is worth your effort.
Roberto
ah…yes, that worked for me. opened up nicely in scrivener. honestly, i’m such a newbie at this that it is my misunderstanding. so thanks for your patience with me, brother. I will be perusing this for the rest of the day. very excited. thanks for the help.
Randy Greenwald
You are very humble – but this was not your fault. It was my haste.
Jeff Brewer (@jnjbrewer)
Thanks so much for your time– I’m looking forward to giving it a try next week!
TulipGirl
I –love– scrivener! (Thanks to you, I know about it and use it.)
Hubby just (re)downloaded the beta windows version today. It is a little frustrating for us non-mac people to have to keep downloading it. . . once it is out of beta and for sale we’ll DEFINITELY be buying it.
Staci Thomas
HAHAHAHAHAHA! Love it. That’s hilarious!
TulipGirl
There is one road not far from where I live, where — for just a few kilometers — it feels like I’m driving down SR 64 in B’ton. I like that.
Oddly, it is the only place here that feels like the US in any way to me.
Geoff Henderson
“I firmly believe that the whole church is under obligation to obey its Lord’s commission to take the gospel to all nations. But I am also concern that we should not regard this as the only instruction which Jesus left us. (29)”
I totally agree with this statement even though some folks wouldn’t like this. Some folks think a little too reductionistically (probably not a word) and want to find single unifying pictures of what the church must look like. Jesus last words seem to be the best place…But I think this is an error. Is the church only to make disciples? I’m not sure that caring for the poor fits very easily into that paradigm. Yet that was a marker of what a saved person looks like according to other words of Jesus. I haven’t read Horton’s more recent book but I wonder if he elevates these words above other words of Jesus…If he doesn’t, I’ve seen plenty of others who do.
Seth Greenwald
Amy says for them to read “For Women Only” and “For Men Only” by Shaunti Feldhann. I say to read “Go Dog Go” by Dr. Seuss. It reminds us to always like the hat.
Randy Greenwald
Actually, all three are great suggestions!
chrisinnm
I really like Paul Tripp’s book, What Did You Expect?: Redeeming the Realities of Marriage which you can see here: http://www.amazon.com/What-Did-You-Expect-Redeeming/dp/1433511762
It is winsome and gospel-saturated about the realities versus the dream. Excellent for the early years.
Stephanie
I agree with the Tripp suggestion. I know that’s surprising.
Staci Thomas
Marriage Builder, by Larry Crabb
What Did You Expect?, by Paul Tripp
Love and Respect, by Emerson Eggerichs (some helpful stuff in here, though I wasn’t 100% sold on the entire thing)
Lost in the Middle, by Paul Tripp (great stuff in here, helpful to marriage)
and
Tim Keller’s new book on marriage is being released November 1st!
David F. Ridenhour
I concur with everything Staci recommended. As usual, my bibliophile friend is more on top of the reading list than I…
Randy Greenwald
Don’t you mean ‘biblio-holic’ friend? 🙂
Rebecca
having recently walked down this path there are 3 books that we read that were very helpful in forming a Biblical view of marriage and each other:
Sacred Marriage by Gary Thomas (one to read and re-read)
When Sinners Say I Do by Dave Harvey
Each for the Other by Bryan and Kathy Chapell
while Jon and I decided in the end to not get married, all three of these books helped us to view our relationship and God in a much more Biblical light and challenged us to truly love each other with the love of Christ.
Adri
We agree with Chris and Staci re Paul Tripp; we watched the video series, and have passed it on/recommended it to others.
–ae
chrisinnm
People like John put me to shame: it is pretty easy to preach at people from a safe distance. I know in B&E’s old church in Bloomington, they saw several babies born to believing mothers because of the ministry of of several godly women, praying and preaching outside the Planned Parenthood offices there every week for years. I am sure God loves these faithful witnesses. It reminds me what a coward I am. May God destroy my complacency, and make me willing to live dangerously for him.
Geoff Henderson
Intimate Allies was solid. I think Allender wrote it. I actually read it before I got myself hitched though.
Stephanie
Ahh, the runners’ high. I once had that, and it felt magnificent. It’ll probably kick in around mile 4. You know… just outside of where you are now.
Randy Greenwald
The operative word is ‘once’. That an ‘just outside’, which is probably where it will stay!
Rebecca
My personal experience (not as a runner, but doing vigorous aerobic exercise/elliptical machine) is that it kicks in between 20-30 min into a workout. It has more to do with sustained elevated heart-rate than mileage. I actually experienced it a lot when I was going to the gym regularly and pushing my heart rate up into the aerobic zone for at least 20-30 min. That meant that I didn’t feel it for the first 20 min or so, hit “the zone” for 20-40 min and then cooled down for 10 min. The final result is lots of endorphins and feeling a little tired, but like you can conquer the world.
Not sure if that is encouragement or not 😉
Rebecca
Btw, if you don’t run with a heart rate monitor, you may want to start. It is invaluable for targeting your workout to the most effective and fruitful pace.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks. Of course, I began to look at monitors that sync with my iPhone and Runkeeper, and my heart stopped beating when I saw the price… 🙂
Rebecca
mine is very basic and doesn’t sync with anything, but I found it for about $30 on Amazon… You could always just enter the info manually 😉
Staci Thomas
My mom told me about Nancy a few weeks ago, having watched/listened to her speak at Piper’s church. She’s coming out with Bible studies for women. They sound wonderful. Here’s hoping that her stuff catches on better than, well, you know….
Adri
Thinking I’m in agreement with Staci –” well, you know….”
–ae
Randy Greenwald
Why am I thinking primary colors and poofy hair?
If you’d like to meet Nancy G up close and personal, she will be speaking here in Winter Springs, at Willow Creek PCA, on September 23, from 7-9 PM.
chrisinnm
Amen.
nateclaiborne
Have you ever read/heard of Gerd Gigerenzer’s book Calculated Risks? I had three statistics classes in college and read this book and have been skeptical of statistical misuse ever since, especially when it comes to ministry stats.
Thanks for your thoughts on this,
Nate
Randy Greenwald
Sounds like a fascinating book. Thanks.
Jenny
Thanks for this posting Randy. I find it fascinating. I’m not well read or studied in this topic, however I find your closing statement to be one that keeps ringing in my ears!
Kedric
Good stuff. I’ll try to read through some of those links. It reminds me of when I’ve heard people say, “I’m concerned about the church.” It’s such a broad statement you may as well say, “I’m concerned about the Atlantic Ocean” or “I’m concerned about Asia.” A little specificity, please.
Randy Greenwald
I have been worried a bit about that Ocean thing… 🙂
Kevin
Dewpoint is the measure of humidity in the air. Technically, it is the temperature at which dew (or frost) will form. E.G. Dewpoints in the 70s are more humid than dewpoints in the 60s.
Relative humidity just measures the dewpoint against the actual temperature, so it will be lower during the heat of the day (75 dewpoint against 95 temperature), but often gets to 100% at night, causing dew.
Dewpoint is the more useful number, but of course, the one you will rarely hear in a weather report.
Randy Greenwald
Hey, thanks! I’ll have to pursue this a bit. Sounds like the number I was looking for.
chrisinnm
This is very cool! And do you remember David and Amy Lawrence (they were at Tim’s wedding, formerly on NM, now in MD at Johns Hopkins Jet Propulsion Lab)? David works on moon stuff, and I wonder if he has an instrument aboard this rocket. Fun!
TulipGirl
Wow, how fun! Enjoy!
Mike
Thanks Randy. Great message today! As one of those lost souls, who at 51+ years of age has NOT heard my calling, I find it frustrating that ‘Christians’ feel it’s remotely necessary to tell me to “follow God’s plan.” I would, gladly, if I knew what IT was!!! In the mean time, just pray with me, worship with me, and teach me. That’s what Jesus did.
You are not mistaken. Stay the course. PLEASE!
TulipGirl
“These I toss into the pile of the dozens and dozens of false inferences from the Bible that I can never directly address. It may be a mistake, but I decided some time ago that I cannot answer every false Christian claim in my preaching, so I won’t try. I will write and speak and preach the truth as I understand it, arising form the best practices of interpretation, and let it stand.”
“This may be a mistake. I am making the assumption that the truth expressed through a demonstrated proper method of handling the Scriptures will strengthen people against falsehood. I am also assuming that a ministry of positive affirmation is a healthier diet for God’s people than a ministry of negative confrontation. ”
This is beautiful. And truly needed.
Even though I get on my soapbox from time to time, what I need to hear from the pulpit is the Gospel expounded from Scripture.
Randy Greenwald
But… this may be simply an excuse for being intellectually lazy combined with a lack of courage. What I have found is that people do not tend to make the connection between the gospel and their pet position without being specifically told, and even then, the pet position, because it is so deeply ingrained, may not budge. But thanks for your encouragement!
Jenifer Hanson
I usually reply to your longer posts, the ones with more commentary. But I loved this one. Thanks!
Randy Greenwald
It’s the kind of post you would expect from a blog called “SOMBER and Dull”. 🙂
Good to hear from you again, by the way!
chrisinnm
We have preacher in the evening here.:-) We decided some time ago to discuss the sermon in our Sunday evening Fellowship time. So we read again the text, and one of the elders leads us through a discussion, sometimes adding pertinent scriptures of other quotes they have found in their afternoon study. One of the cool things that has happened here is that most of us at fellowship, now take notes during the sermon, and bring them to share on Sunday evening. We have sometimes called Henry in the afternoon or caught him after church to clarify things. This is a great way to meditate on God’s word and to have the chance to think about practical application of what we’ve heard. And it has never degenerated into serving up the pastor… So I thought I would share this way of meditating on the preaching we hear.
Randy Greenwald
Sounds like a great plan, Chris. Thanks for sharing.
Adri
It’s not only pastors-in-training that you recommend books to. 🙂
Kedric
Sure enough, we read Chapell in deacon/elder training. Follow the money trail… 🙂
Randy Greenwald
…if you can find a money trail. I WISH there were a money trail.
Rebecca
Love that last quote. That speaks to a struggle that I had once with a pastor’s preaching. I finally realized that the issue was that even though he spoke the truth of the Gospel, it was in the context of telling people how to live, rather than why Christ died.
brown88
I missed hearing the sermon on the 9th because I was working in preschool church. So I look forward to catching up on what I missed!
TulipGirl
That’s so cool. . . Really.
Rebecca
What a beautiful gift!
Adri
Neat!
Connie
Wonderful!
Randy Greenwald
You guys are so verbose… 🙂 But it was all of the above.
Jim Adams
It was our pleasure!
Mike
We forgive you! Thanks Randy. I’ve enjoyed this vey much.
Stephanie
I’ll start. It is my earnest belief that the Church has pet sins, a few of which you’ve brought up. I have begun to feel like they, ironically, are our blind spots. We spend so much time making sure that no one thinks we’re too “accepting” of a lifestyle or a choice that is made that we forget that there are actual, real, skin and bones PEOPLE involved here. The women that are being yelled at and having photos of fetuses shoved in their faces at abortion clinics are our daughters and sisters, and they are all-too-often traumatized, hurting, abused, and desperate women who need to see the love of Christ in a gentle, relational hand. The men and women who love other men and women are PEOPLE, seeking acceptance, understanding, love, and relationships. None of these sinners are any more sinners than me, with my selfish, judgmental, over-indulgent, unbelieving ways. They are no more monsters that me, and the Church lets me teach their children, pass out their bulletins, and serve their food. All the while they would seek to shield their children’s eyes from women with unplanned pregnancies and homosexuals.
And on a shorter soapbox, I’m not convinced that the Church of the south can clearly see it’s past blind spots.
(….and exhale…)
keithasnow
What about our eager participation in excessive American consumerism? Not that having things is necessarily the problem, but often we are undiscerning about the types of products we buy, from whom, and how those products (gadgets, food, toys, clothes, etc) came to be. As Christians we could probably do a better job at thinking about how our financial decisions are affecting bigger-picture injustices. For example, shopping at giant retail stores that drive out local businesses, don’t take care of their employees, use sweatshops overseas, etc.
Rebecca
I would say that there are a few areas that seem to be hidden from most Christians as a community: personal sins such as gluttony, vanity, and anger are often seen as less serious or important than sexual sins; human trafficking is on par with slavery of the past and happens in every community but is hardly ever mentioned in churches; the general conflation of conservative politics and unbridled capitalism with Biblical Christianity (I happen to be both conservative and a capitalist, but it is a system created by and operated by broken men just like any other and needs the church to stand firm as a check on immoral and unjust behavior); and I would agree with @keithasnow that consumerism and environmental carelessness both are rampant in especially middle-class Christianity.
But that is just my two cents 🙂
chrisinnm
Like Rebecca, one of the first things that came to mind for me was sexual trafficking. But I also wonder about our adoption of “celebrity culture”, where we idolize certain preachers, singers, teachers, etc. This may be the hidden idolatry of the church.
chrisinnm
Oh my- now there is a frightening prayer to pray– bBut I suspect an excellent one.
Adrianna Espino
Have read all – or nearly all – James’ mysteries. She’s a favorite; may be time to reread one or more.
–ae
Randy Greenwald
You may find that a certain former Canadian friend of ours is a great fan as well. She is the one who put me on to her. What was your James’ favorite?
--ae
Hard to say which is the favorite; it’s been several years that I’ve been reading her.
Probably most memorable is Devices and Desires. That’s probably the first I read; and it was when hubby was away on a business trip. Made the mistake of telling my sons a few details — you can see where this is going. 🙂
As I’d go upstairs to read and then sleep, I’d hear whistling; I think it was “Jesus Loves Me” that the suspected killer whistled in the dark and that was of course what I heard behind and around me. Scary! And not sleep-inducing.
–ae
Jay
At our next TF lunch you’ll have to share a few of your favorites from the 158.
Randy Greenwald
That could make for a really long, and potentially boring (for you), lunch! You might have to order extra tacos.
ae
You didn’t include an additional favorite portion of mine which follows a bit after “Great is your faithfulness.” Cf vs 33 – “for he does not willingly afflict or grieve the children of men.” Personally, I find great comfort in that.
I hope you don’t deem me one who “hide[s] behind abbreviated texts.”
Jenifer Hanson
I can’t imagine a better author of “Theology for Future Presidents” than you. Great idea – go for it!
Randy Greenwald
I appreciate that YOU cannot imagine a better author. I’m afraid that I can imagine several hundred, some of whom might even be able to SELL what they would write! But thanks anyway for the affirmation.
Cry, Beloved Country
1) I, too, took the name of my blog from Cry, the Beloved Country.
2) I think your aversion to Black Friday creep deserves a post of its own.
3) I love your reasons for disliking study Bibles! They are mine as well, but I’ve never heard anyone else but me give them.
You nailed the two biggest reasons. In a somewhat smaller font I would also add that most study Bible notes have a maddening tendency to act as if there is One Right Answer even in situations where the writers of the comments have to know good and well that theirs is one opinion among several that can be held amongst people who love the Lord and accept the authority of Scripture.
*And* (smaller font yet) they clutter up pages with stuff I already know and neglect to address that passage in [well, actually, there are several books I could insert here] that has driven me to distraction over the years!
ae
Glad to wake up and realize I was reading your blog. I thought I’d stumbled upon a new Food Network program!
Randy Greenwald
Trying not to be too dull. Or somber.
Adria
The red one made your eldest daughter very happy, and you should have seen me scouring the house and getting rather panicky when the batteries died. Adria
Randy Greenwald
See. Kitchen scales have the added benefit of leading to house scouring. Sounds clean. 🙂
ae
Being forewarned = no first of the morning coffee spewed onto the computer keyboard and screen. Thanks for the laughs!
Reminds me of a used book on my shelf: White Trash Cooking (1986), featuring such items as potato chip sandwich, which of course includes mayonnaise; Oozie’s okra omelet; Russian Communist tea cakes; chicken feet and rice; and last but not least Our Lord’s scripture cake: the references are all from the Old Testament.
Next time we visit, we can share a laugh over the recipes and the full color photographs.
Randy Greenwald
Can’t wait to see it. So, does the “next time we visit” have a date attached to it?
jenion
Read this entry while still under the covers, lights off. Laughing out loud=great way to start a cold Thursday morning (with chance of snow)!
Randy Greenwald
For sure, a great way to start the day. Although I’m not sure about the in-the-dark part. Still. Hope you come back to it time and again for renewed delight. And now, go put a banana on your cereal like I did.
chrisinnm
LOL! Those pictures are horrendous. Just goes to show you that we, as people, are a varied bunch…
Jenny
I am laughing so hard tears are running down my face, and I need to redo my mascara!!!
Lloyd Dawson
Thanks for the laugh 🙂 This was hilarious, just the laugh I needed today!
Randy Greenwald
Kinda unbelievable. I’ve been wondering if it was a hoax, but if it is, it’s a funny one.
ae
Suggested alternate title for this post: “How to multi-task on your Monday morning run.”
Enjoyed your archeological findings. Whose is the last one? 😉
–ae
Jenny
1st pic – “You this rug really doesn’t match my Christmas decor at all, (and ever since potty training jr, it’s had a funny smell.)” “Is THAT where the smell is coming from?”
Randy Greenwald
See? Isn’t curbside archeology fun? We can indulge nosiness and be creative at the same time! Win-win!
Mike Kennedy
Thanks Randy. I needed to read this. Hope you’re doing well. Peace, Mike
Randy Greenwald
Other than missing an occasional coffee sit-down, we are doing well!
Rebecca
Thanks for sharing. My roommate Sara and I sat down yesterday and looked at where our time is going and what our priorities are and discussed the things that keep us going when we want to be more quiet and still. It continually amazes me how much I am motivated by a guilt brought on by the expectation of others when they never even said anything about my response times, or the amount of time I spend with them, etc.
We both also spent some time in confession and acknowledging that so much of our struggle with time (as well as with money and food, etc.) comes directly out of our unwillingness to follow the Holy Spirit moment-by-moment in obedience to Christ, rather than setting our own goals or parameter and pushing ahead according to our own logic and common sense.
It was a very humbling experience, but one full of rejoicing. It is always a joy to find that the Holy Spirit is still prompting you to obedience and that your heart also agrees 🙂
Randy Greenwald
And thanks for sharing your experience. I despair having much success n that direction, but God is a God of wonders. I’ll have some follow up posts to this one – when I get a chance!
Sean Breslin
I think it’s a nice story, and he handled the sudden success well. But I think we all saw yesterday’s loss coming, and if he has an NFL career that finishes with a winning record, we’ll all be surprised again.
Curt Moore
Thanks for your great insight and consistently well thought out Biblical worldview.
Randy Greenwald
Why thank you. But this one is simply a nod to another!
jenion
Wow, a short but a beautiful post. “And let us pray that we all, especially at Christmas, may have a clear vision of a benevolent God’s breaking into this broken world through a Child.” Amen.
Rebecca
Have enjoyed EB White’s essays for years. Very under-appreciated by most people nowadays.
Randy Greenwald
Well, in the final analysis, I find that you are a pretty hard core renaissance woman!
ae
I’m going to slow down; starting now!
Stephanie
Semi-off topic: I, too, struggle with earbuds. May I suggest these: http://www.amazon.com/JBuds-Earbuds-style-Headphones-Tablet-Kindle/dp/B005VEZ58C/ref=sr_1_1?s=electronics&ie=UTF8&qid=1326123488&sr=1-1
There are much cheaper versions all over the place, but they are SUPER comfortable and easily stay in place. 🙂
Randy Greenwald
Should I come to the place where I use them frequently, or have a cause to do so, I’ll keep this in mind. Thanks!
Carolyn
It would be an epic fail if the American people were to make the ginormous mistake of banishing the word “amazing.” What we need to banish is simply its mindless overuse. If you continue to advocate for Really Cool Grace, you run the risk that the idea will go viral, in which case your readers might be forced to start an Occupy Somber & Dull site. It’s high time for you to retreat to your man cave, man up, and come out singing Amazing Grace at the top of your lungs. 🙂
Randy Greenwald
You made my day. This makes us co-conspirators (1993). Together we can git-er-done (2006). For the American People (2011) of course.
Adrianna
I agree wholeheartedly (if that’s not on the banned list) with Carolyn. She just said it far more cleverly than I could have.
I say I’m not buyin’ it – if that’s not also a banned phrase – and I think the list makers did not mean we may never use amazing. If we may not say amazing about God’s grace and love, something is dreadfully wrong. As for me, I plan to continue using the word in that way.
–ae
Geoff Henderson
Looks good. Can’t wait to read it. However, since I just bought a ton of books and an Iphon4s, I may wait a few months and stick with my freebies on kindle…But its been recommended to me by a few folks now!
Randy Greenwald
Do NOT let the Kindle freebies dictate your reading plan! Some good stuff there, but…. No, this is a good one. I commend it to you. And it’s only $10!
Delaney
Ha! I enjoyed this.
Renee
So what was your time? I’m sure you can beat me, but Brian is much faster than I am- I wonder…. 🙂
Randy Greenwald
Oh, so I might also be able to say that I was faster than a ___ year-old woman? Or, shudder, slower? Nope. My time is privileged info. I’ll keep it between me and Parry. 🙂
Adrianna
Ha! Pardon me for LOL! So good to see you get your comeuppance! And that by and “old” person. :>)
–ae
Randy Greenwald
Careful, now. I BEAT the old person, remember. And why is ‘old’ in quotation marks?
jenion
I would have bet on the 16-year old – since when are they considered the underdogs against middle-aged runners?! I will kindly remain silent on your win against Parry!
Randy Greenwald
Your silence is appreciated. I am currently in the process of ‘re-framing’ the experience. I learned that somewhere.
chrisinnmChris in NM
LOL! Thanks for this- it plays before me like a movie!
Randy Greenwald
…in slow motion and with a Vangelis soundtrack, no doubt.
Thomas Ho (@DrThomasHo)
I walk, but ask Laura about her running…she’s remarkable although she’s more “reasonable” than when she was younger!
Kedric
English is the language of Star Fleet in the 22nd century. Though it’s likely because the show was made in an American context, it’s interesting that what has been displayed in science fiction seems to be happening today. And I get much of my info from ST Enterprise.
TulipGirl
How cool is that! I’m geeking out just reading about it. I really, really miss my blackberry and all the good apps on it. (Most US cell/smart phones don’t have sim card slots for use overseas. Ugh.)
Staci Thomas
I’m 41. These questions ring true. I appreciate how you turned the “trapped” thoughts into an encouragement to focus energies in a new way for good.
Randy Greenwald
I cannot take credit for that. I was paraphrasing MacDonald.
Gail Brightbill
You recently posted on how various age groups view life. There was a time when I boycotted Disney and even Kmart with, as you said, no results.
I now have a different perspective that has come with the years. I have mellowed on many things. I agree that an economic boycott aimed at strong-arming a position is not the wise course to take. G
Jeff MacFarlane
I am struck by the straight up courage of men like Tyndale. I just finished reading ‘John Knox’ by Rosalind K. Marshall. Amazing.
Randy Greenwald
Absolutely. Not sure I’d hold up. Their faith was solid, and that infused their courage. Oh, to have a fraction of that faith.
Steve Girnus
Baseball, baseball, baseball – what about hockey stories?
SPG
Randy Greenwald
Because there is no longer anyone around anymore to take me to hockey games and to teach me the finer points of both hockey!
Steve Girnus
Well…………I tried to convert you but you were a tough nut to crack!
Then we should try and do something about that!
Jay
The succinctness and brevity (is that redundant?) of your post wasn’t lost on me. 🙂
Randy Greenwald
Strunk and White, Rule #17: “Avoid needless words.”
chrisinnm
I think *I* need such an editor…
Stephanie
I’m not sure what you were intending to preach on Sunday, but from where I sat, it was an intensely convicting, yet grace-filled discussion. Just sayin.
Jenny
I LOVE HOLLY!!!! Please tell her that I still have such high esteem for her and how much wisdom she imparted to a psycho, terrified, young mommy!
Randy Greenwald
But now you’ve changed. You are no longer young.
I’ll tell her. She is a gem, for sure.
Jenny
PS – I love seeing “Starbucks Kuwait” come up on my checking account. Hmmmmm I know what Kevin’s been up to.
chrisinnm
Amen- and looking forward to Shared Calamity pictures…
Adrianna
Thanks for a timely reminder of what’s most important in life.
Kedric
A lot of it may be a “grass is greener” concept, even in the Reformed world. I saw it while working at Ligonier. Leaders in the public eye are assumed to have more wisdom and more knowledge than the pastor or friend in their local congregation.
chrisinnm
Can’t help you understand here, because I agree with you! The whole idea of “Christian celebrities” is anathama to me, but so prevalent in our media-soaked culture! And I fall prey to it in my favorite authors, favorite musicians, favorite preachers, etc. May God forgive us our idolatry. Our hearts truly are idol factories, and old Jean said…at least I think it was him…
amandalovesmovies
Such an amazing movie. I regularly say things go to eleven. Check out my review http://amandalovesmovies.com/2012/04/12/this-is-spinal-tap/
Gus
This doesn’t intersect any of your lines, and is not even serendipity, but it reminded me of a foto of Einstein and his wife shopping in Panama City, Panama, but I doubt it was covered in his bio!!
Unfortunately for Colin he’ll have to trudge through elemental physics before he gets to the nuclear stuff.
chrisinnm
Praying for excellent and uninterrupted study that will lead to much future fruit for you and your flock.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks for your prayers. Your comment, of course, begs a question: What does fruit in the flock look like?
chrisinnm
I know that’s a rhetorical question, but I won;t let that stop me from answering. :-). I think God is the one who knows that, and it is not easy for us to discern. Perhaps it is part of walking by faith and not by sight to believe that when we do what God calls us to do, He will create fruit even when we are unaware of it. Perhaps it is our vanity that wants to see that fruit all the time, and build a little monument to ourselves out of it. What do you think? And really, I am having this conversation within myself, and applying it to my own calling, lest you feel like I am picking on you…
chrisinnm
Well said, and praying here. 🙂
brown88
A similar, unofficial unit of measurement is the story. One often reads such statements as “The monument is 20 stories tall.” But how high is a story? A general rule of thumb is 10 feet, but this is by no means a standard measure. Lots of buildings have stories much higher than that.
Randy Greenwald
Great point! I was trying to give my son some perspective last night on how far the 10 meter platform was. A three story building was my unit of choice!
Randy Greenwald
So, it says so far that 3 bloggers like this post. I’m heading now over to settings to see if I can block ‘people’ from ‘liking’ a post because these are not anyone who have actually read the post. Software trolls WP looking for some key words which triggers and automatic ‘like’ response as a baited hook to get ME or others of you to return back to their site to see who THEY are, thus increasing traffic to their site. Pretty much irritates me. Honestly at this early hour I doubt if there have been any who have actually READ this post. Most certainly, the three above have not.
Randy Greenwald
Okay. Looks like I was successful in turning that feature off. Now, back to work…
jenion
I actually read your post. Thank you. I have wondered the same thing – though I am no more clear on the answer than you, I am concerned that we keep drawing lines in the wrong places. My nephew, Tim, likes guns and supports the right to own them. Great. I’d trust Tim with any gun he chooses to possess. But I also trust most of us with that bottle of liquid we accidentally packed in our carry-ons – yet, that isn’t allowed on the plane. Statistically speaking, one of these is more likely to cause loss of human life (and in much greater numbers) than the other. Instead of letting fear or abstract notions guide us, let’s be guided by and firmly grounded in the real costs of our choices.
Stephanie
Reminds me VERY much of this song: http://open.spotify.com/track/1DFSIRTpPwiYDZkBi4zWhc
Keith Snow
I have this book on Kindle, but have felt guilty for not taking the time to read it. Great insights here – thanks for writing this. I shall feel guilty no longer…
Randy Greenwald
Well, glad to save you both time and guilt. Quite the two-for-one special. Of course, there are other takes on the same book. To wit: http://geoffsnook.blogspot.com/2010/07/bonhoeffer-completed.html
mkultra76
Science and Faith is a fascinating book. I highly recommend it! Happy reading!
Stephanie
Oooh! What’s Republocrat?!
Randy Greenwald
Subtitled: “Confessions of a Liberal Conservative” I’ll let you know when I get to it…
Kedric
Republocrat was very good. The Trueman show is a good writer and teacher.
chrisinnm
The only one I’ve read is Voskamp. Liked it in places- her voice drove me crazy in other places. Let me know what you think!
I really enjoy reading Carl Trueman, so that should be a great read! I am hoping for reviews as you finish.
I am 75% of the way through Gilead, and savoring every word. 🙂
Randy Greenwald
Glad to hear re Gilead. That she could write so well about what it is like to be a pastor without having been there amazes me.
As for Voskamp her style, her voice, is what has kept me from reading her so far. But recommendations from those I trust continue to push me toward it.
Weird that where I am now I KNOW the authors of five of the books in that stack.
chrisinnm
Happy belated birthday, C!
Orthodox Radical
See, rather hear, also Derek Webb “King and a Kingdom”.
Orthodox Radical
See also, or hear rather, Derek Webb “King and a Kingdom”.
Orthodox Radical
chrisinnm
Amen and amen…
And when you figure out how to live there consistently, can you please let me know how?
Steve Girnus
Amen.
Gail Brightbill
Kudos to Barb, and you Randy, on your successful homeschooling career. Sure seems like long ago and far, far away when we first met at Trails meetings–and it was! The cinnamon buns and tissues are just a small example of your thoughtfulness and care toward others. You’ve set yourselves up for high expectations from the teachers–they’ll be hoping for warm, gooey, soft, moist, cinnamony rolls at every parent-teacher meeting! I’m sending your link to my public school teacher friend who is dedicated to her students–she will appreciate the recognition you’ve given teachers.
The E's
Best wishes and blessings on the three of you – and of course the teachers – as you make this major transition.
How blessed the teachers are to have your child in their classrooms; certainly the cinnamon rolls have already won their hearts. :~)
Kedric
I thought of this blog post after reading this column about Stan Van Gundy in the Sentinel.
http://articles.orlandosentinel.com/2012-09-11/sports/os-mike-bianchi-stan-van-gundy-0912-20120911_1_stan-van-gundy-budget-cuts-quality-schools
Randy Greenwald
Yes, I’m sympathetic.
Eva
THANK YOU, Randy! This post brought tears to my eyes. As a public school teacher, and now a trainer of public school teachers, I so appreciate a post where teachers are not being criticized. We have a funny attitude towards teachers in this country. They are either honored with Teacher Appreciation Week or villified with reports of school failures, student drop-out rates, low international rankings, etc. Teachers jobs aren’t necessarily harder than other jobs out there–but they are critiqued far more than most. (How many times have you read about plumbers being held accountable for the number of drippy faucets in local homes, dentists for the number of cavities their patients have, or lawyers for the number of people being locked up in prison?) Your post hit home. Teachers care! That doesn’t mean we are the best educators in the world–but we want to be! And teachers are working to get there. Recognizing that, and bringing them a tangible way to show your support, was no doubt the highlight of their day.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, Eva. That these teachers care, and genuinely care about my child – that means the world to me. I’m glad this was an encouragement to you. I hope it is to others as well. I think I’m probably saying things that many others feel. Or perhaps after spending 24 years bearing these burdens on our own, we can appreciate more what others may take for granted.
Randy Greenwald
A friend wanted to comment on this post, but was having tech issues, and so sent her comments to me separately. I post them here without comment:
“May I suggest # 7: laugh – or groan – at his outrageous puns/jokes; even blond jokes.”
Adrianna
“The truth is, though, that God never gets edited.”
I love that simple but profound statement!
Kedric
Private Bible reading is usually emphasized more in broadly evangelical/non-denom circles. I say “more” because there is private devotions and spontaneous prayer among more liturgical traditions (see the Book of Common Prayer) that is in addition to what is already in place in the life of the church. The importance of reading through the Bible outside the BCP can be found in devotionals such as Daily Bread, Upper Room and Table Talk. If we put too much emphasis on it, it is in the thought that if a person has not read the Bible today, then they have not really met with God.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks for the reminder of how these emphases are made in other traditions. Something to ponder.
JerryH
Thank you for raising this question. I have recently been wondering “How did christians grow before the printing press?” I am a layman in my church and have been trying to apply sound “lay logic” to the question. Psalm 119 certainly emphasizes to the importance of scripture. But it seems to me that the epistles instruct us to pray more often than to read our bibles. Their recipients would not have owned a bible. Rising early to pray was a daily habit for Jesus but we are not told that he also read his bible every morning. I am not anti-Bible at all; I am a long time Sunday school teacher. But I am concerned that we may be in error to some extent about the role of bible reading in disciple making. If so, what should we do to recapture effective disciple making practices. I sometimes wonder if Sunday school and our emphasis on bible reading are products of modernity’s conviction that “education” is the answer to everything. What was the historical and biblical approach to disciple making?
Do you know of any good books that deal with discipleship before the printing press or how it is done today in illiterate or primitive cultures?
Randy Greenwald
I’m afraid I do not know of any books dealing with this. But the question is a really good one. What was the historical approach to disciple making? I too am not ‘anti-bible’ – I just wonder if we have elevated a measurable thing, bible reading, to a place of disproportionate importance. Thanks for your thoughts.
Stephanie
Yes and no. Daily, private study is a good discipline to have, no doubt. And 20-30 years ago, at least where I’m from, admitting that you don’t have daily “quiet time” was like renouncing the faith. These days, the culture is more likely to be honest about the reality of their daily Bible reading habits because we are no longer a society that holds Christianity as the moral standard (now, whether that is a good or bad thing isn’t the topic here).
So… all that to say, reading our Bibles doesn’t save us. But ask the preschool kids how God speaks to us and they will answer with certainty- “the Bible!” That certainly lends itself to a high priority, I think.
And for the record, I SUCK at daily Bible reading… or weekly Bible reading for that matter.
Randy Greenwald
I’m with the pre-schoolers! Jesus loves me, this I know, for the bible tells me so. My question is this: does the content of the bible come to us through reading alone? To read the alarmists, one would think so, and that if we stop reading the bible we will know longer know God. I wish you were better at bible reading, for sure. I wish you were finding daily delight and encouragement from it. But perhaps bible READING is not the only way in which bible CONTENT comes our way. Perhaps our panic is misplaced? I think so.
Stephanie
Oh yeah, I do think it is. I get the panic, though. I think you’ve probably got this group of mostly conservative, mostly orthodox Christians here who see the devaluing of Scripture happening all around them and panic! I was guilty last week (see Held Evans, Rachel). 😀
thetrigs
Very interesting, Randy. Thanks for your thoughts here. Gives me a lot to think and pray about.
Blessings,
Jessi Trigger
Randy Greenwald
Well, when you are on the other side of your thinking and praying, I’d love to know where that leads you. These are thoughts in process on my end which I’d love to have others engage.
thetrigs
Sounds good. Maybe we can chat over a cup of coffee at Sbux sometime!
Keith Snow
I agree with what you’re saying, Randy. I think the individualism of the secular culture has influenced Christian culture in its emphasis on personal ‘quiet time’. As a result we’ve lost sight of our need for corporate worship and the preaching of the Word. This makes me think of the Second Helvetic Confession’s teaching that “the preaching of the Word of God is the Word of God”:
THE PREACHING OF THE WORD OF GOD IS THE WORD OF GOD. Wherefore when this Word of God is now preached in the church by preachers lawfully called, we believe that the very Word of God is proclaimed, and received by the faithful; and that neither any other Word of God is to be invented nor is to be expected from heaven: and that now the Word itself which is preached is to be regarded, not the minister that preaches; for even if he be evil and a sinner, nevertheless the Word of God remains still true and good…
INWARD ILLUMINATION DOES NOT ELIMINATE EXTERNAL PREACHING. For he that illuminates inwardly by giving men the Holy Spirit, the same one, by way of commandment, said unto his disciples, “Go into all the world, and preach the gospel to the whole creation” (Mark 16:15). And so in Phillippi, Paul preached the word outwardly to Lydia, a seller of purple goods; but the Lord inwardly opened the woman’s heart (Acts 16:14). And the same Paul, after a beautiful development of his thought, in Romans 10:17 at length comes to the conclusion, “So faith comes from hearing and hearing from the Word of God by the preaching of Christ.”
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, Keith, for your helpful thoughts. I’m glad you ‘get’ where I was headed.
I don’t want, however, to isolate preaching as the source of the knowledge of God, either. I’ve seen too often those who believe that the only really valuable part of corporate worship is the preaching. In my mind, the Word is imbibed in the liturgy itself, in the Lord’s table, and in the fellowship of God’s people as they teach and admonish “one another in all wisdom, singing psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, with thankfulness in” their hearts to God (Colossians 3:16), as well as in private study and in the preaching.
Keith Snow
I’m 100% in agreement with you there as well! Why don’t more people think like us? : )
Randy Greenwald
Brilliance, I suppose, is a rare commodity… 🙂
chrisinnm
Praying here, Randy!
Gus and Adri
Here too.
David F. Ridenhour
Randy, I read it would love to talk about it with you! David http://davidfridenhour.com
> >
Randy Greenwald
You are QUICK! Let’s have a cup of coffee over this. You heading this way? 🙂 I’m about 70 pages from the end.
David F. Ridenhour
Coffee may be a stretch, but a phone call/Facetime over an apple device might be both fitting and helpful. And ironic. If that word means anything anymore.
Michael Sacasas
Here’s a review for you (all) to consider after you finish the book. I’ve not read the book, so you’ll have to tell me if it is on target or not:
http://www.tnr.com/article/books-and-arts/magazine/100978/form-fortune-steve-jobs-philosopher
Randy Greenwald
Oh, my. An 11,400 word essay. And he accuses Isaacson of being rather pedestrian? I’m afraid I could not finish it. I could not quite make out the point he was aiming to substantiate and so did not have the patience to persevere. You will have to summarize his conclusions for me. If he intended to show that Jobs was a festival of contradictions, and Apple in his image, that does come through in the bio. It seems, at least in reading half and skipping to the end, that he does go many steps beyond Isaacson in assessing the hidden impact of our religious/cultic devotion to Apple. But apple won and wins my affection by making things that help me do what I want to do, and are beautiful in the process. I look forward to your 100 word summary of his 11,000 word essay.
Sandra Patient
She is now flying with our Angels, Taken way too soon…
Love Always, Sandra Patient
Jenny
Thank you for this post. I have been praying for Caitlin and her family; and I will continue to pray them.
Eugene Wagner
Such a wonderful tribute to Caitlin and the Downing family.
A true testament of the capacity of the human heart, the Downing family, and the wonderful people in Oviedo,
The outpouring of support restores, and supports our collective faith.
Thanks Caitlin for the message, and the lesson.
Now off you go Caitlin to be with the Angels and live in Gods house.
Peace.
The Wagner-Maselli Family
Oviedo, Florida
Jeanne
Thank you Randy,very convicting and just what I needed.
Gail Brightbill
I wholeheartedly agree with your assessment. At one point in the movie I traitorously toyed with the idea of leaving the movie early, but being the loyal hobbit fan that I am, I soon quashed my fool hardy thought. Freeman is perfect for the part of Bilbo and it was good to see old friends from the past.
jenion
You said what I felt. I loved the movie, except for the horribly long goblin and orc scenes. I really enjoyed the ways they echoed and paid homage to the LOTR trilogy movies – but I already saw a company of companions fight their way out of The Mines of Moria, I didn’t need to see an extended remake featuring goblins! Casting was spot-on; my particular favorite is the actor who plays Thorin Oakenshield – don’t know who he is, but I LIKED him 🙂
jenion
Funny! I am of two minds about the snow on WordPress sites. It can be a little distracting when looking at art or photos. Still, it is “seasonally festive” I suppose. Oh, and even if most of the world doesn’t go to your blog, there are a few of us loyal readers out here who miss your posts in the “lean” times 🙂
tulipgrrl
We just returned from seeing the Hobbit. I both liked it and was disappointed. Thankful they kept a lot of the musical themes. Felt happy just hearing the opening score of the Shire music.
Suzanne
Well we all need something to laugh about from time to time. Very funny!
Suzanne Santana
Although I have not read the book, I could not agree with you more wholeheartedly. While I believe we as Christians have good intentions, it seems like we are on a treadmill running at a high speed and cannot slow down, let alone get off. Our lives are filled with activities that we have convinced ourselves are for our own survival, and we cannot even keep up with our own lives, let alone have time to reach out and include others into it. As you stated, letter writing, and petition signing are much easier and require really no commitment. We sign for the cause and go back to running. Somehow this eases our conscience.
Besides the fact that we are too busy, most of us gravitate towards those like us and avoid anything that doesn’t fit our ideas, match our personalities, or would cause us to be uncomfortable. Instead of looking beyond what the eyes can see, we look only at the surface, draw conclusions, and then move on forgetting our real purpose.
We judge by what is visible and then build barriers. In all actuality, since we are selfish creatures of habit, we like what makes us comfortable and doesn’t interrupt our time or cultural beliefs.
The church has the greatest opportunity to make the biggest impact within the community, and the world, but charity begins at home. We have to role model this as Christians with each other. We MUST make time for each other, take time to get to know those that are different within our own congregation, and take the time to share a smile or a hug with those that enter our churches, as well as those that we interact with each day. Once we do that we can move mountains,
Love and actions are more powerful than a thousand pages of signatures.
I think Casting Crowns said it best in their song…
Does anybody hear her? Can anybody see?
Or does anybody even knows she’s going down today
Under the shadow of our steeple
With all the lost and lonely people
Searching for the hope that’s tucked away in you and me
Does anybody hear her? Can anybody see?
Randy Greenwald
What a wonderfully articulate and passionate response. Thanks, Suzanne.
ae
Could you please ask Brightlights to open a branch in Bradenton? Sounds like a place for me. Do they have a website/mailorder service?
Pssst! Don’t let hubby know I asked; he’s trying to downsize….
Randy Greenwald
Dear ae – you will see that Brightlight Books above is underlined, indicating a hyperlink to their web site. As for downsizing, here is how it works. Gather up the books you no longer want, take them to Brightlight. They give you store credit for them, and you can then use that credit to buy stuff. My two Churchill volumes are mine with no $$ changing hands. So, gather the books you no longer want, drive to Oviedo, spend the night with us, and we’ll take you to Brightlight. It’s that simple…
Stephanie
I’m impressed with the far reaching abilities of this series! Someone in our house owns the first two and may or may not be receiving the third from Santa.
And about Brightlight- the former owners of our house sweetly left us their store credit when they found that we were readers! So sweet.
Randy Greenwald
“…may or may not…”
I vote for “may”.
Suzanne Santana
There truly is not enough compassion in the world and we should all work to ensure we do not profile people or assume we have the facts based on what others say or conclusions drawn due to media coverage. The problem with society is that we have developed profiles of what we think children should be. As a society we promote the “cookie cutter” idea that every child should fit a certain mold. Our schools follow this pattern which is demonstrated with every child doing the same thing, at the same time, and learning the same way in order to be qualified to get to the next level. If it is contrary to society’s standard we think the child is weird, or odd, or something is wrong with them.
We also blame the parents when a child is not the little angel that we think it should be. As a parent myself I can assure you that no two children are alike, and even children without any defined neurological disorders can display some pretty alarming behaviors that are quite contrary to the ideologies that we may have had when first entering parenthood. Even if we teach them to be respectable and well behaved individuals they sometimes behave contrary and then we as parents blame ourselves or may even question whether our own child is normal or may have mental disorders. If it is not our own child we really jump on the “judging” bandwagon and assume the child was not taught properly or didn’t have a normal childhood, which is what the media is promoting regarding the killer Adam Lanza. I feel very sad for his father who is dealing with undoubtedly insurmountable grief, let alone guilt, and is under constant attacks by the media.
We may be falling short by teaching our children to follow the same set of guidelines, giving them the same type of love, and the same discipline, when in reality they may need a different type of affection, and a different type of discipline.
I agree with Ms.Gillman that we should lay aside the assumptions and judging when looking at children. We should recognize their individuality and their uniqueness and tailor or parenting to this standard.
Randy Greenwald
Your sensitivity is refreshing. Thanks for sharing. There are parents who need to be reminded that they are not responsible for their children’s poor choices! Hard to remember that, however.
Suzanne
Yes it is! We blame ourselves enough without the additional burden of others criticism. Love and understanding are certainly slipping away from this society.
Staci Thomas
Very encouraging. Thanks for this
Gail Brightbill
Ditto to what Staci said. Encouraging words to read as I look around me and see what looks like threads unraveling.
Suzanne Santana
I could not have read at a better time. I think we in our humanity get hung up with focusing on the Chapter 37 of our lives and are quick to forget the promises. Simply spoken from the heart, thank you for reminding us that he has began a good work in us, and will not leave us unfinished. This was very encouraging!
Suzanne Santana
A great leader always role models the behaviors they expect from their team. It really says a lot of Helen as a leader that she got in line as a customer and that she demonstrated customer service excellence. Most likely she was trying to see things from a customer perspective in order to provide the kind of service that keeps customers coming back. Remember it’s not just the coffee at Starbucks but rather “the experience.”
We should all do random acts of kindness more often. I truly believe that when things like this happen we should “pay it forward” even if it is just paying the toll for the person behind you.
You never know the impact you will have on others and it truly is the little things that matter most in life.
Staci Thomas
I love this story. 🙂
Suzanne
Noticed the blogs have slowed down. I certainly hope you won’t abandon them entirely although I can certainly understand the ‘time’ issues. Your blogs have been encouraging and helpful, as well mind stirring. I know the Sanctification blogs helped me a lot as well as the blogs about current life issues that we as Christians need reminding of. Continue to write as time allows and perhaps you can write a blog about time. 🙂
stacithomas
So glad you are enjoying Chabon! His writing is just. so. good.
Randy Greenwald
I wonder who put me on to him? Curious what you make of what seems to me to be the Christian themes.
sethgreenwald
Much of humor is rooted in incongruity. When things aren’t what we expect, it strikes us as humorous. In this clip, the incongruity is the idea of Jesus seeking revenge. It is so far outside the realm of expectations, even for our culture as a whole. The idea of Jesus exhibiting violence is ludicrous, especially in our culture, where turn the other cheek is near the extent of common knowledge about Jesus.
The extreme nature of the violence is less about Jesus than it is about making fun of Tarantino. In reality, it is likely that the only reason the story of Jesus was chosen in the first place was the ability to add the ‘D’ to riff on Django. I have not seen Django Unchained, but I’d wager there is a scene where he states “The ‘D’ is silent”, thus the “The ‘H’ is silent” line.
Take a look at our faith, from a strictly factual perspective. If we are honest, it IS ridiculous. There is plenty to be found that is incongruous with common experience, at least on the surface. I embrace the humor surrounding my faith, simply because it strengthens the awe and wonder in my heart that stem from its truth. To me, I saw this clip on two planes, the humor around the faith, and the humor around Tarantino, so I could laugh.
The only thing that truly bothered me was the ‘quote’, stating “I never knew Jesus used the n-word that much”. I hate that word, regardless of how it is used, even when used by one black person talking to, or about, another. I am sure that this is inconsistent of me, but the idea of a vengeful Jesus struck me as funny, but a Jesus who uses racial slurs left a bitter taste in my mouth. The use of that word is nothing but a giant wedge, dividing us on lines that we are supposed to have crossed. None but a black person can use the word without outcry. So attributing it to the one who has overcome those lines is grating to me. Jesus was never racist. He crossed the dividing lines with boldness.
If we think on it, when we abandon the story of grace, we turn Jesus into the one portrayed in this clip.
Kedric
There were probably a few first century jewish zealots who would have gone for all that.
Stephanie
First century? I know some 21st century peeps who’d be up for it too. That said, I pretty much agree with Seth, particularly in his last line. Not to get all super-spiritual, but in my times of unbelief (often), I’m sort of waiting on Him to come do this to me.
Suzanne Santana
I find the SNL skit offensive to Christianity and it’s sad that we live in a society that is tolerant of portraying Jesus as violent or vengeful, let alone that we might find this type of entertainment humorous.
I remember only a few short months ago we were having riots across the world over someone making a video clip making fun of the Prophet Mohammed. This person was actually arrested right here in the U.S.
One thing is sure that those who believe in Mohammed would never be silent or tolerant of the mocking of their prophet, yet most so called “Christians” would not even address this topic. Let me say that I am definitely not a fan of rioting in the streets but I do think that we who claim him as our savior should not be so afraid to stand up for what we believe in.
The suggestion that Jesus used the n-word is offensive and I agree with Seth that these comments only keep us fighting a war that should have already been won.
I think there were humorous parts to the skit but personally thought it was tasteless and offensive. I’m sure there are those who secretly wish Jesus would come back and get revenge, however; I do not believe he would want to be portrayed as he was.
stacithomas
I completely agree with Seth. It was mocking Tarantino as opposed to mocking Jesus. Was it clever? I guess. Was it funny? Not really. Was it blasphemous? Not any more than when I treat Jesus like Santa Claus in my daily life.
Stephanie
But then again… I rarely find much on SNL funny these days. /snobbery
Adrianna
The tv was on but I watched with only half my full attention. I think it’s good if the series contributes to people’s Bible literacy. At the same time, I was bothered by some minor details that were not true to the Bible’s narrative. For example: After Abraham releases Issac from the altar, Sarah suddenly appears, running up the mountain. Genesis says that father and son traveled a long distance from home, and nothing about Sarah being on the scene. Yes, a minor detail, but people unfamiliar with the story will be sure it happened exactly that way: “I saw it on tv!”
Randy Greenwald
Yes, I’m torn by the whole biblical literacy argument. I want that to be restored, but biblical accuracy has to count for something.
stacithomas
I didn’t watch it. My mom’s biggest complaint is that, while the show mentioned Abraham’s faithfulness to God, it never mentioned God’s faithfulness to us.
Randy Greenwald
Hooray for your mom. Insightful.
Gus
There was no need to mention God’s faithfulness. It was hugely portrayed in the opening of the Red Sea!
gus
I watched it, but agree with Randy, that a good preacher would relate the Bible to the hearer much better than the latest attempt to illustrate it.
Randy Greenwald
But even here my ambivalence shows. The preacher needs to show how the parts interrelate and point to Jesus, but that is aided if the hearer has some basic insight into the parts.
Gus
Exactly. The video series provides a basic insight.
Stephanie
Being very invested in details, such shows (particularly on the Sci-Fi… I mean History Channel aren’t good for my sanctification.
Orthodox Radical
Amen. The last half iis what we have spent the last months really praying over and putting into practice. It’s amazing how arrogant we can be in our ignorance. It’s more amazing how gracious God is with us.
Orthodox Radical
Reblogged this on On the Horizon and commented:
Helpful post from pastor Randy in consider the intellectual landscape of a great Reformed thinker. Also, helpful to consider our own posture to the King.
chrisinnm
Beautiful and worthy.
child4
We liked reading Calvin’s institutes, and found many instances where the writing is quite beautiful.
Also enjoyed the fact that he doesn’t mince words; he would not be considered polite or politically correct these days.
Randy Greenwald
Actually, I find him at times impolite and rude in that regard. I don’t consider his abrasiveness one of his merits, myself. There is a difference between speaking the truth and doing so with gentleness and respect. So, no, I would not consider him polite or politically wise, and I wish he were moreso.
Suzanne
His words are certainly full of good advice and to reflect on. Almost sounds like this should be a song. Good point regarding how the message is delivered. Something we all have to remember to work on is delivering the truth, or any message for that matter, with respect.
Adrianna
Yes, but look at Loveland’s high for Saturday; it’s not much warmer than that right now where we are. I speak as one who DOES NOT like out current low temps.
But have fun w/ your guests. Will you be taking them to the beach?
Randy Greenwald
No beach. Don’t think they are beach people!
Jenny
Ha – I did the reverse when I headed to Dayton right after Christmas to visit Sarah Kaye. SNOW-POCALYPSE!! well – it was for me. I mean there were snow plows and everything. At one point Sarah did mutter that I was a “green” but I had fun!
Randy Greenwald
I wouldn’t mind visiting snow-pocalypse (or the recent snow-quester) but I’m kinda glad that I live somewhere people come from out of town to visit. Speaking of which….
jenion
Once again you’ve said something powerful in a gentle voice. Thanks!
Randy Greenwald
You are so kind. Thanks for your encouragement. Now, is ‘cardinal’ supposed to be capitalized? ‘Pope’? I didn’t take the time to find out…
jenion
I believe cardinal is not capitalized unless you are using it as a specific individual’s title. Pope, on the other hand is probably capitalized as there is only one and it is always an honorific. Making that up as I type, so you probably still want to check if you care 🙂
Randy Greenwald
You make sense. Of course, I’m a Protestant, and so I could stick with ‘pope’ as a protest, ‘cuz that’s what we do.
chrisinnm
LOL! I would take Jen’s “made-up” version of grammar most any time!
And someone once gave me that very same book. It also changed the direction of my life. Thanks, old friend!
Randy Greenwald
But that’s my point, of course. His careful listening and recommendation with a single student among hundreds had a wonderful ripple effect. If you didn’t, go back and read this: http://randygreenwald.com/2010/07/24/a-final-status-update/
Randy Greenwald
And by the way, “old friend” is much more descriptive than things like “gentle reader”. I am “old”, a “friend”, and a “reader”. But gentle just does not seem EVER to fit.
chrisinnm
But all my readers have always been gentle to me– I have never had any be aggressive or rough– so it appropriate to MY interaction with my readers!
jenion
You two are making me smile! Randy: protest away! I take no offense. Also, I refer you to the first comment in this stream, where I do, in fact, call you gentle 🙂 Chris, calling your readers gentle may actually call forth gentility of response. I wouldn’t mess with it if it has been working for you!
Penni Holt
I didn’t notice any extra length in the sermon. I was struck with the masterful work of the Holy Spirit enabling you to preach a powerful Lenten sermon from this very brief psalm.
Suzanne
I agree with Penny and I was surprised when you commented about the time. A powerful and moving sermon and one in which I will reflect on. I needed this and wouldn’t have minded ignoring the clock.
Randy Greenwald
Suzanne and Penni – you guys are too kind. The person who commented was not being critical, but was making a joke with me. It’s all good. And the sermon itself may not have been long, but the service was running long and so I did need to bring it to a close. But thanks for your encouraging words.
Suzanne
I think we both realized they were joking, just noting that being caught up in the moment didn’t even realize the time had passed so quickly. 🙂 I am certainly in favor of the snacks as long as we include the coffee.
chrisinnm
I knew it. You really are a geek and belong with us in Los Alamos.
Randy Greenwald
You just NOW figured that out, Gentle Reader?
Kedric
The point I found interesting was Jesus’ reason for driving out the animal sellers and money-changers. The text says nothing about anyone being cheated. But if it was happening in the court of the Gentiles, then the operations were still taking place within the Temple area, instead of outside of it. The part about the den robbers comes from the part of Jeremiah where the people are taken to task for thinking they can claim safety in the Temple without regard to their behavior.
Randy Greenwald
Turns out the sermon was actually shorter than normal. Service was running long due to other factors. So maybe snacks will NOT be necessary in a future sermon! http://www.cpconline.net/resources/multimedia/details?id=196678
Mike
Thank you, Randy.
Suzanne
Enlightening, touching, and encouraging. I’m still amazed at the timing of God.
Suzanne
Again, encouraging for all of us that visit Jeremiah’s coach so often.
Adrianna
the hymn. But I also find great comfort in a verse you did not quote: For he does not afflict willingly or grieve the sons of men. (vs 33 NASB) I remember so well my father telling this, along with vs 22-23, to my sister grieving the death of a 3 year old daughter. It has been a comfort to me many times in the 40 years since.
Adrianna
Aack-ck! The comment did not post completely. I wrote that vss 22-23 were long familiar to me, probably because of the hymn…
stacithomas
Thank YOU for walking me through the shadow of doubt recently. I’m forever grateful for the impact you’ve had on my spiritual walk.
Jenny McCarty
So, I took a break from typing up my notes on Donald MacLeod to check my email. Saw a new post at Somber and Dull and adequately reminded to get back to work! Ahhh… the sovereign hand of God.
Randy Greenwald
So why is Jenny typing up notes on Donald Macleod? But too funny, this!
Suzanne
I am evidence of the impossible, and grateful that God made it possible.
Suzanne
This was a ‘classic’ moment! We all got a good laugh, even the children. I’m sure will be the topic of many conversations to come and a few more chuckles. 🙂
jlevee
I loved it!! And I felt “sad” for you because I think the excitement on your face when it popped up was killed so suddenly by the “it’s Grover” response in the audience 🙂 At least it makes for a good story LOL.
sheldon68
Very well stated, Randy. Thank you for your gracious and kind words. I have read Bryan Chapell’s message more than once. It is comforting even when no one I personally know has taken his/her own life.
Adri
John
Well said, Randy.
untaught
Thank you for these ministerially-sensitive, wise words, Randy.
kbrightbill
I must admit, I have a hard time using the word “sin” within the context of suicide. If someone has reached the mental state where they feel driven to try and end their own life, isn’t that a function of sickness just as much as something like cancer? That’s not to criticize anything that you wrote here, it’s just something that’s troubled me for a long time and I’ve never been really sure how to reconcile it.
Randy Greenwald
Kathryn, this is such a helpful corrective. If I were to re-write this, I would do so in a way that makes it clear that many consider the act sin – and my point is that even this ‘sin’ is covered by Christ. Cornelius Plantinga in his wonderful book Not the Way It Is Supposed to Be (the title, you might note, comes fromt he movie Grand Canyon!) wrestles with this subject in a very helpful way – that even though something necessarily disrupts shalom, is it always helpful to call it ‘sin’. So, your sensitivity makes me want to revisit that. Thanks for speaking up!
Stephanie
For a minute, I thought it was one of Nathan’s students’ research papers.
Randy Greenwald
THAT is scary.
Suzanne
Haha so funny! Gives me ATL flashbacks.
Most of it is just poor spelling and auto terms.
bcuzbi is ‘because I need the money’ or I won’t phrase the other.
hmu is ‘hit me up’ which means give me a call.
Randy Greenwald
I did not know you were multilingual! Impressive.
Suzanne
My vocabulary has been enhanced through leading the youth in ATL. 🙂
Mike
I have teenaged sons. Let me help. It says: I have a very old car, in very poor condition, but I spent all my cash on silly extras so now I’m broke. Please take it off my hands. Price negotiable, but I’m seriouly broke.
Randy Greenwald
This is great! Some of the best exegesis I’ve seen in a long, long time! Which means, I think I’ll pass on the car. 🙂
kbrightbill
Not to get into a debate on the marriage issue, but as a broader concept, I think that what the quote ignores is that there have been numerous times in the past where the churches and denominations have changed on issues, not because the media told them to, but because they realized that the position they initially held was wrong or short-sighted. The quote seems to wall off the possibility for people to change their views over the course of time and with the addition of new information by suggesting that to do so automatically means being blown about by popular culture.
Randy Greenwald
A good point well made. The application of Scripture to life calls for wisdom and humility and courage all at the same time. And it calls for an ability to listen to Scripture without telling Scripture what we want it to say. Therein, I think, lies the greatest challenge.
Nina Klein
Beautifully written response to a painful, public event in Pastor Rick Warren’s life. I get this question often and I’m going to direct people to this blog for the answer. Thanks. And thanks to Geoff Henderson to pointing me your way.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks. Very encouraging to me to have you say this.
Kedric
One of the best books to read about Florida history is the novel A Land Remembered.
jenion
You are neither somber nor dull – I haven’t even read “Cry the Beloved Country” and think this is a great name for your blog! (Don’t worry, the book is on my “must read” list!)
Randy Greenwald
Yes, but WHERE on your “must read” list? Scootch it toward the top, girl!
jenion
At your recommendation, I will do so. Sounds like a good choice for New Mexico in June…
Suzanne
Beautifully stated!
chrisinnm
Excellent thoughts, and helpful to lay folks like me. (Lovely sentence structure, too!)
Suzanne
I have wanted to hear this for a long time and look forward with excitement your upcoming sermons on the book of Revelations. I have only heard the linear approach, so I anxiously await to hear it from a different perspective!
Randy Greenwald
Do keep in mind that it will be yet some time before I actually preach such a series. Jesus may return first…
Kedric
Carter Johnson, pastor of Westminster Pres in Dayton, TN, preached through Revelation and it took nearly a year. They were really good. Unfortunately that was back when they were recorded on tape and are not available online.
Randy Greenwald
A braver man than I, no doubt.
Jayson Quinones
Great analysis! I wish I could have been with my fellow laborers in the gospel! I was there in spirit. Praise The Lord for all who were able to make it and desire to grow in unity!
Randy Greenwald
We missed you, Jayson. Especially me, the reluctant leader!
jenion
“we gather together not as colleagues, but as friends, and more than friends, as fellow pilgrims.” I think such gatherings are both powerful and meaningful – as well as unfortunately rare!
Randy Greenwald
Working here to reduce such rarity!
butimbeautiful
Tell me something, though. Why does a person who believes in god nevertheless not want to die, and not want other people to die? if death leads to heaven and happiness, why wouldn’t everyone welcome it for themselves and others? It’s a genuine puzzle to me.
Randy Greenwald
Great question, and I’m not sure that my answer will satisfy, but here goes:
Though God has made great provisions for his people on the other side of death, death is still an enemy. It is an aberration. It introduces abnormalities into life. It is therefore something to be fought against. It separates loved ones. It is rife with pain. It deprives the living of gifts and companionship. It is associated with sin and judgment. It is not something to be sought or celebrated. That said, God has through the death of Jesus vanquished death, so that it’s impact is softened and its long term impact nullified. So that, when facing death, if I really believed, I would not fear it. And if my faith was what it should be, I would grieve for those death has taken, but with a grief greatly ameliorated.
But my guess is that most Christians, like me, are made of imperfect stuff, and struggle with death far more than we should.
Really a great question. It’s one we should raise and think deeply about. I probably have only a few readers, and fewer still who read the comments. But if any do, I’d love to hear some others weigh in on this question.
Thanks.
Suzanne Santana
This is a great question and one that I have pondered for years. I personally have never been anxious for death and even in my lowest moments of life I have not had any desire to enter into death. I too have have asked myself this very question, if death leads to heaven and happiness, why would I not want to go?
I have often heard Christians pronounce that they long for the day when they can be on the other side. I believe most Christian’s proclaim this as a longing to escape from suffering and the evil that is in this world. Although I long for a day of when suffering ends, in all honestly I don’t want my life to end.
I have witnessed death on several occasions and noted as death approaches, the person entering death has no fear. I think when it actually transpires, the fear is taken away. What we fear is actually not death itself, but rather the fear of the unknown. Death is surrounded by so many unknown variables. What will be on the other side? What will happen to our loved ones? Who will take care of all of the things that we are responsible for when we are gone? Since we have never died before, we don’t know what to expect.
I believe that because I am so acutely aware of my own imperfection, this causes me to fear where I will be on the day of judgement, or rather when I die. Maintaining the assurance of forgiveness and acceptance of my frailties, helps to remove the fear of death and accept that death is not the end, but the beginning of life in heaven.
Randy Greenwald
I appreciate your honest reflections.
Suzanne Santana
I love your explanation of the unexplainable. How timely!
I find the 7 questions presented by Thomas Boston quite interesting and reflective. Of course in my own crisis I tend to naturally migrate towards dwelling on #1,3,& 4, with more emphasis on the #4, but am thinking # 2 may play a vital role in the overall purpose of our trials.
Love the song by AKUS, which has amazing lyrics and beautiful harmony. (I used to listen to them frequently back in the day of my attempts to understand and appreciate country music)
I really like the quote from Tim Keller and cling to the closing sentence.
Randy Greenwald
It would not surprise me to find out that the author of the song, Ron Block, was also a fan of Mr. Boston, or his ilk. The book is called “The Crook in the Lot”. You might enjoy reading it, though he can be hard going at times.
Suzanne
I’ll add the book to my list since I have improved my work/life balance, with added time to actual living. 🙂
When saying the author is hard going, do you mean hard to follow, or that he is tough and direct?
Randy Greenwald
Hard going in that as a writer from 300 years ago, the style is different than we are accustomed to.
Suzanne Santana
Ah..like Shakespeare 🙂 I’ll check it out in the near future and let you know my thoughts.
Another question regarding the subject of the blog. What are your thoughts regarding Thomas Boston’s item # 4? Does God still allow suffering for correction or to punish us for our sins?
Randy Greenwald
I might take issue with him on that point, for sure. But it is true that some suffering is the natural outcome of our sinful choices.
Suzanne
Oh yes indeed! Agreed.
Suzanne
This is so funny! My laughter for the day. Perhaps Barb should go away more often. 🙂
sheldon68
You didn’t say what you ate. How many days did you survive on cinnamon rolls; or homemade pizza?
Suzanne
Sometimes simple statements or a few words are more powerful than a lengthy script. Less is more, but something that does always come easy to those of us prone to in depth conversations.
Makes me reflect on some of the most powerful statements with very limited words.
I love you
I’m sorry
I forgive you
I care
We rarely see them in tweets and most of us don’t speak or write them often enough.
Dwight Dolby
Well…I guess I won’t be reading Keller’s book, Center Church. I never let Peterson off my desk. Though he’s not THE friend who sticks closer than a brother, he’s the next closest. Thanks Randy, for putting me on to his Contemplative Pastor year ago. I’ve done: Earth and Altar; Five Smooth Stones; Pastor; A Long Obedience; and now I’m anticipating Christ Plays in Ten Thousand Places. ~Dwight
Randy Greenwald
Glad Peterson has been helpful. But don’t NOT read Center Church! Very helpful stuff – but potentially off-setting if not read in tandem with an author who values ‘mere’ pastoral ministry.
kbrightbill
And people say that it’s impossible to say anything worthwhile in 140 characters…
Randy Greenwald
Twitter is evidence, however, that it is very, very hard and the gift is rare!
kbrightbill
Touché.
jenion
Short but very true! Happy to know your unpublished drafts WAY outnumber mine – I was beginning to worry because mine are now in the double digits! Writing is hard work, at least in part (for me, anyway) because my name and identity are tied to it – so I want it to be a good representation. Also, I would hate for anyone to think the BVM sisters at St. Raphael’s grade school didn’t instill perfectionist tendencies with regard to grammar, syntax, and spelling!
Randy Greenwald
But at the same time the sisters at St. Raphael’s might need to be taught that this is, after all, a blog and not a formal essay. Perhaps they could cut you a little bit of slack. But then it strikes me that perhaps ‘cut slack’ might be a bit too colloquial for the sisters. Whatever. (And with the use of that word and tone, the sisters are pulling out their hair.) One professional journalist told me not to stress over the posts, but to just ‘let it rip’. (911 has just been summoned to St. Raphael’s). I can’t do that – but I have had to relax a bit.
Elsa
I wish you had gotten more response to this! I’ve been clicking back every few days to check; maybe all of your readers are doing the same.
I also have not seen the movie and had heard about this portrayal of childhood sexuality. I like the self-conscious quirkiness of Wes Anderson movies (Fantastic Mr. Fox, in particular), but I don’t love some of the sexual things and family dysfunction that he seems to paint as normal. I think it is wrong to use young actors in this way, and I am really torn about sex in movies generally.
I’m particularly uncomfortable with how comfortable I am with sex in movies. It doesn’t keep me from seeing films, but when I actually stop to think, I have to acknowledge that I believe it would be sinful for me to act out sex or to kiss someone “in pretend.” So why am I okay watching it? I don’t know. I guess it’s too inconvenient to stop watching movies or seems too prudish. I don’t want to look prudish.
I also feel like movie directors and writers make a lot of excuses about how their movies are received as opposed to what they intend. Wes Anderson presumably thinks that teenage sex is normal and healthy so showing this kissing and groping is A-OK (I don’t agree with him, of course, but his is a common view); if pedophiles get a charge out of it, that’s on them. I’m not convinced. I think artists have a responsibility to for the responses they evoke, not just for the responses they intended to evoke. (Ben and I have gone in circles on this point for years with regard to the violence and racism in Tarantino films. Ben thinks that Tarantino uses extreme violence and racist language to point out how bad it is, so that’s a good use. I say that, regardless of his intentions, a lot of people just like gore and giggling over taboo words, and Tarantino is NOT having the effect of making people stop and think about violence and racism.)
Not sure I have a point here! I do think that there are things that are common (perhaps such as teenage petting) that ought not to be portrayed in a positive or neutral light. On the other hand, I myself don’t do much to avoid seeing those things. I think I probably need to repent, but I don’t really want to.
Randy Greenwald
I, too, wish I’d gotten more responses. Gives you a sense of how widely this blog is read, doesn’t it?!
I’ve had to conclude that when I try to remove all the distasteful from the art around me, I embark on a trek that I cannot possibly ever complete without spending my days reading books published by Bethany House and, well, that’s about it. Many Christians learn figure drawing by looking at naked men and women. I would not want a daughter of mine on that platform – but I’ve given up trying to prove it’s wrong.
However, I find that there are limits that even a secular culture embraces. What struck me about Moonrise Kingdom is that I think he crossed a clear line, and the culture was silent – even Christian culture. That’s a concern to me.
Last night, had a half dozen college guys over, all of whom loved Tarantino. I confess I only have seen one – and felt dirty after watching it. Not sure what there is with this male 20-something fascination with him. Perhaps Ben could enlighten me some day.
By the way, I love the honesty of your confession: “I think I probably need to repent, but I don’t want to.” Not sure repentance, though, is the issue, but one of figuring out just what discernment means for the Christian.
Elsa
As an aside to paragraph three, I have actually thought to myself, “Well, I couldn’t be an actor and do those things because I’M a CHRISTIAN. Those people aren’t Christians and probably don’t care though, so it’s nice that my entertainment choices don’t have to be to safe and square.” Shameful.
jjbrand
I am reading the third volume of Manchester’s biography now. It is great stuff. True, he was no kind a Christian though. Your words today may explain why.
Randy Greenwald
This will take me a while – I’m only on page 30ish. I just re-read the first two volumes. Glad to hear you find it good.
Kedric
A list of punishments:
You will have to read Metaxas’ book on Wilberforce,
while drinking decaf coffee at a Waffle House,
with a cat constantly rubbing against your leg,
and being served Jeremiah’s Italian Ice.
Randy Greenwald
We are approaching 8th amendment extremes here. I could handle 2-4. #1 would break me.
sheldon68
Okay, here’s someone who partially agrees with you; but maybe that’s b/c not only did I read your original review but you personally shared some additional thoughts with me.
I did find that it was repetitious and found myself wondering, “Why is he writing this again; he already stated this at least once before.”
Both my husband and I were impressed with the character of Bonhoeffer; his deep dedication to the gospel and the church, his thoughtful and giving nature and other fine qualities. Of course that has nothing to do with Metaxas’ writing.
As for punishment, I can’t think of anything suitable.
Randy Greenwald
Your husband was the one who said he loved the book (paragraph #5)! And you guys KNOW that you are not allowed to disagree with me… 😉
chrisinnm
I am mid stream in the book, and while I am favorably impressed with Metaxis from his National Prayer Breakfast speech– likely the source of the Bush/Obama allusions– I must confess that almost half way through the book, I am not in love with his writing. But I am moved and intrigued with Bonhoeffer. I am constantly amazed at how few people know his story, and perhaps it is the power of that story that people are reacting to more than the writing itself.
🙂
Randy Greenwald
When you finish, go immediately to read Unbroken, which is on your list, and then imagine what Laura Hillenbrand would have been able to do with this story.
child4
1) I second your recommendation on Unbroken.
2) I thought it was a different friend from this area who LOVED the Bonhoeffer book.
3) Agree with Chris that it’s surprising (and I think sad) so many are not familiar with the Bonhoeffer story.
Keith Snow (@snowkeith)
If I intentionally never bothered to read the book, does that put me on your side?
Randy Greenwald
Actually, we are so desperate, that if you never ever HEARD of the book, we’d claim you for our team!
Suzanne Santana
You moved, resurrected your Cinnamon Pumpkin Rolls, unearthed your over, and resurrected Somber and Dull! What a month!!!
On a serious note, I personally have found your blog both helpful and often entertaining, although at times, due to the depth of the writing, I am at a loss of words for a response. Welcome Back!
jenion
I wondered.
Randy Greenwald
So which did you conclude: was I sick, dying, or dead? 🙂
Suzanne
…..the entertainment returns.
child4
I’ve heard this before. And now I have a slightly used NKJV study Bible….; you (or anyone who wants it) may have it. We saw that there is an ESV study Bible but decided against it for these very reasons.
P. Holt
Randy, have you read How To Read Slowly by James Sire? Another excellent effort to teach reading comprehension of various genres.
Randy Greenwald
I own it. Does that count?! I have skimmed it which, ironically, is the opposite of slowly.
Seth Greenwald
Such a potent display of the hidden greed and envy in our hearts, isn’t it? If we’re honest, this bothers us not because those monies could be used to “do the work”, but rather that it is being deposited into a bank account that doesn’t have our name on it. And to think that those at the helm of ministries, and all nonprofit organizations, aren’t worked to the bone is plain ignorant. A friend of mine is a VP for a local NPO, and I’ve never seen anyone work harder or longer or more passionately than Eddie. He is intimately familiar with the financial structure of NPOs, and how that relates to efficacy. According to him, every successful NPO pays salaries that are competitive in the for profit market. Infrastructure is pivotal to the efficient implementation of humanitarian aid, and the stronger the infrastructure, the farther each dollar can be stretched. Good stewardship doesn’t have to mean poverty.
Kedric
I’ve seen several articles that mention the need to offer competitive salaries at or near what is found in for-profit companies because, with the hours and commitment needed, very few would be willing to do the job if the money was lower. That would leave out many qualified people.
dwightdolby
I appreciated your post and the previous comments – very much. Thanks for taking the time to respond.
jenion
Of course, I immediately clicked on the Huffington Post link – before commenting I needed to see the whole list for myself, you know!
Seth’s comment that our biggest outrage is that the money isn’t being deposited in our accounts is telling and truthful. However…
While you and the first two commenters do a nice job of coming up with possible justifications, I’d like to suggest this: that when Catholic Charities pays a front-line worker a barely livable wage ($25-28,000 in my city) and expects them to work hard and long hours (ads in Minneapolis often say 40 hours plus some evenings and weekends), the CEO has no business as a priest pulling in over $200,000 a year – regardless of what good he may do with the money. He should make less and the front-line social worker, senior care provider, etc. should make enough to cover her/his rent and basic needs. OR the money goes directly back to the good works of the organization. (I’ve never had a job that paid me more so that I could donate the “extra”, have you?!)
Additionally, the idea that nonprofits need to be salary competitive with for-profits is misguided in my opinion. The whole point of religiously-affiliated nonprofits is that they stand for a different way of viewing the world – they are supposedly about changing the status quo, not encouraging everyone to buy into it. Many, if not all, who are committed to working within these organizations understand this. For years, I worked at a small, private, religiously-affiliated university knowing that I would never make a salary competitive with what my colleagues in public universities were making. That I accepted the trade-offs (working for a mission I believed in, being able to address student’s needs in a holistic manner, etc.) in lieu of the greater financial package was part of viewing my work as vocation.
Finally, suggesting that finding talented, hard-working leaders is only possible if we pay them what they would make in the for-profit world is tantamount to saying that celebrity equates with talent. I believe Kim Kardashian, Paris Hilton, and a slew of others disprove that theory. We are too quick to hire for personality rather than for character. Some of these organizations would do well to re-evaluate their assumptions, their social-justice focus, and their executive hiring practices.
Randy Greenwald
I so appreciate the debate this has sparked. It confirms to me that these issues are complicated ones… and Jenny, I do appreciate that there often is, or perhaps should be, a willingness to accept less in order to serve the mission one believes in. But there is logic built in to that thinking that can and does backfire on those who are making their living serving that mission. Should a church increase it’s mercy ministry budget by $10,000 or pay the pastor $10,000 more? If the decision is made to put the money toward the mercy ministry and defer the pastor’s pay increase, those making those decisions have in effect asked the pastor to make a $10,000 contribution to the ministry. Often those decisions are not made by people who are willing to make the same sacrifice they are imposing upon the pastor.
I’m not, by the way, saying that I’ve been ever placed in that position. But I have faced that logic. The decisions in ministry compensation are always more complex than a tweet or a journalist can convey. You all have helped me see some of that complexity, and I appreciate that.
Eva
Excellent post, Randy! Wish it would make the Huffington Post editorial pages. Like you said, we know nothing for sure. But it is wise to not jump to the wrong conclusions. Thanks for the reminder!
Jeb
This was beautiful Randy. Such a sweet, sweet reminder. Thank you.
Suzanne
This was beautiful and compelling!
Often as humans we feel insignificant because we measure ourselves to those around us and we feel we should have accomplished more, or should have been more successful. We often fail to realize the positive impact we may have made on others, because we rarely hear positive recognition from the important people in our life.
We live in a world that is constantly critiquing and challenging us to to things differently and do things better. This starts as a child, and goes well in our adult life. Just as a child longs to be assured of our love, we long for that same assurance by our family, friends, employers, and by those we may lead. Positive recognition/reinforcement is key to producing a healthy self-esteem where we feel valued, loved, accepted, and thought well of by others. This is turn carries over to how much we value, love, and accept ourselves.
In a leadership role, positive recognition is often forgotten for the leader. It is not intentional, but rather comes due to the fact that leaders are usually the ones listening to the struggles of others, and then being the provider of the encouragement and positive affirmation for others.
I would guess that pastors get more feedback and critiquing regarding what should have been said, or done differently, and receive very little praise for what they have said or done.
Perhaps we don’t do it because as Christians, we equate praise and recognition with pride?
Regardless, we all need to be encouraged, and we should all take time to recognize those that have positively impacted our lives. Why do we wait till one departs this world before we genuinely acknowledge, or pay tribute to them? Or to say, “Well done?”
I appreciate the countless hours that you have spent listening and supporting/encouraging me in my walk with Christ. I have no doubt that you have made a positive impact on countless individuals over the years! For dedicating your life to helping others, I am sure that you are significant not only in our eyes, but in Gods eyes, and if there is a refrigerator in heaven, I’m confident your work of art is on it.
Thanks for all you do!
chrisinnm
Amen. May it be so!
Adri
Whoever promised to read the book is missing something great if she/he has not already read the book. It’s a wonderful story; Paton’s writing is lyrical and poetic.
It’s a book worth reading more than once; I can’t count how many times I’ve read it, each time finding something new to think on and marvel at.
Jenny McCarty
Hey Randy – did I ever tell you that I am working on this book too? Just found it in Kevin’s gear from when he’d finished it. I was sad when I bought it off of Amazon used to find that it was a Los Angeles High School library book that had never been checked out (card still in pocked) and was summarily “discarded.” I figure if we add it to the McCarty Library then redemption will be achieved for this particular copy.
Randy Greenwald
Uh, ‘working’ on? Wow – sounds laborious! Glad redemption is in process!
Michael Sacasas
Good luck parsing the varieties of hipster sensibility … but, don’t give up on O’Connor. Try her letters.
Randy Greenwald
Good advice. Not giving up. Actually read a good chunk 25 years ago. I think I’m not quite in the mood – but I’m also finding that a few days away and I’m wanting to be introduced again to some of her quirky characters.
What I did not say above is that I switched from O’Connor to Annie Dillard. Me and Annie get along better, and she’s hip, too, in a Eugene Peterson kind of way.
Michael Sacasas
Just came across this today: http://religion.blogs.cnn.com/2013/12/15/why-christians-need-flannery-oconnor/
Randy Greenwald
I WILL get to her. I promise!
kbrightbill
Saying that you liked something (i.e. sandals) before other people did is a very hipster thing to do. Just sayin’
Randy Greenwald
Unless of course its country music. To like country music before others probably doesn’t work. 🙂
kbrightbill
Well, it depends on the kind of country music. If it’s old school bluegrass or honkey tonk, you might be good. Pop country, however, will never be hipster-fashionable.
On another note, whenever I see the Metaxas biography of Bonhoeffer sitting there in my Kindle app, I’m reminded of your negative review and go on to something else instead. I suppose I should read it for myself some day though.
Randy Greenwald
Negative crusade is probably more accurate. How hip of me to take on the entire evangelical establishment… 😉 I’d really be interested in what you think. I sometimes think I’ve lost a few screws not to be enamored with it as others are.
kbrightbill
I’m not sure if I’m the best judge or not since as it is, I tend to be the one who reads whatever happens to be the “in” book only to end up hating it. I am interested in reading it though, because Bonhoeffer is such a fascinating person. Maybe if I can quickly make it through the 600ish pages about conserving jaguars and macaws in Belize that I need to read over break I’ll finally be able to get to it.
Seth Greenwald
Every subculture has its hipster element, even Country Music. As Katherine said, old school country would be the ticket. And pointing out the fact that you are intimately familiar with something that has passed its heyday, a hipster MUST, is popular among anyone who needs to feel better about themselves by claiming such knowledge as intrinsic proof that they aren’t just better listened(or read or culinarily informed or any other thing), they are better people.
All this, while tongue in cheek(and quite funny…), saddens me to some degree. It’s evidence that we are all shackled to prejudice, and when we abandon one set, we invent new ones. I’ve known Hipsters who are truly beautiful in their ability to look past skin color and social status, supremely generous in their care for those in need, who will look at you sideways if you admit that you like Amberbock, instead of the tiny small-batch craft brewery in Portland. And that if you go to(let alone LIKE) Starbucks, your coffee connisuer card is immediately revoked.
Come quickly, Lord Jesus, the only one of us to never once cling to prejudice.
phillydull
I fortunately came across a “book on tape” version in our local library, tuned out sports talk radio for a couple of days during my commute, and enjoyed the meanderings of Kumalo patiently grappling with his pain. I listened carefully to the description of the parson; somber and rather dull. couldn’t get visions of James Earl Jones out of my head though . . . .no doubt. . Thanks for the recommendation.
dwightdolby
Always enjoy the “grist” you pick up and pass along. Already want to talk about the “relationship” questions. Surely it is a mistake to think that the person we are seeking to share our lives with is any more stable or mature or together than we are. To ask, “what will she think?” is to make a god of her. For some strange reason, we project God’s privilege to judge onto those we hope will love us. Why do we do this? Does all love in the final analysis strum the deepest chord of our being – people created to know the love of God and realizing we don’t deserve it?
Suzanne
Three altogether different, but interesting topics.
1) I enjoyed the blog by Scot McKnight, although I somewhat disagree with the statement implying “communion” is what brings us together. Coming together and taking communion certainly stirs the heart with remembrance and gratitude for the sacrifice that was made for us, and reminds us to uphold each other in prayer, but once it’s over, I feel many go about the next 6 days with little to no communication with each other. Do we really know, or put effort into getting to know, those we take communion with? Do we really care about those we take communion with? I think churches would be very different if this were the case.
Stephen feels that people haven’t given up on God but as he stated
“They’re sick of the hypocrisy, judgment, infighting, fear, and shame associated with institutionalized “Christianity.” What does the statement that we must surrender our ideals of the church and learn to live with its brokenness really mean? Are we accepting the brokenness by ignoring it and claiming communion will bring us together?
2) I read Mike’s blog. Interesting, and I agree that sometimes we lose people with our cliche’ phrases and our formality. Perhaps it’s better to pattern ourselves after Jesus with how he reached out to the non-believers. Communication is key.
3) I am probably the worst person to weigh in on the topic of relationships. I am not sure I believe that love is renewed once it is lost, being one that walked away as a result. I have heard many stories from those who claim that it has been restored, however; I often wonder, did real love and commitment take place, or did one just settle? I would think there is hope, when the love is not lost completely. I do know from experience that relationships require MUCH effort, sometimes to the point of exhaustion, which leave little room to “feel” the love, or whatever we imagine that love should be.
I also know from experience that the grass is not necessarily greener on the other side of the fence. Most couples don’t want to admit to each other, let alone to others, that their love is wavering, let alone lost. I do think that if we are honest, most of us know enough about our partner to know if the relationship is not working, so why not discuss it? Most people hide their true thoughts and are not willing to be brutally honest. Some people like to hold on to the hurts/differences that divide them, so it’s hard to ever move forward. Even if you are completely open and honest, not all people are willing to change. If there is any hope of rekindling a flickering flame, there must be complete honesty, and a willingness to make an effort, by both persons. One person cannot save the relationship.
Anyway, anxious to see the movie “Her” as I’m always intrigued by others view on life, and love.
As always, and the reason I don’t respond much, this is very lengthy for which I apologize.
Suzanne
The compelling realism of Dr. Chapell”s memorial message is a much needed reminder of why we MUST uphold our leaders in prayer. The message gave me new insight into the meaning of “blessed are the poor in spirit.”
As always, I appreciate the transparency provided in your blogs.
Adri
I’ve read Chapell’s sermon more than once; it’s excellent, and, strangely somehow, comforting even if one has never had thoughts of taking one’s own life.
Suzanne
A reminder of the power of prayer and the positive impact of the church demonstrating love and kindness! Thank you for sharing!
Suzanne
Such a tragedy! It is sobering to realize the amount of people succumbing to addictions in hopes of escaping inner turmoil. Statistics show that 75% of all Heroin users resort to it to self-medicate due to depression. As Overstreet noted, “Hoffman was fighting a terrible battle behind closed doors, while audiences enjoyed what he could do to bring other personalities to life.”
There are people we know that live as Hoffman, showing a face of happiness, but fighting depression behind closed doors. This is a serious reality, but do we even see it?
This is a reminder of our responsibility as Christians, to get out of our comfort zone, stop hiding behind curtains, stop focusing on our own pleasures, share our stories, and share the message of hope to the broken. This also brings to mind the song by Casting Crowns, “Does Anybody See Her?”
I am inspired by the profound effect that Hoffman’s sister and her church community had upon him.
jenion
Fun post, Randy! Love these kinds of conversations – exactly how I discovered Naomi Shihab Nye’s poetry…and so many other great reads. This isn’t only how art is meant to be appreciated, it is the gift of art and artists to the larger community: bringing strangers together to share ideas, commonalities, new perspectives!
Randy Greenwald
Good point – the function of art, whether it is good or bad, is to create that community. Fascinating.
This is, btw, the reason I try to work as often as possible, in coffee shops.
Adri
Exactly why I joined a book club. Have read things I would not otherwise have chosen to read. And certainly not all choices are “my cup of tea” but it’s good to learn others’ opinions and share thoughts.
Randy Greenwald
Yes, as a fifty-ish married male, my only experience in joining a book club was that it was populated with middle-aged single women. I didn’t really fit in…
Elsa
I hope you enjoy Middlemarch! Along with Anna Karenina, it’s one of my favorite re-reads because it yields something new every time.
Randy Greenwald
I said it is on my list. I did NOT say how close to the top of the list it is!
Jeb
Man, that friend of yours reading “On Writing” has got some really good taste in books. 😉
Randy Greenwald
Kinda eclectic tastes, he has. I’m trying to broaden him. But you should meet him some day. I think you’d like him.
Suzanne
As one who was taught an alternate version of Sanctification which included achieving perfection in order to be accepted by God, this class provided me with a much needed understanding of being loved and accepted as I am, as well as the source of where lasting change is found.
I have read two of your suggested books, the first being “Holiness by Grace” and the second, “The Prodigal God.” The first provided new insight into the true meaning of ‘Grace’ and the second gave me perspective on the dangers of perfectionism, clarity on the definition of sin, and a much deeper understanding of God’s love. I highly recommend them both.
I particularly found the ‘5 steps’ invaluable and will utilize my notes on each of these steps, as well as the audio for future reference. I thoroughly enjoyed the class and the overall study was both transforming and inspirational.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks! So glad it was helpful.
Elsa
Do you do anything with the excess whey?
bg7878
I haven’t but I’ve read that you can use it to replace milk in baking and in soups. I tasted it and ours is very sour. We were wondering if it would work as a substitute for buttermilk in pancakes, for example. Might be worth a try.
Elsa
Let me know if you do any experiments! I use mine in bread dough. I understand that yeast actually likes a slightly acidic environment, and I can’t taste it in the final product.
Randy Greenwald
Elsa – Just revisited this post and saw that you asked for the results of any experiments. We have found the whey such a successful replacement for buttermilk that we now use it exclusively in the pancakes, biscuits and scones in which we use buttermilk. Since it lacks the solids of buttermilk, we need to use, uh, ‘way’ less whey, but the adjustment is not hard to make and we notice no difference in results. Free whey vs. $$ buttermilk is a contest that buttermilk will lose every time!
grandcru47
So pleased you’ve been introduced to Kathleen Norris. Have read quite a bit of her writing. It so resonates with me. Two favorites are Acedia and Quotidian Mysteries. How are you and Pascal getting on?
Randy Greenwald
P and I did quite well, thank you. Moved on now…
Adri
One of two things needs to happen: 1) you need to stop writing about books – because my list of “to read” is already too long; or, 2) I need to stop reading your blog – which is not an option I like.
Randy Greenwald
#1 is very close to reality as I rarely have time to write about anything, much less books, which makes #2 much easier.
Suzanne
I realize this is an older post but one that have I not had the time to read or comment until now. I find this particular blog extremely thought provoking particularly your comments noted below:
1) Would it be worth the six week investment it would take to read?
2) And I realize that to come to this place, I needed to spend hours with each. I understand these fictional characters better than I understand many real people. And it’s quite possible that I have spent something like fifteen-twenty hours letting their story be told without interjecting my own words and thoughts and judgments. I’ve only been able to listen. How many real people – even those in my own family – get such attention from me? Not many. Maybe none.
Why do we connect so deeply with a character from a book, a TV series, or a movie, that is either fictional or someone that we do not know personally, while we do not take the time to truly know the people that God has placed in our lives?
What would our relationships be like if we made the same investment with ‘real’ people? If we made the investment and we really listened without interjecting our own thoughts/judgements long enough to genuinely know them?
Once we truly know and understand a person we create a deep connection that will allow us to love even those that we may fiercely differ with. We build bridges, we break down barriers, and we form a bond that cannot be broken.
Adri
Hear, hear. Or is it here, here? I’m never quite sure. But I’d like to join this select group – if I may. I usually know I’ve read the book – same goes for seeing a movie – but many details/the meaning escape me. Sometimes a particular passage, one I’d rather forget, sticks in my mind.
Randy Greenwald
Hear here! And you just read a blog post about which, I suppose, you can remember next to nothing…
keith
I have the same problem. Too bad that won’t give me a pass for my ordination Bible exams. : )
Randy Greenwald
I guess showing them an article in the NYTimes Review of Books defending your disability won’t carry much weight with these guys? Wow – that’s harsh!
Suzanne
I appreciate you sharing your insight on forgiveness. This is a gentle reminder of what the bible teaches we all should do.
I was deeply moved at Tullians heartfelt apology and willingness to openly embrace his actions and seek forgiveness. Reconciliation is hard and you are right, not something we do well. I admire that Tullian attempted to right his wrongs.
Reflecting on your admonition made me ponder true forgiveness. I realize that ‘if’ we would ask forgiveness by honestly confessing what we have done to hurt/damage any relationship, we would be careful of our actions going forward. In addition, we would foster an environment of trust and one that is conducive to growing and maintaining a loving community.
Randy Greenwald
He does better than most public figures at modeling a spirit of reconciliation that owns his own behavior, and for that we should be grateful. I only hope that he and others move beyond words and really seek genuine restoration of relationship!
dwightdolby
I found it an easy addition to corporate worship to follow the lectionary readings each Sunday morning. We have an Old Testament reading, a Gospel reading, and an Epistle reading back to back each Lord’s day. They often harmonize quite dramatically and our people really appreciate them. They are also helpful in supporting Advent, Epiphany, Lent, Easter, Ascension Sunday, Trinity Sunday, and Pentecost.
Randy Greenwald
So, I suspect that the history of compiling lectionaries is quite long and complicated. What resource do you use, and why?
richard downey
A worship service is always more attractive when it is “intellectually credible and existentially satisfying”. It is unfortunate when it is neither one.
Suzanne
Encouraging! Thanks for sharing.
Randy Greenwald
Glad it was encouraging.
Adri
She is one of my favorite authors. Need to re-read some favorites. I remember one in particular (but not the name) in which the killer whistles “Jesus Loves Me” as he walks behind the next victim.
I made the mistake of telling my sons that part; so while Dad is away on business and I’m upstairs reading in bed, what do I hear as one of them comes up the stairs? Of course, “the whistler”; and do you think I slept well that evening?
Randy Greenwald
Lovely, lovely children. That’s great!
Suzanne
Glad to see you are back to writing again!
I really don’t know anything about E. Peterson and sad to say, I have never read any of his books. I feel less ashamed of that though after hearing that he didn’t know who Bono was. I value his insight and I would love to share coffee and just chat with him at length. Of course, if he turned down Bono, I’m sure those chances are slim to nothing. This interview is a wonderful introduction to who he is and I absolutely cannot wait to read his writings.
My favorite parts of the interview.
His story of himself as a young pastor, although I am now wondering if you too have equated ‘us’ (your members) to characters in the books you read?
“Storytellers tell us about ways of living that we have not yet appropriated ourselves, or thought of ourselves. They expand the horizons of our lives, or they open up depths in our lives that we didn’t know we had.”
“Community is a story, we are not stories by ourselves.” (reference to Wendell Berry)
“A gem stone you turn a little bit and new light comes off of it. The stone doesn’t change, but the light, the hew, the vibrations, they change a little bit. Every time the bible is translated, it expands, it’s not diluted, it is larger.”
(on languages and interpreting the bible)
Discussion on God and how we perceive him.
His advice to those who want to be writers/storytellers. – “Do it!”
“I think writing is one of the sacred callings.”
This interview is brilliant!
Thanks for sharing!
Randy Greenwald
Not only brilliant, but fun. Peterson has been very influential in stabilizing who I am as a pastor.
Sarah Kaye
I haven’t read any of her books before, and I’ve been wanting to get into something new! Also, it makes you wonder what words she would use to describe yourself if she came upon you 😉
Randy Greenwald
Oh, my. That IS a scary thought. Fascinating, but scary!
jenion
This entry made me laugh! More than that, though, it made me smile. Once or twice, I’ve had treasured lines or quotes “corrected”. After the initial disappointment that what I’ve treasured wasn’t exactly what was said, I’ve realized that what I read/heard WAS exactly what I needed to know/remember. Perhaps that is the case here?
I don’t know how often Pastors are thought sober, but I know they are regularly assumed to be somber. While I’m sure you can be somber, it is not a word I would typically associate with you – you’re playful sense of humor keeps that from being the case. I, for one, am glad you’ve decided to retain the irony of your domain name!
As for inspiring readers to try “Cry the Beloved Country”, both you and my sister Chris have convinced me that it’s one I need to read…and there’s a copy around here somewhere!
Randy Greenwald
So, we’ve inspired you to acquire a book whose present whereabouts are unknown. I think the record remains intact.
Michael Sacasas
Too funny! But I do think it will take at lest three glasses of wine.
Randy Greenwald
To show that I’m not averse to receiving counsel, I shall begin now.
Michael Sacasas
Duly noted!
Adri
Just as jenion commented, I’m also laughing. And, having often been the victim of your jesting, including blond jokes, I agree with her regarding the playful sense of humor. Please, please – do keep the name, whether or not you choose to be sober or imbibing too much (which by the way I have a hard time envisioning.)
Randy Greenwald
Paton, of course, chose the right word to commend Kumalo’s Christ-like attributes. Paul reminds us that an elder is to be sober, in that good sense of having a clear sense of the seriousness of life. Kumalo could chuckle and laugh. But he had a proper seriousness as well. As for imbibing, do keep in mind that ‘too much’ is entirely a relative measure.
Avery w foster
Wonderfully done! Cheers!!
Randy Greenwald
I’m 58 years old and it’s still strangely meaningful to receive the smile of approval from my high school English teacher. I need to ponder the ‘cheers’, of course. It can mean good wishes in general, or more particularly good wishes prior to drinking. Given the drift of the whole here, I guess I need to go with the latter. Cheers!
Kedric
Nerds
Randy Greenwald
I plead guilty, your honor.
Avery w foster
Beautifully done!!’
Randy Greenwald
I had a good English teacher. 🙂
Suzanne
I love the overview and would love to read the book. I am not a pastor, nor am I any type of spiritual leader, but I do desire to care for others. I also struggle with doubt and trying to make sense of my own life. You note that the book addresses the struggle between belief and doubt and asked two specific questions.
1) Are some of us meant to believe and others meant not to believe?
2) Do we freely choose belief and unbelief?
I am curious to know if you gained additional insight to these questions?
Randy Greenwald
Nope. No answers. Just a context in which to do the reflection. As I said above, “Good art raises and rarely answers questions.”
Eva
Well, I didn’t know about “The Dress” but I do now. (And, for the record, I see white and gold.) But I thought your use of this analogy was a good one. Two people hearing the exact same sermon will hear two entirely different things. Preach on, and don’t worry about it! 🙂
Winkie
I always wanted to teach a course entitled “Theology and the Detective Story”!! My proposal was never embraced!! Winkie
>
Elsa
There are a number of Agatha Christie stories that DON’T end with justice being done, usually because the murderer is some combination of elderly, of high birth, and/or “justified” in committing homicide. It comes up in Sayers too, where there is the idea that Peter’s brother (name is slipping my mind) shouldn’t be on trial because he is a lord, and being subject to a law, rather than his own sense of honor, is common (meaning vulgar).
That’s always rubbed me the wrong way. I don’t think you would find it in American detective fiction.
Randy Greenwald
That’s a fascinating conundrum. I wonder how PD James handles that. In any event, give Foyle’s War a shot. A fascinating show, we think!
Adri
That is a funny cartoon; hubby and I are LOL.
Dave and other church planters were in church a few weeks ago. Met his wife briefly; hubby spoke with Dave.
Sorry to learn this news today. yet rejoicing knowing Dave sees the face of his Savior and Lord.
Suzanne
This is such a beautiful tribute to your friend.
Praying for all who are grieving his loss.
Avery w foster
Very nicely done!!! Love the way you tie everything together at the end!!
Randy Greenwald
I get an “A” then? Or does it mean that I’m excused from the final? 🙂
Adri
Good excuse; you know you wanted the Oreos all along; you can’t fool your readers.
Have you read The Devil and the White City. Informative — and chilling. The “Devil” was a monster with monstrous deeds.
Randy Greenwald
Absolutely one of my favorite books of all time. I commend it whenever and wherever I can.
Adri
So clever; but we’d expect nothing less from you.
And are your pockets large enough to hold these aids? I need a larger purse calendar than the tiny-squared ones I purchased. But I’m about to have to tote a suitcase with me to hold all my gadgets, gear, and gizmos: iPad and MacBookAir; also PDM, CGM; breath-freshening gum/mints, hard candy for emergencies, juice, crackers; then there are cosmetics, tissues, comb; house key, newer/larger smart phone, two pens because hubby may need one; magnetic name ID badges and fob for meals at this facility. Need carry-all with organized pockets so all doesn’t fall to the bottom of the pit.
And then I see women with a tiny clutch purse and how I envy them!
Randy Greenwald
Of the many sins of covetousness of which I have been and am guilty, it is safe to say that ‘a tiny clutch purse’ is not among them. And yes, actually, if need be, my yPad mine DOES fit in my pocket.
Suzanne
This made me laugh! I’ll chuckle every time I use a yPad.
Randy Greenwald
Or yPad mini. And what is curious is that my autocorrect flags ‘ypad’ as erroneous, but ‘yPad’ as correct. Weird.
Eva
I think I know who converted you! And–as an aside–it has been proven that yellow actually works better as a background when reading or writing. White is a natural camouflage. (Think zebra). 🙂
Randy Greenwald
Ah, yes, I think you might.
Suzanne
Those rose colored glasses. 😊
Randy Greenwald
Yes, there is that.
Suzanne
I agree with the professor. G
dwightdolby
Perhaps the image of the white flag – which was accessible to my eyes some place, but not here, now – is purposed to let me know you’re giving up something. I have yet to fly any white flags of my own, but I probably should give it serious consideration.
Randy Greenwald
Ha! Glad to see that someone is still out there. Posting that was an accident – I was experimenting. However, it was not the white flag of surrender, which I sometimes find tempting, but the white flag of the NASCAR race, indicating one more lap until the end. For what it’s worth… 🙂
SarahKaye
I’m still out here too! 🙂
Randy Greenwald
You guys are among the incredibly faithful remnant!
Surely SOMEONE knows what the symbol in this post means, no?
jenion
As soon as I realized there appeared to be a progression, I stopped being concerned!
Randy Greenwald
I hope your vacated concerns are wisely cast away. 🙂
Jason Strong
“Sin Wars” The Pastor Awakens!
Randy Greenwald
You are a riot. I love it.
Adri
I am puzzled, but maybe that’s your intention?
Randy Greenwald
Hmmm. Could be….
But then, I would never tease, would I?
Adri
Oh, no. I can’t imagine that happening, Unless perhaps lack of proximity has made great changes in your personality and relationships.
Eva
So, did you enjoy Star Wars?
Jason
The new Star Wars movie has a lot of the feel of the original in 1977, plus a bunch of the same actors playing themselves 40 years later.
I thoroughly enjoyed it the storyline was pretty good and I will probably go see it again.
They definitely set it up for another sequel to bring back one of the original characters to save the day once again. 😊
Jason
Actually, I think we could make our own Star Wars movie with Randy as Obi-Wan Kenobi, Rob could be Luke Skywalker, I would be Hans Solo, we can Put Kedric in a Wookie costume and he could be Chewbacca, you could be Princess Leia, and Brian could be Darth Vader. David Clow would be C-3 PO .😀
Randy Greenwald
You mean the one retitled “A New Hope”? Yes, in fact, I did. As to the one now in theaters, that I have not seen.
winkie
What good New Year’s news!!!! I’ve missed your words of wisdom!!
>
jenion
Happy New Year, Randy! Looking forward to 2016!
Sarah Kaye
So happy you will be continuing your blog, even if just a little. Out of the many blogs I’ve subscribed to over time, yours would be one of the few that I make sure to read when I see an email with a new post notification. It’s comforting and easy on the heart and mind to read your words, thank you!
Adri
This is good; a thought-provoking beginning to a busy day. I am glad you are writing again and appreciate your work and the time spent in producing a post. Thanks.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, Adri.
Randy Greenwald
To all who replied, thanks for the encouragement.
“Words of wisdom”? I have lots of words; I often question the wisdom. But that has rarely stopped the words. I look forward to the feedback they generate.
Suzanne Santana
I’m out there too! I’ve just been temporarily hijacked by holiday guest.
Suzanne Santana
Glad to see you are back to writing.
I have often questioned God about his ‘seemingly’ absence of during times of distress and yet it has been during my most difficult times that I have found comfort in viewing a sunrise, a sunset, or just the sun shinning brightly in the sky. Viewing the magnificent beauty of creation reminds me of the power of the creator and gives me hope for better things to come.
Jmac
Nice to see you back my brutha! Trust 2016 will be a bright and prosperous year for you – I look forward to reading.
Adri
Joined Shores book club; Wright Brothers is selection for February. Plan to read though not certain I can attend. For other club we will discuss 1776 which I’ve read before. Love his writing.
Randy Greenwald
Great selections!
dwightdolby
Hope you don’t mind that I copied your fun post to my FB page.
Randy Greenwald
If you want, you can copy the not so fun posts. The good ones, be sure to attribute to me. The bad ones, you can claim credit for those. 😉
jenion
I haven’t read this particular book. However, it is an increasingly common experience for me to get to the end of a novel and think, “the author must have gotten tired of writing ” rather than feeling a sense of completeness. Even ongoing stories need that. J.K. Rowling did this beautifully.
Randy Greenwald
I agree wholeheartedly. I thought about Rowling or even Lewis. One long story, but each portion is neatly wrapped up and self contained. Not so this one.
dwightdolby
Falling bricks. I think I’m just now getting it! That didn’t happen. 🙂
Randy Greenwald
My ‘humor’ is often obtuse.
Kedric
🙂
Jason Strong
Randy, Another “home run” blog post. Thank you for sharing your literary talents with us. Jason
Jason Webb Caribbean Chillers Entertainment, LLC PO Box 427 Eustis, FL. 32727-0427 http://www.caribbeanchillers.com (352) 250-3535
On Mon, Feb 8, 2016 at 6:43 AM, Somber and Dull wrote:
> Randy Greenwald posted: “I was on the phone the other day with a friend > who is a Roman Catholic priest. In his closing words he promised to pray > for the subject of our conversation, and I believe he meant it. In fact I > once was running through his church’s parking lot early one m” >
Randy Greenwald
Thanks. There have been plenty of strike outs, too. But my question is this: when do you plan to step up to the plate?
Adri
Not a comment so much on this particular post; just generally that I am glad you are posting so often. As always, I enjoy your writing.
Here’s something else: a warning – if you don’t want an outburst of laughter during your Sunday morning service, don’t tell a joke to a blond on Saturday night.
No longer blond myself – gray-white so I’m allowed to tell you these things.
Randy Greenwald
Are you saying, then, that it takes a blond about 12 hours to get a joke? I thought the average was much longer. And, sorry to tell you, but once a blond, always a blond.
Adri
You should be glad I still consider you a dear friend. 🙂
Jason Strong
That discipline thing, unfortunately, does not apply to ALL musicians…present company included. 🙂
Great post! Thank you.
Randy Greenwald
My guess is that you have more discipline flowing in your veins than you are willing to confess….
Suzanne
I’ve made it through many difficult moments in life by going to the sea. It’s where I go. There between land and sea I meditate and communicate with the creator. Somehow the experience helps me to gain perspective and inspiration.
Where would I go if the sea were not on option? I suppose I’d find a magnificent tree to sit under, or a bench near the river. If those were not an option, I’d most likely find a quaint little coffee shop.
Randy Greenwald
I know one… 😉
jenion
We are so quick to let another person’s criticism, whether kindly or cruelly meant, confirm our own suspicion that we aren’t good enough. You speak of discipline (Ollie McLellan from “Hoosiers”) in another piece – wouldn’t it be nice to meet the challenge of self-doubt with the discipline of trust? Trust that what urges us to try – writing, painting, running, basketball, whatever – is worthy of our attention and effort, regardless of outcome? Think of the ways our lives would be richer if we trusted external voices less, and followed these interior callings more? I’m truly glad you are getting the red out and writing!
Randy Greenwald
I agree in many ways. But there is art (if I may be so pretentious to introduce that term here) that requires and audience. I don’t think there are many who write or draw or speak or sing or compose simply for their own pleasure. They do so for an audience, even if that audience is only one or two. So the writer, painter, or whatever IS concerned for the response of his audience, if he wants what he is saying to be heard. The task, of course, is making sure that we are listening to the right audience. If we value the wrong voices, as I did 39 years ago, we will shut down.
jenion
Agreed. For so many years, I wrote only in my journal. Once I actually started having readers, I loved writing so much more – because then it became more than inner dialogue! Art, communication, dialogue…suddenly there was relationship!
jenion
Whatever you may think about strike outs, I will counter, saying that I am binge-reading your blog tonight. And this post is beautifully crafted – in addition to sharing profound truth with simple eloquence.
BTW, I (also) am no longer young… 🙂
jenion
When I first met you, I loved your voice. I don’t mean your speaking voice, or your singing voice – though I thoroughly enjoyed them. But your Voice voice, that funny, punny, self-deprecating but always, somehow, wise voice that came out in late night conversations or the occasional letter you wrote from college or leading prayer at ICY and backyard campfires. It is truly lovely to meet that voice again, here in your blog. I’ve finished binge-reading this season of postings…I can hardly wait for the next!
Randy Greenwald
Clearly, an acquired taste, acquired by a few very special people over a long period of time. Thanks.
And binge reading? Wow! It’s going to take me a while to process that concept.
Suzanne
How romantic. Perhaps the point is never saying sorry for love itself, for falling in love.
Seeing how far the seat reclines, as well as the TWA seat back covers, makes me laugh. (oh how far we’ve come)
Randy Greenwald
I simply assumed they modified the seat for the movie!
Jason Strong
As I near the age of 65, I’ve found that my “spiritual receptivity” increases. 🙂
Another great post Randy. You definitely have a gift
Randy Greenwald
Increasing spiritual receptivity – ’tis a good thing! Fortunately, it is coming while you are yet young.
Kedric
Reading this again for the political season:
http://www.amazon.com/Republocrat-Confessions-Conservative-Carl-Trueman/dp/1596381833
Randy Greenwald
Carl Trueman for President. 🙂
Adri
This, referring to “novice whaler Ishmael,” I had to read twice, wondering if it was an intentional play on words:
“he slowly spins his tail,”
Randy Greenwald
I may need to hire a new copy editor. I pay the new one twice what I pay the current one…
Thanks for the spot. No play on words.
Stephanie
Randy! How dare you be logical under such dire circumstances! The sky is falling!!!!!
Randy Greenwald
Of course, I should add that all my brave talk, whether logical or now, does not take into account the realities that I see as critical. I can have a bit of an alarmist inner life that will creep out now and then.
Suzanne
Thou hast made us for thyself, O Lord, and our heart is restless until it finds its rest in thee.
Augustine of Hippo
Randy Greenwald
Well put.
Adri
HAHA! Glad to see that even after all these years you have not lost your sense of humor.
Randy Greenwald
I have to work harder at it since there aren’t as many blondes around….
jenion
Very funny!
Since you asked for input in your first post on branding, I’ll weigh in to say that I like “Somber and Dull”. It is clever, and I think no one whose blog was actually those things would name it so. Case in point, I named mine “Jenion” (ba-dump-bump).
Branding as a topic though…I’ve been thinking about this a lot lately because of what I see as the trend/habit of conflating people with brands. The to-do over Kim Kardashian’s latest nude selfie is a perfect example – some people responded to it as an issue of “brand”, some as a very personal issue. When the person is the brand, it makes it difficult to be even appropriately critical of the brand without seeming to attack the person. It is easiest to see this with celebrities, but I know a number of millennials who worry about their “brand” with regard to a host of life choices. Feels awfully limiting to me, thinking of yourself as your “product”.
Plus, when we remember that branding is what is done to prove ownership of cattle…it just seems like we need to be thoughtful about how far we take the idea of branding.
Not a complete or thorough analysis, just some of what has been running through my mind…
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, Jen. I’m not likely to change the name even if a persuasive argument were made to move in that direction. What I need to do is to own it and not shrink from it.
Fortunately, I’ve been insulated from any to do about a KK nude selfie, which is probably a good thing. To be honest, I’ve not thought much about the conflation of brand and person. But I can see how a ‘brand’ can absorb the person. A celebrity preacher, as a result, cannot grow beyond his brand without facing a potential a loss of consumers. I wonder how much that impacts me, even though I’m not a celebrity. Never seemed to bother Jesus.
And thanks for the insight into the source of the word. I’ve never thought about that. Intriguing.
For what it is worth, I like the title ‘Jenion’.
Suzanne
I appreciate your willingness to address ‘the elephant in the room’. This is huge!
You make an excellent point, that abuse is not a Catholic issue, but rather a problem in Protestant churches as well. Whether is it physical abuse, sexual abuse, or verbal abuse, our churches, and our country, is filled with it. I think it has become a problem within the church for several reasons, it is rarely addressed, predators have unsupervised access to children, parents are blind to the facts, (or they ignore them) and when predators do confess, members are not informed of the potential threat. I also believe that we tend to turn off our ‘intuitions’ and so the signs go undetected. If we did happen to suspect something suspicious, we would probably ignore it in the belief that God will protect our children, or that we shouldn’t think bad thoughts about our fellow brothers/sisters. Sadly, the abuse goes on and it takes years before the victims come forward, usually after much anguish and turmoil of feeling like perhaps it was their fault. Even more pathetic is the fact that when they finally come forward, they are met by leaders who want to cover it up. Leaders inflict additional damage by reinforcing the fact that it must have been something they had done to cause the person to ‘lust’ after them. In the countless cases I have known, when the abuse was exposed, the emphasis was to ‘love’ and ‘forgive’ the abuser. Oddly, those who preach unconditional love and forgiveness for all, withdrew from the victim, leaving them helpless and hurting. I personally have NEVER seen where the ‘victim’ was wrapped in love and supported. Actually, I have NEVER seen where the victim was shown the ‘grace’ that the abuser was shown, but rather the opposite. This results in a victim wondering why God abandoned them and why the church abandoned them. The scars are carried throughout their life.
The thing about being abused, is that you know the signs and you can sense a predator almost upon first observance. Perhaps the awareness helps by saving a victim or two. I think predators know when someone can see through them. Perhaps we should all tune into our intuitions and be more vigilant. I don’t think Christ would stand silently by while predators attacked the children he loved so much, nor do I think he would have been silent at the men/women who abuse either verbally or physically.
Thank you for reminding us that we must not get complacent and that we must address these issues. I am grateful for Marci Preheim and Sarah Taras, and for movies like “Spotlight’ that bring about awareness. I am very grateful that you are willing to bring to light the ‘hidden’ things. I appreciate your transparency for it says to every victim that there is someone who cares, and someone who will be their advocate. This is a tremendous aid in their healing process.
Some alarming stats below.
“Every year more than 3 million reports of child abuse are made in the United States involving more than 6 million children. The United States has one of the worst records among industrialized nations – losing on average between four and seven children every day to child abuse and neglect.” -National Child Abuse Hotline
Kedric
Ah, good ole Joe. He was great when he was with the Kansas City Star. I remember emailing him a long time ago asking about how he got into sports writing (since I was doing sports writing 18 years ago). To paraphrase:
“I was an accounting major when I was suddenly hit with this lightning bolt of thought, ‘You are about to fail out of accounting.’ Then I somehow snookered the Charlotte Observer into hiring me part-time and the rest is history.”
Brilliant.
Randy Greenwald
The wonderful thing here is that he replied. Perhaps since his star has risen he would not now. But I think he would. I sense no pretense, no sense of self-importance.
So cool, though. Thanks for sharing!
Suzanne
Don’t underestimate yourself, your writing is definitely one of your strengths and you do it well!
You made a valuable point about what defines Mr. Posnanski and makes him a great writer.
“Posnanski talks about what made him great as a ball player, but he also talks about what made him human.”
One of the hierarchy of human needs is human connection. This is foundation of all relationships. This is also the tool of successful marketers and the one component that takes businesses from good, to great. Imagine if we were to make a connection with everyone we came in contact with either in person or through writing.
Great writers often leave us feeling like we ‘know’ the character/s or that we personally relate to the story itself. Write and speak from your heart, and continue to nurture your dreams. To make the human connection is to touch the heart and that makes all the difference.
“Every great dream begins with a dreamer. Always remember, you have within you the strength, the patience, and the passion to reach for the stars to change the world.” ~ Harriet Tubman
Randy Greenwald
Ah, but ANOTHER of my great strengths is underestimating myself. 😉
Suzanne
A strength we have in common. ☺
Staci Thomas
It has left me somewhat discouraged as I have tried extremely hard to put it all into practice. As I read it (right when it was released), I was convinced that it was the only way to pray. But since then (so….well longer than a year), I try to implement all of it into my morning Bible time. And it’s frustrating because I want to do everything that’s in it and I can’t seem to get the rhythm right. I feel like I’m failing because I can’t get it all done or because I choose the “wrong” set of verses to focus on or because I choose the wrong method from the appendix that morning. Truly, I’ve been trying to master it for over a year. I would love to hear if anyone feels similarly.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, Staci. I’ll have more to say about this, but this is helpful. Thanks for sharing.
P. Holt
I asked for and received Keller’s book on prayer for Christmas 2014. I got about halfway in before I got bored, honestly, finding the writing rather flat and the approach more scholarly than pastoral (though I did learn some interesting nuggets from reading the footnotes).
While not without some merit to me as evidenced by several underlined sentences in my copy, Keller’s book came nowhere near affecting me the way Paul Miller’s book, A Praying Life, did when I read it in 2013. Miller’s work did much more to demonstrate for me actual faith-filled prayers and elicit in me a desire to pray and to (gasp!) pray boldly. Similarly, of late, certain of Spurgeon’s sermons on prayer, compiled as chapters in The Power of Prayer in a Believer’s Life, have lifted my heart in worship and put words of faith and hope in my mouth.
I haven’t given up completely on finishing Keller’s book. There’s a lot of great stuff there, no doubt, and I have great respect for the author. It just may take me a while to circle back and try again.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks, “P.” This is really helpful. Like I mentioned above, I’ll have more to say, but this is helpful and I appreciate you taking the time to express these things. Stay tuned…
Suzanne
Appreciate your thoughts on this. I still haven’t figured out why so faith is so broadly interpreted.
Suzanne
Politicians are leaders. We vote for them hoping that they’ll be the leader that makes the changes for ideas and beliefs that we value. People are tired of dishonesty and why they are attracted to one that may ‘seem’ straightforward, regardless his delivery style. The difficult part is knowing if their actions line up with what they speak as truth. As for politicians, or anyone who is a candidate for a leadership position, we can only go by their past and present track record. Do they role model what they promote?
Leaders are our heroes and I think you said it perfectly, ” I want my heroes to be men of character who tell the truth.”
Truth builds trust and once you have the trust of the people, you’ve got power to move mountains.
Stephanie
Royal Tenenbaums? And I REALLY want to see Brooklyn.
Stephanie
WAIT! WAIT! Is it O Brother Where Art Thou?!
Randy Greenwald
I will withhold cheers or raspberries, whichever are deserved, until I’ve heard from others.
dwightdolby
Nice… I’m glad there was some good from Keller’s book on prayer. I took your earlier inquiry to heart and downloaded his book. I only read into it about a half-hour and agreed with you – it read more like a time-crunched term paper without any heart, than a typical Tim Keller “gift.” I lost interest. But I find sustained reading challenging. The book has to grab me or I likely won’t persevere. Now God’s Word, that’s a different story. I respect your daily approach with paper and prayer.
Randy Greenwald
Oops! Full disclosure: “Each morning…” means “Each morning that I afford myself the discipline of a time in the word…” Or, as the Most Interesting Christian in the World might say, “I don’t often have a devotional period during the day, but when I do…”
Suzanne
Awareness is the first step in sustainable change. Thank you for creating awareness!
Jason Strong
Thank you for another great and insightful post😊
Randy Greenwald
Thank you, sir!
Adri
I love it! Also love folks’ ingenuity. It’s one of those things that make me say, “Now why didn’t I think of that?”
Now if only I could think of a solution to stop insomnia. (It’s 4:30 AM.) Even a dull and somber blog doesn’t work!
Randy Greenwald
I have some sermons that might do the trick…
dwightdolby
Thanks for the suggestions Randy. I’m glad to hear of Mike’s book and particularly glad to hear you find it worth the price. I take your critiques seriously.
Randy Greenwald
He DID go to the right seminary… 😉
Suzanne
For years I ran on the beach which was so invigorating and inspirational. I can understand just what you mean when you say your mind is free to wander. I still run to clear my head or to gain a different perspective on life although, I have traded the sneakers for my vehicle, and my run usually consist of a ‘drive’ up I-75 vs.
I’m glad you have an outlet that strengthens both your body and your mind. Problem solving is enhanced when we are able to ‘think outside the box’ and observe things from a different vantage point. Keep running and “Trust the run.”
Stephanie
Come on over and take your pick! I’d bet I know what neighbor you saw. He’s very kind!
Randy Greenwald
Oooooh, better than a dog of one’s own is probably the dog of a friend and neighbor. I can come pet them, they you get to clean up their messes. Kinda like being a grandparent.
dwightdolby
First, what kind of dogs is Stephanie selling? Second, I am currently walking our dog, Red, every morning, with my camera hanging around my neck. I also had a heart stent put in nearly three years ago for stress induced heart disease. Of course, the challenge with a dog and camera (nature shots, birds, gators, etc) is that the walk is not aerobic in any manner. But neither is it stressful. As the brother of C.S. Lewis once described his own walking partner, “he’s a very companionable dog,” I have found Red to be the same.
meoupc
Thanks for the kind words, Randy!
Randy Greenwald
I fear she’s not selling. The dogs are joked about, but woe to the man who comes between her and her dogs! Sorry to hear about the stent. I hope you are well! But, hey – where’s the stress? You have a cushy job… 😉
Adri
Probably I would choose the PD James first, though I think I’ve read all of hers. So then maybe Dickens would be a good option. I’ve read several of his; I’m in agreement with Mrs. Somber and Dull (not an apt title for her) re Bleak House. I did finish, but it was a l-o-n-g struggle.
Randy Greenwald
I’m trying to pace my Phyllis Dorothy books so I can savor them, since she is producing no more…. but I really did want a short one. Alas, it was not on my shelf and so Chuck and I are going for a long walk.
Adri
Ha! Getting a chuckle out of this; especially the teacher’s name, Miss Blimber. Also the descriptions of the subjects covered in the old dead tomes.
jenion
I don’t know why this piece struck me so powerfully tonight. It just did. I’m in a place of being able to feel it, without being able to articulate it. But I wanted you to know that it struck a chord within me.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks for saying so. If you are ever able to articulate it, I’d love to hear.
Suzanne Santana
Reading this really made me think of how many times throughout my life I have petitioned God for particular desires, and the countless times those particular prayers were not answered. While I’ve never prayed for a tractor, I have prayed countless prayers leaving out ‘thy will be done’ and seeking mine own, thinking I knew best. I can’t imagine my life now had some of those prayers been answered according to my desires.
I am only beginning to understand the beauty of the Lord’s Prayer and the magnitude of all that his prayer entails.
After reading this I realized just how grateful I am for my many ‘unanswered’ prayers.
Randy Greenwald
If I am ahead of you at all in the understanding department, it is not by much.
Suzanne
Always appreciate your ‘thought provoking’ blogs. This is really good.
Randy Greenwald
And I always appreciate your encouragement!
Suzanne
Beautiful!
Jason
Welcome Back 🙂
Suzanne Santana
I’ve thoroughly enjoyed this series on prayer. So many times we take the simplist things and create rules and guidelines for how it should be done. I really appreciate the reminder that God is a person, and prayer is a conversation between two persons. That is so simple, and yet so beautiful.
I hope to read the book referenced one day soon, but in the meantime I would be interested in further clarification regarding # 5.
Randy Greenwald
I have not forgotten your question. The answer has been circling the blog for several weeks now and has been cleared for landing this coming Monday morning.
Suzanne
I appreciate your honesty in this and especially love the closing paragraph. Your point regarding “losing confidence in prayer” is compelling. I’ve never thought about it in this perspective before, but it makes so much has sense.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks. It’s odd, but though I wrote these, coming back and reading them is helpful to me all over again!
Jason
I get a Daily Bible Verse sent to me by email, sometimes appearing relevant to my ongoing trip around the sun, often times just wonderful reminders of how much I need to pray.
Today, that verse was 1 Corinthians 2:5: “That your faith should not stand in the wisdom of men, but in the power of God.”
A fitting and relevant verse considering your latest insightful post. 🙂
Randy Greenwald
Funny how that happens. Almost as if it were planned.
Jason
If there is any “power” maybe that “power” resides in the fact that God IS Faithful.
Jenny
Well, I honestly can’t say that I will read the book, but I have enjoyed your blog about it. So I ordered it for Kevin for Christmas 🙂
Randy Greenwald
You are The Good Wife. But Christmas is a long way away. Have you decided what you are giving him for Labor Day?
Suzanne
No worries.
Sometimes it’s necessary to make a diversion for refueling due to weather and then reposition yourself for a new approach.
You are cleared to land on the east side. ✈
Randy Greenwald
Roger that.
jenion
And this is why I loved Flannery O’Connor enough to write about her for my undergraduate “thesis” – about the theme of vocation in her work! It has been many years since I heard you play guitar, but it gave me much joy back then…my ear heard only good notes. (Admittedly, I have a crappy ear myself, but the joy should count, I think!)
Randy Greenwald
Grateful for your ear. 🙂 And you should be, too!
Roy Starling
That’s where the little drummer comes in. He’s got no money, he’s got no fame, just plays his best for Him, barumpa-bum-bum.
Randy Greenwald
There is a lot of truth in that. Thanks.
Suzanne
This is great and I appreciate the explanation.
Self examination is a necrssary componant of growth, but the clarification of deliberate, persistent misbehavior vs. our inability to be consistently perfect, helps those of us who seek perfection before feeling we able to approach God with real confidence.
The word ‘deliberate’ is one I’ll try to keep in my mind when doing any sort of self-examination.
Randy Greenwald
Glad it was helpful.
Suzanne
The picture of a Shepherd caring for his sheep is a beautiful one.
I think your writing already reflects how you do that, as depicted here in this blog.
In our environment it’s easy to get distracted. It is good to be reminded by our shepherd that we want to have a spirit of caring and concern for others that is represented by the selfless giving of ourselves.
Jason
Good point. I find myself facing the same dilemma every day.
I think you should…. (oops, see what i mean?)
Jason
Randy Greenwald
Of course, sometimes I NEED to be told…
Suzanne
I am deeply grateful for all the countless times you have thoroughly listened to me.
I also appreciate the gentle reminder that we need to listen and avoid hastily spoken solutions.
child4
I’m with you on children in public worship. Glad you welcomed little ones to worship with us when you were our pastor.
(Don’t know how that name below got in there. You know who I am. -a-)
Randy Greenwald
Well, I can guess you you are by the “-a-“, but it is merely a guess. The ‘child4’ is an oddity for sure.
child4
I have three older siblings (two now deceased) and two younger sisters. I’m 4th in line; sort of a middle child with all the attendant woes; with six children there can’t be an exact middle. Maybe my only brother and I were the two middles.
Enough clues?
TulipGirl
<3
And I still have the notes from when you shared when out children became professing members of the church. Did I tell you I was present, same building, when J became a member of Providence OPC? Fruit from hunger years? God's grip of grace showing fruit while he is still young?
Randy Greenwald
I’m glad the building is still being used to care for God’s people, and those I know! But seriously, you need to do some housecleaning of old notes. That was some time ago!
TulipGirl
I have them in a scrivener file for reference… Lol!
Jason Strong
“Jesus Loves Me, This I Know…. 🙂
Randy Greenwald
Indeed!
Stephanie
It is my sincere and utmodt hope that my children find these liturgical truths deep within them when it counts, rather than the lies that always seem to find a passage way in.
Stephanie
Utmost even.
Randy Greenwald
I like utmodt. That’s a word that has potential.
I suppose we need to transform ‘hope’ into ‘prayer’. But it is ever surprising to me that the words put into my young brain still come out like that.
Roy Starling
Great advice. Those words that come easily to us have been used so often, they’re pretty much dead. Thanks for writing/posting this.
Randy Greenwald
I just caught the irony… I was giving advice. Sheesh!
AWFoster
A+++++++++++++++++++++
Randy Greenwald
A bit more generous with your grading then I recall from time past…
Roy Starling
I would also give it an A, but I’m gonna hold off on the A+ just to push you to reach your true potential! I will read that book. Great sales job!
Randy Greenwald
…and then MAYBE I’ll be able to prove I got learned a bunch by passing them standardized tests.
Adri
I’d say it’s a favorite, and I don’t know for sure how many times I’ve read it. It saddens me to learn that some are not familiar with it. A woman in a book club I’ve joined had lived in South Africa (her husband was with Chrysler) and had not read it. Astonishing! The other book club read it and I’d say most loved it, which was gratifying to me.
Sorry, it’s that 4th child again :>) and I don’t know how it got there nor how to change it.
TulipGirl
When I saw the title of this post in feedly, I was afraid this meant you wouldn’t be writing here anymore. . . I’m thankful to know that this just means a tech/title update.
Sadly, TulipGirl was internally corrupted by spammy hackers. Almost all content from years ago? Lost. I have a backup on some hard drive somewhere. And a few posts in Scrivener. One of Hubby’s and my projects is to battle the tech stuff and emerge on the other side. One day. I miss writing.
Glad you aren’t disappearing. . .
Gail Brightbill
I, too, TulipGirl, was afraid Somber and Dull was disappearing forever. I thought, “Noooooooooo.” My hasty jump to the wrong conclusion just proves it’s wise to read beyond the headline. I’m happy you’ll be continuing your posts albeit under a different handle.
Randy Greenwald
Thanks to both of you. Clearly one of the tasks on the ‘to-do’ list is to increase the accuracy of my headlines!
Roy Starling
I wish you all the best in growing your blog as long as you have fewer views than I do. Plus I’m not going to make any cheap duck puns.
Suzanne Santana
As I read this I also thought you were giving up your writing. Glad to know you will keep the blog alive and excited to see the changes.
Larry
Awesome! Refreshingly “new” perspective. In a world full of “Christiian” advice for men, this one tops all that I have read. I think you’ve hit the nail on the head. Good job, Randy
Roy Starling
“Christian Masculinity” seems like a made-up issue like the ones on SportsCenter: “Should Westbrook be jealous of Kevin Durant or supportive?” Who cares? They’re basketball players. Men are human beings and, like women, are children of God. Thanks for puncturing this hot-air balloon without sounding like an old coot, Randy. Your prose is really eloquent . . . for a guy!!
Suzanne
I love this! Such a beautiful perspective on masculinity.
Perhaps you could write that book that hasn’t been written.
Randy Greenwald
Well, I suppose I could. Never thought about that. Give me a good title and I might.
Suzanne
The title you had for this might be a good one.
Suzanne
You made extremely thought provoking points here. Far too often we put people in a box under the labels created by our own cultural upbringings or by idealogies of our current social surroundings.
You really summed it up well in your closing statement.
TulipGirl
Related. . .
Years ago I remember you saying something along the lines of “buying a book is like buying myself time/permission to read it.”
That is true for me. . . Except sometimes buying the book is symbolic of wanting the permission/promise to read it, and the reality doesn’t always follow.
And, you’ll laugh at this, but I’ve had a crisis of getting older this year. I realized the obvious, but it was a gut-wrenching realization. I don’t have enough time or years left to read what I really want to read, to read all the good books.
I don’t have the same emotional reaction to the infinite info on the internet. People already “curate” content online. I don’t have a problem with more “good” stuff online than I can get to.
But I do struggle with knowing I can’t read all the good books I want to read.
jenion
“Restoring things to the way they are supposed to be will always be a restoration of community.” Agreed. And in that lies the great work of our times, daunting as it feels today. Thank you for this beautifully written piece, Randy.
Nora B Manwiller
I appreciate your thoughts about how the church needs to consider carefully consider how it relates to a political world. What we have to say indeed does have politically executed application in some cases. But certainly the Gospel message transcends all political parties, countries and cultures while seeking to transform each person who may be a member or citizen of one.
Randy
Agreed on all points. Thanks for your reply.
Nina and Ron
Happy Thanksgiving!
John Kimball
As am I, Randy! It’s the most refreshing gathering of pastors I’ve been a part of in my career. And I’ve told that to many folks over the last two years. I would argue, however, that we DO do something besides eat. We pray for each other. And there have been times where that was something significant indeed — especially for me. Happy Thanksgiving brother!
Randy
I clearly agree with you. The definition of ‘doing something’ to some is focused on events and agenda and not relationships. So, I do mean the ‘do nothing’ as somewhat ironic!
Christine Finnegan
Yes, forest fire brings real grief. It lasts the rest of our lives. But it does remind us that as beautiful as this world is, it is not our home. Sweet friends of ours who lost their home in one of our fires said it was like the fire was God’s loving fingers sorting through the things they loved and saying, “You don’t need this, my child.” And I am so grateful for that all important hope!
Randy
Thanks, Chris. Yes, I had forgotten how ‘up close’ and personal fire like this is for you guys. I’m sure such things like that tend to focus us – things like cancer. Or mental illness. Come, Lord Jesus!
chrisinnm
Amen and amen!
Suzanne Santana
I didn’t realize that this is where you and your family vacationed each year. I’m sorry for the sadness it has caused you, all as well as the countless families that have suffered immense loss. It is painful to read each story.
I appreciate your portrayal of the new life as it emerges out of devastation and somehow it reminded me of the beauty of grace. I hope you find comfort in the beautiful memories made there.
Thank you for sharing a vision of hope for a better tomorrow.
Randy
Thanks. I’m glad you caught the beauty of grace!
Suzanne
It’s random moments like this that I make a connection and see its beauty.
Rebekah Dasari
1. Yes
2. Too many to list!
3. Not sure why–lack of time after marriage, ubiquity of Netflix, getting out of the habit…
Randy
Ahhh, I was expecting Netflix to show up here somewhere. I get it!
Mary Greenwald
Now that I am retired, I read for pleasure constantly. When I was teaching, there wasn’t time to just read for the joy of it;however, I did often enjoy the reading that was required. Time or lack of it, I believe, is one of the main culprits.
Randy
I get the time comment. But if we are too busy to do what we love, which has positive benefits, perhaps, as they say, we are too busy?
Gail Brightbill
Yes. Re-read “Between the World and Me” by Ta-Neshi Coates. Haven’t done it because of getting bogged down in the messiness of life. Reading for me is sheer pleasure like savoring an exquisitely prepared meal at an upscale restaurant.
Gail Brightbill
Correction on spelling of the author’s name: Ta-Nehisi Coates.
Randy
Love your metaphor. Of course, some of what I chose to read is tough or underdone, and I can’t sent it back to the kitchen.
Stephanie
1. Yes.
2. “How to Read a Book”
3. A combo of time, energy, and distraction.
Randy
HOW TO READ A BOOK is far more interesting and accessible than it sounds. Reading and insomnia go well together. I think I’ve heard you say that you have ONE of those components. 😉
Jeff MacFarlane
1. Yes
2. “Crime & Punishment”
3. its Intimidating length.
Randy
So, C & P shows up twice here. Truth be told, it’s not that long. Can be tedious, but it will stick with you. And when the prostitute is sharing Jesus with the murderer… wow. It’s worth it. Do it!
Kedric W.
Q: Is there a book that you have been meaning to read but haven’t gotten around to reading?
A: A legion of books, for they are many.
Q: What book is it?
A: East of Eden; Crime & Punishment
Q: What has kept you from reading it?
A: East of Eden is still packed away in boxes. Also have many other books. I’ve started reading Crime & Punishment. It is part of my catch up reading from not doing so in the past. Recently finished Frankenstein.
Randy
Good for you!
TG
Skipped over the post to answer first…
1. Is there a book that you have been meaning to read but haven’t gotten around to reading? Yes
What book is it? So many.
What has kept you from reading it? Easily distracted and lack focus. Every time I sit down to read, I feel the pressure of all the other things left undone. Fall asleep as soon as I pick up a book….
Randy
Reading is one of those things which we relegate to the role of an ‘only if I have the time’ luxury. Yes, for some it is a tool of procrastination. But for many, it falls to the bottom of list of important things. It feels like ‘doing nothing’ and we should be ‘doing something.’ Something of the devaluing of rest at play here, methinks.
chrisinnm
1. Yes, of course.
2. Like so many others, they are legion, however one that comes to mind is Home (opr Housekeeping) by Marilyn Robinson
3. Hate getting library books that I have to keep re-checking because I am a slow reader. Waiting to find it free on paperback swap or come across a sale. I have a husband who is loathe to pay the going rate for new books.
Now back to read the post…
Randy
HOME not as wonderful as GILEAD or LILA, but still worth reading. And no, never pay for new books. Rather, mine them from abebooks.com. And find a used book store that will give you credit for used books. And finally, tell that husband of yours to loosen up!
chrisinnm
Now a comment post reading: I live surrounded by PhD scientists. I know few who do NOT read for pleasure, albeit some read for pleasure in their field or a related field. We have one of the highest per-capita PhD levels in the country as a county, and also one of the highest library user-per-capita statistics in the country (or at least a librarian told me so!) So maybe I throw a wrench in your theory…
I try to read a couple of books a month on average– not bad for a slow reader like me. And I mix pure pleasure books with books I want to read for other reasons– to grow, to learn, to experience something I have heard about, etc. I promise to make my next book choice one for pure pleasure. That is the happiest of challenges!
Randy
I’m happy to have wrenches tossed. I’m not sure the library stats help. It’s possible that these PhDs are making their kids read. Does YOUR PhD read for fun? Nevertheless, your observation is a good one. It may not be that education destroys reading for fun, but Netflix might. And a loss of a sense that rest is good may be doing that.
Adrianna Espino
1. Yes
2. The one you recommended recently: STRANGE GLORY – A Life of Dietrich Bonhoeffer by Charles Marsh
3. I don’t want to buy it unless I can find it used at a good price. I plan to suggest it for Westminster Book Club meeting at Shores; the Club or Shores Association will buy some copies for members to pass around; or I will try to get it from Manatee County Library System.
I love to read for pleasure but time to read is a big issue with me. I do enjoy most of the ones for the two book clubs I’m a member of. One of the things I like about book clubs is that I’m “forced” to read books I might otherwise not choose; then I often find I’ve enjoyed the book.
Randy
Time is an issue for you? I despair! Even in retirement?! Help!!
As to books at a good price, always, always, always shop ABEBOOKS.COM.
SG at Amazon is $11.42 for paperback copy. From ABEBOOKS I bought a used, very good condition hard cover first edition for under $10.
Suzanne
1. Yes
2. All the Light We Cannot See
3. Most of my reading is for work or personal growth. I enjoy reading for pleasure, but often feel there is something more important to do. I need to make time away from all the distractions of life a higher priority.
Randy
If I were to criticize the issue of priorities, I would be the kettle talking to the pot. I do find it interesting how we have devalued reading as a legitimate way to rest, where few that I know have a problem with turning on the TV for that! Let me know what you think of ALL THE LIGHT!
Luke Rakestraw
1.) Yes
2.) Fences – August Wilson; & Silence – Shusaku Endo before the movies come out
3.) A combination of seminary reading and distractedness. The more time I spend on computer/television/etc. the less focus I have for reading. Trying to work on this extra in 2017.
Randy
SILENCE is such a good and such a difficult book. It is challenging. And as for being distracted, yeah – seminary will do that to you.
Roy Starling
I’ll like to add a comment I made earlier but couldn’t post it, but now I don’t remember the comment, but I’ll try to post this anyway.
Jenny McCarty
This year I want to read two books : Cry the Belovd Country and also Wives and Daughters.
I desire to read the first one because I have been half way through it for two years, and I think I’m ready. I quit exactly two years ago as the pain of the protagonists loss was so intense and real it was too much for my heart which was also grieving a son.
I like Wives and Dayghters because I laugh at the idea that at one time it’s serial publication was the “Gilmore Girls” of the day. You’ve got to hold us accountable in a year!!
Randy
The wonder of a well written book is that it does capture us emotionally into the pain of the characters, which is then a special difficulty when that pain seems to shine a light on our own. So I get why one would stop reading. But I hope you are able to persevere with CRY. It is so rewarding.
Carol Arnold
The Seminole County Library main branch (Oxford) has a book store with thousands of books for $1.00–of all genres. When you read a good book and want to support the author, go to Amazon and write a positive review of the book. Might encourage someone with more money to buy the book.
Randy
That’s a great observation, Carol, on how to positively support an author. In fact, here is a good place for readers to start: http://a.co/4uuz512
Adrianna Espino
Central Library here has a used books area too, with excellent prices. Sadly, selection is not always the best – a lot of trash you and I would never read. 🙂
Randy
Good comments on local libraries selling off their overstock. Selections can be spotty, but occasional gems are found!
Adrianna Espino
That’s strange, I left a longer comment but only the first part appeared. Oh well.
Randy
Your comments LOOKED complete to me. But perhaps your comment encountered the Blond Word Limit Filter. 😉
Rebecca Jean
I’m so grateful that my PhD work in literature has not deadened my love of reading for pleasure. I definitely still read for pleasure and the list is always long. For 2017 it includes Silence (which I’m planning to read on a silent retreat in Feb), St. Augustine’s Confessions if I can find a good translation, and a handful of novels that are sitting on my “to read” shelf. I find that having a shelf like that helps me to read more, actually.
My biggest obstacle, of course, is time and reading fatigue.
Randy
Ah, time. The constant limit!
Suzanne
Love the humor here…and of course the tips!
I usually visit bookstores when walking through the concourse of an airport, but one of my absolute favorite things to do is to experience coffee shops and used bookstores in whatever city I am visiting.
Have a wonderful Christmas!
Randy
If I ever GOT to other cities, I think I’d do the same!
Suzanne
Perhaps during that sabbatical. 😊
Randy
One can dream.
Gail Landis Brightbill
Okay. Now I’m going to go pore over the book of Numbers to see whereof you speak in prep for your future post. And, my book suggestion is Between the World and Me by Ta-Nehisi Coates.
Randy
To make it easy – it’s between chapters 5 and 7… 😉
Rebecca Jean
I second Gail’s recommendation and would love to see your review of Coates’s book. I’m hoping to teach it next year, but I have no idea how to even bring it to the attention of my white conservative Christian friends.
Randy
A review would be an interesting challenge. I’ve put it on my list. No promises. Sad to me that you have a book you feel is important but you hesitate or even fear to bring it to the attention of a slice of your friends. There is a story there I think I’d like to hear.
Rebecca Jean
After you read it we can chat 😉 It will make more sense then, I think.
Gail Brightbill
Rebecca Jean, I suspect that you and I may have some of the same reasons for hesitating to bring this book to the attention of my/our White, evangelical, conservative friends and family. I will need to organize my thoughts on that and, as you, wait until Rand shares his review of the book.
TG
Glad you are writing, fashionably or not…
Randy
I feed off encouragement like this. Thanks. 🙂
johnscorner
Is there a book that you have been meaning to read but haven’t gotten around to reading? Yes. Dozens. Hundreds.
What book is it? Hardly matters. I wish I could read 200 pages a minutes . . . or even a thousand words a minute (AND comprehend what I am reading).
What has kept you from reading it? Too many books, not enough time. I am CONSTANTLY reading and studying and ATTEMPTING to summarize/communicate the results of my reading and study. There’s just too little time. (And, no, it’s not because other forms of “entertainment” come first. I rarely consume much of anything–let alone time–seeking entertainment.)
Randy
Certainly there must be one or two at the top of your list!
And if you could read that fast, do you not think you miss the opportunity of savoring content? That you would be consuming and not feasting?
Jason
In my humble opinion (IMHO for those in the know) I think they are all great, with the worst case being the fact that some part of each message was great.
Some were just “greater” than others. 🙂
Jason
jenion
Thanks for the much-needed perspective, Randy! Happy New Year to you and all the Greenwalds!
Christine Finnegan
Amen and amen.
Adrianna Espino
Anna, Mockingbird, and C&P I’ve read – each more than once. I still wish I could have sat in on your class when you taught Crime and Punishment; alas, I probably would have been looked at funny by your teen students. I think you’ve read The Elegance of the Hedgehog; I love that the concierge has named her cat Leo, and her Japanese friend understands and has named his pets similarly. Just yesterday I gave that book to a church friend, much younger than I; she wanted me to leave in the sticky notes I’d used to mark important/favorite passages. I hope she enjoys it a lot. My niece loved it, her mom and dad hated it and stopped after a few pages. “There’s no accounting for taste.”
Randy
Hmmm. Why do you use sticky notes and not write directly on the page? That’s curious!
Adrianna Espino
Because then I really couldn’t remove the markings before passing to a friend. I suppose I could use pencil, but all kinds of lovely gel inks are available in a variety of colors and I can’t resist….
TulipGirl
I really enjoy reading the notes others leave in books. Our bookclub recently finished “Persepolis” (I think first recommending by Kathryn B. at ThinkTank years ago!). . . And I loved that the used copy I purchased had a young students notes all over it.
Tracy Gruggett
Here’s a recommendation. “The Pleasures of Reading in an Age of Distraction,” by Alan Jacobs. The author deals with similar territory as this post arguing for whim and serendipidity over plan in reading choices. I have his approach freeing. It worth the read. But take note if you a fan of Adler and Van Dorn you will have sum assumptions challenged. Thanks for the good article above. Tracy
Randy
Great recommendation of Jacobs. You are the second to commend it. I hope to reference it shortly. And yes, I’m a fan of Adler et. al. – they offer a great deal of insight. However, they do disparage reading ‘for mere fun’.
TulipGirl
I’ve enjoyed you sharing your ongoing thoughts on books. And I’m curious about the translation of your book choosing algorithm.
I think I shared earlier one of the sad/challenging realizations I had this year — I won’t live long enough to read all the books that I really want to read.
When I shared this with someone earlier this week, they took it as me being too ambitious/feeling pressured to read so much. Not at all. Just, that there are so many to enjoy and experience and my capacity as a finite human means that I won’t be able to enjoy them all. And so it is sad and hard to decide what gets my attention. (Sometimes that means whatever freebie I’ve downloaded on the kindle. . . so I’m not always even choosing well!)
Randy
I get the ‘age’ issue. I’m in the middle of a book right now that I should dump because 300+ pages in it just has not captured my interest. There are too many others out there, and only a limited amount of time before me!
So, my napkin. This was sketched for a college student wanting to think about some of his reading choices. #1/Q stands for questions. What questions am I confronting or thinking about or obsessing over that I want answered? Or what things have captured my interest? I should read books that are answering my questions. #2/G stands for growth. What can I read that will feed my heart, my Christian walk, my life with God and in his church? I think the B there stands for biblical studies and the D for doctrinal, but I would not limit the category that narrowly. And #3/E gives room for the main focus of these posts – fun. But here is the thing, even reading for ‘Entertainment’ is feeding us, or can, or in a sense, ought to. The best books expose me to other worlds, take me into the heads of other people, or give me a sense of emotions new to me. Or, as I might put it, ‘everything is sermon preparation.’
Thanks for asking.
Adrianna Espino
Wish I could join you – or at least sit at a nearby table and just happen to overhear your discussions.
I’m nearly finished with OATH OF OFFICE, a medical thriller by Michael Palmer. (For Shores book club.) I never would have chosen it; it’s creepy and frightening in some parts. The kind of thing scary nightmares are made of.
Randy
The point in posting these online is to let you join me. And the book you are finishing sounds just like one that my wife would eat up in a heartbeat. [Note the medical thriller allusions there….]
TulipGirl
Looking forward to this!
My friend Rebecca (I think you met her years ago when she visited us in FL) was with us last week. She is a PhD student in American Literature, ABhD. Part of our discussion during her visit included Wesley Hill’s writings, the Church community, and singleness.
I hosted the local book club while she was here so she could join us. The book club here sometimes engages me, sometimes disappoints me. . . I’m looking forward to this series, and especially your interview with the part-time engineer/full-time homeschool mom. *eg*
Randy
Sounds like you and Rebecca had stimulating conversations! And your book club experience I’m sure is typical. Glad that engages at least part of the time.
Roy Starling
Dear Readers, as one of Randy Greenwald’s (as he calls himself) guinea pigs, I must confess I bailed on JCO’s Little Bird of Heaven. In its place is Philip K. Dick’s VALIS trilogy which you will love w/ all your heart if you are exactly like me in both nature and nurture. And thank you, “Randy,” for shining a light on the beauty of reading. Can’t imagine life w/o it.
Randy Greenwald
You are welcome, “Roy.”
TulipGirl
And to think I’ve never read Erik Larson. . .
Randy
There is a fairly simple remedy to that….
Rebecca Jean
Devil in the White City is gripping and entertaining. Not everything Larson writes is equally engaging, but that one definitely is. It’s about the Chicago’s Worlds Fair. It might be a good one for your book club 🙂
Carol Arnold
Never read Larson. Which one might be a good selection for our book club?
Randy
Mike’s favorite and mine is Devil in the White City. Not sure how good of a book club selection that would be, but it’s a great read. Dead Wake which is his most recent I think could be a good one for a book club. Check out their summaries on Amazon.
Roy Starling
This is so good, so reasoned, so unflinching, so rare, it brings tears to my eyes. You have demonstrated a quality our country desperately needs: A mature, thoughtful, measured response to a complex issue. I hope this quality is contagious, and your fellow brothers and sisters in Christ have not been vaccinated against it.
Randy
Thank you. I have this hope that the tribe of those giving ‘mature, thoughtful, measured’ responses is larger than one might think, because they are less vocal, less loud.
Rebecca Jean
I love when my life overlaps or folds in an interesting way 🙂 Wesley Hill’s writings on the Spiritual Friendship blog have been a deep encouragement to me as a long-time single women in the church. As a lit professor in training, I keep reminding myself that reading is a joy, not just a labor, but life doesn’t always give me much time for it. I really miss public transportation and all the fun reading I got done on the L and the bus when I lived in Chicago.
Randy
Then, clearly, you need to visit Florida in August and meet him when he preaches and have lunch with us. Keep the overlapping happening! Wes has encouraged a great many people. Glad to hear he has encouraged you as well.
TulipGirl
Saw this quote, thought of this post specifically and more broadly you and your discussions of books. . .
“Young men, especially in America, write to me and ask me to recommend “a course of reading.” Distrust a course of reading! People who really care for books read all of them. There is no other course.”
― Andrew Lang, Adventures Among Books
Randy Greenwald
Thanks. I do understand that. And yet, with billions in print, it IS sometimes helpful to have a wilderness guide to take you to some of the best vistas until one learns to wander around by oneself, don’t you think?
Carol Arnold
Right on target.
Randy
Thank you.
Adri
This is very welcome, Randy. We are thankful that our church is a wonderful, welcoming, caring community. We especially like that the age range is great – from wee newborns to you know how old, and all ages mix and mingle well.
Randy
You shouldn’t be drawing undo attention to your husband’s age. 😉 And so glad that you are finding good community at your church.
Christine Finnegan
Amen.
TulipGirl
“the demographic slice most looking for and longing for community are those humans created in the image of the Triune God.”
Yes. That.
Yet, it has been interesting to see how my children are different from me, and the glimpses I have in to their generation.
Randy
Yes. But I wonder if those differences are sometimes over emphasized, that there are far greater similarities than differences. I think that when we begin to look too closely at ‘data’ that we fail to look at people.
Cristina
Beautiful!! A revealed truth so eloquently, yet tenderly, expressed. Thank you, Pastor Randy!
Darlene
Thanks for your comments.
Suzanne
It is very sad that we live in a world where harshness and hatefulness are common place. There is something proufound and very beautiful about your words in your 2nd paragraph. A challenge for each of us.
“If we are to be attacked, let it be for our righteousness. And if we are to attack, let it be with kindness.”
I love this! One of my favorite quotes from lyrics is, “Let there be peace on earth and let it begin with me.”
As for the ‘decent’ unknown Christians you’d like the world to meet, perhaps you can introduce them to us. 😊
Randy
Introduce you? Why, first off, take a look in the mirror…
Suzanne
Oh wow. 😪 I am touched, but looking in the mirror I see far too many imperfections. I pray that can I can be one of those mentioned in Malachi, but I feel I am far from the apple of Gods eye. My deepest longing is to have that assurance.
Natacha C Etienne
A Very well written piece! I thank God for inspiring you to help us bringing balance in today’s challenges that we’ll be forced to face daily as Christians. May He equips us to do nothing less than His Will.
johnscorner
!!! Thank you, Randy! Very good reminder!
Angel Meeks
Yes! I was just talking to some friends about this. One of my favorite quotes is by William Wilberforce…
“If there is no passionate love for Christ at the center of everything, we will only jingle and jangle our way across the world, merely making a noise as we go.”
Randy
This is a marvelous quote, Angel. I think I need to extract it from the comments and put it where others can see it!
TulipGirl
Staci is MY go-to for book recommendations! And I would love, love to hear her as a guest on “What Should I Read Next?”
Not long ago, I finished “The Door,” as suggested by Staci. And then passed it along to a friend who has similar reading tastes (and is also an engineer-mom!)
I’m glad you included her in your interviews.
Randy
Stay tuned for part #2…
Neal Ganzel
Sage comment Randy. Thank you.
Both in my previous 20 year business career, and in 16 years of gospel ministry, this has been my practice.
IMO, the current sexually lawless and (especially where women are concerned) anti-clerical culture demands it as wisdom. There are ways to meet with with a woman for counsel that do not compromise either the rule or her right to private counsel with her pastor.
And, especially where younger women are concerned, the Apostle directly reserves their need for discipleship wisdom not to to church planter Titus but to the older women Titus has authoritatively and NO DOUBT carefully & discretely instructed in their need for wisdom.
Randy
Not to challenge your practice, but I think it is important to note that while Paul encourages the older women to teach the younger women, he does not reserve that duty for older women. There is nothing in Titus 2 that would suggest that others, including Titus, might as well teach the younger women.
Neal Ganzel
IMO, what is directly commanded of Titus in the passage (2:1-1o) first of all is what he should teach certain groups.
It is clear that he reserves the specific “training” of younger women to older women who Titus has identified/trained in their mature responsiblies.
If a church has no older women willing to train younger women in the virtues therein described (😱) then of course the church planter or pastor would have to do it–or his wife, or some older wom n imported from another church, etc.
But I think the passage is pretty clear exegetically as to the wise apostolic preference here–especially applicable to a younger man.
Just saying…
Stephanie
So you make a distinction that’s important. There is an enormous difference between alone with a woman and in public/in public view by yourself with a woman. That’s been my only point of contention with those who suggest men and women can’t be friends or that a married man meeting with a woman individually is wrong (and as some have suggested, sinful). Jeb and Betsy have made some phenomenal points about how those who hold the absolutist view are only contributing to the false idea that romantic intimacy is the only intimacy. Now, I just don’t care who VP Pence has dinner with in this scenario. if that is what he has arranged with his wife, then so be it. But I won’t swallow Matt Walsh or Kevin DeYoung’s malarkey that to do so is sin. Incidentally, just a few days ago, I met with Curt in our home, with neither Kelly nor Nathan present. We both awkwardly confirmed with one another that our spouses were cool with this (they were) and then laughed at our complimentarianism.
Randy
As you know, ‘wrong’ and ‘unwise’ are two different categories. I might counsel that a practice is ‘unwise’ but not ‘wrong’. And something that might be unwise for me, might be of no consequence for others. On that I suspect we agree. I am, however, cautious here. Intimacy between a man and a woman has to be carefully guarded. Too many who have felt that their laps could contain the coals have ended up being burned. Discretion is key.
Jason
Looking forward to your return to “revived and fully alive” status. 🙂
Alexandra
We always have hope for the mostly dead…
Rebecca Jean
I read most of the World Book Encyclopedia set when I was in 6th grade. It was new, I sat in the back of the room, and everyone told me 6th grade was review for 7th, so I figured I only needed to pay limited attention (and in reality, that was all I had to do to pass with good grades). But I only got to H or I volume, I think.
Randy
Which is another reason to lament the loss of paper encyclopedias. Gone is the joy of browsing!
Stephanie
<3
Randy
Oh, to be multilingual and speak emoji. I think this is good, right?
Kedric W.
One disagreement. Bill Gates may be very wealthy, but there’s no way he could buy Amazon at this point. He probably has the stock, though. 🙂
Randy
See – there is another way, then, that Bill Gates and I are JUST alike. Neither of us is capable of buying Amazon.
Adri
This was highly recommended by a member of one of my book clubs. I’ve requested it from the library. I’m probably 37th in line! When I do eventually get and read it, I’ll keep in mind your thoughtful comments, so I thank you for reviewing.
Randy
I look forward to hearing what you think.
Adri
I’m taking a free writing class; meets alternate Saturdays at Towers, and last time was canceled because of IRMA’s visit. The teacher assigns a topic; I struggle to decide what to write – within her guidelines – and like you, put it off.
For the canceled class I finally decided what to write, made changes several times, and finally got it done. Guess who read it and declared it “excellent.” You know him, and I don’t mean my younger son. 🙂
I’m hoping we’ll carry through for Saturday. Others want to change to writing about hurricane experience.
Randy
Well, your clues are good but my sleuthing skills are weak. You have me curious, if it is not your younger son.
Stephanie Ilderton
A whole lotta yes.
Carol Arnold
I agree with you, as I see a lot of Matthew 16:18 going on as I travel throughout the world. Whatever “gates” are, God’s church continues to prevail.
chrisinnm
Confidence in Christ to preserve His church? And that actually affecting how we walk and act? What a novel concept…
{Sorry for the sarcasm… Yes. Get on loving others and standing faithfully for Christ is what we have always needed to do and been called to do, and will always be.}
Randy
Sarcasm can be a powerful rhetorical tool which tends to leave the stable when it should not. I’m having to learn to handle it better, with only minimal results!
Christine Finnegan
Yes. I also need to learn to keep it stabled… 🤔
Randy Bronson
As a postmil I see things this way as well. Progress is like a yo-yo on an up escalator. But some only see the yo-yo when it’s falling. That is the best time to raise funds I suppose. 🙂
The main thing I missed in the statement was the church’s responsibility to love the marginalized people referred to in the statement(calling ourselves, as well as them, to holiness.) It’s an ethical conflict and we contend for our King with acts of service. And judgment begins with the household of God.
Randy
Good take on the absence of a pastoral tone. As to raising funds, it is telling that at the end of the online statement there is a ‘donate’ button.
Stephanie
The thing that keeps popping onto my head is just how nuanced the entire issue is within our denomination. This statement was so very obviously put together without even a small amount of understanding regarding some of the dynamics involved and I am frustrated by its tone-deafness in regard to anyone who doesn’t share Rosaria Butterfield’s (very valid, but different than many) experiences regarding homosexuality. And yes, I 100% believe this is a “breathless” response to her recent criticisms of our denomination. I am disappointed by many of the names signed to this, particularly the original signers. Such a rush to make sure nobody mistakes what we’re against that we neglect the real lives being lived. All echoes of the wisdom commented and blogged here…
Randy
You are putting your finger on another, deeper, issue – that of parachurch swallowing church. More on that soon to come.
Stephanie
I hadn’t even considered this. I think I still carry a blind spot for the Church’s authority because I grew up in a tradition that completely ignored/rejected that the Chirch existed in favor of the local church. And my age doesn’t help. I’ve come up in a time where parachurch ministry is treated by many (most?) to be another version of the Church, making this too-big-for-its-britches concern all the more tolerated and threatening.
Randy
Yes, and exactly my point. A great erosion in the importance of the church has occurred and we now mistakenly consider the church an amorphous invisible and ill-defined mass of believers, and not as the messy institutional community of diverse persons. Whereas once one might have looked upon a position issued by the church as having authority, though we struggled with its content, now we determine whether to accept the content of a thing based upon the fame and reputation of those whose names appear at the end. I say it again: this is an Evangelical Celebrity Document which we are to accept on that basis. And that is problematic, it seems to me. We have lost respect for the church. The church is messy and its counsels may err. But it is the church and the CBMW is not.
Eva
I haven’t read the full statement because, honestly, it made me angry. I was reading it through the eyes of those I know and love who are homosexual. And all I could see was “anti-(name of person)”. I agree with you that a kinder, more compassionate statement would have been appropriate. But this statement made me wonder, “Where is the statement on sexual relationships outside of marriage, period? Or the statement on adultery? Or the statement on pride?” I think those are missing because perhaps we as Christians have already given in to the “culture” on those–the culture being “human-ness and our capacity to sin.”
Randy
Much here with which I am in agreement. The statements you seek do exist, by the way, in the creeds of the church. And that is in one sense the point of my follow-up post here: http://randygreenwald.com/2017/09/27/chutzpah-in-nashville/
Kedric W.
“But having not arisen from the church, a statement like this bears no ecclesiastical authority. There is no labor of any church court or body behind it. It lacks the carefully weighed, though painfully slow, nuanced pastoral concern of ecclesiastical process. It was not generated at the request of the church, and it has not been adopted as the stated judgment of the church. Hence it has no authority beyond the respect given to the names attached to it.”
Money statement. Sorry you don’t get any royalties. The Mortification of Spin podcast on this subject basically said the same thing.
Randy
Thanks. I am kind of surprised that more people don’t raise this question. As for royalties, well, there is this: https://www.paypal.me/somberanddull Not royalties, but it does help support the site. You need not donate, but if you link this site on FB, and such, others might!
Neal Ganzel
Thank you brother! Excellent analysis!
Randy
Thank you. I’m always happy when we can agree!
Simone C
I do agree that this type of statements are arguable, not for the content rather for the form.
However, I believe that the promoters and signers of this statement had good intentions behind this, one of them is a member of our church and “celebrity theologian”, but I can’t barely imagine him as a hidden revolutionary, and it would be interesting to know what his thoughts are.
My real concern is the choice of the city, why Nashville? Initially I thought that was a statement about church music, why not San Francisco or Las Vegas? 🙂
Oops, I accidentally gave a hint, we may be getting soon a declaration on church music… 🙂
Randy
Ah, but the revolution occurred many years ago. We are only now seeing how revolutionary it was/is. And IF said statement on church music were to come, many of us would base its merit on who signed it. That’s how we function these days.
Gail Brightbill
A thumbs-up to your commentary. It spurs me on to reread this very important book. It serves to remind me to not grow complacent in my understanding of and support for those who live and continue to live the experience of being Black in America.
Randy
And the book is short, a virtue far too many books lack! Thanks for the thumbs up.
Suzanne
I believe the commenter speaks for countless women and I appreciate her transparency.
I grew up in a church that taught me from childhood that by being a female I was a threat to the opposite sex, that men were superior, and that women were to be subservient. This fostered disrespect and abuse. Sadly, I think there are still elements of this mindset today.
I too agree that going to church as a woman can sometimes be a heartbreaking experience. I am not a single woman, but one that has a spouse that is a non-believer and doesn’t attend church with me. As a result, I often feel single within my community. It may not be the reality, but it certainly is my perception that women who attend with their spouse or companion are treated differently. I don’t think that single women (outside of college girls) are welcomed into the community with the same openness as those with a companion. Perhaps many would disagree, but perhaps that is because they have not personally experienced the isolation that comes from being a female that attends church alone.
There is so much to discuss and while this is most definitely an ‘elephant in the room’ we need awareness on the topic.
Thanks for being brave enough to embrace it.
Randy
Awareness is important, and it takes brave people to bring that awareness to us who aren’t always ready to hear. Thanks.
Eva
I agree with her as well on many fronts. It is awkward as a woman. I think it is especially hard on “older” single women–by which I mean, not in their twenties. I realized when I was in my 30s and most of my friends were married already that something had changed. I was treated differently by men. Married men didn’t talk to me any more. And though I understood that a big part of that was that they wanted to respect their wives, I also felt a new kind of loneliness as many of these men had been my friends in the past.
As a woman, talking to men about life concerns is just not comfortable. And yet, in our tradition, that is who we have in leadership. I am just not going to call up my elder to ask him for council. Not unless it is about something mundane.
And the question of how women are to use their gifts in the church is also a very difficult one that I struggle with to this day. My gift is teaching, but I can’t use that in the tradition I am in outside of with children. And although I love working with children, I feel “boxed in” in a way I don’t outside of church where I spend the vast mafoirty of my time teaching and training adults.
So, yes. Being a woman in church is a challenge. But with all that said, I feel blessed to be a part of the church–our church!
Rebecca Jean
All of this (both the original post and this comment) resonate with me deeply. I’ll be 39 in a couple of weeks, have always been single, and am looking at the possibility of moving next year for work and really dreading having to find a new church. I’ve visited (and found) churches by myself most of my life, so I don’t feel uncomfortable going some place new by myself. I am friendly, although I am introverted, and have learned to put myself out there after a few visits if no one has reached out to me. But I also have major tattoos and dress colorfully, so it is hard for me to blend in in a new place 🙂
The struggle I am coming to now, however, echos yours. What do I do with my leadership and teaching gifts when I attend churches that all believe that women should not be in leadership? I am training to be a college professor and regularly teach men and women, some even older than myself, and always get respect and engagement from all my students. But those gifts seem to have no home in the churches I choose to attend. I’m not interested in a church or denomination that has strayed from orthodoxy enough to ordain women, because I usually have many other issues with their theology, but I wonder if they might be a place where my gifts would be more welcome and could be more fruitful.
And as I get older, I do get a bit restless under church leadership where no one looks like me. I am blessed to be part of church where I have a good relationship with both my pastor and several of the elders. They are willing to meet with me individually and I feel comfortable sharing some of my struggles with them. But I am also very close to their wives, and so I think they consider me family in a way that makes that relationship less awkward. But why are there so few single men, even, in leadership? I rarely meet unmarried church leaders, and there are struggles very specific to long-term singleness that often go overlooked in the church because there is no one in the leadership who can speak to them. And since most of the long-term single people in conservative churches are women, it feels doubly isolating.
So, thank you for sharing this letter, for opening up the conversation a little more, and for being interested in the stories of others! It encourages my heart!
Randy
I’m intrigued by how the issues of being a woman and being single seem to overlap in the comments. It is not simply the experience of a woman that is hard, but that of being an unmarried woman. Thanks for sharing your take on this. And should you move to Central Florida, at CPC, tattoos are okay. And colorful dress.
Randy Greenwald
Well, I’m glad you’ve found a church in which you feel blessed. 😉
Betsy
Randy. This was so good. Thank you for being a pastor who listens and has thoughtful engagement with his entire congregation. I often mention how you would meet me for coffee or have meetings with me alone because I’m that small act you made me feel equally valuable to the other staff members and not “dangerous” because I was a woman.
I’ve been thinking a lot about how discouraging it can be to be a woman in a conservative denomination. I have a voice and am listened to, and yet there often feels that there is a limit to how far I can go with my gifts and voice/ I’m thankful that I have worked in two very healthy environments in which I was able to bring my concerns before the session or my pastor/boss, but not every woman gets that chance in other conservative churches and denominations.
And I echo Eva, that as a single woman it can be even harder. Sometimes women are lumped in with their husbands voice and without a significant other it can feel as though your voice is lessened, especially in decision making processes. And similarly, I will be less likely to go to a man when I have a struggle and so the lack of women in leadership positions can limit the pastoral care of women in general in the church.
I am incredible thankful for my time I was under your care because you were intentional and thoughtful in including my voice and the other women of the church – as well as other marginalized voices. My current church is also led by a man who seeks to hear and understand the minority experience in church. I didn’t realize how much I needed it until I experienced it from you.
Rebecca Jean
Thanks for sharing your insights. I am teaching this book starting next week to a class that is majority white, with a few people of color to mix things up a little bit. I have been praying a lot that the conversation will be fruitful and that I’ll know how to manage expectations so that real, deep learning can happen. We started with Twelve Years A Slave, are currently marching quick-step through speeches from Frederick Douglass, MLK, Jr, and James Baldwin this week, and next week we open with the introduction from The New Jim Crow by Michelle Alexander to set-up Coates’s story.
On a side note, you may want to consider picking up a copy of Daniel Hill’s recent book White Awake. I heard him speak at the Christian Community Development Association conference earlier this month and it was very challenging. His words are a helpful guide into learning to be aware of our own whiteness as a way of humbling meeting our brothers and sisters of color in the freedom and challenge of the Gospel.
Angel
All the “spiritual gift” type tests that I’ve ever been asked to take have listed pastor and teacher as my top two. While I’m not a huge fan of those kinds of test, these gifts are also the ones affirmed by the Lord and many people in my life.
It’s been difficult in the past to reconcile people in leadership, who see my God given talents, and then immediately go silent when the next question, “so how/where should I use these gifts! ” comes up. So yes, I agree. It feels like there isn’t a place for women in the church when the church leadership is all male. I am young, but already have the “boxed in” feeling that Eva mentions.
I definitely struggled not having women in the church who were in positions of mentorship and discipleship. As men, you go the pastor. As women, you quietly search around until maybe, just maybe, you find a women willing to invest in you. For a long time I did not have that and would not go to a male leader. The change in my spiritual growth was huge once Godly women stepped into my life as leaders (through my mission organization). They weren’t just with me during a women’s bible study once a week, they are invested in mentoring and discipling me throughout my life with the Lord.
“Women in leadership” is such a controversial topic. But whatever the type of church, I think having women of all ages who are open, dedicated, and willing to mentor and disciple other women would be amazing and produce women who feel comfortable in the church, grow in the Lord, and make more disciples.
Randy
It’s possible that conversations like these will cause we who are in leadership to think how women can be better integrated, especially confident women with leadership and teaching gifts, into the ministry of a church, even in a church that believes the ordained office of elder is biblically restricted to men. Your comments are also a reminder for older women to aggressively seek out young women desperate for someone to pour into their lives. Thanks for sharing.
Holly
I, as a woman respectfully disagree. I grew up in the church, my father a pastor, my husband a deacon. I take ownership of me, I do not wait for someone to come to me to say hello or make me feel welcome, I go and say hello and shake hands and introduce myself. I also completely understand if a man is not comfortable meeting alone behind closed doors with a woman, not because women as a group are evil, but many times good men have been accused of things they did not do and it has ruined their reputation. Just like a doctor has a nurse in the room, so a man should feel he can protect himself. I just don’t like that women feel they are less than or they are ignored. Women in my opinion, can hold supportive roles in the church and they have other women they can talk to, such as the pastors wife or your bible study group, but men are to be the leaders of the church. I know so many disagree with me, but it is in the bible that way and we are made to be helpmates to our husbands as he is the leader of the home. Jesus had many women friends, but he did not chose any as disciples or in roles of leadership. Just my thought, NOT trying to be offensive by any means.
Randy
Thanks, Holly. I actually think that there are those commenting here who agree with your judgment concerning leadership. What we can’t disagree with is someone else’s experience, of course. And you are not being offensive at all. I think we need to share our experiences and our perceptions and to genuinely listen. That’s all I’m trying to do here. Thanks for sharing!
Randy
I should add here the uncovering of a weird coincidence. The church I pastor has a ‘Holly’ whose father was a pastor and whose husband is a deacon. She is not the Holly who commented here!
Andrea
Randy, thank you for your sensitivity to this subject and your willingness to offer a listening ear. In general, I agree that it is difficult being female in a more conservative theological camp. It is true that when a woman has deeper theological questions, or just life questions, she often feels disadvantaged by the fact that she usually feels the need to take those to a male. Although in the past, an elder from whom I sought theological advice helped me find a female mentor in the church. I have also been blessed that you and Barb have taken time to mentor me together in the past. At the same time, I have talked to many women who feel like there is not a place in the church to use their teaching gifts.
Sometimes I am afraid we run into the problem of confusing (or merging) the ideas of discipleship with leadership. While leadership in the Church is exclusive to males, I don’t believe Scripture distinguishes between men and women when it comes to discipleship. We are all disciples of Christ. Jesus had a number of female followers, even though they were not one of the Twelve. He commended Mary for sitting at his feet as he taught. I would love to see an increased emphasis on discipleship among women in the Church; not only in regards to things like helping our husbands well if we are married (though that is important for wives, and we need mentors in that too). I would love to see the Church encouraging women to gain a robust understanding of God and his Word (through formal or informal training) so they can disciple other women (of course, under the overall leadership of the church elders).
Women’s teaching gifts need not to be limited to children’s ministry (though we need to have great teachers there!); there is a huge need for them to be used with women. The challenge is, while the church’s pastors and elders are, by default, known to be biblically astute and wise, and have accepted a “pastoral” role in the church (I am using that term losely; I am not promoting the idea of female pastors), younger women desiring mentorship from women don’t always know whom they should ask, or feel intimidated. Older women in the faith might be interested in mentoring younger women, but think they aren’t “qualified” even though they do have a lot to offer. I guess there are times when women are pushed to be a bit more vulnerable when looking to be discipled, and hopefully are met with older women who have the courage to offer themselves as mentors.
In saying all this, I do not wish to belittle anyone’s experience. This is a hard topic, and I know many of the feelings, experiences, and opinions shared are deeply personal and painful. I am thankful for those church leaders in the past who have treated me, along with the men in my midst, as a disciple of Christ first and foremost, albeit respecting (and not ignoring) my gender.
Kedric W.
Although it’s not directly related to the topic at hand, it came to my mind as something that churches are pursuing regarding lay ministry and one of those is St. Elmo Presbyterian in Chattanooga. It’s called Stephen Ministry and the website describes it as “congregations [that] equip and empower lay caregivers—called Stephen Ministers—to provide high-quality, confidential, Christ-centered care to people who are hurting.”
It tends to lean more toward caring for those going through some sort of crisis situation, but I thought it relevant because both men and women lay members go through training. All the things I’ve heard from those at St. Elmo who have become Stephen Ministers have been very good and a great blessing to the congregation.
https://www.stephenministries.org/
Andrea Milgate
I am a hospital chaplain and have taken a look at the training manual used to prepare Steven ministers. It really is great! I have a lot of respect for that program, and agree that it presents a wonderful opportunity for men and women to serve!
Brightflash
!!! Nice, Randy!
Sarah Kaye
Hope you have a nice breakfast, I’ll be over here eagerly awaiting part 2 and bribing my toddler with cheese so I can have 5 min of quiet time!
Adri
Both of us read the book. The CEO of Bradenton Courtyard, Shores, Towers – now renamed Westminster Point Pleasant – ordered copies for each of the three libraries, and for managers of all departments. He required – or at least encouraged – each manager to read it.
The husband says, “I liked it. I think people 50 years and older should read it.”
We are as busy as you. We often wonder how there was a full time job to support us, now that we see how packed full our retirement days are.
Carol
Breakfast is good. Keep up the good work.
Kedric
We went through a Sunday School class with that book as a guide. I didn’t finish it, but what I did read was excellent.
Jason
Dreams are the stuff Prayers are made of.😊
Carol Arnold
Those who bless others will be blessed. You deserve these dreams come true.
Jason
You should be like the man who, when asked by his wife, “What are you going to do today?”, replied, “NUTHIN’.”
She said, “That’s what you did yesterday!” to which he replied, “Yeah, but I didn’t finish.” 🙂
Randy
That’s funny! But I’m not very good at doing ‘nuthin’.
Kedric
I will be listening to that line up.
Randy
As will I!
Larry Edison
So amazing! Our God sure put together an amazing time for you. Literally almost unbelievable. So glad for you guys – and so glad for the church that they are in such obviously capable hands. Be refreshed! As for doing “nuthin” – well, I look at your schedule and think, “wow, I would be kept busy just being at the right place on time.” Getting here and there “and back again” will keep you busy enough.
Randy
Yes, and this is a LIGHT schedule….
chrisinnm
Lovely. Praying for you as your grapple with the calling/hobby problem, praying all things to His glory, of course. You do have a gift for both preaching and writing.
Randy
Thanks. I appreciate your prayers and your encouragement.
randybronson
Having benefited greatly from your writing prowess(in your note to Kelly) I’m firmly convinced you should see this as a calling(I may be wrong but I’m never unsure! 🙂 ) Perhaps your sabbatical would be a chance to devote some time to producing a long essay.
God has given me many good gifts but the ability to write is not one of them. I pray that God will provide the avenue for your writing to be a blessing to others as it has been to me(in your sermons as well as in other ways.)
Randy
Thanks, Randy. Of course, your perspective may be a bit skewed given the subject matter of that prior piece. 😉
Suzanne Santana
Glad you and Barb were able to attend the fesitival and found inspiration in the stories of others. Thankful you were able to step out of your comfort zone for this is where we are able to learn about and understand others and also gain greater insight of ourselves.
Praying you find clarity with your writing and your calling.
Carol Arnold
Can we have only one “calling” in life? Hmm. I think not. As a former wife, mother, pastor’s wife, erzatz artist and writer, which of those was my calling and the rest just hobbies? You are gifted as a writer AND pastor/preacher/teacher. Use your gifts. We, the body of Christ, will reap the benefits.
johnscorner
Amen to Carol’s question. (My answer: NO.) And amen to her exhortation to use your gifts.
Adri
Thanks; the list is concise and helpful. I like the way you’ve organized it. Some I heartily agree with, others not so much.
Randy
I would love to hear your ‘not so much’ selections…
Jenny
I just finished reading the Miraculous Journey of Edward Tulane to Hezekiah this week. He Loved it – though it made us both very sad at times.
Randy
Was it good or bad that it made you sad?
johnscorner
Chernow is relatively unknown!?!
Randy
I’m puzzling over this comment. Did I suggest that Chernow is unknown? I think my point was the opposite.
johnscorner
Sorry. I should have first said THANKS. Haack’s book sounds very worthy of reading. And I had not heard of it.
Adri
Sadly, I may have to stop reading your blog. You keep posting about books, enticing me to read, when I already have difficulty reading the books for two book clubs. Please don’t suggest, as husband did, that I quit one of the clubs.
Randy
So let me get this straight. Quitting the blog is an option. Quitting a book club is not. Should I be offended or hurt?
Adri
Neither. You’ve known me for 20+ years. :>)
Christine Finnegan
Amen.
Denise Lawe
Thank you Randy.
Kedric
Just FYI, Dixie Cream Cafe has the best biscuits. Yes, it’s worth the drive.
I’m listening to Rosaria Butterfield’s Thoughts of an Unlikely Convert and Timothy Shutt’s lectures on the Literature of C.S. Lewis. Reading Space Odyssey: Stanley Kubrick, Arthur C. Clarke, and the Making of a Masterpiece by Michael Benson.
Randy
You are keeping busy, it seems! And, though you’ve never lead me wrong, I won’t drive an hour for a biscuit!
A W Foster
Did you know that Bill Schickel designed the chapel?
Randy
I did NOT! Add that to the list of things that I did not know while I was there but wish I had.
Eva
So glad you had a restful time, Randy! Got me wondering if there is a monastery for women anywhere. I’ll have to look into that!
Randy
Probably half the ‘retreatants’ (as we were called) were women.
Jeanne Edison
Beautifully and thoughtfully written!Thanks Randy!!
Randy
Thank YOU!
Carol Arnold
So good, Randy. So encouraging. Especially “the soil out of which real renewal will arise is the daily rhythms of a life faithfully lived.” Billy Graham called it “the godly mundane.” It’s where most of us are, most of the time. And God can meet us there. You’re such a gifted writer. (Knowing you, you’re denying this). But it rises in you in “the daily rhythms of a life faithfully lived.”
chrisinnm
Yes.
I have a missionary friend who recently asked in a prayer letter, “How do you enjoy God?”. Good to ponder, and seems related here. He really wanted an answer, so I replied that I enjoy God through gratitude in the mundane. That seems to me related to what you are saying about renewal. What a good God we serve who meets us where we are living in this broken place, and breaks in upon our routine to provide renewal in and through it.
Praying for the rest of Sabbatical to continue to bear good fruit.
Randy
You are right, of course. Would it be right to say that it’s like humility? You don’t really ‘seek it’. You live life faithfully and it sneaks up on you? Just a thought. I struggled with Keller’s book on ‘prayer’ because it wasn’t a book on prayer, it was an attempt to provide a formula for ‘experiencing awe and intimacy with God.’ Formulas only work for some people. I would remind your friend that what we seek we will not find in its fulness but in the resurrection: “At the resurrection believers being raised up in glory shall be…made perfectly blessed in the full enjoying of God to all eternity.” (Westminster Shorter Catechism #39)
chrisinnm
And again, Amen!
Carol Arnold
All of which Jesus summed up in the second greatest commandment to love others.
Randy
True, of course. But to this some reply, “I am not loving someone if I don’t point out their sin.” There is truth to that, of course. But what follows makes all the difference. I will not listen to one’s assessment of another’s sin, or my own, if it is not couched in language that shows that you genuinely care and are not just eager to win a point.
Carol Arnold
Good thoughts. “Decency” is much needed in the world today, whether nationally or in our personal lives.
Carol Arnold
Jack taught me to play early in our marriage. He and I played cribbage on our loooong flights to Africa. I love that game!
Randy
The secret to a long marriage…
Staci Thomas
I’m buying it this weekend! Thanks for such a great endorsement!
Randy
If you are able to learn how to play from written instructions, I will be impressed! Let me know…
Denise Lawe
Cribbage is awesome. My aunt plays tournaments in Florida. I can hook you up if you wish; although I will warn, I have never beaten her in a game. She always wins.
Randy
Which assessment pretty much answers your own question. Do I want to play someone who never loses? Me?
chrisinnm
Another George taught me to play early on in my relationship with his son. We have been enjoying cribbage ever since!
Randy
Well, good, then. WHEN (not if) you come visit, we’ll play.
Jenny
I have SO many memories of my grandparents playing cribbage. I just associate it with happiness and wine and relaxation. I converted Kevin VERY early in our marriage. Honeymoon I think. We’ve been playing for 18 years. I used to win quite a bit, but lately the tables have turned on me. It is something I truly look forward to with his return this fall. Evenings of quiet cribbage.
Randy
Wine. Not there is a component we did not consider. See – you can’t learn this game from printed directions. It’s a lifestyle, a community, into which one is wooed.
Kevin
Yes! Wine is my secret to actually winning against my numbers obsessed wife! I have to adle her brain a bit if I’m going to have a hope!
Randy
Brilliant strategy. I’m in awe.
child4
I saw the problem immediately. You asked, “Why cribbage?” And Barb lied when she answered that she thought it looked like fun. What really happened it that she wanted to annoy you. She thought you would think *cabbage* and she knows you don’t like that healthful, nutritious, vegetable.
So now you have something more to work on for the next 10 or 20 or 25 years of marriage. Don’t let your enjoyment of the game get in the way of working things out peacefully. >;)
(I have no doubt you’ll work on me too, trying to get me to change. HA!)
Randy
Don’t drag cabbage into this. You’re just jealous. This is a game in which one needs to be able to add numbers. And you, being blonde,…well, I think I’ll leave it.
Flip
In 1965, when I was working on Cape Cod, two of my brothers came up, and we decided to drive to Freeport Maine to see the L. L. Bean store, which we only knew through the catalog – just to say we’d been there. After a great day together, we walked out of the store having bought one item between the three of us… a cribbage set. ‘Nuff said!
Randy
And L.L.Bean cribbage set! Now that is style!
Carol Arnold
Love this. Happy anniversary.
Barb
Thank you Carol.
Barb
Thank you Carol 😊!
child4
CONGRATULATIONS! And here’s to the next 40; live the years in good health and great happiness.
chrisinnm
Wonderful. Congratulations!
chrisinnm
Glad to have your cyber presence re-emerge. <3
Randy
My challenge is to not let it consume me. That is always my problem. We’ll work this slow…
Carol Arnold
All thoughts welcome. Even those without clarity or brevity.
Randy
There is always that one person who says, “Pastor, I don’t care how long you preach. It’s all good.” The emphasis there is on the ‘one’ person. 😉
Carol Arnold
😄
Suzanne
Looking forward to that direction of hope and vision of better things to come.
Adria Bautista
This is expertly spoken, thanks Dad.
Randy
Except, of course, for the fact that in the initial posting, I misspelled Ms. Danticat’s name a half dozen times. Kind of throws the ‘expert’ label into dispute. But thank you!
Sarah Kaye
You have flock that are still following and looking to be guided by those they trust 😊, who are much more likely to read your sparesly spaced posts than of those who plaster all over daily or even weekly!
Because the commenting is closed on your “give me Jesus” post I’ll comment here…if your looking to sit and listen to some deep truthful “give me Jesus” preaching, please check out the audio sermons from our old church back in Yorktown VA by Pastor Kevin Haas. His series on Luke has been awesome and I found myself glued to every word….also the current church home to the McCarty family who I’m sure will agree! Hope you get to enjoy…
http://www.bygrace.cc/wp/resources/sermons?pagenum=8
Randy
You are quite the resourceful reader/commenter! What a wonderful affirmation of this pastor’s preaching. I hope he knows that you think so highly and appreciatively of him. Makes me wish we’d been in that part of the world during my sabbatical!
Gail Landis Brightbill
Yes, thank you!
Suzanne
“They are all people. And that matters”
Well said.
Roy Starling
Yeah, well where would this Great Nation be if we had called Native Americans-American Indians-Indigenous Tribes “people”?
Randy
What? Instead of ‘savages’? Point well taken.
Kedric
You know the best biscuit ever is made at Dixie Cream Cafe in Windermere.
Randy
No. The best biscuit is made in my kitchen. 😉
But if I’m ever in Windemere I’ll be delighted to taste #2.
Fiona McQuarrie
A good portion of what you have shared in your post is in line with what the Holy Spirit has been convicting me of, and has been prompting me (particularly over the last year) and that is to seek what God says in his infallible word of truth when doubt, questions, or debate arise. It has become more “second nature” for me now, when either discussing a topic with others, or just as I’m thinking in private, and that is to ask, “What does the Lord say about this question or issue?” I am no longer interested in spiritual “improvising” as it were, but I want assurance and the hard facts taught by seeking the Lord’s guidance and reading what He has laid out in scriptures for us as believers.
It is so encouraging to see the Lord at work within others as well as myself, concerning our approach and attitude to seeking out and obeying what God has instructed us to believe, act or think..
May the Lord continue to bless you and yours richly, as well as your congregation in the coming New Year!
Randy
Thank you, Fiona.
SarahKaye
Looking forward to these future posts and desperately missing being apart of a church that gives a benediction blessing at the end…our search will continue!
Darlene
Your thoughtful, prayer filled posts are received with a grateful heart and soul. May God continue to bless you. Thanks
Randy
Thanks. You are very kind.
Carol Arnold
Was Adam motivated by fear when he told Eve not to even touch the forbidden fruit?
Randy
Adam didn’t. Eve said that to the serpent. Not sure she was, though.
Kedric W.
“The paranoid spokesman sees the fate of conspiracy in apocalyptic terms—he traffics in the birth and death of whole worlds, whole political orders, whole systems of human values. He is always manning the barricades of civilization. He constantly lives at a turning point. Like religious millennialists he expresses the anxiety of those who are living through the last days and he is sometimes disposed to set a date for the apocalypse.”
— Richard Hofstadter
Randy
WHERE do you find these things! Wonderful.
Kedric W.
Found part of it in the book “The Soul of America” by John Meacham. Then I found the original source in a Harper’s Magazine article.
dwightdolby
Thanks Randy. I hope you don’t mind if I draw from this in my sermon this Sunday morning. Keep up the good and helpful work.
John Holzmann
Hi, Randy.
I don’t know about your opening line” “We will never know . . .” —Hasn’t that been the case in the past, especially prior to social media? But be that as it may. . . .
I love your expressed sentiments . . . AND . . . I wonder how and when and where the gentleness and kindness must, eventually, “even with tears,” give way to hard (difficult . . . but, also, often perceived-as, let’s say, harsh) judgment/discernment/decision: “No! That is WRONG! Yes! I WILL oppose you!”?
And I ask the question WITHOUT REFERENCE to the issue you happened to use by way of illustration in your post. I refer, instead, to such things as, say,
* the massive, socially-accepted abuse of blacks throughout American society that, only FINALLY resulted in the kinds of civil disobedience that came to town in the 1950s and ‘60s (but that led my grandmother—not a hint of racism in her mind, of which I could discern—who was distressed by MLK’s “pushing” for change and upsetting society); or
* the theological liberalism that, only FINALLY led—not to the censure of those who were abandoning the historic teachings of the church, but, instead, to the censure of those who sought to uphold those teachings (I think of the history well-summarized in Gary North’s Crossed Fingers: How the Liberals Captured the Presbyterian Church—available for free at http://www.garynorth.com/freebooks/docs/243a_47e.htm); or
* the sexual depredations that only FINALLY resulted in #MeToo (or, more recently, #OutThem; https://www.scarymommy.com/kristina-kuzmic-outthem/). . . .
Notice, in each of the three cases I have “happened” to reference, the persons who are “calling out” the evil often, themselves, are censured for their “lack of kindness.” . . .
????
Randy
As to the first line, I mean literally that we will never experience that. We will never go back to a time to experience a reality in which viral videos and such do not exist. And yes, you are right. Our best attempts at civility will be often misunderstood. So be it. Be civil anyway. I’m grateful for you counterbalancing my post with the reality that there are times to speak regardless of how our speech is taken. Hard words, I think, can and ought to be spoken with such respect that honors the humanity of those on the other side. The call to reasonableness is not a call to silence. It is a call to temper zeal with gentleness.
John Holzmann
Well put. THANKS! 🙂
randybronson
Surviving Ministry by Mike Osborne would be a good book for pastors.
Randy
It is on my list. Unfortunately, it is not well enough known for it to be on most guys’ radars.
Carol Arnold
Wow.
Carol Arnold
Don’t forget your wife! “The Liberation of a Rezentful Wife” by you know who.
Randy
Yes, that would go on the ‘books for pastors’ spouses’ . . .
Carol Arnold
This is spot on. As usual.
Randy
Thanks, Carol.
Adrianna Espino
I shouldn’t be, yet am always amazed at God’s sovereign providence. How wonderful for you to know that this was not just a “lucky” coincidence or happenstance, but that The Father was/is always in complete control.
Randy
I very much needed that assurance on that occasion!
Mary Ann Porter
I love how God is in control!
Awfoster
Beautifully said and, I am sure, spoken!
Randy
I appreciate your saying so.
Dwight
I’d like to seek some counsel from you with regard to living with some disappointment. My email address is the same. Would you hit me up when you can?
Randy
Check your email inbox!
Nina
I remember Psalm 23 and the word THROUGH. We walk THROUGH the valley of the shadow of death, we don’t camp out there. And there is only a shadow if the sun is shining on the other side.
Kedric W.
A lot of us were shocked at Rachel’s passing, especially those in the BC class of ’03. I hadn’t seen her in 12 or 13 years. Read her blog early on but actually stopped reading it about five or six years ago. I was able to read the CT article by the other author (John Stonestreet) before he requested it be taken down. Some of the comments about it on a Facebook thread said it was good and balanced and others thought it divisive and focused too much on the author. I think both sets made valid points.
Before the thread was taken down, I had commented that many people were writing from a place of deep emotion because the news of Rachel’s death was still so fresh. There are holes in people’s hearts. I also said that the comments reflect some of the tensions that have been simmering for years among those who agree or disagree with her writings because they reflect deeper issues happening in the American church. The issues don’t go away after someone’s passing and neither do the divisions. In fact, they bring up more questions as to how to interact with people with whom we disagree, even vehemently. And it’s not even necessarily disagreements between Christianity and other beliefs, but between Christians themselves. The lines between friendship, peaceful coexistence, and non-interaction are often blurry.
Randy
“The issues don’t go away after someone’s passing and neither do the divisions.”
So good, Kedric. And so true. May God give us grace to manage these divisions.
James W Strong
As For Me and My House…we’ll continue to read your writings. 🙂
Randy
Which, in turn, makes me want to keep writing. Thank you, sir.
Dwight L Dolby
If someone asked me about my friend, Randy, I would say, he is a pastor. If someone asked me about Calvin, I would say he was a theologian. If someone asked me about my wife, I would say, she’s a teacher. All these put pen to paper and I sincerely enjoy reading their “work.” The alcoholic confessing such at an AA meeting is giving expression to what has controlled and almost ruined his / her life. I pray you won’t go there with it! 🙂 Write on, my friend, write on…
Randy
I certainly hope your last sentence was meant with the humor with which it lands! Right on!
The alcoholic parallel is well made and well taken. Thanks.
Fiona McQuarrie
As the Nike slogan says, “Just Do It.” How’s that for chutzpah?
Randy
Ha! and an athletic metaphor is very appropriate. Got something for a marathon? 😉
randybronson
I’ll never forget the goodbye message you wrote for Kelly when she left for seminary. It has brought me to joyful tears more than once. For a father to know that someone else sees the same value in his daughter that he does is a wonderful gift. I just wish I could express it to her as well as you did.
Randy
Thanks, Randy. Kelly, though, was an easy target. ☺ Worth every word.
Alexandra
Sooo… Which projects after you working on?
Randy
That requires a longer answer, and will be the subject of an upcoming post. Nothing as fun as a fantasy novel, however. I’m not creative enough to make stuff up. ☺
Suzanne
Write it so that people hear it and it slides through the brain and goes straight to the heart.
Maya Angelou
Randy
” IF THERE’S A BOOK YOU REALLY WANT TO READ, BUT IT HASN’T BEEN WRITTEN YET, THEN YOU MUST WRITE IT.”
– Toni Morrison
Avery foster
Please let me know when you are published!
Randy
Oh, you’ll know! And I’m grateful for your use of ‘when’ instead of the ‘if’ that I’d be more likely to use. Perhaps in the intervening time, I should send you a segment that makes reference to a certain high school English class. Yes, I need to do that when I get a chance. After I tidy it up.
Adrianna Espino
Wow! Great endorsements. 😉 Count me first in line for an autographed copy when it’s hot off the press.
Randy
It’s a deal. Your end of it is to hang around long enough for the deal to be complete.
Christine Finnegan
I’m with Adri. What a wonderful project!
Randy
Thanks!
Alexandra
Excellent! And I laughed at that third endorsement…
This IS much needed. I love Williamson’s books, but yes… Something similar/different is needed.
Randy
I’m rather fond of that third endorsement, actually. The similarities between GIW’s treatment and mine is that we are both dealing with the WSC. After that, well, I think we diverge in tone and intention. Perhaps someday you’ll be able to make that comparison.
Carol Arnold
I was told a mark of a true scholar is one who can keep it simple. And short. Editing is where the fun begins. Or the agony. Hang in there.
Randy
It is both. Fun and agony. But regardless, I really believe this is something I’m supposed to do.
Adrianna Espino
Will want to pick your brain on A Gentleman in Moscow when my book club gets to it an a couple of months. I’m glad to read that you found it enjoyable.
Randy
Never certain how much brain will be left to pick – but I hope you like it.
Alexandra
A Gentleman in Moscow is one of my favorite reads from the past year. But I’ve been reading a lot of Louise Penny (really beautifully written Canadian murder mystery) and Brad Thor (military espionage thriller) for a “brain break” this year.
Hooray for the encouraging feedback!
Christine Finnegan
Gentleman was one of my recent favorites as well (and hello here Alexandra!) So glad for the “beautiful” epithet. That is how I have always found your writing. Carry on!
Randy
Chris – do you know EVERYONE?? Thanks for the nice words. Gent in Moscow was recommended to me by my older brother and I understand that Jennie’s older sister recommended it to her. So, hurray for older siblings!
Randy
See – that is what I like. Someone who is good to move from literary fiction to mysteries and thrillers. In the international thriller department, have you read I Am Pilgrim? So good.
Carol Arnold
Keep on “keeping on.” We are the grateful recipients.
Randy
As always, you are so kind. Thanks.
Christine Finnegan
I had not heard about this. What a shame! I should have known that Amazon’s easy access would come with a price.
Randy
My source tells me that IVP will be giving something to THW to compensate her for the loss. They are the good guys.
Larry
Wow, Amazon basically says, “we don’t care about ‘our’ artists and authors as long as we are making money as a result of their work” So very sad.
Kedric W.
Amazon just doesn’t seem to want to solve problems anymore. I did some reading about selling on Amazon and came upon a blog talking about the positives and negatives. Apparently one of the negatives is that stuff can be sent back for just about any reason without necessarily explaining why or showing proof of a problem with a product.
The blog said a purchaser bought all of the supply of a certain product from an Amazon-seller. While it was a big sale, it wiped out the product from the inventory. However, turns out the buyer sells the same product. Buyer sells their version (say during the Christmas buying rush), then sends back the initial product saying there was a “problem” with it. So now the original seller not only could not fulfill orders for a holiday rush, but they had to refund the money once the product was sent back. The whole thing was intentional in order to take out a competitor.
Randy
And yet it is hard to escape Amazon’s influence. Read this week about pressure that Etsy is putting its sellers to offer free shipping so they can compete with Amazon.
Adrianna Espino
I’m afraid I’ll have to continue with Amazon despite their distasteful actions. Without a vehicle, and with limited access to shopping centers, I order many things online, not exclusively from Amazon, but often.
I like that they have some “Made in the USA” products; not the majority of course but at least it helps US economy a bit.
I have not read the book and will not be attending the study our church women will be starting later this month, may read the book later. It is not available in our county library system.
I will send your article to the women I know will be attending the study. Thanks for calling it to our attention.
Randy
Actually, apart from the difference in cost, there are attractive online alternatives to Amazon. Keep reading in the days ahead.
chrisinnm
Are you sneaking us into a serial here? Leaving us with a cliff-hanger? 😉
Randy
I suppose it feels ‘sneaking.’ What we have here is, rather, a failure to communicate. On Twitter and Facebook I’ve made it clear that this is a consideration in five parts – just not here on the blog directly. Serving it up in bite-sized portions. Thanks for reading! Thanks more for commenting.
Sallie
I hope that we will always have the option to get in our car and go to the store. It looks like we are headed towards ordering everything, including groceries online and never having to leave our house!
Randy
So true!
Carol Arnold
Amazon fits into the . . . (can I say it) . . .enemy’s persuasion, that “things” matter more than relationships.
Dwight
Very fun!
Jason Strong
In 1971, I was stationed in Columbus Georgia at Fort Benning and I had joined a radio controlled airplane club.
The hobby shop a lot of us used was small, free standing building and was packed full of wonderful goodies, and the owner was very helpful to a novice such as myself.
After four or five months and several purchases later, he told me he was thinking about moving into a much larger more modern building and wanted to know my opinion.
I told him, one of the reasons I did business with him was because of the personality, not only his, but of the place much the same as you have described with your bookstores. I said it would be a shame to lose that just to have a bigger building in some shopping mall.
As is often the case, the U.S. Army transferred me (to Alaska) and I never knew what became of that shop. In addition, I started working on my private pilot certificate and did not have the time nor the money to continue with that hobby.
Hopefully, the hobby store owner continued to be successful and took some of the “magic“ that was the hobby store I loved with him wherever he ended up.
I hope the same is true with the bookstores you are coming to know and enjoy. 😊
Carol Arnold
Yay and congratulations! Bask in perserence and victory over the war of art. Clap clap.
24
25
26
Randy
Which makes me ask if you have read the book, The War of Art?
Chris
Bravo! 1, 42, 105
Randy
Thanks for the cheers, and the suggestions!
Nina Morway
You have given birth. The book exists, and God holds its future. I would love to buy it, and read it.
Three random questions, please.
Nina Morway
Randy
And it has been a labor, but a joyful labor, for the most part.
Larry edison
1,2,95. I bet it feels good
James A. Jones Jr.
Sounds fascinating. Hope you find a publisher. Pretty sure it is well done and done well!
Dwight Dolby
Congratulations! I’m requesting: 1,2, 107
Alexandra
Wow! Thankful!
Randomly. . . 8 & 24
Chris Wright
Congrats Randy, so amazing to get this done. Have u thought of leading a seminar at GA to introduce the concepts in the book? May be a means to get more folks interested
Randy
Well, since the ‘concepts in the book’ are one of our confessional documents, I might hope that the TEs and REs at GA would already be familiar with them! However, you have me thinking that a seminar on the value of the Catechism for those outside our circles looking for a clear and comprehensive presentation of historic Christianity could be put together. But, of course, for the three people who would attend. 😉 If you have more thoughts, email me.
Connie
This is a good suggestion!
Eva
Hooray! 86, 93 and 97
Suzanne
Congratulations! I look forward to reading.
32, 35 and 36
Jay Holt
Congratulations, Randy! This is huge!
7, 8, & 78
Randy
I might note that you have already read the entry on question 7 and 8! Would you like to see if I fixed it? 😉
Randy Bronson
Yay! Theology questions! 🙂 7, 11, 13.
Dwight Dolby
Looking forward to this Randy. You can anticipate from me a pastorally encouraging response. I save my candid comments for Marcia (my wife) and Austin (my son who still lives at home). After sharing my candor with them, I always feel guilty and repent.
Mary Ann Porter
When I first heard that you were writing about the catechism, I couldn’t help thinking that this book would not interest me whatsoever. However, your introduction is appealing, and may be just the right book for me and my scarred ex-Catholic friend, Ben, who is skeptical about this religion thing! When can I buy a copy???
Randy
Thanks. This is how I want this to be used. When can you buy a copy? Well, first I have to find a publisher willing to print it. Pray to that end!
Chris
Lovely and engaging. I am ready for my copy and to use it in my devotions daily!
Randy
Thanks, Chris. So the wait begins.
Connie Amon
Congratulations! Be encouraged that the desire to write has been realized in a book! As Carol said … clap, clap!!
90, 97, 88
Rebekah
I’m so excited to see you’ve finally made this happen! So looking forward to reading it!
Gail Brightbill
Having not grown up with the Catechisms I very much look forward to reading your book. I’m praying for a publisher to take it on. In the meantime I’ll have to be content to read the pages you are sharing with us here. My faith can use a shot in the arm. Oh, and as I write this I am mindful of my grammatical p’s and q’s, aware that at one time you were an English teacher.
Randy
Yes. You wouldn’t want me to send your comment back marked up in red. ☺
Carol Arnold
Great beginning and whets my appetite to read more. Well done.
Randy
Then, mission accomplished! Thanks.
Christine Finnegan
Lovely, and true. I can see reading this aloud with my hubby at night, even as we do Spurgeon right now, and being blessed and encouraged by it.
Randy
That’s some pretty exalted company to be in! Spurgeon, too! Thanks.
Suzanne
As one who was not introduced to the Catechisms until recent years, I appreciate your explanation. Thought provoking for sure. Looking forward to more to come.
Christine Finnegan
Yes and Amen! And one of my favorite Christmas verses into the bargain 😁I particularly love and am comforted by, “yet it is God who works in us to shape us and conform us to the image of Christ so that when we see change, we are seeing the evidence of the work of God.”
Christine Finnegan
AND I love that the table of contents is it’s it’ commentary.♥
Christine Finnegan
It’s own…
Randy
Thanks, Chris! For all your comments and encouragement. Stay tuned for what might be some encouraging news . . .
Christine Finnegan
Praying, and clasping my hands in anticipation!
Gail Brightbill
Hallelujah! Congratulations! I am so excited and happy for you. I’ve always thought you should write. Now I want December 2020 to hurry up and come.
Adria Bautista
So excited and proud!!
Randy
You make an appearance … 😉
Randy
Thanks, Gail! But, the older I get I’m more reticent to hasten time.
Jason Strong
Congratulations Randy, although I can’t help but wonder if you got your best material from those of us at the “Covenant Guys” men’s group. Don’t worry … we won’t tell. 🙂
Randy
You’re a songwriter. You know. EVERYTHING is material!
Carol Arnold
Maybe this “sad little species” can be happy now. We are!
John Holzmann
Super excited for you, Randy! Congratulations!
Randy
Thanks, John!
Sarah
So cool!!!!! Congrats!!!! Can’t wait to buy it, read it, and tell all my friends about it. Sing praise!
Randy
Well, perhaps before you tell your friends, you may want to make sure you get that second step in there! ☺
Jessie Thetford
Yay!!!!!!! Can’t wait to read it!
Randy
Now it’s your turn. When does the CD come out? Or when is the exposition?
Christine Finnegan
Woo hoo! Doing a happy dance here, and delighted, and praising God altogether!
Randy
Like a Snoopy dance?! I’d love to see that.
valdeb
I am so glad the time you have waited for has come – at least the first step of promise of publication. I look forward to rejoicing with you anew when it comes to fruition.
Randy
Yes – this is one step in a long one. Lots to do between here and there.
TulipGirl
Wow! Rejoicing!
Randy
Thanks! And of course when released we might want to take advantage of our friends’ vast internet connectivity. 😉
Jenifer
This is THRILLING news! Congratulations- I have always thought you should be published 😁
Randy
… in which I present my very Protestant theology in as catholic a fashion as possible. I look forward to hearing how I do!
Nina Morway
Happy is not enough. Ecstatic thrilled joyful for you, and all of us who will have the joy of reading it, as well as telling our friends “Oh, this is a book my pastor published.” “A book,” not “The book.” Hope there will be more.
Randy
One step at a time. Thanks for sharing my excitement!
Dwight Dolby
Congratulations Randy!!! It’s a happy and inspiring occasion! I’m looking forward to a merrier Christmas this year!
Randy
And I pray for a merrier Christmas for you, my friend. For reasons far beyond a mere book!
Dwight Dolby
This is EXCELLENT! My own soul stirred. Thank you.
Randy
This means a lot for you to say so. Thanks.
Connie
Congratulations Randy! This wanna-be is thrilled for you!! You have my permission to break into a happy dance whenever I see you!
Randy
Okay. But just one happy dance. The rest of the time I need you and others to keep me grounded.
JEFF BROWN
So excited for you Randy! Congratulations!
Randy
Thanks, Jeff. Your support has been essential.
Jerrygreenwald
My little bro,l say this kiddingly, will be a published writer. Proud! Mary already said she wants 5 or6.
Randy
Thanks, big bro!
Christine Finnegan
Like always, I feel encouraged with your infrequent words. 💗
Carol Arnold
More. More!
Carol Arnold
Yes!
Sometimes the written word, “spoken” from the heart, is more powerful than the spoken words from the lips. Starting with the tablets of stone, scrolls and epistles, and now emails . . . God can and does communicate to us through those who write.
Thank you.
Christine Finnegan
Amen, indeed!
Nina Morway
There will be a grand HALLELUJAH when we gather again. Even I will clap and raise my hands, tears of joy and gratitude running down my face, for the blessing of being with the Body of Christ.
Your letters bless me.
Linda Bennett
Thank you so much for the encouragement and the humor. Seth looks so much like you Randy!
Randy
Ah, thanks! But poor Seth. Don’t tell him that. You’ll traumatize him.
Dwight Dolby
Thanks Randy.
Dwight Dolby
Excellent Randy! Thank you!
johnscorner
Good, Randy!
I’m not sure about the hypocrisy idea. Where does that come from? But I generally agree with the idea of showing, at minimum, a degree of *politeness* by wearing a mask when in places where one might be coming in contact with people in fear for their lives. One wonders when and where it makes sense to speak out *against* so much of modern drama—whether the TSA “security” theater or wearing masks.
Sarita and I are (happily) “stuck” in Belize for the duration of the COVID weirdness. Here, six weeks after the last case was discovered, having never been mandated before, face masks were suddenly mandated whenever one leaves one’s home. And other practices, also, were suddenly mandated. Most people abide by the rules. At least publicly. But when one enters a store (their than food stores), though the masks are still required, it is quite fascinating to see how few people actually wear them other than under their chins (“Hey! I’m wearing my mask! . . . No one defined *how* I’m supposed to wear it!”). . . . We were in a doctor’s office yesterday, and no one wore a mask. . . .
But no one seems particularly angry and there are no arguments (that I have seen) between “wearers” and “non-wearers.” I certainly can’t imagine any “wearer” being treated how this “wearing” diabetic shopper was by a “non-wearer.”
Randy
Hi, John. Sorry I did not see this reply until this morning. Somehow it slid under radar! Time to check my “spam” folder. I wanted to explain the hypocrisy comment: this was a letter to my congregation any one of whom might have run into me at the grocery store sans mask. I really don’t like them, and in large measure question their utility, but, as you rightly understand, my concern here is not for what I think but the message it conveys to others. In private, I, too, have drawn a parallel with TSA and an element of theater. I love the observation about how people wear them. Hanging off one ear and draped across the shoulder? Good enough!
Nina Morway
Oh, how I can relate! I’ve questioned my faith and salvation because prayers is so difficult for me. I’ve found that the best way for me is to pray wonderful, rich hymns. Great is Thy Faithfulness, He Leaderh Me, Under His Wings, Be Thou My Vision, Trust and Obey, Before the Throne of God Above, How Deep the Father’s Love for Me… I shy away from What a Friend we Have in Jesus—it makes me feel like a failure. ,
Carol Arnold
I’m get it. I’m so old my mind started humming Bing Crosby’s recording of “Kiss me once and kiss me twice and kiss me once again, It’s been a long long time…” from 1945!!
dwightdolby
In such a time as ours when the whole idea of God’s creative purpose in making “man” – male and female (Genesis 1) is resisted and opposed, as a minister of the Word, I experience a Biblical “knee-jerk” reaction in your suggesting we pastors and Bible teachers (or the “Church”) move away from “manhood” considerations (and “womanhood” considerations) and consider instead Biblical “decency.” I will read your articles, but I am just saying up front, your “move” off the subject of gender roles to consider Biblical decency is a move I implicitly – don’t trust. I don’t want to avoid gender roles and apsects of my manhood as set forth in scripture, I want to understand them. For God to reveal to me He has purposed my manhood – male gender – and then for you or anyone to suggest – “But you’ll never understand it – so just be a decent Christian person” is a solution I cannot embrace. I’m just saying – this is how I initially respond to your presentation of this subject. I have to overcome this sort of resistance to read your articles, as I suspect others do as well.
Randy
I appreciate your honesty in this. I get the knee jerk. Though I am not in any way suggesting distinctions between male and female, you and I may no doubt differ on how those are to be determined. However, I have two fundamental concerns. The first is that some of the distinctions made are overdrawn and indefensible. On this we no doubt could have a profitable conversation and agree in the end to differ. But the second is far deeper and more important to me. That the Christian not be a bully, that the Christian show respect for all people, that the Christian speak with charity and deference toward and about others, that these things should not be up for dispute. When I see men defending uncharitable behavior as manly, I say something is terribly awry. When I see ungodliness, in me first, but in others, my heart desire is to deal with that first, as the weightier matter of the law. Thanks for weighing in.
jenion
It is interesting to me that the first reply to your post completely ignores the gist of what you said: that the way some Christians are ACTUALLY BEHAVING is not, in fact, ACTUALLY CHRISTIAN. (My inelegant words, not yours!) It is no secret I don’t dwell in your “corner of the Christian world”. But from my corner of the Christian world, where the sin of misogyny also has quite a history and hold on behavior, I am always grateful for your authenticity and compassion. I am also grateful for your courage in suggesting that how we live is every day proclaiming our theology to the world – regardless of the words that come from our lips, regardless of our gender, and regardless of which corner of the Christian world we claim to reside within.
Stephanie Ilderton
Yuuuuuup.
Randy
Thanks, Jen. And I nominate your brother-in-law as a worthy model of decency!
Tim Trouten
This is a great little post Randy. Thank you for being decent!
Gail Brightbill
Thank you for this.
Alden Weichel
I read this, in part, as well written commentary on the two great commandments.
Larry E
Wow Randy, so powerful. Thank you.
chrisinnm
Amen. And well done (again) hitting so many of my favorite novels in one post 🙂
Alexandra
Comments are closed on your Amazon and book buying series. . . I came over here just to see your recommendations.
While it will never be totally over with Amazon, I’ve become more fed up with them. (Even though one of my college kids is hustling in a Bezos warehouse.) They’ve been my primary supplier of books, homeschool materials, and American goods for over a decade.
Anyway, thanks for gathering good resources together.
Gail Brightbill
So very sad. Adri had a fun loving, kind and tender heart. I always said Adri and Gus are the coolest retirees we know. My prayers are with Gus, her son’s, grandchildren, family and for all who knew and loved her.
Jeanne Edison
What a beautiful tribute Randy.! That quote from the Heidelberg catechism is a favorite of mine also. Face to face with her savior!!!
James Jones
Lovely remembrance, Randy, and a valuable lesson, too.
chrisinnm
Weeping, and thanking God that I got to meet and admire Adri. And i continued knowing her through comments right here at times. Praying for all who are grieving her, but glad we do not grieve as those without hope. And comforted that God knows and shows grace. Sending you hugs.
johnscorner
Thank you for this thoughtful—and challenging—tribute.
Bethany Mazzola
Thank you for this beautiful tribute. It wells up so many good memories and thoughts of someone who was a beautiful example to me… Especially in her stellar hospitality 🙂 And honestly, I didn’t know everyone else called her son Nate, I had only ever heard her and Gus say Nathaniel!
Carol arnold
I’m smiling too. Outside. Without a mask.
Christine Finnegan
Smiling, and preordering!!!
Nina Morway
I am excited, too! Will pre-order it. Thank you for all your hard work.
Nina Morway
You’ve got it, on all points. Pre-ordered. Will post review. Will gift it to a few people. Will share with a blogger I follow.
One request: I want my copy autographed.
Nina
Randy
Of course! As I heard one author put it, “Buy my book and I’ll see to it that it is signed. Buy five and I’ll see that it is signed by me.” 😉
Christine Finnegan
Praying for these endeavors, and for you and all your family as God continues to do wondrous things.
Carol Arnold
Yes. For whatever, whenever and however….being enough is an inside job.
Christine Finnegan
Amen. Aren’t we glad for the job grace does on the inside?
Jenny McCarty
Thank you for this thoughtfully written review. Now, I really want to read this text for myself.
Randy
And I look forward to hearing what you think!
Nina Morway
You’ve heard that “one denomination” forbids premarital sex because it might lead to dancing…
Randy
This is hilarious!
Cris Dickason
Great insights. Thanks for writing them down (writing them up?) Hope this might get a more widespread distribution.
Randy
Thank you. Very encouraging to hear you say this.
Kedric W
I’ve been following this situation since Aimee Byrd was let go from the Alliance of Confessing Evangelicals (ACE) and the Mortification of Spin podcast (MOS). I got one of those occasional letters asking for financial support from ACE. I wrote on the paper and mailed it back stating I would not be giving any support to ACE until Aimee Byrd was put back on the podcast. I stated the same in unsubscribing from the emails.
Quite frankly, I would have liked to have seen Carl Trueman and Todd Pruitt state that they would not continue the podcast until Byrd was brought back. However, the podcast continues (sans a listener), even though they would have had to have known this skubalon was happening.
Mrs. Byrd is right to call out the sin leveling, or what I call the Doctrine of False Equivalency. Some people were concerned that some Geneva Common members MAY have been brought to task via guilt through association (they did not make comments about Byrd, but were members of the FB group). That somehow it’s just as bad as what has happened to Rachel Miller and Aimee Byrd. But that is simply not the case and ignores a huge amount of evidence to the contrary.
Randy
Well put, as always. Thanks.
Brandie
Thank you for witing this. Clear, Biblical thinking is really needed on this topic, but because of the nature of the debate, mens’ voices are especially helpful.
Maria
Loved the movie. Waiting for my copy to arrive. Wishing you much success, M.
Penni Holt
We are excited and proud for you! Waiting for our copies to show up!
Gail Brighytbill
They’re here! They’re here! My books are here! Oh boy oh boy, oh boy!
johnscorner
Thank you, Randy, for taking the time and trouble to craft such an amazing statement!
Carol Arnold
So good and so timely
John
Thanks for the update, Randy!
Eva
Very much excited for your literal and figurative next chapter, Randy!